Major
T20I Star
- Joined
- Aug 28, 2013
- Runs
- 32,501
- Post of the Week
- 7
Seniority prevails
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: this_feature_currently_requires_accessing_site_using_safari
im kinda mixed about this
Raheel shareef was so brilliant that i wouldnt have minded him getting another term eventhough all my adult life i have been against that notion
the problem is that our COAS have a lot of power so one crazy loon can lead us to the abyss esp cuz theres always a chance that he might take over n a martial law someday.
atleast with PM there are some checks and protests no matter how pointless and ineffective they may seem.
Best of luck to Qamar Javaid Bajwa....hopefully he will continue with Raheel Sharif's policies especially no interference in politics.
Are you sure? Care to explain in detail?
Can you please answer a amatuer question for me ?
Who makes these Army chief selection ? I mean who appoints COAS?
wish Pakistanis dont make the appointment of COAS a big deal; it should not be even a news; I dont know the name of army chief of Canada and most of Canadians are like that; Pakistanis should be like that too
Canada has a tiny army compared to Pakistan and it does not have any conflicts with any country in the world. Pakistan on the other hand is nuclear armed and has a hostile and war-mongering neighbour on its eastern front. Obviously the Pakistani army chief will be more important for Pakistan than the Canadian chief for Canada.
I can bet 99.5% of Indians do not know who their army chief is, I am sure huge number of Pakistanis also don't know or don't want to know but posters, hoardings and such keep them informed in Pakistan like the popularity of Tendulkar in India, people just know him in India even in non cricketing states. We netizens tend to exaggerate and impose our viewpoint on aam junta. You are also in small minority, a Pakistani Canadian having keen interest in South Asian politics. Consider yourself privileged, average Indian/Pakistan wants to bid adieu to poverty ridden motherland and never return back.
My post was not to compare Canada and Pakistan; it was to show what is the expected behaviour of general public in case of an appointment of army chief in a democracy. The important persons are your political leaders as you are a democracy; the army chief should not be an important person.Canada has a tiny army compared to Pakistan and it does not have any conflicts with any country in the world. Pakistan on the other hand is nuclear armed and has a hostile and war-mongering neighbour on its eastern front. Obviously the Pakistani army chief will be more important for Pakistan than the Canadian chief for Canada.
No need to discuss his caste/ethnicity.
My post was not to compare Canada and Pakistan; it was to show what is the expected behaviour of general public in case of an appointment of army chief in a democracy. The important persons are your political leaders as you are a democracy; the army chief should not be an important person.
I hope he interferes in politics as much as possible since Army is the only check and balance we have to discipline these corrupt parliamentarians.
checks and balances are done by the public, army influence is what kills your democracy
I can bet 99.5% of Indians do not know who their army chief is, I am sure huge number of Pakistanis also don't know or don't want to know but posters, hoardings and such keep them informed in Pakistan like the popularity of Tendulkar in India, people just know him in India even in non cricketing states. We netizens tend to exaggerate and impose our viewpoint on aam junta. You are also in small minority, a Pakistani Canadian having keen interest in South Asian politics. Consider yourself privileged, average Indian/Pakistan wants to bid adieu to poverty ridden motherland and never return back.
exactly this!
Sadly these guys like to keep themselves in the limelight.
Its funny how the COAS is being appointed by the PM, but at the same time it sends a chill on everyones spine as the COAS have been known for taking over under martial law.
Martial law is not the same thing as a coup I've noticed a lot of Pakistanis mix the two words together, I think it's cause of how illiterate the people are.
the bolded part typifies what is wrong with some of the thinking n Pakistan; it is the job of army chief to follow orders of government; the ownership of operation against extremists belongs to the government; army is just a tool to implement that operation; there is no need to hope that he do his job; he has to do his job or else he will be fired and another person will be selected to do his job;According to the article in Dawn he considers religious extremism in Pakistan a bigger threat for Pakistan rather than India. That's good to know. Hope he can continue with the operations against extremists and make Pakistan safe again.
Also there have been questions about his religious affiliation. Not sure if it's true or not but if it is, I consider his appointment a brilliant move!
this is why i think i said,
...........COAS have been known for taking over under martial law
I don't think this is a good move by Nawaz. General Isfaq Nadeem was Raheel Sharif's right hand man and was actually the one who was closely advising RS on all policy matters. Isfaq Nadeem was also quite vocal and let his opinion known amongst all close quarters (I know all this since a friend of mine belongs to Isfaq's family)
Isfaq was the best man if you wanted continuation in RS's mission, Qamar Bajwa may take a different direction on things.
One possible reason that Nawaz didn't nominate Isfaq is because he happened to be Raheel Sharif's personal choice and since he was so opinionated he won't have any qualms in telling NS that you are wrong or you need to do something a certain way. Remember NS wants a chief who is "apna bunda" and loyal to him.
the bolded part typifies what is wrong with some of the thinking n Pakistan; it is the job of army chief to follow orders of government; the ownership of operation against extremists belongs to the government; army is just a tool to implement that operation; there is no need to hope that he do his job; he has to do his job or else he will be fired and another person will be selected to do his job;
Has it ever happened before ?
[UTUBE]JgIJ-p1Qfmk[/UTUBE]
The more they try the "tame" the COAS, the more it will backfire. He will now have to go out of his way to wash himself of this stigma.
We need to understand that he needs to look after the interests of his corp commanders too. He needs to win their loyalty and distance himself from the government.
Lou Ji
According to Senior Dabung Journalist Chaudhry Ghulam Hussain , Hussain Nawaz Son of PM sahib has met COAS & CJCSC yesterday in Bahria Town Phase 8 Rawalpindi.
Mosoof ka kya lena dena tha ?
So new COAS had a meeting with Nawaz Sharif's son (Hussain Nawaz) on his first day in office, had a phone conversation with 'Eent se eent baja deingay" Zardari and selfies with PMLN's Zubair Umar family (that could be due to their Army link). I thought they wanted COAS to stay away from politics?
thats not true; some people are trying to discredit Qamar Bajwa; first they tried to portray him as a Qadiani when he is not; then they tried to show him meeting NS's son when he did not meet; not sure who are those people may be establishment trying to force Qamar Bajwa to toe their line
Brig (retired) Feroz Hassan Khan, who was Bajwa’s commanding officer on the LoC, says the man in what is usually seen as the most powerful position in Pakistan does not have a “visceral hatred” of India.
“There is an assumption that every Pakistani military officer who rises has some sort of a visceral hatred towards India, as if it’s a default. This is not the case with (Bajwa) and I can tell you he has studied India so much,” Khan told Hindustan Times on phone from Monterey, California, where he teaches at the US Naval Postgraduate School.
Bajwa, with whom Khan has stayed in touch over the years, “understands India (and) reads a lot of what India writes and knows a lot about what India thinks”. He added, “There’s hardly any senior officer of his level who reads a lot of what is published in India and he studies, he reflects and he remembers.”
Describing Pakistan's new Army chief, former Indian Army chief General Bikram Singh, under whom Bajwa has worked in UN force, said Bajwa was a "thorough professional" who gave an "outstanding performance" in the Congo mission, but said things change once an officer goes back to his home country and India should wait and watch, and be "careful".
Though little is publicly known about the ancestry of general Bajwa, he is said to be a Punjabi Muslim Jat. Incidentally, Indian Army chief General DS Suhag also happens to be a Jat. The appointment of Qamar Javed Bajwa has sent a significant signal to archrival India as the new army chief has remained clear about his stance towards India all through his service.