What's new

Death toll crosses 100 in Gorakhpur tragedy; Critics Cite Oxygen Shortage [Update Post #35]

boomboomcheema

First Class Star
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Runs
3,827
NEW DELHI — Thirty children have died at a public hospital in India over the past two days, with government critics blaming a shortage of oxygen after a supplier of liquid oxygen cut off deliveries because of unpaid bills.

Government officials were scurrying to explain what had happened, admitting that the state-run hospital owed more than $50,000 to a supplier of liquid oxygen and that oxygen supplies had been “disrupted.”

“There was some payment issue to the oxygen supplier, and there was a shortage of liquid oxygen,” said Anil Kumar, the commissioner of the city of Gorakhpur. But, he added, “those deaths were not due to lack of oxygen.”

Other officials said the hospital had a backup oxygen supply, though they did not explain why so many children had died in such a short time. Since Monday, a total of 60 children have died at the hospital, many from acute encephalitis and others in the neonatal unit.

https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/08/...ortage.html?referer=https://www.google.co.in/

So over a 60 Kids dead within a Week.

It's shocking that a country is spending millions on Moon and Mars conquests while Children are dying over non-payment of 50000 USD Bills.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Typical apathy from the bureaucracy. They sit on payments even when funds are available. My icon Yogi ji will surely do something about it after he gets time from testing patriotism of madrassas.
 
I wonder if it's due to corruption or the government really can't afford to provide adequate facilities to the Poor.
 
RIP to the victims hope god gives strength to the family members of the kids.. Extremely sad to hear such news
 
On the issue of shortage of Oxygen gas supply in the hospital, Singh said, "Children haven't died due to disruption of gas supply."

"There was no shortage of oxygen in the hospital. For two hours, there was shortage of emergency cylinders, during which manual resusciation procedure was was carried out," the Health Minister said.

On the issue of shortage of Oxygen gas supply in the hospital, Singh said, "Children haven't died due to disruption of gas supply."

"There was no shortage of oxygen in the hospital. For two hours, there was shortage of emergency cylinders, during which manual resusciation procedure was was carried out," the Health Minister said.

http://www.timesofindia.com/india/g...-principal-suspended/articleshow/60034144.cms

As usual hospital authorities trying to hide their ineptness, They should have at least kept the labor rooms and NCUS clean.
 
That's the value of human life in this country folks..

Value of human life in India depends on the money you have.

Most Government hospitals are horrible. Facilities are poor. Too many patients and too little beds. Most struggling patients rest on bare floors. Inadequate doctors and nurses. Inadequate supplies.

Poor have no choice. They have to go to these hospitals and suffer.

When there are tons of excess people, the value of human life goes down. Many are born dirt poor and die dirt poor.
 
Unfortunate, everything seems pointless when basic health infrastructure is in such situation.
 
Another non issue being hyped by media to clearly malign CM and the state government. He has much more important matters to attend to like formation of anti Romeo squads and gau rakshak dals.
 
Wth were this medical superintendent ,hospital authorities, and the govt were doing in this hospital??? They already knew there was lack of oxygen supply and still...:(
 
Another non issue being hyped by media to clearly malign CM and the state government. He has much more important matters to attend to like formation of anti Romeo squads and gau rakshak dals.

Yes, he should have been checking all oxygen and sanitation supplies in all hospitals and making sure they are refilled on time.
 
What if a rich influencial person's had passed. I'm sure plenty of heads would have rolled. Leken ghareeb ka bacha hai tou koi masla nahi. RIP to the victims.
 
Death toll crosses 70

Gorakhpur hospital deaths: More than 70 children have died since August 7 at the BRD medical college in Gorakhpur, which falls under Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s Lok Sabha constituency. Infections and possible disruption of oxygen supply in the paediatrics ward are being blamed for the death.

Facing intense scrutiny from the Opposition over the Gorakhpur hospital tragedy, the Yogi Adityanath-led BJP government on Saturday sacked Dr. Kafeel Khan as nodal officer for the Department of Pediatrics of Baba Raghav Das Medical College. The latest development comes a day after the state government suspended Rajeev Mishra as college principal for negligence in delaying the release of payment to the supplier of oxygen to the hospital and ordering a magisterial inquiry into the incident.

More than 70 children have died since August 7 at the BRD medical college in Gorakhpur, which falls under Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s Lok Sabha constituency. Infections and possible disruption of oxygen supply in the paediatrics ward are being blamed for the death. However, the hospital and district administration have rejected the contention that inadequate oxygen supply led to the tragedy.

Among ailments, Japanese encephalitis is claimed to be the major reason for the tragedy. Gorkhapur is the worst-affected region in the state due to encephalitis. Although vaccines are available, there is no such vaccine for checking Acute Encephalitis Syndrome and better hygiene is the only way to ward it off.

In the wake of the tragedy, Union Health Minister J P Nadda has announced that the Centre has approved the setting up of a regional medical centre at a cost of Rs 85 crore in Gorakhpur for research into children’s diseases. He said before coming to Gorakhpur he had sanctioned the proposal for a regional medical research centre. “Before coming here, I have approved the establishment of a regional medical research centre in Gorakhpur, at a cost of Rs 85 crore. This institute will conduct research into the infections of children and their possible reasons,” Nadda said, while addressing a press conference along with CM Adityanath.

Earlier in the day, Adityanath called for a full-fledged virus research centre in his constituency. “The geography of east UP is such that we cannot win the war against vector-borne diseases until we have a full-fledged viral research centre. Prime Minister Narendra Modi has given AIIMS, we have started it. But, there should be a full-fledged viral research centre in Gorakhpur,” Adityanath had said. He also warned that exemplary action would be taken against those found responsible for the scores of deaths.

He also warned that exemplary action would be taken against those found responsible for the scores of deaths. I have formed a high-level Committee under the supervision of the Chief Secretary and a thorough probe has been ordered to check the cause of the deaths in the NICU (neonatal intensive care unit) and the supply of oxygen,” he said.

“Let the report of the Committee come… I want to assure you all that not only in Gorakhpur but in any government hospital if there has been any lapse then we will take strict action after the BRD hospital tragedy,” he said.

Nadda also sought to defend the beleaguered CM, saying Adityanath used to raise the issue of Japanese Encephalitis during every session of the Parliament and that this was the first time that the issue was not raised as he was not present.

On Saturday, CM Adityanath stated that a variety of ailments, not a cut in the supply of oxygen, had led to the deaths. He had also blamed the outbreak of Japanese encephalitis on polluted groundwater and lack of cleanliness and personal hygiene.

Addressing mediapersons in Gorakhpur, state Health Minister Sidhartha Nath Singh admitted that the supply of oxygen had fallen in the evening of August 10, but added that the situation had been brought to control within a few hours. “Around 7.30 pm on August 10, the supply of liquid oxygen became low and the meter started beeping but it was met by oxygen cylinders,” Singh said. “But this system worked only until 11.30 pm… Supply through cylinders was not sufficient until about 1.30 am on August 11, but after that supply resumed.”

Arguing that the deaths could not be blamed on the shortage of oxygen, Singh pointed out that none of the deaths took place between 11.30 pm on August 10 and 1.30 am on August 11, when the supply was short. He also claimed that the hospital administration had failed to inform the chief minister about the pending payment to the oxygen supplier during his two visits to the hospital on July 9 and August 9. Despite releasing funds, the hospital had sat on it without reason, he added.

Oxygen firm warned it would cut supply

Pushpa Sales Pvt Limited, the company which supplies liquid oxygen to BRD medical college, had earlier warned the hospital of discontinuing its supply due to non-payment of dues. The company dispatched at least seven reminders from February to August this year, asking the hospital to clear its pending dues.

Speaking to The Indian Express, Deepankar Sharma, the company’s sales manager in Gorakhpur, said they had also sent a legal notice to the hospital administration on July 31, but there was no response. “As per the agreement, payments should be made within 15 days, and the arrears should never exceed Rs 10 lakh. Our payment was due since November 2016, and only two partial payments were released (in May and June). However, we continued to supply oxygen for about nine months on humanitarian grounds. But finally, we did not have enough funds to pay the company from which we source oxygen,” said Sharma, adding that they maintained supply till August 4.

Opposition mounts attack on ruling government, demands CM’s resignation.

Describing the death of infants as “murder”, UP Congress demanded CM Adityanath’s resignation and said if he was unable to handle an institution, how will he run the state. “70 children were murdered in the last four days (since August 10).The state government is responsible for their murder. This government is a killer and I want to ask how many more children will be killed,” UP Congress Committee chief Raj Babbar told reporters.

Insisting that a case of murder should be registered against those who are found guilty, Babbar demanded a compensation of Rs 1 crore each for the victim’s parents. “The chief minister had visited the hospital, but he was not aware about the oxygen crisis. The CM has constituted a probe committee but the government has already said that deaths were not due to shortage of oxygen. Then why a probe?” the UPCC president said. He also criticised Sidharth Nath Singh for terming deaths in August as “routine”.

Reacting to the suspension of Dr Rajeev Mishra, Bahujan Samaj Party chief Mayawati said he was made a “scapegoat” and termed as “irresponsible” the state health minister’s remarks that “many children die” in the month of August every year at this hospital.

Responding to Congress’ allegations, Adityanath said, “This is not the time to indulge in politics, but to show sensitivity. And sensitivity is in finding an answer to vector-borne diseases and eradicating them.

“When Ghulam Nabi Azad was the Union health minister, he had said that he cannot do anything (about Japanese encephalitis in Gorakhpur) since health is a state subject. People whose sensitivity has died, are now unnecessarily rubbing salt to wounds by raising a sensitive issue,” the chief minister said.

http://indianexpress.com/article/in...acked-as-pressure-mounts-on-yogi-govt-4795206
 
Last edited:
Wth were this medical superintendent ,hospital authorities, and the govt were doing in this hospital??? They already knew there was lack of oxygen supply and still...:(

JE has a very high mortality rate.The focus should be on prevention of JE.I am sure you would have read about JE prevelance in Eastern UP in PSM.No one has tried to put a effective prevention programme.
 
Its ridiculous.....
opposition blaming Govt and in response govt reminding them how many children died when opposition was in control....
politics is important, human life has no value
 
Its ridiculous.....
opposition blaming Govt and in response govt reminding them how many children died when opposition was in control....
politics is important, human life has no value

Opposition was in power for 15 years and govt is in power for 3 months.Yet no one tried to put up a prevention programme for JE.
 
JE has a very high mortality rate.The focus should be on prevention of JE.I am sure you would have read about JE prevelance in Eastern UP in PSM.No one has tried to put a effective prevention programme.

JE is endemic in Alappuzha district were i studied. Still they report death of elderly people because of this flavi viridae group. But neonatal encephalitis has been largely prevented because of the vaccine that we give there. This is our immunisation schedule.

IMG_20170814_161828_978.JPG
 
While i dont agree with doctors being blamed for this incident.The Principal and this incharge are very dodgy person.

I had my reservations too but hearing these AIIMS officials concern, i too feel that they are made the scapegoat for this while a lot of others made money. No one can be trusted tbh.
 
JE is endemic in Alappuzha district were i studied. Still they report death of elderly people because of this flavi viridae group. But neonatal encephalitis has been largely prevented because of the vaccine that we give there. This is our immunisation schedule.

View attachment 75803

Preventive measures of JE in UP is very poor.Every year 100s of neonates die.
 
Amit shah about this tragedy;

Congress ka kaam hai isteefa maangna. Itne bade desh mein bahut saare haadse hue, pehli baar aisa haadsa nahi hua hai.:facepalm:
 
Preventive measures of JE in UP is very poor.Every year 100s of neonates die.

That's different topic for discussion tbh. Here death was accelerated because of lack of Oxygen which was hospital authorities and govt's mistake. The contractor of oxygen supplier have informed them prior with notice about the debt they have created.
 
If any of those patients families can afford better medical care, they need to get the hell out of Government hospitals.
 
Opposition was in power for 15 years and govt is in power for 3 months.Yet no one tried to put up a prevention programme for JE.

How long has been Yogi elected from Gorakhpur?? There is MP fund which can be donated to these hospitals. You can't blame it on previous govt's alone.
 
If any of those patients families can afford better medical care, they need to get the hell out of Government hospitals.

I am not boasting here but Kerala's infant mortality rate is close to some european nations. Do you think majority of us goes only to private hospitals?? Our Public health workers have played a major role in helping the poor and downtroddens..
 
Unless Government tackles the root cause of the encephalitis, these kinds of incidents keep on happening. Government hospitals are terrible and ill equipped to treat thousands of patients who visit them and many of them in critical conditions.

When will the open drainages (clogged) be tackled? This is 2017 and I still see ope drainages and people throwing plastic bottles and trash in drainages. Ideal breeding grounds for mosquitoes. But hey, people curse the Government when a mosquitoes bite them.

There is no city planning. Illegal constructions, houses encroaching roads and effectively blocking drainages.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">More than 100 children have died at a public hospital in northern India - Here's why: <a href="https://t.co/qSkvhYYnmD">https://t.co/qSkvhYYnmD</a> <a href="https://t.co/N23jfAQ0JI">pic.twitter.com/N23jfAQ0JI</a></p>— BBC News Asia (@BBCNewsAsia) <a href="https://twitter.com/BBCNewsAsia/status/898009597587410944">August 17, 2017</a></blockquote>
<script async src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Back
Top