What's new

Iran's border security forces allegedly massacre 'dozens' of Afghan migrants

Champ_Pal

ODI Debutant
Joined
Mar 3, 2022
Runs
10,596
Taliban authorities are looking into allegations that dozens of Afghan civilians were killed and injured by Iranian border forces while trying to enter that country from Pakistan illegally.

Hamdullah Fitrat, the deputy Taliban spokesperson in Kabul, said Wednesday that "various governmental bodies" and Afghan diplomatic missions have initiated "comprehensive investigations" to verify the reported casualties.

“As the incident is reported to have occurred beyond Afghanistan’s borders, the available information remains unverified,” Fitrat noted in his English-language statement posted on social media platform X. He added that a “conclusive decision” would be made after a “thorough clarification of the facts.”

The Taliban probe was announced after an Iranian rights group, known as Halvash, initially reported the alleged Afghan casualties, saying they occurred Sunday in Iran’s Sistan-Baluchistan border province.

The organization quoted survivors as saying that about 300 Afghan migrants were attempting to enter Iran unlawfully when they were assaulted by Iranian border guards, resulting in deaths and injuries.

“As of now, reliable sources confirm that the news about the deaths of dozens of illegal citizens at the Saravan border is not true," Hassan Kazemi Qomi, Iran’s special presidential envoy for and ambassador to Kabul, said in a Persian language statement on X.

He referred to an Iranian region adjacent to Washuk, a border district in Pakistan’s southwestern sparsely populated Baluchistan province.

Qomi emphasized, however, that responding “legally” to the “illegal entry of unauthorized nationals” was “the legitimate right of countries, and the border guards of any country are obliged to prevent the entry of illegal nationals.”

The Iranian envoy wrote that “managing border traffic is a shared responsibility, and neighboring countries must prevent unauthorized” crossings in line with their international border security obligations. Qomi reiterated that Tehran is determined to return undocumented asylum-seekers and deal sternly with illegal border crossers.

“I'm seriously concerned about reports of injuries & deaths of Afghans in Iran's #Saravan border area and I call for authorities to investigate transparently,” Richard Bennett, the United Nations special rapporteur on the human rights situation in Afghanistan, said on X. “Clarity is urgently needed. These reports don't stand in isolation. More dignity & safety is needed for Afghans worldwide,” Bennett wrote.

Residents in the Pakistani border district of Washuk also reported the alleged Iranian assault on Afghan migrants, but they could not provide specific casualty details, citing the remoteness of the border area.

Pakistani provincial authorities did not immediately comment on the alleged incident.

Iran and Pakistan together host millions of documented and undocumented Afghan refugees. Both countries have deported hundreds of thousands of undocumented individuals back to Afghanistan since the Taliban seized power three years ago.

According to the International Organization for Migration, the deportations continue daily, and almost 100,000 Afghans returned home from Pakistan and Iran in September alone.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
"owever, the Islamic Republic’s special representative for Afghanistan denied the shooting."

Unless its confirmed, not worth discussing.

Do not try to enter a land illegally, some may put you on a boat others may shoot you.

Iran is in a state of war atm, its understandable they will be protective over their borders esp from Afghanistan where thousands who worked for Nato are still present.
 
Wouldn’t they be better served going India?
I can guarantee that India will not shoot them and kill dozens like Iran did.

Goes to show that Iran only supports Palestinians because of their hate for Israel. Not love for fellow Muslims of the world.
 
"owever, the Islamic Republic’s special representative for Afghanistan denied the shooting."

Unless its confirmed, not worth discussing.

Do not try to enter a land illegally, some may put you on a boat others may shoot you.

Iran is in a state of war atm, its understandable they will be protective over their borders esp from Afghanistan where thousands who worked for Nato are still present.
Lets give the benefit of doubt to Iran. (y)
 
T
I can guarantee that India will not shoot them and kill dozens like Iran did.

Goes to show that Iran only supports Palestinians because of their hate for Israel. Not love for fellow Muslims of the world.
As harsh as it may sound…Thats the only language some of them understand. Pakistan hosted them and learned that.
 
I can guarantee that India will not shoot them and kill dozens like Iran did.

Goes to show that Iran only supports Palestinians because of their hate for Israel. Not love for fellow Muslims of the world.

Which was the real point of this thread right?
 
T

As harsh as it may sound…Thats the only language some of them understand. Pakistan hosted them and learned that.
Brutal.

Imagine if Indian BSF does the same to Rohingya. This board will have a collective meltdown.
 
T

As harsh as it may sound…Thats the only language some of them understand. Pakistan hosted them and learned that.
No human being should be killed for trying to seek a better life man.

They could be arrested and deported not shot at.

I hope this incident is not true.
 
"owever, the Islamic Republic’s special representative for Afghanistan denied the shooting."

Unless its confirmed, not worth discussing.

Do not try to enter a land illegally, some may put you on a boat others may shoot you.

Iran is in a state of war atm, its understandable they will be protective over their borders esp from Afghanistan where thousands who worked for Nato are still present.

So its OK for iran to protects its borders

But not pakistan we must not have border checks , visas , passports on afghan border no custom checks on borders and free movement army must leave its own soil in kpk and balochistan they should not be allowed to provide security to chinses and workers in companies but allow them to be murdered.

That's what pti and its ethnofascist demanded alongside resettlement of ttp

Imagine if pakistan army did this what the bot team would do on the Internet and subsequent riots and protests they would cause in pakistan our border would probably be invaded by taliban looking for revenge .
 
owever, the Islamic Republic’s special representative for Afghanistan denied the shooting."

Of course they would the videos are there of rows of Afghans killed online

They only can bark and attack pakistan only if our security forces had a similar policy like the iranians and central asian countries when it comes to afghanistan
 
So its OK for iran to protects its borders

But not pakistan we must not have border checks , visas , passports on afghan border no custom checks on borders and free movement army must leave its own soil in kpk and balochistan they should not be allowed to provide security to chinses and workers in companies but allow them to be murdered.

That's what pti and its ethnofascist demanded alongside resettlement of ttp

Imagine if pakistan army did this what the bot team would do on the Internet and subsequent riots and protests they would cause in pakistan our border would probably be invaded by taliban looking for revenge .

If Pakistan was at threat from Israel and US bombings or assassinations on a regular basis they should also shoot any illegals who enter while running in.

However Pakistan(currently) is a puppet of USA, it has no such worries atm.
 
Wouldn’t they be better served going India?
Have you a seen an atlas, map, geography or are you familiar with how demographics are scattered in this region? You know Afghanistan has a border with Iran and technically no border with India as the Durand line goes through disputed Gilgit region.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Have you a seen an atlas, map, geography or are you familiar with how demographics are scattered in this region? You know Afghanistan has a border with Iran and technically no border with India as the Durand line goes through disputed Gilgit region.

Yet to find someone on the forum who argues on actual logic than rhetoric.
Please use some logic yourself.

Indians can cross seas to migrate to USA so I'm Afghans could cross into India if they liked.

However It's likely Iran wasn't their destination and they wanted to go via Iran to Europe.
 
Have you a seen an atlas, map, geography or are you familiar with how demographics are scattered in this region? You know Afghanistan has a border with Iran and technically no border with India as the Durand line goes through disputed Gilgit region.

Yet to find someone on the forum who argues on actual logic than rhetoric.
They will find a way, no map, atlas etc required
 
Please use some logic yourself.

Indians can cross seas to migrate to USA so I'm Afghans could cross into India if they liked.

However It's likely Iran wasn't their destination and they wanted to go via Iran to Europe.

Do you understand the difference between migration and immigration?

Also parts of Iran has people of the same religion and ethnicity, on top of that a shared border. Why would they go through a disputed territory like Gil Git, enter a disputed territory like Kashmir or
Migrate to India or would you think it is easy to cross the border into Iran.

Also sure some Indians immigrate illegally but so do loads of Pakistan like the news we heard recently from Saudi Arabia and the whole Dunki route is not limited to Indians. So unless you want to steer this to your favorite topic of anti-Indian rhetoric that was an extremely dumb point.

We can pick up this topic in another thread if it means so much to you.
 
Back
Top