- Joined
- Oct 2, 2004
- Runs
- 218,133
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Think it is irresponsible behaviour.
You as a batsman get one chance and to deprive yourself and your side of that one chance which could change the course of the game is silly.
He knew he was out and there was no escape unless it was a no ball so why should he waste the time? I think players should now leave the crease if they edge and the review is available for the other team.
How did he know? he was lunging forward and probably had a feeling but he could have taken the chance of staying on and be adjudged not out.
How did he know? he was lunging forward and probably had a feeling but he could have taken the chance of staying on and be adjudged not out.
Why are umpires getting paid? Its their job to make a decision. I have never seen a bowler calling a batsman back if he is given out falsely. Pretty funny to see people label the batsman a cheat if he doesn't walk(even if there is no appeal).
Even if there is an appeal umpire should be the one making the decision
How would bowler know if the batsmen is out or not? And it has happened on a few occasions where captain brought back the player
Why are umpires getting paid? Its their job to make a decision. I have never seen a bowler calling a batsman back if he is given out falsely. Pretty funny to see people label the batsman a cheat if he doesn't walk(even if there is no appeal).
Even if there is an appeal umpire should be the one making the decision
How did he know? he was lunging forward and probably had a feeling but he could have taken the chance of staying on and be adjudged not out.
Depends lol Kohli giving himself out in the world cup when he was not was just dumb. DInesh Karthik did once.
It only shows that Kohli was scared of prevailing conditions as he never walks.Depends lol Kohli giving himself out in the world cup when he was not was just dumb. DInesh Karthik did once.
Think it is irresponsible behaviour.
You as a batsman get one chance and to deprive yourself and your side of that one chance which could change the course of the game is silly.

It only shows that Kohli was scared of prevailing conditions as he never walks.
Those who saw that 'dismissal' LIVE know what I'm talking about.Are you implying that every batsmen who walked were scared of prevailing conditions, including Sohaib Maqsood?
It only shows that Kohli was scared of prevailing conditions as he never walks.
Watched Sohaib Maqsood walk off - not waiting for the umpire's decision.
I am not sure if that is so smart.
What if there was doubt and decision could have come his way - especially in a tight situation.
Also wonder if he would have done this if Pakistan were 20 runs away from target?
View attachment 110506