What's new

"The problem is we don't have anyone to replace Misbah" : Javed Miandad

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,977
Former Pakistan great Javed Miandad has blamed the country's weak domestic cricket structure for not finding a replacement for 42-year-old test captain Misbah-ul-Haq.

Misbah is Pakistan's most successful test captain with 24 victories from 53 test matches, losing 18 and drawing 11. The defeats include a 3-0 whitewash at the hands of Australia completed on Saturday as Pakistan lost the third test by 220 runs at Sydney.

Misbah had been Pakistan's batting mainstay for the past six years but scores of 4, 5, 11, 0, 18 and 38 in six test innings in Australia had led critics to say it was time for him to depart.

"The problem is we don't have anyone to replace Misbah," Miandad told The Associated Press on Saturday. "This shows how weak our cricketing structure is."

Miandad believes the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) had not thought about succession.

"Everywhere in the world there's a system in place and players come and go, but unfortunately we didn't adopt any such system," Miandad said.

"Why are we now asking Misbah to leave? Have we prepared any replacement for him? Unfortunately the answer is no and now it's entirely up to Misbah to decide himself when he wants to quit."

When Pakistan lost the second test at Melbourne, there was strong speculation that Misbah would retire, perhaps even before the third test. But Misbah led the side in Sydney and even after Saturday's defeat, he didn't indicate when he plans to quit test cricket.

Pakistan's next international assignment is a tour to the West Indies after it organises its domestic Twenty20 league in the United Arab Emirates in March.

"That's the unfortunate part of Pakistan cricket," Miandad said. "Misbah knows it very well that there's nobody who could lead the test side and that's why he has not yet made up his mind.” Recently, PCB Chairman Shaharyar Khan also conceded that he couldn't see anyone other than Misbah in the short term.

Sydney's defeat was Pakistan's 12th test loss in a row in Australia, dating back to 1999.

Miandad said it required special skill and technique to play in Australia.

“I am sorry to say but we don't have players of such caliber,” Miandad said. “Playing aggressive cricket is the key to success in Australia and we were too defensive in our approach in batting, bowling and fielding."
 
I dont think this thinking will take us too far
 
I dont think this thinking will take us too far

And thats the whole issue. We never replaced the likes of imran khan and wasim akram doesnt mean they will go on playing till they are 75!

Its time for misbah to move on and retire.
 
As usual. Our formers are the biggest enemies of our cricket. Now they will try to save Misbah and their favorites and result will be the same. Pathetic guy
 
What does that mean, is he suggesting to continue with Misbah forever.

Anyone will be better choice than Misbah as we were playing 10.
 
As usual. Our formers are the biggest enemies of our cricket. Now they will try to save Misbah and their favorites and result will be the same. Pathetic guy

I am also sure that they were even saying that after whitewash in Windies
 
Javed Miandad was a great player, but as a coach or an analyst he is not too good. Lack of education.
 
Javed Miandad was a great player, but as a coach or an analyst he is not too good. Lack of education.

just goes to show how awful he must have been as a coach if he can't read simple thing like this.
 
The irresponsible shot Misbah played to get out under situation that required playing safe itself requires dropping him from the squad, if it was any junior batsman we know how he would have been bashed and 'taught a lesson'. But he keeps getting away despite doing it on repeats because that's the only shot he is going to get his runs from sadly. or may be the reverse sweeps.
 
"This shows how weak our cricketing structure is." Miandad believes the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) had not thought about succession. "Everywhere in the world there's a system in place and players come and go, but unfortunately we didn't adopt any such system," Miandad said.

Here comes Javed with his usual "reform the system" diatribe.

Javed saab why didn't YOU implement any changes to the system in your multiple stints in the PCB as coach or when you were Director General ? You milked millions from the PCB doing nothing when you had the chance to do exactly what you are calling for.
 
Last edited:
Sounds like you know someone better. Care to share?

Fawad doesn't have the technique to survive at highest level and this has been proven by Aussies when he was found out by them in UAE. Hazelwood will make him dance on any day.
 
That's absolute nonsense.

Both Fawad and Salahuddin can replace him.

Time for misbah to pack his bags and leave.
 
I forgot to add, the other day he was talking about dropping rahat ali after 1 game in Aus and effecting his confidence or something along those lines.

But did he forget, that rahat has played 20 Test matches?

He seemed pretty clueless and didn't know much about what was going on.
 
Silly comment and typical of ex players. We have replacements for misbah the bat and for misbah the captain. Fawad, Salahuddin, Harris Sohail, and many others for the batsmen. Sarfaraz for the captain.
 
Ridiculous , how can anyone does worst than losing 6 tests in a row, not even a draw. Nothing wrong to handover captaincy to Azhar or Sarfraz .
 
Problem with Pakistan been over the years is that we never give chance to new players on regular basis to let them use to international matches n give them bit of exposure.
Even when series is lost or won, we go with same team n new comers warm the bench. By now any youngster who has been on selection radar should had exp of 10-12 test matches already but they haven't debut yet.
 
Yes no one could replicate a batting average of 10 except a tail ender maybe.
 
That couldn't be furthest from the truth. There are better batsmen available to take his place and two suitable candidates to take over the captaincy.

This is the mentality that has allowed Misbah to play till the ripe old age of 42, when much much better batsmen like Lara, Sachin, Pointing, Inzi, Kallis, Sanga, Mahela etc all retired much before reaching this age.
 
Javed can't be wrong - he has so much knowledge & experience in Cricket that whenever he opens mouth, that becomes a verse. Let me explain why -

If we consider every possible candidates in current team (no question of bringing someone as Captain from outside - PCB did that with ODI team last time), here are the reason they can't be considered

1. YK: He has bad reputation of a trouble maker & had team revolting against him. Though, he is the 2nd Captain to win a WC for PAK & PAK's next 4 Series are WI, BD, SRL & may be IND - I can safely say that, in those Series he'll be among top 3/4 batsman, not in PAK team, among both teams. And, if he goes to IND early 2018, the Aussies & Poms will come to know how spin is played. He is the fittest guy in the team, best catcher & had led International & Domestic sides. But, he can't be considered as Drama queen.

2. Azhar: A poor tactician, who is on the verge of being sacked as ODI Captain. And he is the best batsman in the team, who shouldn't be over loaded

3. Sarfu - Already over loaded as WK of 3 formats at this age & much more is expected from him as batsman as well. Unfortunately, he is not athletic & his structure is not suitable for WK - low centre of gravity, with bottom heavy structure - if he is made Test Captain a s well, he simply will stop training & won't remain a keeper of any kind; not even the Goal Keeping that he is doing now

4. Asad: Someone a bit shaky with a tendency to hide from challenge. Besides, don't seem to be vocal enough to be a Captain & don't have much experience.

5. Amir: No past experience, with a tinted past - if he is made Captain, it's a National shame for PAK. Besides, there are so much bowling talent in PAK now that, any time Amir might lose his spot in the squad

6. Babar: Too inexperienced & not sealed his Test spot yet. He was PAK Captain from every age group from U13, but he needs about 15 more years to mature & learn how to toss coin (Misbah didn't do much more than that in recent Series, therefore expectation shouldn't be higher)

7. Sami: Replace Babar in previous section ....

8. Sharjeel: Replace Sami in previous section, with an added note that he didn't Captain at U19 level, but he has led few domestics

9. Wahab: An aging fast bowler with very little career left - might not last a year as automatic choice.

10. MoHa: Outside chance, but he has been dropped from Test side & he might not be interested as last time he left the job - also, it makes lots of sense to make him ODI Captain after Azhar, as he can serve PAK for next 2 WCs.

Considering the ground reality, Javed is actually right - Shahriar, or even if required Mian Sharif should request Misbah to continue.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Miandad, I think you could be a great replacement. As just like Misbah, you prefer not to change anything (what did you do while you held so many high profile jobs in PCB?).
 
Javed can't be wrong - he has so much knowledge & experience in Cricket that whenever he opens mouth, that becomes a verse. Let me explain why -

If we consider every possible candidates in current team (no question of bringing someone as Captain from outside - PCB did that with ODI team last time), here are the reason they can't be considered

1. YK: He has bad reputation of a trouble maker & had team revolting against him. Though, he is the 2nd Captain to win a WC for PAK & PAK's next 4 Series are WI, BD, SRL & may be IND - I can safely say that, in those Series he'll be among top 3/4 batsman, not in PAK team, among both teams. And, if he goes to IND early 2018, the Aussies & Poms will come to know how spin is played. He is the fittest guy in the team, best catcher & had led International & Domestic sides. But, he can't be considered as Drama queen.

2. Azhar: A poor tactician, who is on the verge of being sacked as ODI Captain. And he is the best batsman in the team, who shouldn't be over loaded

3. Sarfu - Already over loaded as WK of 3 formats at this age & much more is expected from him as batsman as well. Unfortunately, he is not athletic & his structure is not suitable for WK - low centre of gravity, with bottom heavy structure - if he is made Test Captain a s well, he simply will stop training & won't remain a keeper of any kind; not even the Goal Keeping that he is doing now

4. Asad: Someone a bit shaky with a tendency to hide from challenge. Besides, don't seem to be vocal enough to be a Captain & don't have much experience.

5. Amir: No past experience, with a tinted past - if he is made Captain, it's a National shame for PAK. Besides, there are so much bowling talent in PAK now that, any time Amir might lose his spot in the squad

6. Babar: Too inexperienced & not sealed his Test spot yet. He was PAK Captain from every age group from U13, but he needs about 15 more years to mature & learn how to toss coin (Misbah didn't do much more than that in recent Series, therefore expectation shouldn't be higher)

7. Sami: Replace Babar in previous section ....

8. Sharjeel: Replace Sami in previous section, with an added note that he didn't Captain at U19 level, but he has led few domestics

9. Wahab: An aging fast bowler with very little career left - might not last a year as automatic choice.

10. MoHa: Outside chance, but he has been dropped from Test side & he might not be interested as last time he left the job - also, it makes lots of sense to make him ODI Captain after Azhar, as he can serve PAK for next 2 WCs.

Considering the ground reality, Javed is actually right - Shahriar, or even if required Mian Sharif should request Misbah to continue.

Simply, it's not statistically possible to do worst job than Misbah is doing as captain and as batsman and he is not getting any younger. So, anyone but Misbah.

Azhar is perfect for test captain, he has shown he is one with mental strength required for a test captain, rest is secondary and Sarfraz is fine for ODI captaincy , has long record of captaincy at FC level.
 
The harsh but real fact is that the standard of our players is declining rapidly.

Look at the Test squad at the moment. They are by and large the best players out there. If you look at bench strength, there are hardly any world-beaters not being picked.
 
Batsman? Probably.

Captain? Sarfraz or Azhar might prove to be even better considering Azhar has learnt a few things from Mickey during the ODI series.
 
The harsh but real fact is that the standard of our players is declining rapidly.

Look at the Test squad at the moment. They are by and large the best players out there. If you look at bench strength, there are hardly any world-beaters not being picked.

If players keep on playing in their 40s even with a long stretch of failure , how can you expect new players to emerge ?
 
Pretty stupid statement from Miandad.

Azhar or Sarfraz could be test captain and there are several players that could take Misbah's place.
 
Back
Top