What's new

Australia vs Pakistan: Boxing Day Test loss could hasten end of Misbah's career, mar his legacy

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,977
Writing for FirstPost Sports, Saj Sadiq previews the second Test between Australia and Pakistan at the MCG with the visitors needing to avoid defeat to stay alive in the series.


misbah_fbsport_647_112016124946.jpg


Recent pictures of the Pakistan team practising with enthusiasm at the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG) ahead of their Boxing Day clash with hosts Australia depict an image of a side that exudes confidence and seem to be at ease with each other.

The smiles and energy that shone through the images appeared to indicate a state of happiness with the way the series has progressed so far, and if the press engagements by Grant Flower and Asad Shafiq are to be believed, Pakistan have the momentum which will take them to victory in the upcoming second Test.

But here is where a reality check is important, especially if you are an admirer of Pakistan cricket. The previous Test match, a Day/Night affair in Brisbane, was not a victory for Pakistan. In fact, the team was under the cosh for most parts of the match, with an absolute disaster in the making, when Pakistan slumped to 67/8, ending Day One on a forgettable 97/8. In fact, had it not been for a strange decision by Steve Smith to not enforce the follow-on, the result and the Pakistan outlook for the upcoming game may well have been radically different.

As bizarre as the reaction of some commentators to criticise the Australian captain for his tactics may sound to all, the fact is that Australia have a one-nil advantage in the three Test match series and it is more than talk of momentum that will help the visitors overcome what lies ahead.

For a start, there is weight of history which shows that the MCG has not been a happy hunting ground for Pakistan in the past. Of the nine Test matches played at this venue, Pakistan have won just two, with five losses and two draws. Whilst one could argue that the composition of the current team is different from the past, there is a question of the Pakistan bowlers' inability to come to terms with local conditions. And if some of the teams comprising of bigger names have struggled at this venue, the present lot will also find it difficult.

The Day/Night format with the pink ball chosen for the Brisbane Test was touted as a tough one for Pakistan's brittle batting line-up and they may well feel comfortable in the more familiar red ball version. However, the perennial issue of the inability of Pakistani openers to put up decent partnerships for the remainder of the batsmen to cash in on is not limited to the colour of the ball alone.

And if the Pakistani opening batsmen were hoping for better news from the MCG curator, there wasn't much forthcoming in that regard as he feels that the ball is expected do a bit in the first few overs. Where Pakistan can draw comfort from, however, is the fact that once their openers can see off the new ball, the rest of the batting line-up should find the batting conditions more to their liking. With enough runs on the board, Yasir Shah's leg-spinning skills could also come into play towards the end of the game to help Pakistan square the series.

With a short three match series, the Australian advantage is an important one. The pressure that it puts on Pakistan is immense and had it not been for the second innings fightback in Brisbane, they would have been struggling to come up with answers to the questions that the Australians posed in the opening encounter.

Apart from the opening pair, the visitors are due some big innings from the ageing stalwarts Misbah-ul-Haq and Younis Khan. Whilst Younis did redeem himself in a limited manner in the second innings, to say that he is on the top of his game in the current series would be stretching the truth. And whilst Younis could easily build upon his previous innings at the MCG, the Pakistan captain's abysmal form in the tour is a matter of grave concern.

Misbah, at the age of forty-two, has earned plaudits from many for his outstanding leadership as well as personal feats, but the simple lack of runs so far will be playing on his mind and putting an immeasurable strain on the already-brittle middle order. Whether this is the demise of his batting skills with his advancing age or just a temporary drop in form is what many would be keen to find out.

If the pink ball format presented too much of a challenge for Misbah's reflexes, the MCG offers a more conventional and familiar challenge for the Pakistani captain. His admirers would expect him to come out with an innings of defiance and value to reclaim his place as the cornerstone of the batting order.

Apart from the immediate issue of his form, Misbah's future legacy as a successful captain is also at risk in the MCG Test. What is widely being regarded as his last overseas tour, the stakes are as high as they have ever been for him to go out with a success in a series played in non-Asian conditions.

The Pakistan bowling attack failed to take twenty-wickets in the first Test and a few questions were asked about the choice of Rahat Ali as a member of the three-man fast-bowling attack. All indications are that Pakistan, in the interest of stability, are willing to go ahead with an unchanged bowling line-up.

However, given Rahat's ineffectiveness in Brisbane, there is a growing clamour for him to be replaced by either Sohail Khan or Imran Khan, and Pakistan Head Coach Mickey Arthur will need to have some robust arguments ready should the result of the MCG Test not go in Pakistan's favour.

The stark truth is that a loss at MCG could not only hasten the end of Misbah's career but will also put an end to yet another Pakistan quest for an elusive series victory in Australia. The heat, as they say, is firmly on Misbah and Arthur to motivate the visitors to bring their A game to the MCG, if they are to keep any hopes alive of leaving the Australian shores without another series loss.

Despite Pakistan's fighting talk and the perceived momentum from the moral victory in Brisbane, Australia will know that they hold the higher ground as they go in to the second Test and only a performance of heroic proportions is likely to change their hold on this series.

http://m.firstpost.com/sports/austr...of-misbahs-career-mar-his-legacy-3172814.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If they win, not one expert will disagree with the wisdom that the confidence and form of the first test allowed them to win the second test.
 
If they win, not one expert will disagree with the wisdom that the confidence and form of the first test allowed them to win the second test.

Inshallah but reading too much in that is also a folly
 
And as always it boils down to three catastrophic ways the selectors undermined this team before the series even started:

1. A 42/43 year old at Number 4 and a 42 year old at Number 5.
2. Pakistan's GOAT Batsman in Australia not selected at the age of 32, even though he is in the form of his life.
3. Unselectable right-arm quicks, while the only one competent with the new ball is not in the squad.
 
Winning a series in Australia is a tough ask - and it would be unfair to hold a failure to do so against Misbah given so many Asian captains have tried and failed.

My hopes heading into this Australia tour is that we'd compete and win at least one Test.

My expectations has been fulfilled on the former, and hopefully we can fulfil the latter in conditions more favourable to Pakistan at the MCG and SCG.
 
Winning a series in Australia is a tough ask - and it would be unfair to hold a failure to do so against Misbah given so many Asian captains have tried and failed.

My hopes heading into this Australia tour is that we'd compete and win at least one Test.

My expectations has been fulfilled on the former, and hopefully we can fulfil the latter in conditions more favourable to Pakistan at the MCG and SCG.

Sums up my feelings, I expect us to win a Test at the very least and it would be harsh to say Misbah's legacy is tarnished because he has acheived so much for Pakistan cricket.
 
Misbah should have retired after England, he is losing his stocks fast.
 
Win or loose,Misbah should retire after this series.Newcomer should take his place.
 
This is going to be the most disappointing/disheartening overseas loss of the year along with the Edgbaston and the Christchurch Tests because people expect us to build on the moral victory of the Gabba Test and deliver a standout performance. Unfortunately that is not going to happen and Australia will wrap up the series.
 
I don't think this series mars his legacy. We have been so bad in Australia for so long that just playing 15 days of test cricket on this tour will represent progress vs what he have done there over the last two decades
 
And as always it boils down to three catastrophic ways the selectors undermined this team before the series even started:

1. A 42/43 year old at Number 4 and a 42 year old at Number 5.
2. Pakistan's GOAT Batsman in Australia not selected at the age of 32, even though he is in the form of his life.
3. Unselectable right-arm quicks, while the only one competent with the new ball is not in the squad.

1. YK has reportedly said he was born in 1975. So not 42-43 like you claim.

2. Oh please. What a ridiculous way to describe someone like Butt with so few tests in Aus. It's just plain dumb and I can't believe an adult would refer to him that way.

3. Another hideous exaggeration. You either are trolling or really very silly.
 
If they win, not one expert will disagree with the wisdom that the confidence and form of the first test allowed them to win the second test.

It's a bit like that reverse sweep which Younis played and people overly criticised, when he was looking to be proactive and play a shot which has bought hum runs in the hundreds over the course of his career the shot selection wasn't bad then
 
It does not work in Pakistan. As long as you are senior you can keep holding the spot until selectors are really need to force you out.
 
Pakistan is facing lots of problem and YK and MIsbah are not helping by not retiring and neither are selectors. :leo
 
Misbah's legacy was established when he took Pakistan to number one last summer, albeit for 10 mins. Getting whitewashed here won't mar his legacy, but it would certainly expose the team.
 
Misbah's legacy was established when he took Pakistan to number one last summer, albeit for 10 mins. Getting whitewashed here won't mar his legacy, but it would certainly expose the team.

Hey Misbah fans will crucify you for that 10 minutes comment. They would come back with the exact days, minutes and seconds Pakistan held the number one ranking

Conveniently forgetting that it was a fortunate bit of weather that got us there in the first place.

Misbah and his shoddy captaincy has been utterly exposed out of the UAE. I just hope we are able to come back home with some pride intact.
 
Misbah should have seen it coming. He should have retired on a high after the England series.

Our batsmen can cope with English conditions but for some reason they cannot get it together as a unit on Australian pitches in tests and this time they were found wanting in NZ as well (where we had not lost a test series for a long time). However preparation was less than ideal with the only warm-up match being washed out

Although batting exceeded most people's expectations in the second innings at Brisbane, the first innings effort was nothing short of a disgrace. It was a freakish performance in the second innings, the late order contributing with the bat for a change.

Despite Shafiq's heroics, Brisbane defeat was our 10th straight test loss in Australia.

I still expect Australia to win the test series 3-0 (would be glad to be proved wrong) because I just don't think that our players have the temperament or discipline needed to play consistently well over 5 days in Australia. History is against us.
 
Important last day coming up. A draw seems to be the likely outcome but Pakistan always have the ability to even lose from positions of strength. Hopefully we can draw the game and go to Sydney with a chance of squaring the series.
 
Whatever happens in the rest of the series, I think this should be Misbah's last series. There can be little doubt that Misbah has engineered a remarkable period of transformation in Pakistan cricket. He has fashioned this team in his image: industrious, determined and resilient. For so long, Pakistan cricket has been besotted by the word ‘talent’ but in the Misbah era it is ‘character’ which has been at the forefront. Misbah's style has been well suited to this period of Pakistan cricket. He has brought stability and greater sense of organisation. He will be marked as one of Pakistan's most influential cricketers. But looking ahead, there are three reasons why I think the end of the series is a good time for Misbah to be replaced.

Firstly, Pakistan would ideally like to stagger the departures of Misbah and Younis. If both exit at the same time, the batting could have a very inexperienced look to it.

The second reason is, the next Test series will be against the West Indies. This would seem a good series for a new captain to make a start and make his imprint.

Thirdly, whilst Misbah has been a fantastic leader for Pakistan, they may need another leadership style to get the best out of the bowling. Misbah's default position is to contain whenever possible; to stymie the runs rather than looking to get people out. At times this has worked well. But at other times, we have yearned for a bit more imagination and ambition.
 
Back
Top