What's new

"After the two series (vs SL, Aus), we realised that we need experience in the team" : Misbah-ul-Haq

Abdullah719

T20I Captain
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Runs
44,825
"After the two series (vs SL, Aus), we realised that we need experience in the team" : Misbah-ul-Haq

Misbah-ul-Haq at a presser after the third T20I against Bangladesh was washed out:

"I think that the most important thing for us was to win. When you lose 2 series and even before, you were losing T20s, it was very important for the team to win.

"We should give credit to the bowling, for the way the young bowlers bowled. They didn't give BD a chance to get into a position from where they can threaten us. It's a good performance and for Pakistan cricket, it's good.

"For WC preparations, we have a lot of time. We have PSL and more cricket going forward. We will have challenges going forward and we have time to prepare.

"You play to win and you try to perform as well as you can, it's important to give yourself breathing space. But we have to still look at the shortcomings in the team and where we need to strengthen. Under pressure, you keep running after things and sometimes it's difficult to catch up. So it's good for the team and for me, and for the young players, that we have a confidence booster and we can relax a bit and think about the future.

"Whenever these 2 seniors weren't in the team, whenever I was asked or anyone was asked, I always said that there's no question of their careers being ended or them not being considered going forward. We did try our resources in the SL and Aus series to see where we stand, after the 2 series (against SL, AUS) we realised that we need experience in the team.

"Babar also backed them and the experience benefitted us. Malik and Hafeez played good innings. So the door isn't closed for anyone. Regarding policy, until a player is fit and performing and we think he can contribute, he should be in the team and you can utilise them specially with a World Cup around the corner. Their form is good and their fitness is good, the fitness test results were also improved. So for the team's benefit, there's no issue with including seniors.

"We will keep everything in mind when we are making a team for the T20 World Cup. Obviously, PSL will be very important for us. The hitters who were in the team previously couldn't perform that well. We then brought Khushdil and Iftikhar in the team. We have these options.

"Those 2 series gave us an idea of what happens when you don't play experienced players. We have a problem that we keep just fast-bowling in mind and we judge our senior players on that basis. But if we look, leg-spin and mystery spin is available in every team. So our new players, unfortunately as we saw in the SL series, are struggling to pick the spinners and play them. Even in Australia, teams play with 2 spinners and in the middle overs, it's important to have players like this.

"At the top, you need hitters and aggressive players and also in the lower order, you need hitters. But in the middle overs against spinners also, you need these type of players. PSL will be very important to see how players perform and we can see who fits in our plans and where.

"We were planning on playing all of the players on the bench today. We weren't playing them for the sake of it, we were looking to maintain a balanced team and keep the nucleus of the team. Amad Butt, Usman Qadir, Musa Khan would have played the match. Unfortunately, they'll have to wait and didn't get the opportunity today.

"There's a lot of cricket to be played. Our plan is to look at PSL performances, fitness, form etc. which will all come in front. After 24 April, we have around 2 months' time where there's no matches or domestic cricket. Our plan is to get performers together in that time and play matches and then decide who stands where and fits in the combination. Then we will make a final team, before we start going on tours and then head for the Asia Cup and T20 World Cup.

"The point of looking at PSL is that you get to see the performances and you can analyse where players fit in and where we need players in the team. Then we grind further in the matches we will play, then decide on the squad. In domestic cricket, there is lesser pressure. In PSL, at some level you can say that with media and international players, the standard comes a bit closer to international cricket. The temperament of a player can be checked there and then finally, the requirement of the team. Then you can pick the player and ready them.

"There's no such thing (that Islamabad United players will be given preference). What's important for us is that the Pakistan team is strong. If I pick an IU player, I am not getting his match fees, nor will his records go in my name. All the players are equal for me. If a strong team is formed for Pakistan with good players, I think that's best for us and the thing that will get us the most respect. Yes, it's true that by being a part of PSL, I will get to see the players closely as all the players will face my team, so you can see everything closely and see which player is capable and what can he do.
 
Short sighted comments from Misbah once again. Does he really think Malik and Hafeez would have bullied Aus the same way they did Bangla?

Also, it not like he had a super young team against SL. The middle order was Harris, Asif, Inthikar, Sarfraz - all players around 30, who have been playing cricket for 10+ years.

It was more a case of poor selection (vs SL), extremely tough opponent (vs Aus) and a weak opponent who could be bullied by professional minnow bashers (vs SL). Not experience vs inexperience
 
People after losing to SL in T20s:

Mickey Arthur was great. He took our team to #1 ranking. Bring his #1 formula and combination back!!!

People after Misbah brought back Mickey Arthur's main players:

Misbah is so short-sighted. Why did he bring back Malik & Hafeez? We don't want Mickey Arthur's #1 ranking formula!!


Moral: People will never be happy. Those rankings were fake, they relied on Sarfraz, Hafeez and Malik - the vital players Mickey Arthur relied on in T20s. Malik & Sarfraz can get you to fake #1 ranking by beating sub-par teams, but not contribute at the World T20.

Mickey's combination has to be discarded.

Misbah should discard Malik, but Hafeez will be vital for our success at the World T20. His experience will be invaluable.

Ignore the usual whining and wrist-slitting. Nobody has proven to be better than Hafeez, who's our 2nd best batsman since 2017/18 in LOIs.
 
Last edited:
People after losing to SL in T20s:

Mickey Arthur was great. He took our team to #1 ranking. Bring his #1 formula and combination back!!!

People after Misbah brought back Mickey Arthur's main players:

Misbah is so short-sighted. Why did he bring back Malik & Hafeez? We don't want Mickey Arthur's #1 ranking formula!!


Moral: People will never be happy. Those rankings were fake, they relied on Sarfraz, Hafeez and Malik - the vital players Mickey Arthur relied on in T20s. Malik & Sarfraz can get you to fake #1 ranking by beating sub-par teams, but not contribute at the World T20.

Mickey's combination has to be discarded.

Misbah should discard Malik, but Hafeez will be vital for our success at the World T20. His experience will be invaluable.

Ignore the usual whining and wrist-slitting. Nobody has proven to be better than Hafeez, who's our 2nd best batsman since 2017/18 in LOIs.

The XI that played the most number of T20Is during Mickey's tenure is: Babar, Fakhar, Talat, Malik, Sarfaraz, Asif, Imad, Shadab, Faheem, Hasan, Amir.

Besides Malik, none of Mickey's "main players" has been brought back.
 
Frankly Misbah, if experience was required you wouldn't be dropped Sarfaraz, Fakhar, Aamir and Wahab. How can you go into the World T20 without these 4 players? Who is going to score quickly and who is going to provide the early breakthrough and death over spells? A food for thought for the confused selector. World T20 is in 8 months and if we don't sort out our combination, it should be the end of Misbah from Pakistan cricket for good.
 


"Those 2 series gave us an idea of what happens when you don't play experienced players. We have a problem that we keep just fast-bowling in mind and we judge our senior players on that basis. But if we look, leg-spin and mystery spin is available in every team. So our new players, unfortunately as we saw in the SL series, are struggling to pick the spinners and play them. Even in Australia, teams play with 2 spinners and in the middle overs, it's important to have players like this.


Interesting point made as just like fans and experts Misbah also knows that Hafeez and Malik arent the most accomplished against pace at this stage of their career but having the spinners in the middle overs in mind which our new lot unfortunately werent able to play well (Srl series was an example) these two came into picture.

I think there should be some sort of camps to spin bowling for our young and upcoming as obviously Malik and Hafeez arent gonna be there for long.
 
Poor strategy and comments from misbah

Players esp young batsmen take time to develop and require patience and exposure You cant expect instant results and expect players to thrive straightaway

And anyway its only in pakistan where t20 cricket is taken so seriously He should be using this format to give future talent a chance and not lose his nerve after a couple of losses

By turning to the oldies misbah is ruining the future for short term success
 
Still, there is a problem that both of these guys will leave after WT20. Then what will happen?

It is better that Pakistan pick one of them and play a younger batsman in their place because there is another T20 WC in 2021.
 
it is understandable and I fully support of his decision of bringing back Malik and Hafeez but still I think both are Minnow bashers and cannot be considered as long term solution. He should be looking for their replacement too.
 
I was disappointed at first, but it looks like selecting Malik and Hafeez paid off.

Tbh, wouldn’t mind both of them playing WT20 and then retiring. I just hope Misbah doesn’t bring back Sarfraz.
 
I was disappointed at first, but it looks like selecting Malik and Hafeez paid off.

Tbh, wouldn’t mind both of them playing WT20 and then retiring. I just hope Misbah doesn’t bring back Sarfraz.
Sarfraz was never good T20 player, especially in position he would be batting, that is lower order. So no chance he would be brought back in T20s. Rizwan is doing ok in wicketkeeping and is not tested enough in batting but would be rarely required to bat.
 
Short sighted comments from Misbah once again. Does he really think Malik and Hafeez would have bullied Aus the same way they did Bangla?

Also, it not like he had a super young team against SL. The middle order was Harris, Asif, Inthikar, Sarfraz - all players around 30, who have been playing cricket for 10+ years.

It was more a case of poor selection (vs SL), extremely tough opponent (vs Aus) and a weak opponent who could be bullied by professional minnow bashers (vs SL). Not experience vs inexperience

Shahzad and Umar Akmal were brought in place of Hafeez and Malik that's all. They failed, so back to Hafeez and Malik. Haris Sohail is Not a suitable T20 player he is more suited to longer formats, and Asif Ali has been a Bad experiment. we really don't have any batting Bench strength.
 
Some Misbah supporters gave him credit for moving on from Hafeez and Malik.

It appears that the idea that Babar forced their selection is a myth.

Pakistan is a very poor team in all formats and Misbah is ensuring that it hits rock-bottom very soon.
 
Hahahaha

So we are back to 2013 again where Misbah after beating 12th ranked Zimbabwe [not even convincingly] used to talk as though he has beaten a top 5 ranked team. This guy is really a joke.

He thinks we have short term memory, was'nt bowler Mohammed Irfan picked for Australia because of experience rofl.

Misbah actually protected Hafeez and Malik due to their poor record in Australia.

There is some good news for the TTFs and their supporters here. Any new batting performer from PSL will not be picked for future tours. According to Misbah that door is closed which we already knew. Now they'll search for a spinner or an all rounder for no. 6 or 7 position, he'll continue to ignore any new batting talent in the PSL. One can see the consistency in his decisions sync with Inzamam. There is a whole mafia in the PCB behind it that'll push forward Shan Masoods, Imams , Akmals and their supporters will repeast the same line we have limited options, we don't have replacements, well duh, did selectors Misbah or Inzamam ever selected a domestic performer in the team. Even if they did in some instances they used to pick them in the wrong format. Fakhar Zaman was never allowed to debut against Windies in T20. The first intl. match he faced was against South Africa in the knockout match of Champions Trophy as an opener. Similar thing was done against Sarfaraz Ahmed in a World Cup match against South Africa. And he was made to open and see off the new bowl, and was planned to fail by the captain Misbah and coach Waqar Younis and the opposite thing happened.

Great days ahead for Misbah and the PCB mafia, and bad days to be a Pakistani cricket fan thanks to imported administrator Wasim Khan and Ehsan Mani for this.
 
Next this fool will be bringing back Azhar Ali for ODI and Asad Shafiq for T20

Said the second his name was being suggested that we will be taken back 15 years with his & Waqars style
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's fine selecting these guys for world cup. But T20s in the 3+year gap should have been used for experimentation, it was ok to get losses with young guys. Much harder to replace seniors 1 or 2 series before the world cup, no time.

There's also a real big lack of batting talent in the LO scene in domestic. There are test players like saad ali, Usman, Sami Aslam's doing well, even Fawad Alam, Salman Butt are doing well (not that I'd ever bring back Butt) and more. But players who are able to excel in limited overs, bat at a good SR especially against pace are few. All the Pakistani batsmen look bad in PSL except Babar, Kamran and to an extent Asif Ali. Yet it's our tournament, domestic batsmen should have an advantage over foreign batsmen in these conditions.

I think for the good of Pakistan's LOI matches, we need Pakistani batsmen opening in PSL. See if they can score against pace and play freely. Play the foreign players lower down. Yes a Ronchi or a Watson might do better up top, but the Pakistani batsmen will continue to keep their places and not get exposed.
 
So previous management played malik and Hafeez for 3 years in T20, started giving them a long run when they both were 35+. What exactly were some fans expecting year before the World T20 that the new management will use magic wand and produce couple of young and dynamic batsmen for World T20.

We went with Hafeez and Malik (38,37 years old) in WC 19 because not enough young batsman was developed by previous management and now same thing was inherited by new management.

Many might not like it but its a fact that rather then developing young batsmen in T20s previous management played couple of 35 years old for 3 years or atleast kept them in the team more often than not when at that time we could have developed couple of young players.
 
It's fine selecting these guys for world cup. But T20s in the 3+year gap should have been used for experimentation, it was ok to get losses with young guys. Much harder to replace seniors 1 or 2 series before the world cup, no time.

Exactly.
 
To add I definitely enjoyed no 1 T20 ranking and wins like every fan but I think we could have tried to make couple of young batsmen as well alongside the wins.
 
They lost those T20 matches due to poor batting, not a lack of experience. In fact, Shehzad and Akmal are plenty experienced players and they were the biggest reasons we lost the series vs Sri Lanka.

It was a weak batting lineup with players like Haris who aren't suited for T20 format and then there's Asif Ali who is just consistently mediocre.

The bowlers basically have to be outstanding almost every time for this team to win and that is why they were able to win vs Bangladesh.
 
Back
Top