What's new

Maoist rebels kill 24 paramilitary commandos in central India

Pakpak

ODI Debutant
Joined
Jan 31, 2009
Runs
9,230
Suspected Maoist rebels killed 24 paramilitary commandos and wounded six on Monday in a remote part of central India in one of the deadliest attacks of a long-running internal conflict.

The soldiers were guarding road workers in the Sukma district of Chhattisgargh state, a hotbed of insurgent violence, when they came under heavy fire.

“We have recovered 23 bodies from the spot and one soldier died in Raipur during treatment,” Anand Chhabra, a senior police officer, told AFP, referring to the state capital.

He said six other commandos from the Central Reserve Police Force were critically injured and had been evacuated for treatment.

Another police officer, Sunil Tiwari, told AFP that Indian security forces were looking for “some CRPF soldiers who are missing”, adding that the rebels snatched weapons during the ambush.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi condemned the attack and offered condolences to the families of the deceased, saying the sacrifice of their loved ones would not be in vain.

“Attack on @CRPFIndia personnel in Chhattisgarh is cowardly and deplorable. We are monitoring the situation closely,” Modi posted on Twitter.

Fatal attacks by insurgents on security forces in central and eastern India are frequent, but Monday's assault was among the deadliest in years.

Television footage showed injured commandos in their army fatigues being stretchered from ambulances into hospitals for treatment.

One soldier who survived the attack, Sher Mohammed, told reporters from his hospital bed that “almost 300 of them attacked us”.

More precaution needed
State chief minister Raman Singh said Sukma, where Monday's attack occurred, was a stronghold for Maoists waging a guerilla war from their jungle bases.

The Maoists opposed efforts to build new roads and infrastructure in the remote area because it undermined their long-running campaign against India's security forces, he added.

“In future we will need to take more precautions,” said Singh, who called an emergency meeting and rushed back from New Delhi after the attack.

The Maoist insurgency started as a peasant uprising in 1967, and since then has cost thousands of lives in the rebel-dominated “red corridor” stretching through central and eastern India.

***-for-tat jungle skirmishes often result in heavy casualties on both sides.

Last month 11 paramilitary policemen were killed when their convoy was ambushed in Chhattisgarh, while at least 20 troops died in a separate attack in 2015.

In 2010 Maoists killed 76 police in the worst-ever massacre of security forces by the insurgents. The incident shook the country and led to pressure on the government to rethink its tactics.

Critics believe attempts to end the revolt through tough security offensives are doomed to fail, saying the real solution is better governance and development of the region.

The guerrillas, who say they are fighting for the rights of tribal people and landless farmers, often collect funds through extortion.

Modi had been seeking to stem the insurgency by earmarking development funds for revolt-hit areas and improving policing.

In 2015 he urged Maoists to put down their guns and take up ploughs, saying “violence has no future”.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1328953/maoist-rebels-kill-24-paramilitary-commandos-in-central-india
 
Govt been too soft on these vermin's.

Anyone who attacks CRPF men should be smashed into pieces.
 
What is the conflict about?

In Andhra, it is mostly about Govt taking and encroaching Tribal lands for mining or building roads. Often the tribals are left with no compensation. Even if Govt do give them compensation, middle men and corrupt officials take it away.

So the solution is, some jobless youth inspired by communist ideology who want justice for tribals take up arms and attack Govt building, Army, CRPF men as well as trains, buses etc.

Most Moaists live in some kind of communist/socialist utopia where all resources are distributed equally to everyone and all get to eat/drink etc. They are anti-capitalistc.
Met a few sympathizers and they are all pretty much losers. Blaming the system for their poor state.

Its always someone else's fault.
 
...and they tell us that Indian's don't kill each other or there is n insurgency in India. Either give them a greater share of the pie or keep on suffering such attacks. Surprised they have not found an ISI or Pakistan angle to it yet.
 
...and they tell us that Indian's don't kill each other or there is n insurgency in India. Either give them a greater share of the pie or keep on suffering such attacks. Surprised they have not found an ISI or Pakistan angle to it yet.


Actually the weapons and money come through hawala transactions where ISI is believed to be involved..
 
Actually the weapons and money come through hawala transactions where ISI is believed to be involved..

You see ISI everywhere:))) Much greater chance of China being involved after the Dalai Lama thing. Even many Indians say that the Chinese swore some sort or retribution.
 
You see ISI everywhere:))) Much greater chance of China being involved after the Dalai Lama thing. Even many Indians say that the Chinese swore some sort or retribution.



I don't see ISI anywhere mate I am just replying to your post.. Not talking about this particular attack but in the past there have been reports that links ISI to Maoists/Naxals..

Neither you nor me know who is involved since neither of us work in government/intelligence and rely on media reports..

Anyways RIP to the brave soldiers hopefully the guilty would be punished by the law..
 
Actually the weapons and money come through hawala transactions where ISI is believed to be involved..

Money come through corrupted communist sympathizers who often hold decent positions in India in private and public sectors. Weapons are smuggled from Thailand, Laos, Cambodia and so on. It has nothing to do with ISI. Communist sympathizers hate Pakistani just as much as any other Indian.
 
RIP, I used to be a maoist sympathizer and still feel that not enough is done socially in rural areas thereby pushing the people towards using force.

But tbh they have killed soldiers who probably were following big corporation and govn orders ,they should give up their fight but its not like in a day casteism,exploitation of tribal lands,rapes would stop,with the current law and order situation who would trust BJP?
 
From British colonialist to new colonialists in the form of India now, these tribals have been exploited again and again. Their lands have been taken away, their ways of lives have been interferred with. They have been living the way they were since thousands of years, much before the time when these foreign Aryans came to the land of Bharat to exploit the natives, something which is going on till today. If these tribals were more in number, nobody would have dared to touch them and deprive them of resources which historically belong to them.

The extent of exploitation can be understood by the fact that some of the tribes' population have gone down to as low as 50-100 are have reached the brink of extinction. These were the tribes which didnt resist Indian exploitation and are now as good as extinct. People calling them losers and savages should understand these people are fighting for survival. The tribals never got their freedom which Indians got after britishers left.
 
Not justifying the Maoists here. But Indians need to realise that the central and state governments have been treating the tribals like garbage over 50 years.

Their living space is being intruded, polluted and they are being chased away from their traditional areas with little or no compensation!..

very few of them are educated enough or have the means to express their suffering on the national stage .. so we choose to willfully ignore them and say "it's for the greater good, why don't they move on " ..

In India it's only a problem if people with voices that are heard get affected.. If your voice never gets heard your life is always rotten .
 
But tbh they have killed soldiers who probably were following big corporation and govn orders ,they should give up their fight but its not like in a day casteism,exploitation of tribal lands,rapes would stop,with the current law and order situation who would trust BJP?

Looks like you still are a sympathizer or whatever it is. Maoists killed Soldiers/Police and innocents from years even where BJP have no presence.
 
Armed resistance is not a solution to any issue especially in a democratic country. Army can wipeout these so called armed freedom fighters within in a week I'm glad that they are not going for it but testing the patience of government is not a wise thing. These kind of desperate attempts to disturb the developmental works will only result in losing any kind of sympathy left in minds of common people for nexalites.
 
Before the usual suspects gets excited, no none of them wants 'azaadi' as many of you would like to believe.
 
Before the usual suspects gets excited, no none of them wants 'azaadi' as many of you would like to believe.

neither does TTP in Pakistan

doesnt matter if they are willing to kill
 
neither does TTP in Pakistan

doesnt matter if they are willing to kill

The nexals don't target people, few times people lost life during attacks but they are not done deliberately to target public.
 
The nexals don't target people, few times people lost life during attacks but they are not done deliberately to target public.

youre making excuses for them?

even ttp says that they only target military and govt entities and ppl just happen to be collateral damage and not intended targets (for eg APS even was children of army officers)
 
Looks like you still are a sympathizer or whatever it is. Maoists killed Soldiers/Police and innocents from years even where BJP have no presence.

True but BJP have no leftists and socialists among them,a complete capitalist party which corporations and traders support,so they would least understand the issues. Doesn't mean Maoists aren't at wrong here,no excuse whatsoever for what they have done.
 
youre making excuses for them?

even ttp says that they only target military and govt entities and ppl just happen to be collateral damage and not intended targets (for eg APS even was children of army officers)

The Maoists/naxalites are doing it to protect the tribals/culture and they are sadly idealists who have started using force,they don't want corporations to take over their land/culture,there are others too that join them like professors with leftist agenda no way are they even remotely compared to TTP who massacred so many children not to forget want to force their agenda on people.

And no excuses they are defn at wrong here.
 
The Maoists/naxalites are doing it to protect the tribals/culture and they are sadly idealists who have started using force,they don't want corporations to take over their land/culture,there are others too that join them like professors with leftist agenda no way are they even remotely compared to TTP who massacred so many children not to forget want to force their agenda on people.

And no excuses they are defn at wrong here.

Well said. They are Gandhians with Guns.
 
youre making excuses for them?

even ttp says that they only target military and govt entities and ppl just happen to be collateral damage and not intended targets (for eg APS even was children of army officers)

I actually liked them when they were targeting landlords who used to oppress people and even now they will get plenty of suport if they are willing to target corrupt politicians and dreaded criminals.
 
The Maoists/naxalites are doing it to protect the tribals/culture and they are sadly idealists who have started using force,they don't want corporations to take over their land/culture,there are others too that join them like professors with leftist agenda no way are they even remotely compared to TTP who massacred so many children not to forget want to force their agenda on people.

And no excuses they are defn at wrong here.

Again biggest Naxal attacks happened/originated in WB & Andhra , 2 places BJP never in power and atleast in one place so called parties for poor people CPI [A to Z] ruled for decades.
 
neither does TTP in Pakistan

doesnt matter if they are willing to kill

I had Cash meres in mind when I made that comment.TTP is an internal matter of Pakistan and I couldn't give two hoots about it.
 
Looks like you still are a sympathizer or whatever it is. Maoists killed Soldiers/Police and innocents from years even where BJP have no presence.

He is not sympathizing communists. He is blaming the system which has armed them in the first place.
 
One of the surviving CRPF man said that the Maoists attacked the CRPF men with grenades, Rocket Launchers and AK-47 rifles.

This is considered War in any country.

Whether the attackers are Indians or outsiders, anyone who attacks army men with the intention to kill should not be spared no matter what the reason for attack is.

If you do not respect the authority of Army, then who will these people respect?

I am not a blind supporter of the army/crpf, but no one should dare touch them when they are doing their duty.

Chattishgarh is a failed state even with in India along with Orissa and to some extent Bengal. Extreme backwardness reeks in those places the moment you step there.

Wonder when Communists be banned in India. These useless fools do nothing but shout slogans and oppose every developmental step the Govt tries to take. Where ever there is poverty/laziness/corruption, Communists inevitably have a foot hold there.
 
I don't see ISI anywhere mate I am just replying to your post.. Not talking about this particular attack but in the past there have been reports that links ISI to Maoists/Naxals..

Neither you nor me know who is involved since neither of us work in government/intelligence and rely on media reports..

Anyways RIP to the brave soldiers hopefully the guilty would be punished by the law..

I am glad that like most Indian;s you don't see ISIS everywhere. As I often say every soldiers knows that dying for the country is part of the job. The signed up for it and are in a different world now where there are no countries or borders.
 
One of the surviving CRPF man said that the Maoists attacked the CRPF men with grenades, Rocket Launchers and AK-47 rifles.

This is considered War in any country.

Whether the attackers are Indians or outsiders, anyone who attacks army men with the intention to kill should not be spared no matter what the reason for attack is.

If you do not respect the authority of Army, then who will these people respect?

I am not a blind supporter of the army/crpf, but no one should dare touch them when they are doing their duty.

Chattishgarh is a failed state even with in India along with Orissa and to some extent Bengal. Extreme backwardness reeks in those places the moment you step there.

Wonder when Communists be banned in India. These useless fools do nothing but shout slogans and oppose every developmental step the Govt tries to take. Where ever there is poverty/laziness/corruption, Communists inevitably have a foot hold there.

given that the army regularly beat them up, and molest them in name of searching for maoists why would they respect their authority?let's just be clear. the forest ,land,and wather of those parts belong to the tribals. the bjp-led capitalistic government wants to take away their homes and you expect them to do nothing? the maoists are fighting for the right side of the war.but of course to neo-liberal shinings like you the most important thing in the wold is how much profit big corporates likeadanis or the vedant group makes from the natural resoursec of the forests of chattishgarh.if it is at the expense of the tribals who cares?
 
Back
Top