What's new

"Ian Chappell should first give advice to Steve Smith on how to avoid whitewashes in Asia" : Misbah

Abdullah719

T20I Captain
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Runs
44,825
"Ian Chappell should first give advice to Steve Smith on how to avoid whitewashes in Asia" : Misbah

Karachi, Jan 14 (PTI) Pakistan Test captain Misbah-ul-Haq has come down heavily on former Australian skipper Ian Chappell for advising Cricket Australia to think twice before inviting Pakistan to tour Down Under again, saying the Aussies also don't perform well in the sub-continent or even in UAE.

"It is a very irresponsible and useless statement from him. Does it mean that Australia who have been whitewashed by a young team in Sri Lanka, in India and even in the UAE by Pakistan should not be invited to tour Asian countries," Misbah, who returned home from Australia, said.

"I think he should first give some advice to his captain Steve Smith on how to avoid whitewashes in Asia and then worry about us. Every team faces problems outside their country," he added.

Misbah, who has led Pakistan in Tests since late 2010, also felt that some of the criticisms were not justified.

"One should not forget this team has been doing well for the last six years and every team has to lose or go through a bad patch sometime. It has happened to us, we have struggled in New Zealand and Australia. But it does not mean we don't have a good team or we have not performed well in the last few years," he said.

"I think there are those critics who are genuinely disappointed at our defeats in Australia and with my form.

They care about our performances. But there are also some critics who were just not happy with our becoming the number one Test side and are now venting heir anger on the team."

Misbah also he would think hard before taking a decision on his retirement.

"I have two months to take a decision on my retirement. I had reacted emotionally because of the disappointment of losing the Melbourne Test but after a while I thought about it and also played the third Test in Sydney. One thing is for sure I want to go out gracefully and with good memories," he told the urdu website of BBC.

The skipper said he himself was very disappointed with Pakistan losing to Australia and about his own form.

"I felt helpless as I have always believed that a good leader always sets the trend for his players. I couldn't do that in Australia despite my best efforts and that really saddened me a lot.

"I think every player goes through a phase of bad form when nothing goes right for him and this has a bearing on his shot selection which leads to his downfall. But one has to fight through it and live with it. I am very disappointed at losing the Test series in Australia and not performing as I had very high hopes from myself and the team," Misbah said.

http://www.ptinews.com/news/8289795_Misbah-hits-back-at-Chappell-s-comments-.html

Pakistan's Misbah wants better planning for Australia cricket tours

Pakistan's Test captain Misbah-ul-Haq Saturday urged the country's cricket authorities to plan extensively for future tours to Australia to end a long losing streak.

Pakistan's Misbah-led team were beaten 3-0 in a Test series last week, their fourth successive whitewash in Australia since 1999.

The defeat prompted former Australia captain Ian Chappell to advise Cricket Australia (CA) to consider before inviting Pakistan again on future tours.

"CA have got to start saying 'listen if things don't improve we will stop with the invites. You can't bowl, have conservative field placings and field sloppily and expect to play decent cricket in Australia," Chappell said.

Misbah said Pakistan should prepare their teams before tough tours to Australia.

"The most important thing is to prepare a good team for the Australia tour, which is always tough," Misbah told AFP. "We go there after five or six years and most of the players are not used to it, which is tough on them."

Pakistan were drubbed 3-0 in Australia in 1999, 2004 and 2010. On their last tour they also lost five one-day matches and a Twenty20 international.

They are again facing the prospect of another all-defeat tour after going down by 92 runs in the first of five one-day internationals on Friday.

Misbah said the Pakistan Cricket Board should send teams to Australia on a regular basis.

"Tours to Australia, South Africa and England need proper planning, like we did before the England tour and results were good," said Misbah of his team's 2-2 drawn series in England last year.

That result briefly lifted Pakistan to the world number one spot in Test rankings.

Misbah said scheduling was also important before each tour Down Under.

"Like we went to England some 20 days before, the same should be done for the Australia tour, we must play two to three side games so that we can understand what combinations should be played and how to play in those conditions."

Misbah said he does not fear any backlash from CA.

"What (Ian) Chappell said was unwarranted and uncalled for and doesn't suit a cricketer of his stature," he said.

"Australia get whitewashed on the subcontinent on a regular basis, then they should also not travel there?" he added.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/wires/af...-better-planning-Australia-cricket-tours.html
 
Last edited:
Damn, shots fired ! Good comments, that condescending old bore Chappell deserves it.

Asian teams shouldn't have to face this nonsense from Western teams when their own touring records in Asia are abysmal.
 
desperation seems so evident in Misbah's last few days. First attacked the 99 Pak team and now Chappell. well done gentleman.
 
"I think every player goes through a phase of bad form when nothing goes right for him and this has a bearing on his shot selection which leads to his downfall. But one has to fight through it and live with it. I am very disappointed at losing the Test series in Australia and not performing as I had very high hopes from myself and the team," Misbah said.

lmao so he is definitely staying. This quote sounds like coming from a 26 years old batsman who is having tough time in his career not from someone who has to decide when to retire.
 
Captain coming to defense of his team, how it should be.
Check Chappell's twitter, after seeing that I have zero respect for him.
 
desperation seems so evident in Misbah's last few days. First attacked the 99 Pak team and now Chappell. well done gentleman.

He didn't attack 99 team, don't distort facts.
 
Tbf to Chappell he did say the same for Australia and their tours to Asia.
 
Well done misbah . You have done excellent job as a player and as a team men .we as a nation are proud of you. Mard e buhraan of pakistan.
 
He didn't attack 99 team, don't distort facts.

مصباح الحق نے موجودہ ٹیم کا 1999 کی ٹیم سے موازنہ کرنے پر ہونے والی تنقید کی وضاحت کرتے ہوئے کہا کہ ان سے یہ سوال کیا گیا تھا کہ کیا موجودہ پاکستانی ٹیم آسٹریلیا کا دورہ کرنے والی سب سے مضبوط ٹیم ہے تو انھوں نے سادہ لفظوں میں یہ جواب دیا تھا کہ ان کے خیال میں1999 میں آسٹریلیا کا دورہ کرنے والی ٹیم سب سے مضبوط ٹیم تھی۔ انھوں نے قطعاً یہ نہیں کہا تھا کہ ننانوے کی ٹیم بھی تو ہاری تھی تو ہم پر کیوں تنقید ہورہی ہے۔​

http://www.bbc.com/urdu/sport-38611384

Rough translation from the article:
Misbah said that he was asked about whether this current team is the strongest to have toured Australia - he responded in simple words, saying that the 1999 team to tour Australia was the strongest. He certainly didn't mean to say that the 99 team lost too so we should get a free pass.
 
Chappell is an honest man he cares about Pakistan cricket hence his criticism should be taken positively he's absolutely justified in his comments on the abysmal condition of Pak cricket and poor captaincy of Misbah who has been thoroughly exposed. Seems Misbah is used to having media fawning over him and self-glorification through PR team so when the reality finally got exposed he can't handle it gracefully. Not only did he make a mockery of himself by taking a u-turn in the middle of the tournament he has continuously failed as a captain. Misbah is noway near Steve Smith as a batsman. Time for a reality check. if you can't perform on the field then better keep quiet. So Misbah instead of giving rejoinders and pointing fingers at potential ATG look in the mirror and prove yourself in the ground.
 
He is basically saying he will not retire yet. You know when your cricket is a joke when a 42 year old is still thinking about retirement. :91:

Afridi literally had to be dropped after enduring a 2 years of absolute medicore horror show with bat and ball. We can't keep losing because players want to retire 'gracefully'.

Misbah why don't you score 10,000 runs and then maybe you can get a 'graceful' exit. Take your 5000 runs and 42 year old self and retire.
 
Chappel didn't say anything wrong. Australia has not been swept 4 series in a row in any Asian country. Also, unlike Pakistan, they're competitive in ODIs everywhere, Pakistan has been thrashed in that format as well.

Why is he treating all Asian countries as one? Chappell didn't say anything about Pakistan being invited to other non-Asian countries. It's understandable why Misbah is crying. He basically has no answer after his embarrassing on-field and batting performance.

Furthermore, "gentleman" still thinking about retirement. We were told he'd retire as soon as that plane lands.
 
The usual Misbah haters are at it again. Good on him for sticking up for the team.
 
Misbah is right.

What has Aus done in UAE, India, Sri Lanka recently?

Sure Pak got whitewashed in New Zealand and Australia, but we managed a draw in England. That is no small accomplishment in this era of home track bullies.

Pakistan have nothing to be ashamed of, if you put things into context (i.e comparing to all other teams touring away from home). The only thing in recent memory Pakistan should be embarrassed about is the Zimbabwe test match they lost.

Other than that, winning and losing is part of the game.

Our fans just have unrealistic expectations expecting Pakistan to compete in Australia, when Australia couldn't compete in UAE.

People still talking about Warner smashing our "trundlers", do you guys even remember the thrashing Misbah gave to Aussie bowlers in UAE?
 
Great response from Misbah. :))

Expected some bitter comments on this thread as usual from his haters—and voila.
 
Only excuses:

Is it fair to blame bowlers, if batting collapse happens every match?
Okay, winning need 20 wickets, but good batting alone can draw matches. And you lost all.

You even did not try to touch the topic of your ridiculous field placing.

Regarding, shot selection, you played two balls and same shot and you yourself has a big role in collapses.

Pakistan has not won any match in Australia in decades , however Australia won few in Pakistan during same period. You even failed to understand Ian's argument. He was was talking about Pakistani team and not about team under Misbah or Smith.

Extremely over rated player who has become an obstacle for the progress of team.
 
Last edited:
I must say that i would be more concerned about the current Aus team getting whitewashed everywhere in Asia, than different Pak teams losing all the matches to Aus in Aus over the years!
 
Misbah has attacked the Australian team because of remarks made by Chappelli.

Would have been better if he had of attacked Chappelli and left the Australian team out of it especially Smith. Misbah has no reason to bring the Australian team into it at all, no one from the Australian camp have made any comments about the Pakistan team not being invited to play in Australia and good form from Misbah would be to retract his comments about the Australian team.
 
Misbah has attacked the Australian team because of remarks made by Chappelli.

Would have been better if he had of attacked Chappelli and left the Australian team out of it especially Smith. Misbah has no reason to bring the Australian team into it at all, no one from the Australian camp have made any comments about the Pakistan team not being invited to play in Australia and good form from Misbah would be to retract his comments about the Australian team.

He wasn't attacking the Aussie team. He was merely pointing out Chappell should think about Aus performing away from home before wondering if Pakistan is not good enough to travel.

Fair enough by Misbah esp since Pakistan competed better than Aus have been competing in Asia/UAE.
 
Why is Misbah still 'thinking' about retirement? He should realize his time is up... he is 42.... :facepalm:
 
Misbah has attacked the Australian team because of remarks made by Chappelli.

Would have been better if he had of attacked Chappelli and left the Australian team out of it especially Smith. Misbah has no reason to bring the Australian team into it at all, no one from the Australian camp have made any comments about the Pakistan team not being invited to play in Australia and good form from Misbah would be to retract his comments about the Australian team.

Attacked ? He has merely used the Aussie teams performances in Asia(Just as Chappelli did ) to turn the tables on him.

Well done Misbah ... good response. Knowing how stubborn Chappelli is ... I dont expect him to back down at all.
 
Superb response from King Misbah as usual. Defending his teamand their honour, admitting his faults and a fair and balanced viewpoint as usual.

It will be a huge loss when he goes.
 
Looks like Chappell is more sincere with future of Pakistan cricket, how come Misbah did not expect any criticism after leading us this humiliation in cricketing world. He better keep quite and when he speaks again, only to announce his retirement.
 
He is basically saying he will not retire yet. You know when your cricket is a joke when a 42 year old is still thinking about retirement. :91:

Afridi literally had to be dropped after enduring a 2 years of absolute medicore horror show with bat and ball. We can't keep losing because players want to retire 'gracefully'.

Misbah why don't you score 10,000 runs and then maybe you can get a 'graceful' exit. Take your 5000 runs and 42 year old self and retire.

But sir, I thought you wanted Mukhtar Ahmed to open?
 
Why him and some people club all Asian countries into one? Chappell is merely stating Pakistan's atrocious record in Australia over the years. Have been whitewashed in every series for like 20 years. Despite Australia's awful record in Asia in recent years, they haven't really been as bad as Pakistan over the course of a long period in single country.
 
Why him and some people club all Asian countries into one? Chappell is merely stating Pakistan's atrocious record in Australia over the years. Have been whitewashed in every series for like 20 years. Despite Australia's awful record in Asia in recent years, they haven't really been as bad as Pakistan over the course of a long period in single country.

And what should concern chappel more? the current aus team losing all the matches in Asia, or different Pak team losing all its matches over the years in Aus?
 
And what should concern chappel more? the current aus team losing all the matches in Asia, or different Pak team losing all its matches over the years in Aus?

Experts do criticize teams for not performing. If Australia failed in India, you will have your chance, at the moment listen what Chappell is saying and we should learn from our mistakes.
 
So much for being a "gentleman",everytime he is under the pump he makes stupid statement,throw him out of the team like yk in odis and he will make even more fuss.
Only in pakistan a rubbish player can captains and plays for years for being a "gentleman".
 
So much for being a "gentleman",everytime he is under the pump he makes stupid statement,throw him out of the team like yk in odis and he will make even more fuss.
Only in pakistan a rubbish player can captains and plays for years for being a "gentleman".

And the selectors are waiting for him to retire and not simply showing him the door. No one retires in Pakistan, if we leave it to Misbah, he will continue to play 10 more years and beyond.
 
Experts do criticize teams for not performing. If Australia failed in India, you will have your chance, at the moment listen what Chappell is saying and we should learn from our mistakes.

WE? Aus fared extremely poorly against Misbah's men in UAE, and he had the right to respond to him, he doesn't need to wait till Aus get thrashed by India for a response.
 
WE? Aus fared extremely poorly against Misbah's men in UAE, and he had the right to respond to him, he doesn't need to wait till Aus get thrashed by India for a response.

that same side thrashed Misbah's ODI team 3-0 and T20 team 2-0 you do remember that? Aus has been very very competitive in ODIs and T20s in Asian conditions. tests they are in a rebuilding phase.
 
Misbah has attacked the Australian team because of remarks made by Chappelli.

Would have been better if he had of attacked Chappelli and left the Australian team out of it especially Smith. Misbah has no reason to bring the Australian team into it at all, no one from the Australian camp have made any comments about the Pakistan team not being invited to play in Australia and good form from Misbah would be to retract his comments about the Australian team.

Chappell also attacked Pakistan by saying they should stop touring unless they improve. Both Chappell and Misbah are in the wrong here
 
Why him and some people club all Asian countries into one? Chappell is merely stating Pakistan's atrocious record in Australia over the years. Have been whitewashed in every series for like 20 years. Despite Australia's awful record in Asia in recent years, they haven't really been as bad as Pakistan over the course of a long period in single country.

If Australia only went to Asia once every six or seven years then their record wouldn't be that much better than Pakistan in Australia. If Australia didn't go to England constantly for the Ashes they'd regularly get battered like India.

Australia (and other non-Asian teams) have the benefit of playing a decent number of games in subcontinental conditions because there are four test nations who play in somewhat similar conditions and they still got humiliated beyond belief in Asia.
 
Misbah has attacked the Australian team because of remarks made by Chappelli.

Would have been better if he had of attacked Chappelli and left the Australian team out of it especially Smith. Misbah has no reason to bring the Australian team into it at all, no one from the Australian camp have made any comments about the Pakistan team not being invited to play in Australia and good form from Misbah would be to retract his comments about the Australian team.

Toughen up mate. Misbah just pointed out to the hypocrisy in Chappel's statement. I'm sure Smith understands it wasn't targeted at him.
 
Chappell also attacked Pakistan by saying they should stop touring unless they improve. Both Chappell and Misbah are in the wrong here

Chappell is paid to say controversial things, to provoke a response, to get people reading his stories, I'm suprised Misbah felt the need to even give more oxygen to Chappelli's drivel.
 
that same side thrashed Misbah's ODI team 3-0 and T20 team 2-0 you do remember that? Aus has been very very competitive in ODIs and T20s in Asian conditions. tests they are in a rebuilding phase.

We here are talking about test cricket, do you know that? Test is a different ball game, and we all know Pak are rubbish in onedayer!
 
Toughen up mate. Misbah just pointed out to the hypocrisy in Chappel's statement. I'm sure Smith understands it wasn't targeted at him.

Well then Misbah is going to spend his entire life fighting hypocrisy in the media, is that the job of Pakistans captain or do double standards come into play and he only points it out when its an Australian Journalist. LOL :)
 
Well then Misbah is going to spend his entire life fighting hypocrisy in the media, is that the job of Pakistans captain or do double standards come into play and he only points it out when its an Australian Journalist. LOL :)

Agree with you. Misbah can very well avoid such statements but now that he has said I don't think he owes any apology to anyone.
 
As usual our players never accept their shortcoming and involve in arguments. Instead concentrate with your performance, team selection and strategy preferably retirement
 
Disappointed with Misbah.

You are known to be the guy who is above these things.

Never enter a battle that others are fighting for you.
 
Back to back Spirit of Cricket awards would have been nice, don't see it happening now. :facepalm:
 
Misbah bhai for the first time reacting to criticism, some of this critcism is justified, and Misbah I think took it a little too heart, he has been in very poor form, and in the wrong end of his career.. he should've retired out gracefully, he doesn't look fit to carry on and his body language showed he wasn't enjoying his cricket
 
I think Misbah prepared really well for the England tour since he was contemplating retirement before that, but then we overperformed from our abilities, and that made him a country and cricketing hero for Pakistan and the world.. for the first time since England series Misbah actually accepted the praise and sort of relaxed on his achievements and laurels, that lead to him losing his form a little bit, he took the WI series lightly, and by the time NZ and Aus tours came about our team lacked the passion to play well.. hence even after Misbah tried his best he couldn't regain the level he was at in the England series.. he said it himself you have to forget past mistakes but past glories too.. I think he didn't forget the glory in the England series and relaxed for a bit.. (that can happen in a sportsman career) but he wants to go out on a high...

However this move could actually dampen the legacy that he created for himself.. because some mouths are starting to mumble about his form and age.. there will be a backlash if he isn't able to win this time
 
Excellent comment from Misbah. The Chappells have never been too bright.
 
Damn, shots fired ! Good comments, that condescending old bore Chappell deserves it.

Asian teams shouldn't have to face this nonsense from Western teams when their own touring records in Asia are abysmal.

Actually, Australia is an Eastern team, so is New Zealand
 
Take that bata chappal in the face, great comments from Misbah. Why should it be one set of rules for them and another for us

Some of these Aussies are deluded big time
 
Back
Top