What's new

Merit ignored by PCB in appointing coaches of provincial associations: Mudassar Nazar

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,138
LAHORE: Former Test all-rounder Mudassar Nazar on Saturday strongly criticised the Pakistan Cricket Board for what he claimed ignoring merit in the appointments of new panel of coaches, particularly of the six provincial cricket associations.

Mudassar, who featured in 76 Tests and 122 ODIs between 1976 and 1989, expressed his regret over the recent appointments of 36 coaches with different teams of the provincial associations, saying merit had been ruined in these appointments and reckoned that preference had been given to those who were closer to the current PCB set-up.

“A number of [appointed] coaches have no coaching degree, which should be a must for a coach to train any team. I was expecting good changes. Hopefully, these things will not be repeated in future,” said Mudassar in an interview to Dawn.

Mudassar, who quit as head of the National Cricket Academy, which is now named as the National High Performance Centre (NHPC), expressed his surprise over ignoring Ijaz Ahmed Junior for a coaching position in any provincial team while noting that under his coaching Central Punjab won the Quaid-i-Azam Trophy, the country’s most prestigious domestic competition, last year.

Similarly, Mudassar agreed that Sajjad Akbar, whose South Punjab side claimed the Second XI trophy last year, was retained at the same position. Whereas, Mudassar argued, Sajjad deserved to be appointed as coach of any team for the Quaid-i-Azam Trophy.

“Sajjad is a brilliant coach who likes to keep the record of everything and he talks in writing,” Mudassar stated.

“But now the PCB has adopted the stance that players’ feedback was also considered in removing some old coaches like Ijaz Ahmed Junior and others. What type of approach is this? This is mind boggling! [A number of] players have always complained against competent coaches. If Pakistan lose the Test series in England and [as a result] the players make any complaint against [head coach] Misbah, would you axe Misbah?” he asked.

Mudassar slammed the PCB also for not making the six provincial associations functional in line with its constitution despite the passage of two years, and not staging any club or inter-city competition during the same period.

“Now they are going to select the provincial teams based on the players’ performances of the last two years, making the mockery of affairs,” he denounced.

Mudassar, whose contract was to expire on May 30, 2020, had surprisingly informed the PCB in December 2019 that he would not be the candidate for the said post in future.

“Actually the purpose for which I had joined the NCA could not be fulfilled due to the lacklustre attitude of [former PCB chairman] Najam Sethi and that of the incumbent body [headed by Ehsan Mani],” he lamented.

“When Shaharyar M. Khan as PCB chairman brought me from the ICC Academy I agreed to join [NCA] because the chairman had assured me that he will give me funds to set up academies in four different cities,” Mudassar said.

“But after Shaharyar left, Sethi [next chairman] was reluctant to invest money on these projects. And then after noticing that the current PCB management is also not ready to go for the said project I decided to quit.”

But when reminded that the current PCB management had announced it would set up NHPC at four centres, Mudassar said he did not have any information on this.

“I don’t know from where now the money has come as they had refused to go with my plans,” he recalled.

“But I will tell you this [PCB] management will not succeed in setting up such centres in any city and what they are claiming is all pack of lies.

Mudassar continued, “I believe unless we invest in this area we will not be able to beat strong teams like Australia and England consistently.”

When asked the PCB hired Nadeem Khan in his place as the head of NHPC, despite a big difference in the credentials of both, (Mudassar came from the ICC Academy and Nadeem running Moin Khan Academy in Karachi), Mudassar reckoned commercialisation might have been the reason.

“I think the PCB preferred Nadeem because it wants to run the NHPC on commercial basis, the way Nadeem has been running [Moin Khan Academy] in Karachi, but I did not agree to this,” he said.

“In fact, our academies lacked the facilities to perform on commercial basis. We could not even set up a gymnasium at the Karachi HPC even after four years,” he regretted.

Commenting on the ongoing third Test in Southampton, Mudassar said Pakistan, trailing 1-0 in the series, now faced a massive task ahead.

“The wicket [in Southampton] was straight on the first day and remained so till rain on the second day. However, after rain [on Saturday] it has become difficult for batsmen as the Pakistan bowlers started troubling the English batsmen. If the wicket continues to behave like this in the coming days [of the Test] Stuart Broad, James Anderson and other fast bowlers will not allow the Pakistan batsmen to settle,” Mudassar said.

Mudassar said now the Pakistan batsmen faced a huge pressure in the ongoing Test to take first-innings lead or minimise the England lead to remain in contention.

“In cricket one cannot rule out anything. Though the challenge is massive, still with renewed fighting spirit our team can come back in this Test,” the 64-year-old underlined.

Responding to a question on the stinging criticism Azhar Ali is currently facing as captain, Mudassar said the former’s dismal batting form had intensified this criticism.

“Criticising captain and coaches in case of a defeat has been a tradition in Pakistan cricket. However, it is also a fact that Azhar’s poor batting performance is adding fuel to this criticism,” he added.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1575874/m...g-coaches-of-provincial-associations-mudassar
 
Sounds like he was fed up with the PCB regardless of who was in charge.
 
The blueprint of ex-cricketers in Pakistan:-

"When on PCB's payroll, everything is fine, else nothing is fine".
 
The blueprint of ex-cricketers in Pakistan:-

"When on PCB's payroll, everything is fine, else nothing is fine".

Yes exactly , if you don’t get the job or you are not asked for your input on who should get the job, then clearly things are not being done on merit.
 
He is saying what many of us are also saying.

The appointments seem to be done on basis of "whoever shouts loudest" basis.
 
Coaching degree is a also a mafia.

You think there is no jugaar that can be applied to get that paper? If the degree requires English vocabulary then majority of our 'coaches' won't even get in. Add to that the lessons in psychology, theory, background, application and majority of the moulvis will be back to eating halwas, let alone doing 'degrees'.
 
I doubt misbah has any coaching degree and Nazar is lamenting about regional coaches.
 
Abdul Razzaq, Faisal Iqbal and Basit Ali were very puzzling appointments. We need the very best coaches at domestic level nurturing the youngsters, not loudmouth TV pundits.
 
Abdul Razzaq, Faisal Iqbal and Basit Ali were very puzzling appointments. We need the very best coaches at domestic level nurturing the youngsters, not loudmouth TV pundits.

Basit has coaching credentials for a while now so I am ok with that selection, Razzaq and Faisal are purely inducted because someone somewhere pulled some strings.
 
Wasim Khan made the comment a few months ago that the coaching courses that the PCB was offering was a sham, a lot of ex players were literally buying these 2-4 weeks coaching courses, degrees and were developing an entitlement to a job attitude. That's how low the standards were whereas in the ECB you can't enrol in advanced levels, advanced coaching courses unless you have put in the hard yards ie coached for a number of years at the domestic, club level and this is what has made the ECB coaching courses more valuable and prestigious over time compared to the fast, fraudulent 2 week PCB coaching certificates.
 
Coaching degree is a also a mafia.

You think there is no jugaar that can be applied to get that paper? If the degree requires English vocabulary then majority of our 'coaches' won't even get in. Add to that the lessons in psychology, theory, background, application and majority of the moulvis will be back to eating halwas, let alone doing 'degrees'.

Agreed, and strongly so. What psychology? We don’t do that sh*t.
 
Wasim Khan made the comment a few months ago that the coaching courses that the PCB was offering was a sham, a lot of ex players were literally buying these 2-4 weeks coaching courses, degrees and were developing an entitlement to a job attitude. That's how low the standards were whereas in the ECB you can't enrol in advanced levels, advanced coaching courses unless you have put in the hard yards ie coached for a number of years at the domestic, club level and this is what has made the ECB coaching courses more valuable and prestigious over time compared to the fast, fraudulent 2 week PCB coaching certificates.

Would be amazing to see a solid investigative piece on this. Not the stupid local channel quality one, but either a good one by Dawn or a foreign channel like Al-J. Sadly, won’t do much for the reputation but as long as it does not involve players there shouldn’t be too much by way of image. Lately of the mind that a lot of the crap in our system needs to be shown the mirror.
 
The blueprint of ex-cricketers in Pakistan:-

"When on PCB's payroll, everything is fine, else nothing is fine".

Pretty much. Expected better from Mudassar. He might be right but starting to bombard ex employer with number allegations and criticism in media just few months after you leave is not very professional.
 
Basit has coaching credentials for a while now so I am ok with that selection, Razzaq and Faisal are purely inducted because someone somewhere pulled some strings.

Thing is wasn't Grant Bradburn overseeing the recruitment process ? How could he have signed off on Razzaq and Faisal given their coaching experience is next to nothing (not counting glorified cheerleading in PSL) ?

Is it a case of Saqlain, also part of the process, hiring his former teammates ? But again, Ehsan Mani had the final say on all these appointments.

I feel Ehsan Mani and Wasim Khan have introduced the right reforms - 6 FC teams, NCA revamp, dual head coach-chief selector position - but the wrong personnel for these crucial roles.

Most of their hires have no experience for their positions and aren't qualified.
 
Reports indicate that Misbah is not happy with the appointment of NHPC coaches.
 
Reports indicate that Misbah is not happy with the appointment of NHPC coaches.

Pretty rich coming from a non merit based appointment. Atleast Zahid has ECB coaching certifates and Razzaq has coached in the PSL whereas Misbah did squat
 
Pretty much. Expected better from Mudassar. He might be right but starting to bombard ex employer with number allegations and criticism in media just few months after you leave is not very professional.

Let's be real, Mudassar was asked to leave, the PCB was not happy with his performance and felt he was part of the old guard who needed to be moved on. What has Mudassar really down for the academies, we have not produced a single world class player under his watch
 
Reports indicate that Misbah is not happy with the appointment of NHPC coaches.

Thats interesting. So PCB didnt ask input of Misbah on this? Looks like the level of involvement of Misbah in Pak cricket is gradually becoming less. It was gonna happen with the lack of results as if the end result which is the performance of national team isnt impressive then someone with as much responsibility as Misbah was always gonna come under fire to an extent.
 
Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) Chairman Ehsan Mani claims that under the National High Performance Centre revamp programme, the PCB is keen to take Pakistan cricket to the next level and bring it at par with the best international standards.

Former Test all-rounder Mudassar Nazar recently criticised the PCB for what he claimed ignoring merit in the appointments of new panel of coaches, particularly of the six provincial cricket associations. On this, Mani said: “The PCB has continued to invest in players and coaches development as part of National High Performance Centre revamp. “We have engaged Saqlain Mushtaq (head of international player development) and Grant Bradburn (head of coach development) to take the programme to the next level and bring it at par with the best international standards. This is part of the PCB’s strategy to build its own capacity and capability, and put a stop on its over-reliance on foreign experts.

“Mohammad Yousuf, Mohammad Zahid and Atiq-uz-Zaman’s appointments reflect our vision and if you take into consideration that he High Performance Centre and Domestic cricket were now in sync and aligned, and operating under one umbrella, you will understand the philosophy, vision and strategy,” he added. The PCB has recommended tough sanctions for corrupts in cricket in its drive to assist the government around legislation on criminalizing corruption in sports. “The PCB has reviewed the existing legislation enacted within Pakistan and has noted that the same fail to adequately target and address corruption/illegal manipulation in sports,” said the PCB chairman.

“In the draft paper, the PCB has proposed severe sanctions pertaining to corruption, illegal manipulation, betting, match and spot-fixing as well as aiding and abetting such conduct and has proposed penalties to be imposed on individuals found guilty of engaging in such offences,” he added.

Mani further said: “Too many meaningless matches and events were being organized, which was costing the PCB a fortune without benefitting Pakistan cricket. Also, contrary to the constitution, the Regions were not generating their own funds and had become completely dependent financially on the PCB without any tangible results.

“We introduced a high-quality and competitive 2019-20 season in which the best of the best players featured and as a result, some of the top performers broke into the recent Pakistan sides, most prominent being Haider Ali.”

To ensure our best domestic cricketers continue to be looked after and are well paid, the PCB offered decent player contracts in the 2019-20 season, which have further been improved for the 2020-21 season,” he added.

On the resumption of club cricket, Mani said the interim committees of the six Cricket Associations will be put in place shortly, which will also be responsible for club registrations under the new operating rules. He, however, clarified just under 50 clubs events have been held worldwide in the past 18 months (minus the time when cricket activities were suspended due to Covid-19), which took permission from the board to hold these.

https://nation.com.pk/07-Sep-2020/revamp-programme-to-take-pakistan-to-next-level-claims-mani
 
Former Test cricketer and current high performance coach Rao Iftikhar Anjum will be amongst 19 participants which will undergo a three-day ICC Tutors’ Course at the National High Performance Centre (NHPC) from Monday, 14 November.

Amongst 19 participants, eight are Level 2 qualified, nine possess Level 3 coaching course certificates, while two are Level 4 qualified coaches.

Former Pakistan international cricketer Iqbal Sikander and former Bangladesh Test captain Amin-ul-Islam – both assigned by ICC, will be tutors for the course. They will teach participants on how to conduct Level 1 coaching course.

After undergoing the three-day course, the participants will be in a position to work with PCB coaches to conduct Level 1 coaching course in their respective cricket association.

Participants along with their coaching levels (in alphabetical order):

Amanullah (Level 2), Ansar Javed (Level 2), Ateeq-ur-Rehman (Level 2), Fahad Akram (Level 3), Hafiz Sajjad Akbar (Level 4), Hajra Sarwar (Level 3), Hanif Malik (Level 2), Hussain Khosa (Level 3), Imran Abbas (Level 3), Kamran Hussain (Level 2), Rahat Abbas Asadi (Level 3), Rao Iftikhar (Level 2), Rehan Rafique (Level 2), Sajid Shah (Level 3), Saqib Faqir (Level 3), Tahir Mehmood (Level 3), Taimur Azam (Level 4), Waseem Yousafi (Level 3) and Zafar Iqbal (Level 2)
 
Pakistan legend and current batting coach Mohammad Yousuf and Test batter Azhar Ali will be part of the Level 3 coaching course that begins on Thursday at the National High Performance Centre in Lahore.

The course will run till 22 November and will be attended by 35 participants, 17 of which are current and former Test cricketers.

The course will provide opportunities to current and former cricketers to evolve into coaches so they can share their knowledge with the up and coming cricketers.

Names of 35 participants: Abdul Rehman, Abdul Saad, Adnan Rasool, Aftab Khan, Agha Sabir Ali, Amanullah Dehpal, Anwar Ali, Arshad Khan, Ashraf Ali, Azhar Ali, Ghulam Ali, Hafiz Majid, Humayun Farhat, Imran Farhat, Jamal Uddin, Muhammad Saeed Anwer, Mohammad Yousaf, Muhammad Sami, Nadeem Zafar Gondal, Qaisar Abbas, Raees Amjad, Rao Iftikhar Anjum, Riaz Afridi, Riffat Ullah, Rizwan Quraishi, Roze Khan, Shahid Latif, Shoaib Khan, Shoaib Khan, Syed Wajahat Ullha Wasti, Tabish Khan, Taufiq Umer, Waqar Oraqzai, Waqas Ahmad And Zulfiqar Babar
 
Back
Top