What's new

Is Pakistan lucky to have India as their neighbour and not Israel?

R

Rajdeep

ODI Debutant
Joined
Jan 26, 2020
Runs
11,013
Post of the Week
1
Both Israel and India face similar threats, particularly from non-state actors operating with varying degrees of support or tolerance from neighbouring countries. India is largely defensive and reactive, with selective offensive actions where as Israel conducts Proactive & pre-emptive strikes, often offensive.

So the question is - does Pakistan considers themselves lucky to have peaceful neighbour like India?

Will the condition of Lahore and Karachi be same as Gaza Strip if Israel was immediate neighbour of Pakistan?

Discuss

@IAJ @Bhaijaan

:kp
 
To be honest, Israel would have never been this hostile if she had a nuclear neighbor. Another thing is that if Palestine had Pakistan's resources then they would have been Russia to Israel (Ukraine).
 
If Indian neighborhoods can’t keep peace among themselves, with religious riots, caste clashes, political mob violence, how exactly is the nation supposed to project itself as a “peaceful neighbor” to others?

It’s like claiming you’re a great roommate when you can’t even stop fighting with your own family in the next room.

Hindutva dimwit thread.
 
So you got your wish in the end lol.

If you think and believe Pakistan is behind what is happening in India, do you also acknowlegde India's role in Balochistan for instance?

And I don't think Israel would dare to take on Pakistan just like that. One thing is to bomb poor Palestinians, but to take on a nuclear power is a different ball-game.
 
One thing common between India and Israel is their support for terrorism in their enemy countries, while pretending to be the greatest victims of terror and whatnot. At least for India the mask has slipped in the recent past, while for Israel the mask slipped in other ways.
 
Only some posters know the real story behind what happened to the original thread and how it hit some nerves. So I dont mind if others are finding it dimwit thread :kp


However, lets discuss on this reign down (PG) version of OP.

I think the nuclear threat would not have worked with Israel.

Lets think of a hypothetical scenario of Pahalgam type attack and if Israel was there in India's place. What could be their reaction? I think the following:
  • Israel would have likely responded within 12-24 hours
  • Would have conducted air strikes deep inside Pakistan, including in communication hubs linked to ISI
  • Targeted assassinations of key terrorist leaders using drones or undercover operatives.
  • Cyberattacks on Pakistan’s military communication networks.
  • Mossad likely to expose links between terrorists and their akas to the global press.
  • Israel would present its evidence upfront to allies (U.S., EU) but would not wait for international approval.
  • It would frame the retaliation as self-defense under Article 51 of the UN Charter.
  • Likely U.S. support, muted European concern, and sharp criticism from OIC and China.
  • Israel may target high-value infrastructure (radars, ammunition dumps, etc.) without warning.
  • Pakistan's use of nuclear threats would be taken seriously but might not deter surgical escalation.
 
Rajdeep said:
Only some posters know the real story behind what happened to the original thread and how it hit some nerves. So I dont mind if others are finding it dimwit thread :kp


However, lets discuss on this reign down (PG) version of OP.

I think the nuclear threat would not have worked with Israel.

Lets think of a hypothetical scenario of Pahalgam type attack and if Israel was there in India's place. What could be their reaction? I think the following:
  • Israel would have likely responded within 12-24 hours
  • Would have conducted air strikes deep inside Pakistan, including in communication hubs linked to ISI
  • Targeted assassinations of key terrorist leaders using drones or undercover operatives.
  • Cyberattacks on Pakistan’s military communication networks.
  • Mossad likely to expose links between terrorists and their akas to the global press.
  • Israel would present its evidence upfront to allies (U.S., EU) but would not wait for international approval.
  • It would frame the retaliation as self-defense under Article 51 of the UN Charter.
  • Likely U.S. support, muted European concern, and sharp criticism from OIC and China.
  • Israel may target high-value infrastructure (radars, ammunition dumps, etc.) without warning.
  • Pakistan's use of nuclear threats would be taken seriously but might not deter surgical escalation.
Click to expand...
Before having delusions of grandeur, you should ask what they have done against Iran all these years. This is the country they claim is behind all these groups. And Iran doesn't even have nuclear weapons.
 
IAJ said:
So you got your wish in the end lol.

If you think and believe Pakistan is behind what is happening in India, do you also acknowlegde India's role in Balochistan for instance?

And I don't think Israel would dare to take on Pakistan just like that. One thing is to bomb poor Palestinians, but to take on a nuclear power is a different ball-game.
Click to expand...
Even Pakistan don't believe India is behind Balochistan. :yk

I hear it mostly from posters here. Pakistan's real issue with India is Kashmir and not Balochistan. Your defense minister openly admits on television of harbouring terrorist's and doing dirty work for USA for last 3 decades. So blaming India for Balochistan will not work.

Lets stick to the topic to this specific thread and pls dnt derail. :inti


Do you think Pakistan is lucky to have a peaceful neighbour as India as opposed to revengeful merciless beasts like Israel who manage to defeat entire Arab world in 5 days war?
 
Rajdeep said:
Even Pakistan don't believe India is behind Balochistan. :yk

I hear it mostly from posters here. Pakistan's real issue with India is Kashmir and not Balochistan. Your defense minister openly admits on television of harbouring terrorist's and doing dirty work for USA for last 3 decades. So blaming India for Balochistan will not work.

Lets stick to the topic to this specific thread and pls dnt derail. :inti


Do you think Pakistan is lucky to have a peaceful neighbour as India as opposed to revengeful merciless beasts like Israel who manage to defeat entire Arab world in 5 days war?
Click to expand...
Your arguments are mostly very weak, and you seem to have a short memory, or at least you give that impression. I have already informed you of Pakistan's official stance on the attacks in Balochistan. Anyway, let's move on.

As I mentioned in the first thread, which was removed, I just want both countries to live in peace because we, as keyboard warriors in our comfortable homes, won't suffer; it's the people living there who will have to deal with this.

And when you talk about Israel like that, what assumptions are you making? Israel as it is today in terms of size and population, or an Israel with India's population and geographical size? I don't see Israel as a real threat to Pakistan. Really no match for Pakistan.
 
Israel would have attacked on pakistan Nuclear site when they were developing it . :kp
 
Devadwal said:
Israel would have attacked on pakistan Nuclear site when they were developing it . :kp
Click to expand...
You are aware that they tried? I know bakhts are generally down to 2 brain cells, so you have to be spoonfed all information.
 
ahsan17 said:
You are aware that they tried? I know bakhts are generally down to 2 brain cells, so you have to be spoonfed all information.
Click to expand...
You're a Islamist so you don't know that this thread is hypnotical where Israel is a pakistan neighbour .😂 :kp
 
The OP is suggesting 10 million people from a tiny land are braver and stronger than 1 billion Indians. lol.

If Pak was next to Israel, the Zionist Europeans squatters would be back in Germany or Poland by now.
 
Like picking between drowning in a river or the deep blue sea. Only way either could be described as lucky is if we are talking bad luck.
 
Devadwal said:
You're a Islamist so you don't know that this thread is hypnotical where Israel is a pakistan neighbour .😂 :kp
Click to expand...
Hypnotical? :misbah :inti

images
 
ahsan17 said:
Your 2 brain cells can't even process the fact that they tried regardless and failed.
Click to expand...
Even if they tried from thousands Km away is not same as trying at just few km away. There is huge difference but delusional peoples won't understand it.

:kp
 
Devadwal said:
Even if they tried from thousands Km away is not same as trying at just few km away. There is huge difference but delusional peoples won't understand it.

:kp
Click to expand...
They were trying with India. Again, 2 brain cells won't go too far.
 
Rajdeep said:
Even Pakistan don't believe India is behind Balochistan. :yk

I hear it mostly from posters here. Pakistan's real issue with India is Kashmir and not Balochistan. Your defense minister openly admits on television of harbouring terrorist's and doing dirty work for USA for last 3 decades. So blaming India for Balochistan will not work.

Lets stick to the topic to this specific thread and pls dnt derail. :inti


Do you think Pakistan is lucky to have a peaceful neighbour as India as opposed to revengeful merciless beasts like Israel who manage to defeat entire Arab world in 5 days war?
Click to expand...

Y'all want to waste your time with this?
 
Bhaag Viru Bhaag said:
Like India, Israel would likely avoid provoking a nuclear-armed country like Pakistan. :inti
Click to expand...
Thats a one way of looking at things and glad Modi has corrected it. Pak will not use nukes unless their country is at risk which India has zero intention of invading or conquering land. India is also a nuclear country with much greater resources and geographical depth...that doesn't stop Pakistan to use terrorists. As multiple actions show pak generals doesn't give two **** about their people or land...they celebrate shooting couple of jets over defending their cities or air bases....they will not destroy their wealth for nuking India..the jehadi underlings would absolutely love nuking India...so India always reacts and we are now reacting well..every terror attack would see commensurate response and would require Pak to mobilize spend ammo..handle water shortage risk fatf ban or donations drying up ..netiher of which will risk a nuclear war
 
Suleiman said:
Bechare now want back up from their big bro Israel. Haha 🤣
Click to expand...
There was a thread whether Israel and India love affair is mutual.

So its a rhetorical follow up question - whether Pakistan is lucky to have India as neighbour and not Israel.

Rajdeep is always one step ahead.

:genius :kp
 
Israel seems to attack those countries without an airforce, imagine what happens when they come up against the PAF 🤣
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

H
It is time for India and Pakistan to repeal their sedition laws
Replies
1
Views
538
Ronaldo7
Ronaldo7
Back
Top