What's new

Only Muslim school in Paris closed down amid claims of Islamophobia

Madplayer

Senior Test Player
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Runs
28,686
Post of the Week
1
Paris’s only Muslim school was shut down by French authorities while pressure continues to increase on Europe’s largest Muslim community.

MHS College and High School is a private secondary in Paris, originally established in 2015. Although the school is officially secular and follows the national curriculum, its students are predominantly Muslim.

One of the school’s founders spoke to TRT World on the condition of anonymity saying that “we are an open school to all cultures religion convictions origins” adding that “we don’t teach any courses around religion.”

A unique feature of the school, however, is that it allows its female students to follow their religious convictions and wear the hijab if they wish, “because we think that everybody should wear the clothes they want!” said the founder of the MHS.

In 2004, France cracked down on Muslim girls’ right to wear the headscarf on school premises, compelling many to take off their head-covering at the entrance of the school gate.

Since then, there have been few options in which a Muslim woman could receive an education while still being able to practice her faith.

MHS in Paris was one such unique operation which allowed this freedom.

In a statement, the school called this latest decision to shut the school as “arbitrary”, not least because the closure has left more than 110 students without a placement in the middle of an academic year, as well 18 teachers and support staff unemployed.

The closure order came about after an inspection took place on November 17.

During that inspection, students “found themselves surrounded by around forty controllers, inspectors and ministerial agents and police officers.”

Authorities claimed that the building’s safety standards were insufficient. The school contends that it had carried out extensive renovation to meet legal obligations. In addition, they explained the building is shared with other institutions that are also working with children and “they were not asked to shutdown. Only MHS was ordered to.”

The school warned that the disruption to students' education will hamper their progression at a time when the country is grappling with the Covid-19 pandemic, during which academic institutions are facing the heavy burden of trying to teach in difficult circumstances.

The abrupt closure at this inconvenient, mid-year time, has left some wondering whether rising anti-Muslim sentiment in the country and recent statements by the French President Emmanuel Macron singling out Muslims, has helped this decision come to pass.

One online user said that “France has now shut down the first and only Muslim school in Paris @mhs_paris. This was a secular school that taught the national curriculum, the difference was 90% of students were Muslims, and girls were free to wear hijab, unlike other French schools where it's banned.”

Another called the move an “absolute scandal” drawing attention to the more than seven Jewish schools in Paris alone and at least twenty Catholic Schools which have not been molested by the state.

So far the school has appealed for “solidarity, responsible and peaceful support in the face of this injustice."

https://www.trtworld.com/magazine/o...amophobia-42199/amp?__twitter_impression=true
 
they can keep on about being socially responsible all they like. France has made its feelings about Muslims clear. Its now upto Muslims in France to decide what they want to do. Personally i would have migrated away from france years ago if i had lived their. I dont get why French Muslims are not keen on leaving. hell ive been trying to get out of england for a while and havent quite managed it so perhaps they have the same issues as me ...
 
they can keep on about being socially responsible all they like. France has made its feelings about Muslims clear. Its now upto Muslims in France to decide what they want to do. Personally i would have migrated away from france years ago if i had lived their. I dont get why French Muslims are not keen on leaving. hell ive been trying to get out of england for a while and havent quite managed it so perhaps they have the same issues as me ...

They are not keen on leaving because it is not as simple as packing your bags and heading to the airport.

These people have been living in France for generations, they have families, jobs, assets, roots etc., and the cons of leaving are greater than the pros.

It is not easy to relocate and find jobs in another country.

I am sure as a British Pakistani you can relate. You pay taxes to the British government that use your tax money to bomb Muslims in the Middle East, but you have morally accepted it and you have tried to clear your guilty conscience because leaving the UK is not feasible for you.

So please don’t judge French muslims. As a British Pakistani, you should be able to empathize with them.
 
They are not keen on leaving because it is not as simple as packing your bags and heading to the airport.

These people have been living in France for generations, they have families, jobs, assets, roots etc., and the cons of leaving are greater than the pros.

It is not easy to relocate and find jobs in another country.

I am sure as a British Pakistani you can relate. You pay taxes to the British government that use your tax money to bomb Muslims in the Middle East, but you have morally accepted it and you have tried to clear your guilty conscience because leaving the UK is not feasible for you.

So please don’t judge French muslims. As a British Pakistani, you should be able to empathize with them.

I did caveat my comment. But I don't need lessons of morality from the likes of you.

On topic, yes it is difficult to leave when you have lived in a place for generations but when it comes to the point where your children's future will be affected I think its is legitimate to at least encourage the youngsters to look at better pastures elsewhere.
 
I did caveat my comment. But I don't need lessons of morality from the likes of you.

On topic, yes it is difficult to leave when you have lived in a place for generations but when it comes to the point where your children's future will be affected I think its is legitimate to at least encourage the youngsters to look at better pastures elsewhere.
Where do you think they would be able to leave and have the same level of quality of life? I see lot of Europeans coming to US for work but its worse for Muslims there.
 
France’s draft law aimed at tackling what the government terms “Islamist radicalism” was unveiled on Wednesday.

President Emmanuel Macron has promoted the bill to target what he calls “separatists” undermining the nation, but rights groups have raised concerns over the law, saying it would discriminate against French Muslims.

Among notable measures is making school obligatory from age three with the ability to opt-out in favour of homeschooling for special cases only. The measure is aimed at ending so-called “clandestine” schools run by hardliners.

Another article encourages mosques to register as places of worship, so as to better identify them. Many of the nation’s more than 2,600 mosques currently operate under rules for associations. Foreign funding for mosques, while not forbidden, would have to be declared if more than 10,000 euros ($12,000).

The draft law would make it a crime punishable by fines and up to one year in prison for a doctor to provide a young woman with virginity certificates, sometimes demanded ahead of marriage.

French doctors and Muslim feminists are also against such certificates, but some have argued against an outright ban, saying it could harm women who could face violence without them.


To do away with forced marriages, a measure in the bill requires the couple to meet separately for an interview with an official when there is a doubt about free consent. If the doubt persists, the official must take the issue to a prosecutor who could forbid the marriage.

Those practising polygamy would be forbidden French residence cards.

When Macron spoke about the bill earlier this year in an attempt to drum up support, he said Islam was a “religion in crisis” globally – a comment that upset Muslims across the world and led to anti-France protests.

But Prime Minister Jean Castex and others insist the text “is not against religions”.

Neither the word Islam nor Muslim are named in the text made up of about 50 articles aimed at enabling better oversight of mosques, associations, public services and schools – and hoped to further protect French secularism, which is already enshrined in law.

Parliament is expected to open what is likely to be a lively debate on the draft law in the months ahead.

The measure is now known by the delicate title, Supporting Republican Principles.

Castex said those whose project is to “divide and spread hate and violence” are at the centre of “separatism”.

Separatism is especially dangerous because it “is the manifestation of a conscious, theorised, political-religious project with an ambition to make religious norms predominate over the law,” he said at a news conference.

In an interview with newspaper Le Monde he said the nature of a law is long-term and it would apply to any political ideology that threatens French values, “even if today it is radical Islamism that we try by all means to fight.”
 
Becoming quite a sad and worrying situation for French Muslims.
 
While I don't think religious schools should exist, especially state-funded ones, this isn't right. If the claim of discrimination is true, then it's terrible. I am surprised that religious schools are a thing in France, however.
 
hell ive been trying to get out of england for a while and havent quite managed it so perhaps they have the same issues as me ...

Where are you looking to head? The US/Canada? The Middle East? Or back to Pakistan?
 
Extremist France at it again.

These secular fools need to accept nothing they can do will stop people believing in Islam or any other religion. Half of their world cup winning team are Muslims, perhaps they should ban them from playing for France too.
 
France is building a ticking time bomb with these policies. They are becoming increasingly authoritarian and dictatorial, and they are in danger of growing a resentful Muslim community that will end up hating French values and eventually French people.
 
French outcry over academic in Grenoble Islamophobia row

Dozens of French academics have warned that freedom of expression is at risk after a German professor was suspended over a row with politics students.

Klaus Kinzler has been locked in dispute for months over accusations of Islamophobia at Sciences Po Grenoble.

In a case that has provoked allegations of left-wing cancel culture, the political studies institute has suspended him for "defamatory remarks".

The institute is now set to lose local funding because of the row.

Laurent Wauquiez, the right-wing leader of the Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes region, said an annual €100,000 (£85,000) subsidy was being suspended.

His decision was widely welcomed by figures on the right of French politics, with just four months to go before a presidential election in which centrist sitting President Emmanuel Macron is leading the opinion polls.But the politics institute said the removal of funding was politically motivated and jeopardised students who struggled to access higher education.

Forty people, mostly academics, have now signed an open letter to Higher Education Minister Frédérique Vidal, warning that pluralism in teaching and research is under threat, with teachers and students alike resorting to self-censorship.

CANCEL CULTURE: France resists US challenge to its values

At the heart of the row is Prof Kinzler, who has been challenged for months by a group of politics students who accused him of fascism and Islamophobia.

The professor of German civilisation initially got into an email argument with a colleague over a day of debates on racism, anti-Semitism and Islamophobia. Prof Kinzler reportedly argued that it was not appropriate to equate Islamophobia with racism and anti-Semitism.
'Re-education camp'

A left-wing union accused him of Islamophobia, but the disagreement took on a new lease of life last March when posters were put up on the Grenoble campus that read "Fascists in our lecture halls. Islamophobia kills", targeting Prof Kinzler and a colleague.

The head of the political studies institute, Sabine Saurugger, said she had repeatedly asked Prof Kinzler not to talk to the media about the row. However, he gave a series of interviews this month, accusing the institute of being a "political re-education camp", with a management impotent in the face of a hard core of academics spreading "wokeism".

Prof Kinzler's lawyers have spoken of a "witch hunt", adding that he was forced to speak out after he had been subjected to a political attack.

Ms Saurugger told Le Monde newspaper that the management had supported Prof Kinzler when he had come under attack from "shocking and unacceptable posters". However, she said it was "my duty to intervene when the reputation of the institution is targeted, when I hear of 'a political re-education camp'."

She called on Laurent Wauquiez, the regional political head who is also a former Republicans (centre-right) party leader, to visit the university away from the media storm to see the reality of its teaching.

However, with next April's presidential elections looming, the row has roused widespread political comment. Far-right candidates have backed the decision to withhold funding.

An MP from President Macron's party, François Jolivet, has called for the university to be placed under supervision, while Republicans leader Valérie Pécresse has said she fears freedom of expression is no longer guaranteed there.

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-59753043
 
Back
Top