What's new

[VIDEO] Mehdi Hasan Miraz's controversial run-out of Salman Ali Agha: Fair or not?

Mehdi Hasan Miraj's controversial run-out of Salman Ali Agha: Fair or not?

  • Yes, it falls within rules of cricket

    Votes: 18 40.0%
  • No, it is against the spirit of sportsmanship

    Votes: 27 60.0%

  • Total voters
    45
I even if Ball was Dead, First Thing Salman should have to was to get back in to the Crease. In this case the ball was not dead, beacause, the Ball is not dead until the nonstriker is back in the Crease. This is Brainfade. Very Legitimate Dismissal and within spirit of cricket.
 
That was clearly out. Bowler well within his rights.

What’s was Agha doing outside the crease trying to pick up a ball in play?

Team management should have a word with him about presence of mind, game awareness.
 
100% brain fade from Agha.

This isn't a friendly benefit match to raise funds for polio riddled children.
 
Not a Brain fade from agha but lack of common sense .otherwise who will trust a bng player. Haven't he seen what happened to Mathews in India?. He must be in high alert mode than friendly SENAI mode. DARE I say even afridi didn't attempted against india.
 
Game awareness coach needed ,they don't even know the rules at times, the nb bowled of Kohli comes to mind.
 
Fair decision, agha was at fault.

There is no need to show sportsmanship all the time.
 
Rizwan was hugging Bangladeshi players when Salman was abusing them and they were responding back. What a clown this guy is lol? And then he plays a hacky shot and gets out in the same over. If i was a selector I will drop this guy forever @Rana
 
Within "technical range" sportsmanship "massive hit"- Ramiz keeps topping himself with unusual sentences.
 
I remember Deepti Sharma was trolled for her mankad to Charlie. It just shows bowlers' presence of mind and absence of batters' mind. Similar is the case here, Salman should have been proactive
 
Nothing new from the Bangladeshis. The most pathetic, bottom-feeding, unsportsmanlike team in world cricket. From the timed-out dismissal of Angelo to this. Yes, Agha should have been more aware, but he probably didn’t think they were low enough to actually do something like this.
 
I remember Deepti Sharma was trolled for her mankad to Charlie. It just shows bowlers' presence of mind and absence of batters' mind. Similar is the case here, Salman should have been proactive
This is international cricket but Pakistani players showing too much bhaichara. Very unprofessional from Agha Salman. :kp
 
Game awareness coach needed ,they don't even know the rules at times, the nb bowled of Kohli comes to mind.
If that how run out happens....then millions opportunity comes to do this third class thing....... put your hand in heart and tell me any other team would have done this? Don't think soo...... Mathew's out was clear example of these third class people......
 
Nothing new from the Bangladeshis. The most pathetic, bottom-feeding, unsportsmanlike team in world cricket. From the timed-out dismissal of Angelo to this. Yes, Agha should have been more aware, but he probably didn’t think they were low enough to actually do something like this.
Millions times I have seen this scene but no other team did this type of thing till now....I would rather loose than be shameless..... If I am mohsin naqvi I would be kicking their ass instead of helping them...
 
What's unfair in this? He wasn't in the crease and the ball was still in play. Miraz had every right to run him out
 
There is no issue with sportsmanship on the part of Bangaladeshi Players. Imagine this happened at Short Mid-on with another feilder rather than bowler, What was expected of Salman? to get back to crease or hand over the ball to the fielder.
 
Millions times I have seen this scene but no other team did this type of thing till now....I would rather loose than be shameless..... If I am mohsin naqvi I would be kicking their ass instead of helping them...
Expecting sportsmanship from Bangladesh players, given their past history? You're expecting too much from these losers. :kp
 
Millions times I have seen this scene but no other team did this type of thing till now....I would rather loose than be shameless..... If I am mohsin naqvi I would be kicking their ass instead of helping them...
Has more to do with the players than the boards tbh. I'm sure both boards have good intentions and warm relations but the Bangladesh players are another story. This is what they do.
 
So I was watching the video again and looks like Agha was trying to get back into the crease and Mehidy obstructed him. Then he just tried to pick up the ball and give it to Mehidy (as batsmen often do to save time) but Mehidy snatched it and ran him out lol.

And this guy just became their captain.

Leading by example. :cobra
 
Nothing new from the Bangladeshis. The most pathetic, bottom-feeding, unsportsmanlike team in world cricket. From the timed-out dismissal of Angelo to this. Yes, Agha should have been more aware, but he probably didn’t think they were low enough to actually do something like this.
Bro, agha was way out of his crease. If this was a matter of few inches, that would had made sense.

Bangladesh owned nothing to pakistan or agha. He had a brainfade, they took advantage and got the breakthrough that led to a collapse.

Its a sport, not a charity dinner. Tired of the kissing up we tend to do.
 
Against the spirit of the game.

Bangladeshis always lacked honour. There’s a reason why they lost the privilege to call themselves Pakistanis. We took it away from them in 1971 when we deemed them unworthy of such an honour bestowed to all of us by Qaid.

Delulu is ur only solulu. That's bdesh is way ahead of ur economy healthcare education . U name it they r ahead of u
 
So I was watching the video again and looks like Agha was trying to get back into the crease and Mehidy obstructed him. Then he just tried to pick up the ball and give it to Mehidy (as batsmen often do to save time) but Mehidy snatched it and ran him out lol.

And this guy just became their captain.

Leading by example. :cobra
If I was agha I wouldn't have gone out
 
Bro, agha was way out of his crease. If this was a matter of few inches, that would had made sense.

Bangladesh owned nothing to pakistan or agha. He had a brainfade, they took advantage and got the breakthrough that led to a collapse.

Its a sport, not a charity dinner. Tired of the kissing up we tend to do.
 
This is almost same like Bawli running away with trophy n locking it. Bdesh taking badla 🤣
 
It was clear out. No obstruction.
 
Watch the video more clearly, because it doesn't seem like you did
I have watched it. It is clear out. There is no obstruction. The bowler even backed off and agha had a chance to go back in, but agha decided to give him the ball, which he didnt need to.

Its a clear out decision, but you went out of your way to bash Bangladeshis.

In the context of the game, the Bangladeshis did nothing wrong, and them being minnows has nothing do with it
 
I have watched it. It is clear out. There is no obstruction. The bowler even backed off and agha had a chance to go back in, but agha decided to give him the ball, which he didnt need to.

Its a clear out decision, but you went out of your way to bash Bangladeshis.

In the context of the game, the Bangladeshis did nothing wrong, and them being minnows has nothing do with it
I think you need to get your eyes checked then.


1773406960813.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is a pure brainfade.

As legal a form of dismissal as mankad is.
 
Agha's first priority should be to go full fledged back towards the wicket.
 
I think you need to get your eyes checked then. Nothing else to say

View attachment 162807
I think you need to calm down and grow up.

First bashing bangladeshi cricket history and now having an issue with me.

Its out. Clear out. No obstruction. The bowler went after the ball. Even backed out when Agha was stopping. Agha had to make a decision, either go back in the crease or hand him the ball, he choose latter, bowler took advantage.

Rules followed, by Bangladeshi cricketers, and icc. But you had to insult their cricket team for following rules.
 
Imagine bangladesh doing this to virat kohli
Kohli would have the sense to safe guard his wicket first. Go bats down and make the crease. If the Bangladesh bowler is stupid enough to impede him , then he'll get a proper bat in the ribs
 
Imagine bangladesh doing this to virat kohli
Kohli wouldnt act like an idiot where he is out of his crease and ends up helping the fielding side.

Bangladesh did nothing wrong. It was poor from agha to throw a tantrum
 
If that how run out happens....then millions opportunity comes to do this third class thing....... put your hand in heart and tell me any other team would have done this? Don't think soo...... Mathew's out was clear example of these third class people......
That’s the issue isn’t it, PCT didn’t know about Bangladeshi tactics on field?

I posted on other thread as well, a fan asked Rizwan about Indian cricket match and he said I don’t watch them play, so my assumption here is someone who doesn’t watch other teams play cannot prepare against them, and that shows how PCT prepares for games.
 
Waiting for Anil chaudry to give his pov on this. Guy gives very good insights on contemporary umpiring decisions
 
That said , while the naivete of Agha is majorly to blame , the behaviour of the Bangladeshi player is borderline unsporting.

And this is often a recurring trend with this team.
 
If that how run out happens....then millions opportunity comes to do this third class thing....... put your hand in heart and tell me any other team would have done this? Don't think soo...... Mathew's out was clear example of these third class people......
Based on what they do on the field, why are you making comments on the people?

So if bangladesh follows the laws of cricket, they become pathetic people?

You can call the decision unsportsmanlike, but you cant call third class people for it
 
I think you need to calm down and grow up.

First bashing bangladeshi cricket history and now having an issue with me.

Its out. Clear out. No obstruction. The bowler went after the ball. Even backed out when Agha was stopping. Agha had to make a decision, either go back in the crease or hand him the ball, he choose latter, bowler took advantage.

Rules followed, by Bangladeshi cricketers, and icc. But you had to insult their cricket team for following rules.
Bashing Bangladesh cricket history? What Bangladesh cricket history?? Winning 5-match ODI series against Zimbabwe?

Also, if you think it's out then why are you repeating the same thing over and over again? If you want to kiss their behinds for factors that have nothing to do with this dismissal then that's your prerogative, not mine. I have two eyes and can see for myself what actually happened.
 
Based on what they do on the field, why are you making comments on the people?

So if bangladesh follows the laws of cricket, they become pathetic people?

You can call the decision unsportsmanlike, but you cant call third class people for it
You put salman agha in mehidi place and mehidi in salman agha place and you will knew who is third class?
 
Bashing Bangladesh cricket history? What Bangladesh cricket history?? Winning 5-match ODI series against Zimbabwe?

Also, if you think it's out then why are you repeating the same thing over and over again? If you want to kiss their behinds for factors that have nothing to do with this dismissal then that's your prerogative, not mine. I have two eyes and can see for myself what actually happened.
India did right thing to not facilitate these losers.....pathetic bunch of jokers
 
Bashing Bangladesh cricket history? What Bangladesh cricket history?? Winning 5-match ODI series against Zimbabwe?

Also, if you think it's out then why are you repeating the same thing over and over again? If you want to kiss their behinds for factors that have nothing to do with this dismissal then that's your prerogative, not mine. As for me, I have two eyes and can see for myself what actually happened.
Grow up mate.

There is one thing to have an opinion, but to go and bash their cricket history or insult posters that disagree with you shows how immature you are.

Ur or my two eyes dont matter. Third umpires does, and he made the correct decision
 
That said , while the naivete of Agha is majorly to blame , the behaviour of the Bangladeshi player is borderline unsporting.

And this is often a recurring trend with this team.
well said it was definitely both ..

A)cheap from Bangladesh
B)dumb from Agha
 
Back
Top