I am with
@Mamoon on this one while acknowledging, concurrently, that Babar (and rizwan) is a mediocre T20 player today. The game has evolved rapidly in the last 2 years and back then Babar was absolutely an above average batsman then.
But even today, which batsman, going by PSL record, has shown up Babar? Babar failing to win Pakistan games is one thing but the when rubber hits the gravel, you want to know what options you have? Saim Ayub, I have to say, is a poor man's version of Ishan Kishan. A lappebaaz who comes off now and then but hopelessly out of his depth against any decent attack.
Babar is *never* out of his depth against *any& attack. He's not as belligerent as the top 30 T20 bats but how can you hold that against him? He only has to be better than the next pakistani batsman. Which he resoundingly is.
I can only compare the situation with Kohli. Kohli has had a profitable IPL so far but anyone who's followed this season knows that Riyan Parag has bossed him in terms of contextually/situationally important runs. That's a check mark against Indian selectors.
I don't see any Parag equivalent in Pakistan challenging Babar.