What's new

Best batsmen in a crisis ever from the subcontinent?

Harsh Thakor

First Class Star
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Runs
3,519
Post of the Week
2
In tentative order of merit the best batsmen when the chips were down.Not asessed in terms of pure class thus excluded Inzamam,Zaheer Abbas,Majid Khan ,Kumar Sangakaara,Virat Kohli etc.Under pressure they would come out on top.


1.Javed Miandad
2.Rahul Dravid
3.Sachin Tendulkar
4.Younus Khan
5.Mohinder Amarnath
6.Gundapa Vishwanath
7.Sunil Gavaskar
8.Aravinda De'Silva
9.Salim Malik
10.Asif Iqbal
11.Hanif Mohammad
12.Mahela Jayewardene



Miandad at the top because he wast he ultimate fighter who literally through his eyes intimidated opponents.Even if not the most elegant or correct played shots most apt to the situation,niggling the best opponents to his last breadth.Dravid was a champion when the team's back was to the wall,particulary in England in 2002 and 2011 and in Australia in 2004.Tendulkar bore more pressure than any great and played some epic knocks but still not at his absolute best when the chips were down.Few batsmen turned more games from the depth s of despair than Younus Khan.Amarnath displayed determination and guts at it's highest zenith against the West Indies in 1983 which had the best pace attack of all time.On bad wickets or in a crisis Vishy often overshadowed the great Gavaskar like in Madras v West Indies in 1974-75 and 1978-79 and Dunedin in 1975-76.Being a opener Gavaskar did not have the opportunity to confront many crisis situations but still played many classic knock sunder pressure.Aravinda was the ultimate craftsmen when the chips were down,particularly on bad pitches.Salim Malik at his best could ressurect his team from the grave as much as Javed like in England in 1987 and 92 and in a home series v Australia in 1994.Asif was the best batsmen I ever saw with tail -enders and heroic in losing battles .I can never forget his unbeaten 146 at the Oval in 1967,152 n.o at Brisbane in 1976-77 and 135 at Kingston in 1977.Hanif Mohammad was champion in batting for his life in any situation.Mahela Jayewardene was elegance personified even in a crisis and would resemble a surgeon stitching a wound.

The likes of Kumar Sangakaara,Inzamam Ul Haq and Virat Kohli missed out by just a whisker or even Wasim Raja.
 
VVS Laxman.

Really sorry, missed the great V.V.S.Laxman .Close to the ultimate champion when the chips were down.Out No doubt he was a genius .Re-posting list.Thanks.


In tentative order of merit the best batsmen when the chips were down.Not asessed in terms of pure class thus excluded Inzamam,Zaheer Abbas,Majid Khan ,Kumar Sangakaara,Virat Kohli etc.Under pressure they would come out on top.


1.Javed Miandad
2.Rahul Dravid
3.Sachin Tendulkar
4.Younus Khan
5.V.V.S.Laxman
6.Mohinder Amarnath
7.Gundapa Vishwanath
8.Sunil Gavaskar
9.Aravinda De'Silva
10.Salim Malik
11.Asif Iqbal
12.Mahela Jayewardene



Miandad at the top because he wast he ultimate fighter who literally through his eyes intimidated opponents.Even if not the most elegant or correct played shots most apt to the situation,niggling the best opponents to his last breadth.Dravid was a champion when the team's back was to the wall,particulars in England in 2002 and 2011 and in Australia in 2004.Tendulkar bore more pressure than any great and played some epic knocks but still not at his absolute best when the chips were down.Few batsmen turned more games from the depth s of despair than Younus Khan.V.V.S Laxman was the best architect in turning the complexion of game when a team was in dire straits and arguably the best batsmen of his era in 4th innings run chases.Made epic contributions to take India from the brink of defeat to the pinnacle of glory against Australia at Mumbai in 2001 and at Bangalore in 2010. Amarnath displayed determination and guts at it's highest zenith against the West Indies in 1983 which had the best pace attack of all time.On bad wickets or in a crisis Vishy often overshadowed the great Gavaskar like in Madras v West Indies in 1974-75 and 1978-79 and Dunedin in 1975-76.Being a opener Gavaskar did not have the opportunity to confront many crisis situations but still played many classic knock sunder pressure.Aravinda was the ultimate craftsmen when the chips were down,particularly on bad pitches.Salim Malik at his best could ressurect his team from the grave as much as Javed like in England in 1987 and 92 and in a home series v Australia in 1994.Asif was the best batsmen I ever saw with tail -enders and heroic in losing battles .I can never forget his unbeaten 146 at the Oval in 1967,152 n.o at Brisbane in 1976-77 and 135 at Kingston in 1977.Mahela Jayewardene was elegance personified even in a crisis and would resemble a surgeon stitching a wound.

The likes of Kumar Sangakaara,Inzamam Ul Haq and Virat Kohli missed out by just a whisker or even Wasim Raja.
 
Younis Khan's every innings was basically a crisis situation .
 
Against ATG attacks like Steyn , Donald , McGrath, Wasim etc I would take either Sachin or VVS or even Inzi

Against Tier 2 attacks like England , NZ etc Dravid , Sanga, Miandad, YK
 
Laxman.... not in terms of strict stats, but in terms of several memorable performances.
 
Misbah has to be in the discussion. Not the most gifted or the greatest batsman but he's bailed us out of trouble more times than I can remember.
 
Against ATG attacks like Steyn , Donald , McGrath, Wasim etc I would take either Sachin or VVS or even Inzi

Against Tier 2 attacks like England , NZ etc Dravid , Sanga, Miandad, YK

Something doesn't add up.
 
Laxman.... not in terms of strict stats, but in terms of several memorable performances.

Great choice.Still Miandad had better temperament and Daravid more consistent.Javed was more intimidating.
 
Something doesn't add up.

Do check out his record against a full strength WI attack, better than anyone else during his era I would believe. Also has a ton against McWarne in Australia (which Dravid doesn't)
 
Miandad and Khan, without a shadow of a doubt.

Dravid may be a distant 3rd but no one cares about bronze.
 
I like the list and agree tha Laxman has done great service to his country. I also think YK was less combative verbally, but he did more with his bat than Javed. But Javed like Viv brought much more to the table than their batting prowess.. intimidation..
 
From the ones I've seen a fair bit of so aside from Gavaskar, Miandad and co.

Tests

YK - Lost count of the number of times he has bailed Pak out with wickets tumbling all around him. Misbah probably the only reliable support he had post late 2000s.

Sanga - Was basically an opener pretty much always having to come in early to steady the ship. Did have more support than YK I would say although away was mostly a lone wolf.

Dravid - Team man personified. Did have some solid support for the most part but he was quite often the wall keeping the opposition at bay very difficult to dislodge.

Sachin - Pretty much always had a massive target on his back but delivered more often than not. Carried India throughout most of the the 90s. Was brilliant against the great Aus side.

VVS - Another one who was brilliant against the great Aus side. Played some gems and super calm under pressure. Probably someone who under achieved on the whole given the potential.


LOIs

Kohli
Sachin
Arjuna (super under-rated)
Jayasuriya
Aravinda
 
Miandad
Misbah
Younis

IND:
Dravid
VVS

Can't really include Tendulkar here, let's be real. Or if you really want to he comes at 3 or 4th position from IND.
 
[MENTION=132062]Harsh Thakor[/MENTION] Misbah was the primary rescue 911 for Pakistan especially in Tests. Often accompanied by YK.

Should include him up there.

He has done it more often than probably every other Pak batsman in our history.
 
Vangipurapu venkata sai laxman
Rahul sharad Dravid
Mohammad younis khan
Misbah ul haq niazi
Kumar chokshananda sangakkara
Pinnaduwage Aravinda de Silva
 
In the order of merit-

Pakistan:
Miandad
Younis Khan
Hanif Mohammad
Inzamam

India:
VVS Laxman
Gavaskar
Sachin
Dravid

Sri Lanka:
Sangakkara
Aravinda
Mahela
Angelo
 
Last edited:
In the order of merit-

Pakistan:
Miandad
Younis Khan
Hanif Mohammad
Inzamam

India:
VVS Laxman
Gavaskar
Sachin
Dravid

Sri Lanka:
Sangakkara
Aravinda
Mahela
Angelo

Why Dravid below Tendulkar in a crisis?I feel Dravid was ahead when the teams back was to the wall.Numerous times he pulled India out of trouble.
 
Why Dravid below Tendulkar in a crisis?I feel Dravid was ahead when the teams back was to the wall.Numerous times he pulled India out of trouble.

Because Sachin did it against superior bowling attacks. In the 90s he didn't have much support but stood up in every single series, even in overseas matches. Again in 2007-11 when India became a prime contender for top spot it was Sachin who was our best batsman and ensured we didn't lose against Eng 2008/Aus 2010/SA 2010 etc, Dravid was very average in those 3-4 years. Dravid pulled us out of trouble frequently in 2000-2006, Sachin did it over a greater length of time.
 
Back
Top