Pakistan's woes in New Zealand points to sudden Test decline

jeetu

PPCL Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 19, 2010
Runs
9,883
Post of the Week
4
Writing for FirstPost Sports, Saj discusses the worrying decline in Pakistan's Test fortunes in the light of their 2-0 loss to New Zealand.

CyetPFDUsAAtkRL.jpg


"If anything can go wrong, it will” states one of the most popularly quoted Murphy’s laws. And judging from what transpired in the second and final Test between New Zealand and Pakistan, this law holds completely true for Azhar Ali and his beleaguered team mates not only for the second Test but probably for most parts of the recently-concluded series.

The team suffered a hefty blow to its morale in the first Test with what many felt was an ambush victory by the hosts. It appeared that Pakistan went into this series under-cooked to tackle the playing conditions which they encountered in Christchurch, and duly lost the first match of the series.

In a two-match series, losing the first game immediately put Pakistan on the back-foot; the margin of error was tight and it would have needed nerves of steel and great staying power as well as a better effort from them to come out with their recent unbeaten Test series record unscathed.

An unfortunate personal tragedy deprived Pakistan of their dependable and strangely much-reviled captain Misbah-ul-Haq, who missed the line-up for the must-win final Test in Hamilton. That left Azhar Ali, the chosen successor, with the unenviable task of not only picking up his own poor form, but also to rally the troops to perform better than what they had done so far.

Whilst Azhar Ali had been known to answer his critics whenever questions were raised about his batting, he was now also charged with leading the team through a very low point. Captaincy was thrust upon Azhar and though he was named as vice-captain for the series, it was clear that he was not prepared nor sufficiently trained for the job. But then, fates of teams are not only dictated by captains alone.

The Pakistan batsmen were shell-shocked by being put into bat in the first Test but this time around they were asked to bat second with plenty of time to reflect on their tactics. The results, however were eerily similar to that at Christchurch.

The familiar inability to handle the moving ball or play outrageously inappropriate shots was on display in both innings. Whilst one could forgive the likes of debutant Mohammad Rizwan for perishing in trying to attempt something aggressive in the first innings, the continued poor form of Pakistan’s batting maestro Younis Khan possibly hurt the side the most. His inability to provide any solidity or support to a frail middle-order which was already wilting due to Misbah’s absence probably was a major cause in Pakistan’s defeat.

Sixteen runs in four innings for Younis tells a story of a player clearly struggling for form once again. In addition, Asad Shafiq’s mysterious decline from the status of 'Mr Dependable' to a nervous wreck when Pakistan wanted him to stand and be counted was not only shocking throughout this series but also spells danger for the upcoming series against Australia.

Just when it appeared that the Pakistan batting had finally recovered its composure in time for stiffer challenges, the batting suffered a catastrophic failure on the final day which left even the staunchest supporters close to tears.

It was as if the last few series, which had seen a “fight to the last man” attitude develop in a team notorious for its mental fragility, had never happened. In a matter of forty-nine runs the progress that many had taken for granted was blown away as Pakistan placed on 181/2 slumped to an embarrassing 138-run loss after being bowled out for a paltry and puzzling 230. Last day pressure does strange things to teams, but this Pakistan Test side — which was recently rated as number one in the world — was surely capable of a better and more cohesive showing.

The recent history of Pakistan batting has never given much hope to followers of this team, so it was par for the course for many to expect miracles from the much-vaunted bowling attack instead. With Mohammad Amir now a set feature of the bowling line-up, and given the support for his style of bowling on New Zealand pitches, it was fair to hope that Amir would be able to lead the Pakistan bowlers to untold successes in this series. Granted that he continues to be the victim of some of the worst pieces of fielding in terms of catches dropped, the very talent that he represented was expected to surmount all and deliver victory for Pakistan. His total of three wickets in two innings at Hamilton may not have done justice to his skills but what it also reflected was the inability of Pakistan bowling to come to the aid of their beleaguered batting line-up.

Yes, Sohail Khan and the less-fancied Imran Khan stepped in to pick wickets but Amir and Wahab Riaz’s failure to light-up the sky inflicted great self-damage to Pakistan’s chances in the concluded game. Yasir Shah’s omission from the second Test team did raise some eye-brows, but to imagine that he would have single-handedly turned the game on its head is as ludicrous as thinking that Pakistan's tail-enders could hold the fort for even a few overs to eke out a face-saving draw on the fifth day.

In the end, a suicidal effort by the Pakistan team to attempt an unlikely winning target without realizing their own weaknesses may well have been the cause of an embarrassing defeat. They may have been encouraged by the batting skills of Sami Aslam and Babar Azam to hope that they could do the impossible but to dream of a victory with the middle-order in its current shape was foolhardy, and so it proved.

From the heady days of posing with the ICC Test Championship mace to looking forlorn in post-match ceremonies in Hamilton where the realisation that they had dropped seven rating points to be rated number four in the world was slowly dawning on them. The Pakistan Test team seems to have regressed in a matter of weeks. There was further bad news for Pakistan players as they were fined for slow over-rates losing a hefty part of their match fees.

Whilst that may represent another low point in the team’s progress, they know that inability to improve upon their weaknesses as well as the promise shown by a new-look Australia after the Adelaide Test against South Africa may well present further heartache and pain in the coming few months.

http://www.firstpost.com/sports/pak...ts-their-sudden-decline-in-tests-3131364.html
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Nice one Saj.

I really dont think we are this bad. Just the preparation for this series was more of an after thought although YK does need to look at his future very seriously
 
Younis is not going anywhere.. if he does before scoring 10,000 runs ill eat Boycott's hat!
 
.....321 runs to go...please hurry!

And to think, PCB kept Misbah and YK on to help in NZ and Aus?
Well, if you gonna lose anyway...why keep these guys!
 
Pakistans next two away Test series are in Australia and then the W.I we need to show in both there series that the Kiwi series was a possible blip and the team can perform outside of UAE/Asia shores.
 
Sami
Azhar
Babar
Asad?
????
????

Who do you guys think will seriously fill the 5th and 6th spot?

Any serious contenders or just the old mish-mash....
 
I felt that the reason for the whitewash was due to poor preparation. Any team will fail if they don't prepare well enough for future games, you can't be complacent about this.
 
There are really only two problems.

Firstly, Younis and Misbah were always going to be exposed in Australia in their forties. The failure to replace them these last couple of years will be catastrophic. And predictable.

Secondly, Sohail Khan and Imran Khan aren't good enough to succeed in Australia.

Watching "Inside Cricket" on Aussie TV now. They are talking about how good Amir has been, but how bad the slips have been.
 
There are really only two problems.

Firstly, Younis and Misbah were always going to be exposed in Australia in their forties. The failure to replace them these last couple of years will be catastrophic. And predictable.

Secondly, Sohail Khan and Imran Khan aren't good enough to succeed in Australia.

Watching "Inside Cricket" on Aussie TV now. They are talking about how good Amir has been, but how bad the slips have been.

One thing I want to know is why do people hate on Sohail Khan that much. The guy at least picks up wickets and can contribute the best with the bat compared to the other bowlers. I understand that he's slow but he's a million times better than Wahab.
 
Reasons for failure:

Defensive captaincy.
Poor "fast" bowling.
Weak middle order.
 
I think people need to calm down. I'm disappointed as everyone but people ought to remember this is the same team that since Aug 2014 went 7 Test series unbeaten for just the third time in its history. They haven't become bad players overnight.

However the series has been a wakeup call. The collapse triggered by Colin de Grandhomme on the first actual day's play in Hamilton was a sign of things to come. For me, this series defeat is on the batsmen. Yes we didn't bowl with sufficient control but when you don't cross 250 even once in a series its obvious where responsibility lies. Our mindset was so muddled - we were either too defensive in Azhar's case or downright reckless in the case of Younis. Azhar doesn't have the variety of shots against pace needed to up the tempo. Consequently, he ends up building pressure on himself and his partners with dot ball after another. Sami Aslam is a gutsy player but he must understand just blunting the new ball isn't enough. In these conditions there'll be a ball with your name on it so rotating strike is crucial. Otherwise you end up occupying the crease for long periods without shifting the scoreboard nor have put the bowlers under pressure.

Shafiq has been a letdown too. After the England tour he was promoted to 3 and expected to kick on. However he's been inconsistent and had to be demoted back to 6. His record outside Asia is very poor, averaging below 30 - this Australia tour is huge for him. He needs to rectify his issue against fuller, inswinging deliveries otherwise he'll struggle against Starc.

Finally, I like Younis a lot and haven't jumped on his back like many PPers after every failure because he has the ability to produce a special knock like he did at The Oval. But he's starting to become a worry outside Asia with how he's fishing outside off. Hopefully on flatter Australian wickets he can redeem himself after an abysmal series.

I agree with [MENTION=135332]ExplicitAI[/MENTION] that the preparation was terrible. Seriously, how could only one tour match be arranged, just days after the end of the WI series, at a venue during a particularly rainy season without any backup plans ?!

Our preparation for the England series set the template for how we should prepare for all tours outside Asia. The WI series should've been shorter to allow us more time to acclimatise to AUS/NZL conditions. That's not to make excuses and take nothing away from NZ's disciplined bowling. But enough navel gazing. Australia are vulnerable and pitches in Melbourne and Sydney will suit us. Yasir will be vital given their weakness against spin. It'll be tough of course, our record in Australia is dire but let's dust ourselves down and go again.
 
Last edited:
Anthing less than 3-0 in Australia will be a miracle of sorts.

I think it could be a continuation of the shambles we saw in New Zealand.
 
Anthing less than 3-0 in Australia will be a miracle of sorts.

I think it could be a continuation of the shambles we saw in New Zealand.

What makes you think that? There's enough in our team to win a test. We can sort things out. Mickey will know the conditions. I wouldn't go as far as saying it would be a miracle to avoid a whitewash!
 
What makes you think that? There's enough in our team to win a test. We can sort things out. Mickey will know the conditions. I wouldn't go as far as saying it would be a miracle to avoid a whitewash!
What makes me think that? The debacle in New Zealand makes me think it.

Hope I am proved wrong though.
 
What makes me think that? The debacle in New Zealand makes me think it.

Hope I am proved wrong though.

I understand where you're coming from. Those pitches were like England in early April. We had no time to get any practice.

I'm guessing that the pitches and climate in Australia should be more to Pakistan's liking. There's enough to do something good in this series.
 
Anthing less than 3-0 in Australia will be a miracle of sorts.

I think it could be a continuation of the shambles we saw in New Zealand.
As Misbah said, just because we didn't do well in NZ doesn't mean that will do poorly in AUS as well.
 
One thing I want to know is why do people hate on Sohail Khan that much. The guy at least picks up wickets and can contribute the best with the bat compared to the other bowlers. I understand that he's slow but he's a million times better than Wahab.

People are just blind man, just want their favorites to play.
 
Back
Top