What's new

Should PSL consider banning players who opt out for non-injury reasons?

Should PSL consider banning players who opt out for non-injury reasons?


  • Total voters
    25

FearlessRoar

T20I Star
Joined
Sep 11, 2023
Runs
30,521

As the PSL prepares to share a window with the IPL next year, the issue of player availability is likely to become even more pressing. By considering a rule like the one suggested by Maran, the PSL can ensure that teams are not unfairly disadvantaged and that fans get to see the best possible talent on display.

In the past, several high-profile players have opted out of the PSL for reasons other than injury. For example:

Kieron Pollard, a key player for the Karachi Kings, left the team mid-season in 2024 to attend the wedding of Anant Ambani, the son of Indian business tycoon Mukesh Ambani, in India.

What are your suggestions?
 
They should, IPL should, BBL should, and everyone should. It is perfectly fine if a player considers a league beneath them and decide not to participate. But once you decide to participate, and a team has accommodated you, it is your professional responsibility to show and do your best. They should ban and ensure players like that are never recruited
 
That is too harsh but what else can one expect after spending so much money
 
PCB lacks the financial clout to make this policy work.
 
Only the IPL could pull off something like that.

They throw big money contracts at these players and can use this as leverage to get them to listen. PSL or any other league would get laughed at because they're all in the same boat.

As long as players have their IPL contract + national team contract, they will be happy to sacrifice everyone else.
 
PSL is not such a big brand that they would be able to pull out such a thing. IPL can do that because they throw a huge sum of money and the payers will fear about their place for the next time so it can work for them but PSL?? I guess not.
 
IPL teams can do this because most teams own multiple franchisees across leagues. So if they get together to ban anyone, it may affect the player in other leagues as well.

This is usually a problem with English players. And sometimes Aussies. Rest don't create this issue.

BCCI should take up this with ECB. They have been pulling out players at the last moment.
 
Psl don't have such status . Pakistan should be thankful that few oldies are coming for now to play such low grade unprofessional league.
 
They should, IPL should, BBL should, and everyone should. It is perfectly fine if a player considers a league beneath them and decide not to participate. But once you decide to participate, and a team has accommodated you, it is your professional responsibility to show and do your best. They should ban and ensure players like that are never recruited

Can't the onus then fall on the teams and the leagues to not continue signing players that have demonstrated such behaviour in the past? Effectively creating their own informal "blacklist" of players?
 
Corbin Bosch served legal notice by PCB

Lahore, 16 March 2025:

South Africa’s Corbin Bosch has been served a legal notice by the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) alleging breach of the all-rounder’s contractual obligations to the PCB.

The 30-year-old Bosch was picked by Peshawar Zalmi in the Diamond category during the tenth edition of HBL PSL Player Draft, held in Lahore on 13 January. The legal notice was served through his agent, and the player has been asked to justify his actions of withdrawing from his professional and contractual commitments.

The PCB management has also outlined the repercussions of his departure from the league and expects his response within the stipulated time frame. The PCB will not make any further comments on the matter.
 
Corbin Bosch served legal notice by PCB

Lahore, 16 March 2025:

South Africa’s Corbin Bosch has been served a legal notice by the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) alleging breach of the all-rounder’s contractual obligations to the PCB.

The 30-year-old Bosch was picked by Peshawar Zalmi in the Diamond category during the tenth edition of HBL PSL Player Draft, held in Lahore on 13 January. The legal notice was served through his agent, and the player has been asked to justify his actions of withdrawing from his professional and contractual commitments.

The PCB management has also outlined the repercussions of his departure from the league and expects his response within the stipulated time frame. The PCB will not make any further comments on the matter.
He has joined Mumbai Indians as replacement
 
Idiotic move by the PCB. If they decided to come exist and be a subsidiary to the IPL, then they need to accept things like this happening where psl foreign players will be called up to the IPL as replacements in the event of injuries and accommodate these requests.

By threatening to take legal action against psl foreign players who leave the league at the start or midway if they get called up by the IPL, they are going to deter foreign players from signing up with the PSL in the future.

PCB and psl cannot compete with the BCCI and IPL franchises for money. Don't forget, a lot of the IPL franchise owners now own teams in the US T20 league, hundred, SA T20 and ILT20 leagues therefore even if a foreign player does not get picked in the IPL, they will be mindful that they can get picked in the other leagues and they will never get into the bad books of the IPL franchise owners.
 
The easy and reasonable solution here would be for the ICC to ban leagues from selecting players who are already contracted to another tournament.
 
The easy and reasonable solution here would be for the ICC to ban leagues from selecting players who are already contracted to another tournament.

Corbin bosch already plays for MI cape Town. And ICC cannot ban leagues on how they function. IPL owners own multiple teams across multiple leagues if they start banning their players from PSL, PSL would have nothing left.

Pakistanis and PCB may have problems but then anyone who gets a IPL contract and already plays for one of the IPL owned teams will choose his IPL owners over PSL.
 
Corbin Bosch served legal notice by PCB

Lahore, 16 March 2025:

South Africa’s Corbin Bosch has been served a legal notice by the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) alleging breach of the all-rounder’s contractual obligations to the PCB.

The 30-year-old Bosch was picked by Peshawar Zalmi in the Diamond category during the tenth edition of HBL PSL Player Draft, held in Lahore on 13 January. The legal notice was served through his agent, and the player has been asked to justify his actions of withdrawing from his professional and contractual commitments.

The PCB management has also outlined the repercussions of his departure from the league and expects his response within the stipulated time frame. The PCB will not make any further comments on the matter.

TLDR: manifestation of Impotent rage by PCB.

Tumhari yeh zurrat .... etc etc
 
Corbin bosch already plays for MI cape Town. And ICC cannot ban leagues on how they function. IPL owners own multiple teams across multiple leagues if they start banning their players from PSL, PSL would have nothing left.

Pakistanis and PCB may have problems but then anyone who gets a IPL contract and already plays for one of the IPL owned teams will choose his IPL owners over PSL.

The ICC can put regulations in place that need to be met for leagues to be approved. Not permitting leagues to select players who are already under contract to play elsewhere at the same time could be one of those regulations. If players want to keep themselves available on the off chance someone gets injured then they would have to make that decision in advance rather than violate their existing contract.
 
The ICC can put regulations in place that need to be met for leagues to be approved. Not permitting leagues to select players who are already under contract to play elsewhere at the same time could be one of those regulations. If players want to keep themselves available on the off chance someone gets injured then they would have to make that decision in advance rather than violate their existing contract.

Then IPL owners will simply ask players contracted by them in other leagues to not sign with the PSL.

IPL will simply not allow anyone who wants to appear in the PSL sign for the IPL.

Whether contract has been violated or not will be decided by courts.

ICC isn't going to make rules just for PSL and PCB. No matter how much pakistanis want that kind of special treatment.
 
Then IPL owners will simply ask players contracted by them in other leagues to not sign with the PSL.

IPL will simply not allow anyone who wants to appear in the PSL sign for the IPL.

Whether contract has been violated or not will be decided by courts.

ICC isn't going to make rules just for PSL and PCB. No matter how much pakistanis want that kind of special treatment.

These wouldn't be rules for the PCB/PSL, they'd be rules around all leagues. Others that should be considered are if a player has signed for a league they shouldn't be allowed to start playing for a team in another league until the original league has finished in full (regardless of whether their team has been knocked out).
 
Corbin Bosch served legal notice by PCB

Lahore, 16 March 2025:

South Africa’s Corbin Bosch has been served a legal notice by the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) alleging breach of the all-rounder’s contractual obligations to the PCB.

The 30-year-old Bosch was picked by Peshawar Zalmi in the Diamond category during the tenth edition of HBL PSL Player Draft, held in Lahore on 13 January. The legal notice was served through his agent, and the player has been asked to justify his actions of withdrawing from his professional and contractual commitments.

The PCB management has also outlined the repercussions of his departure from the league and expects his response within the stipulated time frame. The PCB will not make any further comments on the matter.
It was expected and I hope PCB had laid a thick legal document when the player was signed/drafted for PSL.

But things will get real spicy.
 
Then IPL owners will simply ask players contracted by them in other leagues to not sign with the PSL.
How many players are they going to buy like this really? Each year a new foreign player shows up.

Realistically speaking they cannot buy every player and not every player is going to agree to their dictation of what league they do or do not play.

Though with Indian franchises around the world and in different leagues it will compell some to sign pre contracts to not sign for Non Indian influenced league.

But this will not last very long. At the end of the day the players will decide what they want and will not get bullied into anything.
 
These wouldn't be rules for the PCB/PSL, they'd be rules around all leagues. Others that should be considered are if a player has signed for a league they shouldn't be allowed to start playing for a team in another league until the original league has finished in full (regardless of whether their team has been knocked out).

But other leagues are not asking for this and are not affected by these issues either.

PSL has this issue and its their problem because their league clashes with the IPL.

ICC isn't going to start making rules just for pakistanis.
 
How many players are they going to buy like this really? Each year a new foreign player shows up.

Realistically speaking they cannot buy every player and not every player is going to agree to their dictation of what league they do or do not play.

Though with Indian franchises around the world and in different leagues it will compell some to sign pre contracts to not sign for Non Indian influenced league.

But this will not last very long. At the end of the day the players will decide what they want and will not get bullied into anything.

They have multiple teams across multiple leagues and hence can sign up a large number of players.

Bosch already plays for the MI owned SA20 team. So ofcourse he has affinity towards that franchisee.

With IPL teams now owning teams across the globe, they are likely to have access to any such rising star before because that player probably plays for one of the IPL owned teams.

The only league that has problems with the IPL is PSL.
 
But other leagues are not asking for this and are not affected by these issues either.

PSL has this issue and its their problem because their league clashes with the IPL.

ICC isn't going to start making rules just for pakistanis.

Plenty of leagues have had this issue.
 
Which ones?

AFAIK majority teams in most leagues like SA20 Hundred ILT20 MLC CPL are owned by IPL team owners and they haven't been complaining and are unlikely to complain.

Pakistanis problem isn't everyone's problem.

Purely off the top of my head several players have partially withdrawn from their BBL contracts after gettingi ILT20 deals. Shaheen Afridi withdrew from the hundred with the intention of signing for the GT20. Moeen Ali withdrew from the SA20 to sign for the ILT20.

The other issue of players being allowed to go play another league before the original league they're a part of has concluded is also an integrity issue given it potentially gives them a financial incentive not to win.
 
When will they serve Babar & Rizwan a legal notice for breaching their contractual obligations by deliberately missing domestic cricket games?
Rizwan is playing club cricket in God knows what league in Peshawar whilst the national T20 cup is ongoing
 
Rizwan is playing club cricket in God knows what league in Peshawar whilst the national T20 cup is ongoing
Maybe he was not willing to face Ihsanullah in the national T20 cup who has not been picked in the PSL :)
 
Purely off the top of my head several players have partially withdrawn from their BBL contracts after gettingi ILT20 deals. Shaheen Afridi withdrew from the hundred with the intention of signing for the GT20. Moeen Ali withdrew from the SA20 to sign for the ILT20.

The other issue of players being allowed to go play another league before the original league they're a part of has concluded is also an integrity issue given it potentially gives them a financial incentive not to win.

BBL hasn't sued anyone. Why? Because its known before hand which player will leave when. The players are signed on that basis.


ILT20 hasnt sued anyone. Neither did SA20. They have an understanding on how to deal with this kind of issues.



Speaking on Wednesday, Graeme Smith, the league commissioner of South Africa's newly named SA20, acknowledged the England allrounder's complicated situation, given that he had been announced in the squads for both the Johannesburg Super Kings and the ILT20's Sharjah Warriors. Later the same afternoon, Moeen confirmed in an a announcement on Twitter that he would be choosing the Warriors as his primary destination.





"We have aligned on a strategy in terms of allowing the player to feel comfortable in terms of what he does and where he decides to play," Smith said when asked about Moeen. "I am dealing with the UAE league in that.




"I was in the UAE last week and met with them and that will play itself out over the next few days. We have agreed a way of handling it. There needs to be a way that both of us can co-exist.




"There is a relationship that's opened up there in terms of finding a way forward. I am looking forward to further engagements with the UAE league on that."




The uniqueness of Moeen's situation had centred on the agreements he entered into with both leagues. Having given commitments to both with an understanding he would pick the tournament he preferred, it turns out Moeen had signed directly with the Warriors. Thus, the ILT20 believed they have a greater claim to him than the SA20, given he had only signed with Cricket South Africa rather than a direct team.

That's the whole saga. SA20 and ILT20 have an understanding.

Shaheen Afridi didn't get NoC.

This is a PSL problem because its in the middle of IPL and players will likely choose the IPL over PSL.
 
BBL hasn't sued anyone. Why? Because its known before hand which player will leave when. The players are signed on that basis

Some players have been, others have been signed later and changed their situation however. The point is the leagues shouldn't have to sue anyone, there should be established rules in place around this and expecting players to honour their contracts seems a fairly reasonable baseline for that.

Shaheen Afridi didn't get NoC.

He withdrew from the hundred with the intention of signing for the GT20 before that happened.
 
Rizwan is playing club cricket in God knows what league in Peshawar whilst the national T20 cup is ongoing

He’s playing in his back garden against the local masjid bacheh :yk3
 
Some players have been, others have been signed later and changed their situation however. The point is the leagues shouldn't have to sue anyone, there should be established rules in place around this and expecting players to honour their contracts seems a fairly reasonable baseline for that.



He withdrew from the hundred with the intention of signing for the GT20 before that happened.

If the players and the team and the league have a understanding why should anyone else be bothered with it? Its a mutual thing.

Ofcourse there is little chance PCB and BCCI will have such an understanding.


Shaheen Afridi didn't sign a full contract with ECB before withdrawing.

ECB avoid paying £5,000 to Shaheen Afridi after bowler did not sign full Hundred contracT.​


 
The funny thing is, this Bosch guy was offered more money in PSL than in IPL, yet he chose IPL and ditched PSL.
He might not be considered in PSL in the future, and his IPL participation depends on his performance. Seems like a tough situation for him. :ROFLMAO:
 
The funny thing is, this Bosch guy was offered more money in PSL than in IPL, yet he chose IPL and ditched PSL.
He might not be considered in PSL in the future, and his IPL participation depends on his performance. Seems like a tough situation for him. :ROFLMAO:
What are you waffling on about you numpty.

He was getting $85,000 in the PSL.

compared to $347,000 in ipl.
 
The funny thing is, this Bosch guy was offered more money in PSL than in IPL, yet he chose IPL and ditched PSL.
He might not be considered in PSL in the future, and his IPL participation depends on his performance. Seems like a tough situation for him. :ROFLMAO:

He likely thought he will get more by being loyal to MI and they will reward him with opportunities in IPL, MLT20, SAT20, ILT20 and if he gets selected in all these leagues by the MI owners, he will make 3-4 times more money than what he can earn in the PSL.

If the PCB and the PSL Franchise Owners don't have the stomach for these situations then they should not have held the PSL at the same time as the IPL.
 
What are you waffling on about you numpty.

He was getting $85,000 in the PSL.

compared to $347,000 in ipl.
Bosch was listed at 30lakh INR in IPL (which is $34,600). You added an extra zero.

He was unsold so doubt he will be getting more than that now when he was bought outside auction.
 
How many players are they going to buy like this really? Each year a new foreign player shows up.

Realistically speaking they cannot buy every player and not every player is going to agree to their dictation of what league they do or do not play.

Though with Indian franchises around the world and in different leagues it will compell some to sign pre contracts to not sign for Non Indian influenced league.

But this will not last very long. At the end of the day the players will decide what they want and will not get bullied into anything.
BCCI in The Final Boss mode: :kp @shaz619 @BunnyRabbit @RedwoodOriginal

Used AI to make it so don't delete it please. :inti

file-EoVyTQEqee67VcveBfyL9F.webp
 
Bosch was listed at 30lakh INR in IPL (which is $34,600). You added an extra zero.

He was unsold so doubt he will be getting more than that now when he was bought outside auction.

The maximum he can get is ₹75L.

Thats $86500.

Not more than that. Its the rule. A replacement player cannot get more than what the player he replaced was getting.
 
What are you talking? Where did you get this $347000 ?
Corbin Bosch, a 30-year-old South African bowling all-rounder, is a right-hand batsman and a right-arm medium-fast bowler. He has no prior IPL experience and initially went unsold in the IPL 2025 Mega Auction at a base price of INR 30 lakhs. roughly $347.000 US dollars.

Now, Mumbai Indians have signed him for the same amount as a replacement for Lizaad Williams. Notably, Bosch is already associated with the Mumbai Indians franchise, having played for MI Cape Town in SA20.





Corbin bosch in PSL.

 
I need to know what you have smoked when you type this :kp
What are you talking? Where did you get this $347000 ?
Corbin Bosch, a 30-year-old South African bowling all-rounder, is a right-hand batsman and a right-arm medium-fast bowler. He has no prior IPL experience and initially went unsold in the IPL 2025 Mega Auction at a base price of INR 30 lakhs. roughly $347.000 US dollars.

Now, Mumbai Indians have signed him for the same amount as a replacement for Lizaad Williams. Notably, Bosch is already associated with the Mumbai Indians franchise, having played for MI Cape Town in SA20.





Corbin bosch in PSL.

https://www.clubcricket.co.za/latestnews/corbin-bosch-joins-peshawar-zalmi-in-psl/


Your quote:
I need to know what you have smoked when you type this :kp :

Answer The same stuff kohli ask him.
:shh.


 
Bosch was listed at 30lakh INR in IPL (which is $34,600). You added an extra zero.

He was unsold so doubt he will be getting more than that now when he was bought outside auction.
The figure is currently undisclosed due to the possible legal ramification from the PCB but common sense would dictate he is being paid more.

I've heard he has said due to indian influence in other leagues he didn't want to jeopardise other future opportunities.
 
Corbin Bosch, a 30-year-old South African bowling all-rounder, is a right-hand batsman and a right-arm medium-fast bowler. He has no prior IPL experience and initially went unsold in the IPL 2025 Mega Auction at a base price of INR 30 lakhs. roughly $347.000 US dollars.

Now, Mumbai Indians have signed him for the same amount as a replacement for Lizaad Williams. Notably, Bosch is already associated with the Mumbai Indians franchise, having played for MI Cape Town in SA20.





Corbin bosch in PSL.

https://www.clubcricket.co.za/latestnews/corbin-bosch-joins-peshawar-zalmi-in-psl/


Your quote:
I need to know what you have smoked when you type this :kp :

Answer The same stuff kohli ask him.
:shh.


So is it you who can do basic math or the SA website?
 
The figure is currently undisclosed due to the possible legal ramification from the PCB but common sense would dictate he is being paid more.

I've heard he has said due to indian influence in other leagues he didn't want to jeopardise other future opportunities.
I was curious about this. It is clear violation of contract by Corbin IMO.

Question is will PCB file the case? where? In Pakistan? If he ignore Pak court, can PCB get Interpol involved?

🍿
 

As the PSL prepares to share a window with the IPL next year, the issue of player availability is likely to become even more pressing. By considering a rule like the one suggested by Maran, the PSL can ensure that teams are not unfairly disadvantaged and that fans get to see the best possible talent on display.

In the past, several high-profile players have opted out of the PSL for reasons other than injury. For example:

Kieron Pollard, a key player for the Karachi Kings, left the team mid-season in 2024 to attend the wedding of Anant Ambani, the son of Indian business tycoon Mukesh Ambani, in India.

What are your suggestions?
Absolutely Yes,
Viewership is not determined by the run of the mill players that PSL is able to afford now. PSL should maintain this rule for discipline and ensure consistency in team structure and build loyalty among the fanbases.

Nobody is watching PSL in NZ just because Glen Philips in playing Lahore Qalandars. Your market is Pakistan focus on building and nurturing to that consumer base.
 
Corbin Bosch, a 30-year-old South African bowling all-rounder, is a right-hand batsman and a right-arm medium-fast bowler. He has no prior IPL experience and initially went unsold in the IPL 2025 Mega Auction at a base price of INR 30 lakhs. roughly $347.000 US dollars.

Now, Mumbai Indians have signed him for the same amount as a replacement for Lizaad Williams. Notably, Bosch is already associated with the Mumbai Indians franchise, having played for MI Cape Town in SA20.





Corbin bosch in PSL.

https://www.clubcricket.co.za/latestnews/corbin-bosch-joins-peshawar-zalmi-in-psl/


Your quote:
I need to know what you have smoked when you type this :kp :

Answer The same stuff kohli ask him.
:shh.


How are you doubling down on your stupidity?
30 Lakh INR is 347k USD??
 
Corbin Bosch, a 30-year-old South African bowling all-rounder, is a right-hand batsman and a right-arm medium-fast bowler. He has no prior IPL experience and initially went unsold in the IPL 2025 Mega Auction at a base price of INR 30 lakhs. roughly $347.000 US dollars.

Now, Mumbai Indians have signed him for the same amount as a replacement for Lizaad Williams. Notably, Bosch is already associated with the Mumbai Indians franchise, having played for MI Cape Town in SA20.





Corbin bosch in PSL.

https://www.clubcricket.co.za/latestnews/corbin-bosch-joins-peshawar-zalmi-in-psl/


Your quote:
I need to know what you have smoked when you type this :kp :

Answer The same stuff kohli ask him.
:shh.


30 lakh inr is just $34700.
U are adding one extra zero
U seem to be another math failure like most Indians.
 
As per report, Corbin Bosch explained to PCB officials the reason behind him skipping PSL, saying that it was simply a career move and that he meant no disrespect to PSL:

"Bosch provided his explanation to Pakistani officials, stating that his decision was not meant to disrespect PSL. He said he had to prioritize his future, as Mumbai Indians are not only a strong IPL team but also have franchises in multiple other leagues, which could benefit his career significantly,"

 Peshawar Zalmi had signed Bosch for the 10th edition of the PSL, slated to begin on April 11. However, he pulled out of the league after being presented with the opportunity to join Mumbai Indians in the IPL as a replacement for injured Lizaad Williams. IPL 2025 is scheduled to take place from March 22 to May 25
 
As per report, Corbin Bosch explained to PCB officials the reason behind him skipping PSL, saying that it was simply a career move and that he meant no disrespect to PSL:

"Bosch provided his explanation to Pakistani officials, stating that his decision was not meant to disrespect PSL. He said he had to prioritize his future, as Mumbai Indians are not only a strong IPL team but also have franchises in multiple other leagues, which could benefit his career significantly,"

 Peshawar Zalmi had signed Bosch for the 10th edition of the PSL, slated to begin on April 11. However, he pulled out of the league after being presented with the opportunity to join Mumbai Indians in the IPL as a replacement for injured Lizaad Williams. IPL 2025 is scheduled to take place from March 22 to May 25
Its not you, its me! :inti
 
PCB and PSL Franchises will have to swallow their ego pride and allow their foreign players to leave the PSL for IPL if they truly want their co-existence strategy to work and not want the BCCI, IPL franchises to come down hard against them. If our Pakistani politicians can bow down in front of GHQ then why not the PCB, PSL Franchises in front of BCCI and IPL Franchises to survive.
 
what are PCB's options here?

I'm sure Corbin will be fine with not being able to set foot in Pak ever again.

what can PCB do if Corbin ignores PCB's legal notice?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As per report, Corbin Bosch explained to PCB officials the reason behind him skipping PSL, saying that it was simply a career move and that he meant no disrespect to PSL:

"Bosch provided his explanation to Pakistani officials, stating that his decision was not meant to disrespect PSL. He said he had to prioritize his future, as Mumbai Indians are not only a strong IPL team but also have franchises in multiple other leagues, which could benefit his career significantly,"

 Peshawar Zalmi had signed Bosch for the 10th edition of the PSL, slated to begin on April 11. However, he pulled out of the league after being presented with the opportunity to join Mumbai Indians in the IPL as a replacement for injured Lizaad Williams. IPL 2025 is scheduled to take place from March 22 to May 25
There must be contracts in place. A release clause fee like in Football. Because this is not the first time that it's going to happen. Possibly we'll see player pulling out of PSL for IPL.

With a release clause fee at the very least the PSL will be getting some free money courtesy of IPL.
 
Bosh won’t be the last this season.

Apparently 5 more players in danger of doing the same.
 
Aside IPL, does PSL pays more to its overseas players compared to other leagues. If yes, this might work. If no, then these players may give a damn and skip the PSL which will only impact the PCB board..
 
Back
Top