What's new

POTW (Timepass) : SandyB

Muhammad10

T20I Debutant
Joined
Jul 7, 2013
Runs
6,284
This week's POTW (Timepass) award goes to film expert [MENTION=140459]SandyB[/MENTION] for his cinematic insight. Congratulations!

http://www.pakpassion.net/ppforum/s...p-10-Movies-of-All-Time&p=9089788#post9089788

Here are my 10 favorite pics, from the POV of an Indian Fan of Hollywood Movies . They are not judged solely on artistic merit . Also an attempt has been made to make the genres non repetitive in the list . Its more about how I felt about those movies and the impact they have made on my mind at various stages of my life.

1) The Godfather Part1 & 2 (tied)

I see them as one movie itself. Too good to separate and put either of them anywhere else .

Part one may have had the best cast and some of the greatest characters ever put on film (Don Corleone, Sonny, Luca etc etc ) and some of the greatest ever moments in cinema(the assasination scene, the baptism sequence) ! But part two as a whole was the better film.

Perfection in acting , casting and direction.

2) The Dark Knight

The absolute peak of comic book cinema ! May not be bettered ever !

Perfectly captures the essence of the Batman universe characters , especially the Joker, Harvey and Gordon . All the adjectives used for no.1 stand here as well . Greatness in acting , scripting. Amazing score and incredible moments. One of cinemas greatest villainous acts by Heath Ledger .!

Nolan is truly the most significant filmmaker of the 2K generation.

3) Terminator 2 : Judgement Day

Terminator one is critically the superior film. But the lack of a big budget may have hampered that one from reaching its max. potential. If you thought a movie about warring machines and cyborgs , full of gunfights and acted by one of the most wooden faced actors in Hollywood, would have zero emotional quotient or humanity , James Cameron could prove you wrong !! The final pain you feel when T600 dips into the molten metal will bring tears to most peoples eyes.. Absolute science fiction masterpiece from Cameron

4) The Lion King

My favourite movie as kid. Animated cinema may have scaled further peaks via the Toy Story movies or the Incredibles. But this movies shows why Disney still rules the animated universe. Beautifully crafted movie with some incredible emotional moments (Mufasa's death for eg.) . Great animation (not much help from computers back then ) and incredible music.

5) The Empire Strikes Back

Hollywood's greatest ever popcorn flick.
"A new Hope" may have prototyped the hollywood blockbuster formula (fantastical locations, special effects, endearing characters and vast worlds ), but "empire.." did it to perfection . Still remains the gold standard of what popular cinema is expected to do . Special mention to the great and memorable characters and perhaps cinemas greatest villain in Darth Vader.

6) Saving Private Ryan

Helmed by arguably Hollywood's most versatile and successful filmmaker (only Stanley Kubric and Scorcese come close in terms of versatility and Cameron in terms of sheer success ) ,Saving Private Ryan is arguably the greatest war movie ever. The opening 30 mins, is generally considered the greatest opening in cinema .

Amazing cast, especially the lead performance by Tom hanks. No war movie could put you into the middle of the battlefield and its emotions like this one did.

The film-making brilliance of Spielberg is in full flow throughout, aided by masterful cinematography and a haunting score by John Williams.

7) Memento

Christopher Nolan Appears once again in the list with his earlier (less mainstream) masterpiece and arguably his best film ! I consider this as a spiritual predecessor to the brand of cinema he took mainstream with Inception and Prestige . Not as "big" a movie like Inception in terms of concept or scale. But is an absolutely brilliant and confusing piece of cinema.

8) Raiders of the Lost Arc

Spielberg Makes the list again with a completely different genre of film. Showcases his talent as a filmamker in ample, in a time when CGI wasn't available to bail filmamkers out .The story , action and settings have had countless imitators in film and video games as well(

George Lucas's greatest work outside his original Star war's Trilogy (he wrote it ).

Nominated for Best picture , among the top 3 Action films ever and Indiana Jones is considered one of fictions greatest characters alongside Sherlock holmes and Harry Potter..

9) The Matrix

May surprise some of the posters from the west here , but "The Matrix" has influenced modern cinema like very few movies could. It showed the world (us desis) what "next level" means in hollywood film-making. It also ushered a new era in terms of Action movies and effects.

The action sequences and characterizations have been imitated and referenced in far too many movies across the globe. So are some of the lines . As a movie it was as far ahead and futuristic as a hollywood movie could be.

10) Forest Gump :

One of the greatest feel good cinema's ever. Brilliant movie with humanity at heart. Such an endearing character in Forest, played by Tom Hanks. Brings a smile to your face every time.

Notable mentions :

11) Psycho
12) Titanic
12) Goodfellas
13) Alien
14) Pulp Fiction
15) 2001 a Space Odyssey


PS: I have not seen Shwashank Redemption or the LOTR trilogy to give an assessment on them. So they don't make my list. Many great crime films have been left out to avoid repetition. Did not add all time classics like "Gone with The wind " and "Casablanca" for not having seen them .
 
Well done. Great to see a post about movies winning POTW. I might not completely agree with the list but it's still an excellent one
 
Congrats SandB! enjoyed reading that post! and obviously it's nothing to do with Memento being in your top 10 :yk
 
OMG OMG OMG.. !!!!!:yahoo:yahoo:yahoo

Never in my dreams did I think I'd win a POTW on PP. Have been lurking here since 2012 . I joined in 2016 and had decided to do some serious posting only recently. I just hoped to brush up my writing skills and somehow re-ignite my long-shelved idea of becoming a writer some-day..

Thanks mods !:39: and thanks guys for all the compliments:39: . I've long been a fan of hollywood films and prefer to watch mostly Hollywood movies (out of the various bolly, kolly, molly, tolly - woods available in my state ) .This pretty much gives an impression of a pretentious elitist wannabe, especially in socialist Kerala (south india )..:shrug

The list is pretty heartfelt (especially The Lion King) and a collection of movies that have influenced me right through my childhood , teenage and adulthood .

If we were to judge movies from an adult mid-20's perspective , the list would've had far more arts-y stuff. But you see cinema differently and for different motivations at different ages. So I thought it would be better to not just cinema on academic/artistic merit.

PS: Special shout out to [MENTION=46929]shaz619[/MENTION] who replied positively to many of my opinions in various 'Timepass' threads. You've really given me a boost to try and write and engage a lot more in PP.. :salute
 
Sorry but I am not sure why this is POTW. The list is pretty standard for any 20 something who is into movies. The reviews are also pretty generic. Only interesting addition I see in this list is "Raider of the lost arc". To me, that movie actually exemplifies the beginning of the trend of mindless action in movies. From the start, the movie goes from one action sequence to another, one stunt to the next, making the action while entertaining to some degree, totally mindless. The Fast and the Furious and many other movie franchises today are following the same formula.

As for "Saving Private Ryan" I would argue against it being the greatest war movie ever. "The thin Red line" by Terence Malick is my personal favorite but "Apocalypse Now" is superior to Private Ryan in aesthetics and direction IMO. Yes, the opening sequence is amazing and how Spielberg has handled the camera's POV is what makes him so great. If I can include his "Schindler's list" as a war movie than I would probably put that on top of everything.
 
Interesting list for someone who doesnt venture to that thread often
 
Congrats [MENTION=140459]SandyB[/MENTION], feel you should had won it for SRK one too!
 
Back
Top