Is political intervention the main reason behind the epic downfall of Pakistan cricket?

[The Bald Eagle]

Some say PPP laid the foundation of downfall of PCB. Others disagree and consider PMLN the reason behind this mess. In all this hue and cry, some consider former Prime Minister and world cup winning captain Imran Khan to be the main character behind this dismal state of Pakistan cricket. So as a cricket fan whom do you guys consider the main culprit behind the current dismal state of Pakistan cricket.

 

[The Bald Eagle]

@Bewal Express, @Rana ,@topspin , @aboveandbeyond guys you can use this thread for bashing of the real culprits.

 

[Bewal Express]

Our whole system has criminals running it for the last 75 years with a few notable exceptions. Look at just the last 3 guys. Sethi helped NS to win 2013 election with his rigging- many doubted IK for accusations at the time but we know subsequent events proved him 100% right, as we saw NSs relationship with Sethi develop into a love affair in public, then we had Zaka-AZs front man for his laundering and now we have a boot polisher with no knowledge of cricket and just acts like Raja Baboo.

 

[Josh]

Pakistan, both in cricket and as a nation, often relies on heroes to rise and lead them to success with moments of brilliance. However, this is not a sustainable approach for managing a team sport or even a country.

A robust, well-structured system with accountability and a merit-based reward system, led by capable individuals, will always outperform a reliance on individual brilliance.

 

[SpiritOf1903]

The country's in meltdown

 

[rpant_gabba]

The country's in meltdown

Agree. cricketing woes are simply a symptom

 

[aboveandbeyond]

Yep, politics and sport cannot mingle. Unless we have a proper professional PCB with a clear plan and structure, then im afraid Pakistan as a cricket force will further decline. Sethi, zakah, And Naqwi haven't the slightest clue about the game, yet they were allowed to completely destroy everything.

 

[JaDed]

I guess the reasoning is Pakistanis are very talented and it’s PCB’s fault for the performance?

 

[emranabbas]

I guess the reasoning is Pakistanis are very talented and it’s PCB’s fault for the performance?

Nawaz Sharif disguises himself as Babar and comes to the ground to play as babar,

meanwhile Mohsin Naqvi puts on the mask of shaheen afridi and comes to bowl in the game

thats why you will see mohsin naqvi at the ground most times

 

[aboveandbeyond]

I guess the reasoning is Pakistanis are very talented and it’s PCB’s fault for the performance?

I'm surprised by such poor input.

Do you not think, lack of continuity in coaches, constant chop and change effects the players?

Normally, with lack of clarity like this, players go defensive, they play for their places ,hence the performance of the team is affected.

 

[Champ_Pal]

Its all Showboz Sharif's fault.

 

[JaDed]

I'm surprised by such poor input.

Do you not think, lack of continuity in coaches, constant chop and change effects the players?

Normally, with lack of clarity like this, players go defensive, they play for their places ,hence the performance of the team is affected.

Let me put it this way, there is a tendency of PCB to be like this ever since i started watching cricket(1995-96), but the players were able to manoeuvre around it coz they were capable to compete with other teams, there is a skill gap as well esp in TEST and it’s becoming visible in ODI.

 

[Aang_The_last_airbender]

Pakistan has always faded away as a particular field went from semi- professional era to a more mature professional times. And the reason is lack of institutional strength and performances sway heavily with people in power but there is never a strength in the core institution.

 

[SportsWarrior]

Indian cricket is also riddled with politicians playing games. Alsmot all past BCCI presidents were either politicians or closely linked to politics. Current coach is a former MP. They seem to be doing fine.

Pakistan just relies on heroes and messiahs too much to dig them out of difficult pahses. They need a well defined system and institutions which takes decades to build. If you have built an institution that can autorun with few administrators or bureaucracts then you have done well.

 

[Cpt. Rishwat]

Isn't the first class game in Pakistan less organised than in Scotland or Nederlands? Does Pakistan even have a recognised coaching program? The game has moved on tremendously in the last couple of decades, Pakistan is still playing goolidanda.

 

[Bewal Express]

Pakistan has always faded away as a particular field went from semi- professional era to a more mature professional times. And the reason is lack of institutional strength and performances sway heavily with people in power but there is never a strength in the core institution.

Good point. As cricket became linked to big tv contracts, the other boards upped their game. Our board became a dumping ground where politicians and Generals dumped people that helped them come to power to massage their egos and act as favours returned so today we have him as chairman

 

[FearlessRoar]

ICC banned Sri Lanka for political involvement in the cricket board. Why can’t they do the same with Pakistan?

 

[Rana]

I can see that but there are foreign coaches who have had success with Pakistan my friend, chiefly Bob Woolmer and he to me is best cricket coach of all time; Gary Kirsten is of that ilk and when he is willing to come to the table you treat him with respect. I don’t want to talk politics, look I tend have similar views as you and I could turn against those people just based on that but they’re not bad guys and have been talking a lot of sense about Pakistan cricket when nobody else does and our team keeps stooping to new lows. I appreciate people have some strong political views but we need to try our best to keep them separate from professional sport and just judge the timeline for ourselves.

I like Imran Khan and I know @Rana and a few others don’t as much, in fact I have family who don’t like him much either but it doesn’t mean we can’t get along and if you’re a respectable person that’s what matters more to me. I also know some individuals who support IK but are the spawns of satan as people, so it is worth keeping that in mind as well.

Judge the timeline as I said.

Bro I don’t have as much of an issue with Khan, I only respond harshly to those who see him as everything right and everyone else as wrong.

It hurts me a lot to be disrespectful towards him because there are good people who believe in him.

 

[The Bald Eagle]

Today is the birthday of Mohsin Naqvi and this was his surprise

https://twitter.com/x/status/1850803997965185122

 

[Bewal Express]

Bro I don’t have as much of an issue with Khan, I only respond harshly to those who see him as everything right and everyone else as wrong.

It hurts me a lot to be disrespectful towards him because there are good people who believe in him.

But you supported the torture and murder of people. You had the audacity to make fun of Shaheed people and here you are telling you as that it wasn't much.

 

[Rana]

Today is the birthday of Mohsin Naqvi and this was his surprise

https://twitter.com/x/status/1850803997965185122

Hafeez should explain what was the thought process behind batting Sahibzada Farhan at number 7.

Guy has no credibility

 

[Rana]

But you supported the torture and murder of people. You had the audacity to make fun of Shaheed people and here you are telling you as that it wasn't much.

@shaz619

Tell me now bro, what am I supposed to do with this kind of stuff?

 

[Bewal Express]

@shaz619

Tell me now bro, what am I supposed to do with this kind of stuff?

Easy-Condemn Naqvi and his puppeteers. Condemn the violence unleashed on the PK people by these criminals.

 

[Rana]

Easy-Condemn Naqvi and his puppeteers. Condemn the violence unleashed on the PK people by these criminals.

Sorry, I cannot promote rebellion against the nation. If anyone steps out of line, they must be dealt with Harshly by the law.

 

[IMMY69]

Yeah and what about Wasim Khan, Ramiz, Misbah, Saqlain creating the cancers within the side?

I have taken your Friends advice and stopped replying to either of you...
So I would kindly request you to do likewise..

For anyone else reading this post, the way cricket is run in Pakistan, the inherent issues go back decades and not just when PPP/PTI/PMLN/Military were in power. The problem is systemic and alas I don't see it getting any better unless something drastic happens

 

[Rana]

I have taken your Friends advice and stopped replying to either of you...
So I would kindly request you to do likewise..

For anyone else reading this post, the way cricket is run in Pakistan, the inherent issues go back decades and not just when PPP/PTI/PMLN/Military were in power. The problem is systemic and alas I don't see it getting any better unless something drastic happens

Yeah carry on egging others and making disrespectful remarks about me and my friends. Then come up with this emotional drivel when called out?

Imran Khan’s regime is not blameless! Understand?

 

[Bewal Express]

Sorry, I cannot promote rebellion against the nation. If anyone steps out of line, they must be dealt with Harshly by the law.

As I said you are are supporter of criminality. I didn't ask you to condemn anything that any right minded person would take a second to condemn. Since when has condemning the theft of elections, murder and kidnappings been so controversial?

BTW
what is a bigger rebellion than failing to follow the constitution and then gutting it through theft and kidnappings.

 

[Rana]

As I said you are are supporter of criminality. I didn't ask you to condemn anything that any right minded person would take a second to condemn. Since when has condemning the theft of elections, murder and kidnappings been so controversial?

BTW
what is a bigger rebellion than failing to follow the constitution and then gutting it through theft and kidnappings.

The vandals, hooligans and perpetrators of 9th May deserve the full baton of the law.

Laato ke bhoot…

 

[Bewal Express]

The vandals, hooligans and perpetrators of 9th May deserve the full baton of the law.

Laato ke bhoot…

You mean Naqvi and the boys. Your stupidity has no limits. Where is the evidence for this. I dare you to tell me where the CCTV is. And at this juncture a cretin like you disappears.

 

[Bhaijaan]

The bitter truth is that Pakistan can hardly even be considered a country. As the famous saying goes, every country has an army, in Pakistan’s case however, an army has control of a country since 78 years. Pakistani people in general live in a delusion that they live in an actual country when in fact they do not have functioning institutions, empowered entrepreneurs , their leaders and army have a license to loot them as much as they like, the people can not bring about any change and always have to eventually make peace with whatever they get.

There are deficiencies in Pakistan and its cricket that are beyond any defence or justification yet people feel replacing Babar Azam was a win for them.

Bangladeshiz whom the Pakistanis looked down upon for decades and second class citizens have built an economy significantly larger than theirs, their cricket stadiums are better.

The currency has depreciated to alarming levels. Every other year they go to IMF for bail out.

After all this, if anyone in Pakistan believes he’s living in an actual country, I would say please tell someone to slap you real hard and hope that you wake up soon.

 

[Bewal Express]

@mominsaigol bro nothing will change

This guy will continue to harass everyone with false allegations of encouraging murder. He knows he will just get his posts deleted.

Like what? You refused to condemn the killing, torture and kidnapping of PK people. These aren't some ramdom people, they are my fellow Paks.
You said they deserved it for 9th May. Then i asked you for the evidence and as you and more importantly the Junta didn't have any, you play the card of harassment. As long as Naqvi is chairman, all my points are relevant.

 

[Rana]

If supporting Imran Khan creates a person like the one above,

Then the ideology is a problem. What must be done?

 

[The Bald Eagle]

Guys please refrain from derogatory remarks

 

[aboveandbeyond]

Like what? You refused to condemn the killing, torture and kidnapping of PK people. These aren't some ramdom people, they are my fellow Paks.
You said they deserved it for 9th May. Then i asked you for the evidence and as you and more importantly the Junta didn't have any, you play the card of harassment. As long as Naqvi is chairman, all my points are relevant.

Don't know why you bother with these guys.

 

[The Bald Eagle]

Guys any violence related stuff won't be tolerated be it a direct or indirect threat. Please engage only in constructive interaction