I'm not shifting anything. You said that Pakistan should also do the same thing, and they can do so by choosing not to play with India. That doesn't mean tournaments should be moved to different countries for them. They can forfeit the matches if they want.
-
Contact the PP Team
PCB sends legal notice to ICC for settlement of their dispute with BCCI
- Thread starter MenInG
- Start date
I'm not shifting anything. You said that Pakistan should also do the same thing, and they can do so by choosing not to play with India. That doesn't mean tournaments should be moved to different countries for them. They can forfeit the matches if they want.
Again, not moving the tournament means playing India's game. We know that holding the tournament in India is a great source of prestige and revenue for Indian cricket, so to harm India, the tournament should be hosted anywhere OTHER than India. Whether that's the UAE, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Hong Kong, or Malaysia is irrelevant. Moving tournaments are not meant to accommodate Pakistan-rather, it is to deny India the right to have revenue and economic benefits from Pakistan playing on its soil. In fact, this is what happened with the 2011 World Cup. Rather than Pakistan being permitted to host its home matches in the UAE, they were reallocated and Pakistan was given nothing at all. It's an ICC decision to move tournaments, so you can't blame it on Pakistan. Pakistan has the right to push and lobby ICC to move tournaments. If India doesn't like it they're free to forfeit matches or whine as they please.
cricketjoshila
Test Captain
- Joined
- Mar 16, 2011
- Runs
- 47,983
- Post of the Week
- 1
Bcci' s game at ICC isnt done.Soon Supreme court will finalise the bcci rules and then bcci will be free from SC.They will hit icc where it hurts.Bccis power is its money and that will only grow with the growing economy.
Your thoughts and attitude which reflects PCB's ideology also.That is why general Indian population are not clamoring for Indo pakistan series.
BCCI is not running to Pakistan asking to play series.Asia Cup or any other multinational tournament , if PCB does not participate in those tournaments it will be loss for PCB not for BCCI.
They will play Asia cup or any other tournament with or without PCB's approval.
The benefit which BCCI will get if Pakistan participates or not in those multi national tournaments is negligible.
India cricketing calendar is already over crowded , so they will not miss Pakistan series where as Pakistan desperately needs these series that is the fact even if you chose to ignore it.
Cricket in Pakistan will be destroyed if they continue to be isolated and on top of it not play India.
Indian cricket has functioned very well with or without Pakistan matches. PCB threatened to pull Pakistani player in early editions and once they did it was loss for Pakistani players only.They are still facing the consequences of PCB's follies.
Any cricketing fan would endorse PCB if they appeared genuine and cared for betterment of region and sport.Reality is PCB shares your ideology and that will lead them nowhere.
So it's PCB that doesn't care for the sport? Where on earth did you get this belief?
It's BCCI that doesn't want to play ball.
If PCB cares for sport they wouldn't threatening to pull out of tournaments. BCCI says when everything is ready from their govt they will play Pakistan.
Why is PCB running here and there threatening legal action and all this mumbo jumbo.
BCCI cares for sport that is why hosted Afghanistan and Ireland matches. They could have gone same route which PCB took against WI when their players left them stranded in middle of an ODI series but instead of going to to court against them they toured WI and benefitted West Indies cricket.
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2004
- Runs
- 217,977
In absence of cricket between Pakistan India, this case will become the focal point of rivalry!
Savak
World Star
- Joined
- Feb 16, 2006
- Runs
- 50,134
- Post of the Week
- 3
BCCI must be taught a lesson that they cannot get away with everything. The PCB has every right to be compensated for their losses thanks to the BCCI.
Mp812
First Class Player
- Joined
- Jun 18, 2013
- Runs
- 2,861
True it's not failed venture but 2.6m well....jadeja or irfan pathan probably Make that much alone in1 season of ipl
Savak
World Star
- Joined
- Feb 16, 2006
- Runs
- 50,134
- Post of the Week
- 3
Compared to the Sri Lanka Premier League, Bangladesh Premier League, the PSL has done very well. You can't compare PSL to the IPL at this stage.
You think PSL will ever become even quarter as big as IPL.
cricketjoshila
Test Captain
- Joined
- Mar 16, 2011
- Runs
- 47,983
- Post of the Week
- 1
No one has taken the responsibility of baby sitting PCB and its problems. There is no law in ICC that can force a country to play another.
Savak
World Star
- Joined
- Feb 16, 2006
- Runs
- 50,134
- Post of the Week
- 3
Doubt it. If Big Bash League, English County T-20 league, CPL couldn't do it. PSL can't do it either but being second best is not bad either. PCB should actually be competing with the others. But the PSL has the potential to become the second biggest T-20 league in the world after IPL which is fine.
Savak
World Star
- Joined
- Feb 16, 2006
- Runs
- 50,134
- Post of the Week
- 3
Sure but laws do exist to force one party to compensate the other for damages and losses.
Yes, the laws do exist. But the PCB is knocking on the wrong door (ICC). The ICC is not going to do anything. Next option is legal recourse - courts. Now....to figure out which court.
cricketjoshila
Test Captain
- Joined
- Mar 16, 2011
- Runs
- 47,983
- Post of the Week
- 1
ICC isnt a court.It has no jurisdiction to decide on validity of any papers or anything.
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2004
- Runs
- 217,977
Yes no court but BCCI are part of the ICC and as such need to follow some form of decent behaviour?!
Isn't ICC a body of the members rather than a regulating body ala FIFA, doubt it can do much.
Also is that Mou posted real or fake?
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2004
- Runs
- 217,977
We will find out soon enough but it will set a precedent for sure.
MoU doc - cant vouch for anything in this day and age!
Fair enough, I asked because it won't stand in any legal court case, contractual document not even on letter head of BCCI or stamped as such not to mention the language is more we will sign an actual FTP than this is the FTP will take some doing to be accepted especially when the agreement is between artificial persons.
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2004
- Runs
- 217,977
But I think it would be very poor of BCCI personnel who were present at that signing to deny its existence. Surely they will have some memory and record/copy of this?
But it is a page not an agreement, whose existence is as yet unknown. BCCI seem to be arguing there is no agreement and PCB have yet to prove anything to the contrary.
cricketjoshila
Test Captain
- Joined
- Mar 16, 2011
- Runs
- 47,983
- Post of the Week
- 1
I take it MIG that you have some experience in handling financial and legal documents.Tell me is this letter anything more than a LOI?Even that may be stretching it.
Situation is beyond BCCIs control.Its now a matter that involves the govt and state itself.
cricketjoshila
Test Captain
- Joined
- Mar 16, 2011
- Runs
- 47,983
- Post of the Week
- 1
That letter is more or less the so called MoU.
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2004
- Runs
- 217,977
Then there is probably cause for BCCI to sue PCB for lying!
BCCI will never go for that, onus with any allegation is on the accuser. What I consider a valid agreement may not necessarily be a valid agreement but does not mean I am a lying unless it is proven that i knew the agreement to be invalid and still wilfully tried to mislead the other person.
So the BCCI should sue the PCB for lying at the ICC?
There;s no law against lying, doing so on a public platform, for instance during elections, or wrt financial dealings is illegal. There is no legal case for PCB, let alone BCCI.
Last edited:
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2004
- Runs
- 217,977
But we are overanalysing these documents. For all we know, this is how things have been done in the past. Only difference is that things are going to committees etc so expect people to become much more cautious in the future. Which isnt a bad thing.
Westindies and Australia if I am wrong did not play in Srilanka in 1996 world cup but they forfeited those games.PCB can do that to all future matches which are played in India.
Other than that no other board can force either ICC or any other country's board to do anything.PCB stopped its players from playing IPL and in subsequent IPLs the team stopped bidding for them.
PCB is sadly mistaken if it think they can somehow force BCCI to do anything.
Other than that no other board can force either ICC or any other country's board to do anything.PCB stopped its players from playing IPL and in subsequent IPLs the team stopped bidding for them.
PCB is sadly mistaken if it think they can somehow force BCCI to do anything.
Abdullah719
T20I Captain
- Joined
- Apr 16, 2013
- Runs
- 44,825
Will Make Space For India-Pakistan Bilateral Series Only After Government's Nod: BCCI
New Delhi: The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI)’s Joint Secretary Amitabh Chaudhary on Monday (December 11) said that if the government allows the board will create a window for bilateral series between rivals India and Pakistan.
“If the government agrees will make space for India-Pakistan bilateral series,” Chaudhary was quoted as saying by ANI after the board’s Special General Meeting (SGM).
India and Pakistan have not played against each other in the bilateral series since 2012 when Pakistan toured India for a short limited-overs series. With tensions between the two countries, the traditional-rivals have not played a full bilateral series since 2007.
However, India and Pakistan continue to play against each other at multinational tournaments or at ICC events. The recent being Champions Trophy in England, when the teams met twice in the tournament including the finals.
Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) has been keen on resuming the cricketing ties with India. With BCCI not honouring a memorandum of understanding signed in 2014, PCB decided to legal action.
“Our case is that the BCCI signed a MoU with us in 2014 to play six bilateral series, starting with our home series, which they have not done as yet. Secondly, they have avoided playing us in bilateral series since 2008 although they have no issues playing against us in ICC events,” the then PCB chairman Najam Sethi said.
http://www.india.com/sports/if-gove...tabh-chaudhary-bcci-acting-secretary-2738779/
New Delhi: The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI)’s Joint Secretary Amitabh Chaudhary on Monday (December 11) said that if the government allows the board will create a window for bilateral series between rivals India and Pakistan.
“If the government agrees will make space for India-Pakistan bilateral series,” Chaudhary was quoted as saying by ANI after the board’s Special General Meeting (SGM).
India and Pakistan have not played against each other in the bilateral series since 2012 when Pakistan toured India for a short limited-overs series. With tensions between the two countries, the traditional-rivals have not played a full bilateral series since 2007.
However, India and Pakistan continue to play against each other at multinational tournaments or at ICC events. The recent being Champions Trophy in England, when the teams met twice in the tournament including the finals.
Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) has been keen on resuming the cricketing ties with India. With BCCI not honouring a memorandum of understanding signed in 2014, PCB decided to legal action.
“Our case is that the BCCI signed a MoU with us in 2014 to play six bilateral series, starting with our home series, which they have not done as yet. Secondly, they have avoided playing us in bilateral series since 2008 although they have no issues playing against us in ICC events,” the then PCB chairman Najam Sethi said.
http://www.india.com/sports/if-gove...tabh-chaudhary-bcci-acting-secretary-2738779/
Abdullah719
T20I Captain
- Joined
- Apr 16, 2013
- Runs
- 44,825
PCB Press release on ICC cricket structures
Lahore December 11:
PCB wishes to clarify some reports in the media regarding the ongoing meetings on the new proposed ICC International Cricket Structures and the effect of these on the ICC Future Tours Programme with specific reference to Pakistan v India Series.
Since the onset of these discussions, PCB has reiterated its position on bilateral series vs India. Our position is that PCB’s agreement to the revised structures for international cricket is subject to the condition that PCB has a valid agreement to play bilateral matches with India and India vs Pakistan matches would be included in the FTP. This continues to be our position.
PCB has also informed the ICC that it has initiated a dispute resolution process against the BCCI under the ICC Dispute Resolution Committee Terms of Reference. Further to that the PCB’s claim is based on an existing agreement with the BCCI which contemplates that India will tour Pakistan in December 2019, August 2020 and Nov – Dec 2022 and Pakistan will tour India in Nov – Dec 2021.
Under the prevailing circumstances, it is PCB’s position that if the Dispute Resolution Committee decides the dispute in PCB’s favour then any FTP will need to be adjusted to reflect the decision. Any agreement of the PCB to any new FTP structure will therefore be without prejudice to its existing claims against BCCI and will be subject to the outcome of the ICC dispute resolution process.
Lahore December 11:
PCB wishes to clarify some reports in the media regarding the ongoing meetings on the new proposed ICC International Cricket Structures and the effect of these on the ICC Future Tours Programme with specific reference to Pakistan v India Series.
Since the onset of these discussions, PCB has reiterated its position on bilateral series vs India. Our position is that PCB’s agreement to the revised structures for international cricket is subject to the condition that PCB has a valid agreement to play bilateral matches with India and India vs Pakistan matches would be included in the FTP. This continues to be our position.
PCB has also informed the ICC that it has initiated a dispute resolution process against the BCCI under the ICC Dispute Resolution Committee Terms of Reference. Further to that the PCB’s claim is based on an existing agreement with the BCCI which contemplates that India will tour Pakistan in December 2019, August 2020 and Nov – Dec 2022 and Pakistan will tour India in Nov – Dec 2021.
Under the prevailing circumstances, it is PCB’s position that if the Dispute Resolution Committee decides the dispute in PCB’s favour then any FTP will need to be adjusted to reflect the decision. Any agreement of the PCB to any new FTP structure will therefore be without prejudice to its existing claims against BCCI and will be subject to the outcome of the ICC dispute resolution process.
Remind me again who refuses to play who? PCB's ideology is to play India because the rivalry makes the sport better. India's ideology is to harm Pakistan by refusing to play them outside of ICC tournaments. Who developed Afghanistan to the point of being a quality cricketing country? It was not India, it was Pakistan. India did nothing for years while PCB hosted Afghan teams in Pakistan, let them use the NCA, and was the first Full Member Afghanistan faced in an ODI. After all that India rushed in and bribed ACB with money in return for playing in India, etc. Pakistan is the one building the sport while India during their Big 3 play took money allocated for development of the game in order to fill their own pockets. We know that the word of the BCCI, written or otherwise, means nothing. All BCCI has is money.
Sethi isn't a great leader, he also only cares about money, but mark my words-Pakistan is destined to save cricket. India is working to destroy it, even if they don't realize it yet.
The BCCI cannot take anything. The $$ were in control of the ICC. The ICC was the one who transferred the money to BCCI. The ICC is at fault in this case.
Oh my dear friend!!! Let me tell u some point first.,
1) i understand u see this piece of paper and say damn bcci sent i t and it didnt do what it said so bang we shud go legal
2) you do realise that verbal contract is official in some countries and its not in others, so point u made in some of ur coments about this is a complete legal contract is ********, let me explain u how
Yes BCCI did say those things like you give us vote, we give u tours (maybe-coz i havent checked) but at that time we had hope of indo pak series,
Now something happens betweeb BCCI N PCB and that contract pic above may be is that
Now that has no offical quotes no legal terms or sanctions in it and isnt governed or under juridiction of nor icc nor anything else, ( even grade 10 child can write this kind of thing and it will look official)
Now bcci do want to play with pak but govt declines permission
So bcci cant go through with it, WHILE IN SOME COMMENTS U HIGHLITED BCCI SAYING GIVE US VOTE U GET CONTRACT THING U DIDNT HIGHLIGHT THEM SAYING IT WILL ONLY HAPPEN IF GOVT GIVES PERMISSION,, BUT AGAIN WHY WILL You see parts that doesnt prove ur point?
So even though there is a signed document and bcci cant go through with proposal (and fact that proposal said all this will hapen after this things get included in ftp which never happened) who is at fault here?? Pcb who didnt get tour? bCCi who didnt get permission? Or ind gov who cant give permission coz indian people dont want this to happen?
Now lets come back to point that signed document is not under icc juridiction and nor is it under any international court juridiction (ofc cause it has no terms or sanctions) it cant be judged by them and off national courts cant force judgments on foreign body, only means pcb must bear the loss
Now what pcb does is blame bcci and propogandas about how it wants to isolate pak and cricket stuff on bcci, sends legal notice?!! And expect bcci to pay!!!
But bcci is not bound by any terms or whatso ever that they have to pay if tour didnt happen, so all of this is a hoax
(if u personally ask i say even this document is fake)
But if its not answer above will solve ur trouble
Similar threads
- Poll
