shaz619
ODI Star
- Joined
- Mar 31, 2010
- Runs
- 35,668
- Post of the Week
- 7
Is there a better batsman then Virat in such conditions? he absolutely thrives in such an environment and I expect him to cash in big time 9 times out of 10.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: this_feature_currently_requires_accessing_site_using_safari
Loool Warner is much more of a FTB than Virat. At least Virat has century in Australia on a difficult pitch also one in South Africa on difficult pitch. Whilst most of Warners centuries have come on the roads in Australia.
That was not a difficult pitch at all.
Loool Warner is much more of a FTB than Virat. At least Virat has century in Australia on a difficult pitch also one in South Africa on difficult pitch. Whilst most of Warners centuries have come on the roads in Australia.
That was not a difficult pitch at all.
You weren't complaining when England was batting yesterday
When kohli bats on the same pitch, you have a problem. Cry me a river.
Pak batsmen have scored thousands of runs on such surfaces in uae.
As many posters have already outlined, it was a flat pitch with no lateral movement. For those reasons Virat and Vijay thrived, but Virat is significantly better on such pitches
Look at Adelaide test in the 2nd innings, only Virat and Vijay scored significant scores. Rest of India team fell like a pack of cards, Lyon.picked up 7 wickets.
Look at the 4th innings scorecard for the Adelaide test
Just because the others failed doesn't make the wicket a minefield
If a spinner is picking up 7 wickets in Australia there must be something in the pitch also it was in the 4th innings in a run chase so it's not easy to bat on. Notice how as soon as he got out Indian team fell away like a pack of cards.
There was one pitch where it was difficult to bat, I think only Vijay and Kohli scored big.
Ask [MENTION=134809]sensible-indian-fan[/MENTION] [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] [MENTION=139664]street cricketer[/MENTION] [MENTION=68690]Statsman[/MENTION]
They are crap at playing spin even Mo when he was green destroyed them on wickets which didn't have a lot in it, am not sure if I've ever seen a rank turner in AUS; assuming there was, the bowling should have been dealt with right given the nature of the turfs in India. It was a batting paradise by Indian standards and something you'd wish for the moment you walk out to bat in Australia you'd take such a wicket in a heart beat if offered
You weren't complaining when England was batting yesterday
When kohli bats on the same pitch, you have a problem. Cry me a river.
Pak batsmen have scored thousands of runs on such surfaces in uae.
Adelaide 2nd innings was a Laraesque knock. Enuf said.
Yeah I did, it was a pretty flat pitch
There was one pitch where it was difficult to bat, I think only Vijay and Kohli scored big.
Ask [MENTION=134809]sensible-indian-fan[/MENTION] [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] [MENTION=139664]street cricketer[/MENTION] [MENTION=68690]Statsman[/MENTION]
Btw Shaz if Younis gets a century in Australia how can you rate it seriously when you think Australian pitches are flat? It's not easy to score 100s in Australia for subcontinent batters.
I saw and know very well. No need to ask anyone. It was flat track. Players failed does not prove to be difficult pitch. It was not green mamba or rank turner or low. Flat track. That's why I don't rate performance of ind on that series at all. Very disappointed with the Aus think tanks.
It pretty much was a rank turner on day 5. The rough patch Lyon had to target outside right hander's off stump was crazy.
I saw and know very well. No need to ask anyone. It was flat track. Players failed does not prove to be difficult pitch. It was not green mamba or rank turner or low. Flat track. That's why I don't rate performance of ind on that series at all. Very disappointed with the Aus think tanks.
After uae, Australian pitches are the worst for test cricket
Aussie pitches are flatter then they have ever been in history, yet people will point out x,y,z when this point is highlighted.
We all saw Kohli tackling Amir on a wicket where batsmen weren't even able to put bat on ball. He was hitting cover drives when the ball was swinging miles. Now you can say it was a T20 match. But you either have the ability to play the moving ball or you dont. Kohli clearly had that day. One bad tour of England cannot be used to pass judgement on an entire career
So now we can have threads targeting one player? Cool. I have seen criticism of players when they fail but never when they succeed. Its a first
This wasn't intended to be a criticism thread, but it is welcomed. My goal was to appreciate his prowess on such wickets
The appreciation is not justified by calling him motorway king. Im sure there are a few guys in the pakistan team who deserves that tag better.
I'll give him credit for that, it was a gutsy performance. However I can't recall if Amir moved the ball away as much, Kohli's biggest problem has been the outswinger
We all saw Kohli tackling Amir on a wicket where batsmen weren't even able to put bat on ball. He was hitting cover drives when the ball was swinging miles. Now you can say it was a T20 match. But you either have the ability to play the moving ball or you dont. Kohli clearly had that day. One bad tour of England cannot be used to pass judgement on an entire career
So just because he has an issue with outswinger,he becomes motorway king?
Even there he scored v Steyn in SA.
We all saw Kohli tackling Amir on a wicket where batsmen weren't even able to put bat on ball. He was hitting cover drives when the ball was swinging miles. Now you can say it was a T20 match. But you either have the ability to play the moving ball or you dont. Kohli clearly had that day. One bad tour of England cannot be used to pass judgement on an entire career
There was one pitch where it was difficult to bat, I think only Vijay and Kohli scored big.
Ask [MENTION=134809]sensible-indian-fan[/MENTION] [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] [MENTION=139664]street cricketer[/MENTION] [MENTION=68690]Statsman[/MENTION]
Totally different lasting three overs against a top quality pacer bowling with a white ball, with fielding restrictions in place and a whole different scenario when that bowler has no restrictions and has a red (or pink) ball in hand.
Why do you think the likes of Guptil and Rohit can average in the 40s in ODI cricket? It's because a batsmen's weaknesses can be shrouded in the LOI format.
As of now, Kohli only has one good innings in swing-friendly conditions, in Jo'Burg a couple of years ago.
There was one pitch where it was difficult to bat, I think only Vijay and Kohli scored big.
Ask [MENTION=134809]sensible-indian-fan[/MENTION] [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] [MENTION=139664]street cricketer[/MENTION] [MENTION=68690]Statsman[/MENTION]
Totally different lasting three overs against a top quality pacer bowling with a white ball, with fielding restrictions in place and a whole different scenario when that bowler has no restrictions and has a red (or pink) ball in hand.
Why do you think the likes of Guptil and Rohit can average in the 40s in ODI cricket? It's because a batsmen's weaknesses can be shrouded in the LOI format.
As of now, Kohli only has one good innings in swing-friendly conditions, in Jo'Burg a couple of years ago.
No pitch in that series was difficult. But yes, out of all the roads in that series, that particular pitch was the one that was least flat.
Kohli's problems in test cricket is less to do with his inability to play in swinging conditions and more to do with his lack of concentration in the format.
No pitch in that series was difficult. But yes, out of all the roads in that series, that particular pitch was the one that was least flat.
Guptill and Sharma fail in ODIs on green pitches. Their averages are high due to cashing on flat pitches. Your logic is flawed.
That Adelaide pitch on day 4/5 against Lyon was not difficult?
I disagree with the point of guptil and rohit.
I feel they are more suitable to that format. Doesn't mean the LOI promotes weak players.
Generally sceince students are bad at writing poems. Does it mean science promotes less intelligent people?
It was the 4th innings as well so he deserves credit for that innings
There are less gree pitches in ODIs and thus they can maintain their nice averages in this format.
Are me and you, as an India and Pakistan fan respectively, really deeming a spell by Lyon difficult? Nathan Lyon is an average spinner and no, batting against him on a fourth day wicket is never difficult. However, Moeen Ali got 19 against India so I guess playing Lyon is difficult for them too.
If poetry was the most important and prestigious subject in the world, the answer would be yes.
He deserves credit for all his centuries in Australia. I just acknowledge that they came on some of the most flat wickets ever. So when people say things like "Kohli is better than any subcon batsmen on Aussie pitches", I laugh.
Warne averaged 30 in Australia, while Lyon averages 33. Statistically, Lyon has been better than any non-Australian spinner in this century. On a 4/5 day pitch (and that Adelaide pitch was difficult from even earlier on), he is definitely a threat. I take it that you have not watched the match, so you do not know how Lyon bowled or how the pitch was behaving.
Pitches in Australia have been flat for decades. People who have watched cricket in Australia in the 70s/80s say that pitches were very flat back then too (that's why they rate players like Lillee highly, despite playing mostly at home). It is laughable to hear you say that these were some of the flattest wickets in history.
I did watch the match, not all of that last innings for sure, and Lyon wasn't bowling anything that would trouble good players of spin who would be high on confidence. It was a good innings but not a great one, a tricky pitch but not a difficult one and I would expect any of the current good batsmen to do well there.
Okay, let's continue this in January then.
We can bring up how India and Pakistan fared against Ali in England.
There should be no comparison of any pitches anywhere to that of UAE.UAE pitches are a disgrace for international cricket.I saw hardly 20 to 25 overs in total of all the 9 matches of Pakistan vs West Indies series wheres i watched the other 2 ongoing series daily.Infact i find UAE games really boring.No crowd, no good pitch.
The pitch of this first test between India vs England is not a slow dead one at all.It has bounce, good carry,enough spin and swing to make bowlers and viewers interested.Both English and Indians batted really well so far.If India hold on the dropped catches in first innings the score line would have been different.
Are me and you, as an India and Pakistan fan respectively, really deeming a spell by Lyon difficult? Nathan Lyon is an average spinner and no, batting against him on a fourth day wicket is never difficult. However, Moeen Ali got 19 against India so I guess playing Lyon is difficult for them too.
Sure.
Eng vs Ind - 124 runs at 20.67
Eng vs Pak - 316 runs at 63.20
Or is that not what you meant?
Well in that case Bishoo is also no real great spin bowler that could trouble any top Asian batsmen .... didnt really pan out that way ... did it ?
Point is these things happen. Infact I have seen far worse ... like for example Venkatesh Prasad picking more wkts than Waqar and Wasim combined in big WC matches. Doesnt mean that the Pakistani batsmen were useless. Nor does it mean Venky was a gun fast bowler. All it means was that he was good in big matches vs Pakistan. Ditto for Moen Ali in Tests.
So now virat's adelaide chase is not special?
Shabaash.
So now virat's adelaide chase is not special?
I hope you're smarter than this.
Yes, so if you agree that the Lyon 10-fer was simply a bad day, the match situation was not difficult. It was simply a case of complacency which made Lyon look way better than he is.
Hence, Kohli's innings was nothing special.
That time aus and their pitch were beast not like today's pathetic aus and pathetic pitchesHaHaHa .... never knew his centuries in Australia hurt you so much. Get a grip over it. Your own Inzamam has just 1 century against Australia in both forms of the game during his entire career.
Shaz did India win the series ??
Surely scoring so many tons in such a series must have been a match winning contribution ?