What's new

PTV’s historic 40-run defence: Does this kind of result reflect the strength or weakness of our domestic cricket system?

Does this kind of result reflect the strength or weakness of our domestic cricket system?

  • Shows bowling depth and fighting spirit

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    12

BouncerGuy

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 29, 2023
Runs
41,707
In one of the most astonishing finishes in first-class cricket history, Pakistan Television (PTV) defended a target of just 40 runs against Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL) in the President’s Trophy Grade-I at the National Bank Stadium, Karachi. This wasn’t just a thrilling win—it was a world record.

PTV bowled out SNGPL for 37 in 19.4 overs, breaking a 232-year-old record for the lowest total ever successfully defended in first-class cricket. The previous record dated back to 1794, when Oldfield defended 41 against MCC at Lord’s.

Ali Usman was the star of the show, claiming 6 for 9 in the second innings and finishing with match figures of 10 for 75. He was ably supported by Amad Butt, who took 4 wickets to complete the collapse.

Final Innings Scorecard (SNGPL 2nd Innings, Target: 40):
  • Total: 37 all out in 19.4 overs
  • Top scorer: Mohammad Ilyas – 12 (off 17)
  • Ali Usman: 6.4–2–9–6
  • Amad Butt: 6–1–28–4

This result has sparked a fierce debate: Is this a sign of bowling brilliance and competitive spirit in our domestic circuit? Or does it expose a worrying lack of batting depth and pitch quality?
 
Batsmen just haven't got the chops these days.
 
They were batting aggressively to improve their net run rate. Joke aside. Experienced national Test captain was in that batting lineup. That answers everything
 
Considering the fact that they broke a 232 year old record, I would put it down to the quality of batting
 
These things can happen in sport. Records are there to be broken. Can't read too much into it as a one off.
 
Seems it was just a freak occurrence as others have said - looking at the highlights it doesn't seem the pitch was a minefield.
 
freak occurance, the pitch was turning but apart from one or two balls none was alarmingly poor, and credit where its due ptv fielded really well. also amad butt was swinging it which made it even more difficult for new batsmen to get their eye in. some bad shots, but its part and parcel of first class cricket. ali usman looks like a decent potential replacement for noman ali in a year or two, has decent batting stats too.
 
freak occurance, the pitch was turning but apart from one or two balls none was alarmingly poor, and credit where its due ptv fielded really well. also amad butt was swinging it which made it even more difficult for new batsmen to get their eye in. some bad shots, but its part and parcel of first class cricket. ali usman looks like a decent potential replacement for noman ali in a year or two, has decent batting stats too.
Credit should also go to Shamyl's captaincy. Almost all Pakistani captains, be it international or domestic, are defensive by default. 99% of them won't even bother to try and defend 40. There was a ring of close in fielders for Ali Usman right from the start and Amad Butt also had two or slips at all times.

I don't think Ali Usman needs to do anything more to be selected as the third spinner for tests. He was the highest wicket taker in the QeA trophy, did well in List A games and now picked a ten wicket haul in his first game in the President's cup.
 
'We believed in the miracle': Ali & Amad on PTV's record-breaking 40-run defence

Pakistan Television (PTV) had an improbable task of defending a paltry score on the third morning of the fourth-round President’s Trophy Grade-I game against Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL). An unprecedented bowling display at National Bank Stadium, Karachi helped PTV topple a first-class record that had stood for over 231 years.

Chief architects of the miraculous defence, left-arm spinner Ali Usman and right-arm pacer Amad Butt of PTV, bowled in tandem for 19.4 overs to make the unbelievable happen in little under two hours as SNGPL folded for 37, chasing 40.

The day began with PTV resuming their overnight second innings from 99-5 in 36.5 overs, with a 27 runs lead, and collapsing to 111 in just 36 balls in the first half hour. The next two hours saw PTV ploughing through the first-class records and pushing aside Oldfield’s record defence of 41 runs in August 1794 against Marylebone Cricket Club at the Lord’s Old Ground.

Ali began and closed the heist with the wickets of Ali Zaryab for a four-ball duck at start and Shehzad Gul with a nine-ball duck at the end. In the meanwhile, only Saifullah Bangash and Mohammad Ali put up some fight, batting for 78 and 40 minutes, respectively.

Bagging six for nine from 58 balls including five maidens, Ali also completed his fourth haul of 10 wickets or more on the trot and 86 wickets in the ongoing domestic season starting from Hanif Mohammad Trophy (12) in August, Quaid-e-Azam Trophy (48) and President’s Cup (16).

“When SNGPL had lost five wickets (for 14 runs), only then we started sensing a win and with the sixth falling, I got supreme confidence that we can even defend the remaining 21 runs as well.”, Ali Usman told PCB Digital in an exclusive chat.

He added, “For me this is a very special memory especially having taken six in defence of the meagre 40-run total, which felt unbelievable. It is such a surreal feat that I can’t even imagine now that we have done it.”

Amad’s contribution of four wickets for 28 runs in his 60 balls was only supporting act, but it is worth remembering that he walked in at 93-6 in PTV’s first innings and remained unbeaten on 46 off 64 balls hitting four fours and three sixes. He then took three for 42 in 16.3 overs.

The right-arm pacer downplayed the magnitude of the achievement saying, “To be very honest it wasn’t something special but before walking in to the ground for the defence of the 40 runs, I only had this passing thought of how things often happen for first time and how records are broken and then it just happened.”

Amad also described how late-order resistance from Mohammad Ali made them wait, “I first anticipated the win when we dismissed Shan Masood with 11 runs on the board but Mohammad Ali entered at 19-6 and batted for next eight overs with only one wicket falling, which again took away the hope for a bit. It just kept on fluctuating between the two teams and I feel we couldn’t consider ourselves safe at any point”

Amad led PTV to the President’s Trophy title in the previous edition and in the ongoing tournament he has so far taken 24 wickets at 13 in four matches and scored 126 runs in the lower order.

In the ongoing season, PTV, captained by Shamyl Hussain, have won three out of the four games and look inspired to defend the title.

Talking about the special win, PTV skipper Shamyl said, “I think it was a win based on momentum, which we had on our side and SNGPL just kept on getting under pressure to the point when it started looking like they might lose it altogether. I only felt that we can win this game after the fall of Saifullah, who was the ninth batter to fall.”

List of lowest totals defended in first-class cricket:

40 by PTV v SNGPL 2025

41 by Oldfield v MCC 1794

42 by Eastern Province v Border 1947

44 by England v Kent and Sussex 1856

49 by Kent v Sussex 1925

PCB
 
People are being too charitable.

It's totally inexcusable for a FC team to fail to chase 40. From the highlights, it didn't appear the pitch was a minefield.
 
This game shows that Shan Masood should not be captaining Pakistan. His captaincy record is Panoti. He has established a world record for losing games singlehandedly with his pathetic captaincy from commanding winning positions.
 
People are being too charitable.

It's totally inexcusable for a FC team to fail to chase 40. From the highlights, it didn't appear the pitch was a minefield.
India got 36 all out.
Sydney Thunder got out for 15.

It is inexcusable. But it happens. Teams lose the moment.

They don't become bad teams for that and it's not an indictment of their cricket structure either.

Pakistan has had terrible governance, poor pitches, bad stadiums and chopping and changing in every aspect of its cricket most of its history. But this is the first result of this kind.

It's OK. It happens.
 
Back
Top