What's new

Beyond the Boundary: Shadab Khan's captaincy was ruthlessly exposed in the defeat to Afghanistan

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,944
Many thanks to [MENTION=147314]topspin[/MENTION] for his detailed review of the 3-match T20I series between Afghanistan and Pakistan.


ZAPpFip.png


The recently concluded series in Sharjah saw Afghanistan secure their first T20I series win against Pakistan. A remarkable achievement by a team who have come a long way since 2012, when these two sides first met in a one-off ODI in Dubai. It also marked Afghanistan’s first series win against a top six ranked ICC side.

Babar Azam, Mohammad Rizwan, Shaheen Shah Afridi, Fakhar Zaman and Haris Rauf had all been rested for the Pakistan side following an intense schedule of PSL in recent weeks. This did come as a surprise for many of the fans who have been accustomed to seeing Pakistan stick with their strongest XI in all contests, as opposed to seeing them test out their bench strength and experiment with squad rotations.

The first two contests were dominated by spin, courtesy of the slow and dry Sharjah surface which made batting tremendously difficult to time the ball. The pitches were tailor made for Afghanistan’s majestic spin bowling attack, who to their credit certainly got more out of these conditions.

The challenge for Pakistan going into this series was also compounded by the abundance of inexperience in their batting line-up, particularly with the top three of Muhammad Haris, Saim Ayub and Abdullah Shafique. The latter had a horror show in the first two contests where he was dismissed for a duck to nab an unwanted record of four ducks in a row. It was always going to be a difficult task for them to adjust from the more batting friendly wickets in the PSL to the slow turners of Sharjah.

Rashid Khan and Mujeeb Ur Rehman were terrific but the pick of the bowlers was their seamer Fazalhaq Farooqi, who exhibited a masterclass on how to bowl with the new ball and was regularly clocking in excess of 140 km/h. He utilised his combination of pace and swing to wreak havoc on Pakistan’s top three batsmen during the powerplay throughout the series. Perhaps he could consider himself unlucky to lose out on Man of the Series Award, which was instead awarded to Mohammad Nabi who also had a commendable series.

In Babar’s absence, Shadab Khan was given the honour of captaining this series for Pakistan but there will be question marks over his decision at the toss to bowl first in each of the first two contests. On a challenging batting surface, it was always going to be difficult to determine what was going to be a par score batting first. To make the same mistake twice in back-to-back contests was not only criminal but perhaps a deciding factor on the outcome of this series. One wonders if he had misread the wicket or whether it was just a case of complacency? Even though he played well in the last match, his spin bowling in the earlier games paled in comparison to Rashid Khan. Overall, it’s fair to say that Shadab’s captaincy as well as his bowling, when it mattered the most, left much to be desired.

The words unprecedented and atypical come to mind when looking back at the first match of the series. To see a team bat for 20 overs and only muster 92 runs is a huge statistical anomaly in T20 cricket. This was Pakistan’s 5th lowest score in their history of T20I cricket. None of their batsman were able to score in excess of 20 runs. Pakistan’s inability to score freely was a reflection of the how challenging the wicket was to bat on due to the turn and uneven bounce. It was the type of wicket you would expect in the UAE on day four of a test match.

In the early overs, it was Fazalhaq Farooqi who troubled the Pakistani openers with prodigious swing. Pakistan ended the powerplay on 39/3. Rashid Khan, Mujeeb Ur Rehman and Mohammad Nabi followed up on his good work to produce remarkable figures of 1/15, 2/9 and 2/12 respectively. As a result, Pakistan could only add a further 53 runs off 90 balls to give Afghanistan just 93 to chase.

Pakistan responded well during the powerplay, with Ihsanullah in particular, who picked up the wickets of Ibrahim Zadran and Gulbadin Naib with well-directed short pitched deliveries to leave Afghanistan 29/3 after six overs. There was perhaps further evidence of how Pakistan misread the pitch after having selected only two spinners in their bowling attack. Pakistan may have fancied their chances if they had twelve overs of spin when Afghanistan were 45/4 at one stage. Along with Ihsanullah, Imad Wasim bowled well to produce 1/11 from his four overs, but he deserved more reward, as the side was let down by Azam Khan’s poor glove work behind the stumps.

The collective experience and composure of Mohammad Nabi and Najibullah Zadran saw Afghanistan through to the end with an unbeaten 53 run partnership to mark a historic first win against Pakistan.

The woes with the bat continued for the men in green during the second game of the series and it was once again Fazalhaq Farooqi who troubled Pakistan in the powerplay with the wickets of Saim Ayub and Abdullah Shafique. They were both dismissed without scoring to leave Pakistan reeling again in the Powerplay at 20/3. Imad came in at this stage of the innings to score a much needed half century to help Pakistan reach a competitive total of 130. In difficult circumstances, this was a good effort on another challenging wicket to bat on.

Credit must also be given to Rashid Khan who bowled his four overs to concede just 16 runs to go with his wicket of Azam Khan, who ended up yielding just one run after his two appearances in the series.

Afghanistan began the chase strong, scoring 45 runs after the first six overs with the loss of just one wicket. Pakistan kept fighting and were successful in stemming the run flow for a while but without any wickets until the 16th over.

When Mohammad Nawaz was brought into the side, one would think that common sense had prevailed on Shadab with the requirement of twelve overs of spin. However, he instead only opted for nine from the slower bowlers as Imad was given just the one over.

A pivotal over in the match was when Shadab bowled a half tracker which was dealt with disdain by Ibrahim Zadran. The boundary was then followed up by a wide delivery with a misfield to help relieve the pressure on Afghanistan.

Mohammad Nabi and Najibullah Zadran once again saw their side home with another unbeaten partnership with just one ball to spare. The pair played an instrumental role in Afghanistan’s first ever series win against Pakistan.

The last game of the series was played on a more conventional T20 pitch and the Pakistani batsmen enjoyed the extra pace there was to work with. Pakistan scored 182 from their 20 overs, courtesy of Saim Ayub, who top scored with 49. Abdullah Shafique, Iftikhar Ahmed and Shadab Khan also contributed with some useful cameos. Fazalhaq Farooqi impressed yet again with figures of 1/25 from his 4 overs. Ihsanullah and Shadab took three wickets each to defeat Afghanistan by a big margin of 66 runs.

The main takeaways from this series can be summarised as follows:

1. Afghanistan have proved that they have the most potent spin attack in T20I cricket. Rashid Khan showed again why he is the number one spinner in the shortest format.

2. Shadab’s captaincy was ruthlessly exposed in this series. His decision to give Imad one over on a slow surface in the second game and opting to bat first on two occasions was quite bizarre.

3. Imad’s importance to Pakistan isn’t just limited to T20Is. His presence in the lower middle order will be needed in India during the ODI World Cup later this year.

4. Shaheen and Ihsanullah have nailed two of the three spots for Pakistan’s white ball pace attack but the remaining spot is up for grabs as Naseem Shah has been far from convincing with his track record in T20Is

5. The case of Azam Khan should serve Pakistan cricket a lesson that fitness can never be comprised

6. The last contest showed that even a depleted Pakistan team is well ahead of Afghanistan on a conventional white ball pitch, so they must continue to persist with the likes of Saim Ayub, Mohammad Haris and Abdullah Shafique. Discarding them after one series played on turning pitches would be short-sighted and quite frankly a terrible case of mismanagement, as they have each earned a fair chance to showcase their full potential in various conditions.
 
Last edited:
All Wickets | AFG v PAK T20I Series | ACB


<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/t_Se-o1xTm8" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share" allowfullscreen></iframe>
 
Losing to AFG is still pretty embarrassing considering we’re former t20 world champions and arguably the greatest t20 side throughout the rich history of t20s.

Even so, I welcome the decision of PCB to back the next gen like this, and looking to improve on our shortcomings at the last t20 WC.
 
Great write up

Really enjoyed this series and it feels good to support a balanced Pakistan side with the correct players in the correct positions

If only it could have been a 5 match series but I guess it is what it is.

Here’s to hoping that the same team/squad get a chance to play a significantly weakened NZ side at home in the 5match T20i series.
 
Losing to AFG is still pretty embarrassing considering we’re former t20 world champions and arguably the greatest t20 side throughout the rich history of t20s.

Even so, I welcome the decision of PCB to back the next gen like this, and looking to improve on our shortcomings at the last t20 WC.

Losing to Afghanistan isn’t embarrassing

They have 3 players that have a higher net value than our biggest stars:

Nabi
Rashid
Mujeeb

That’s 3 of the best and most experienced T20 spinners in the world as well, and this was their home deck.

They also have two brilliant seamers in Farooqi and Omarzai who know how to swing the ball unlike everyone in Pakistan

Rehmanullah Gurbaz is probably the best T20 keeper/Batsman in Asia. That’s 6 proper cricketers in the XI.

I’m actually very impressed with our boys effort to fight in all three games. This core new team will grow in strength the more they play. The addition of Usama Mir and Abrar will also enhance our spin bowling options as both IMO are better spinners than Shadab Khan
 
Great post! An excellent summary of the series and the 6 takeaways are bang on the money.

Some small line up tweaks and making the correct decision at the toss could have resulted in a different outcome in the series.
 
Good write up. If we're going to lose to Afghanistan, I'd rather it be in a meaningless T20 bilateral than at a tournament.

Despite playing a reserve team, we still could've won the series had the batsmen adjusted from the flat PSL wickets to the slow, stopping UAE surfaces. The lack of game awareness and misreading of pitches is endemic within Pakistan cricket.

Emergence of Ihsanullah provides much needed competition in the seam bowling department. Bit disappointed we didn't see Usama Mir in the squad who I thought impressed in the NZL ODIs.

Shadab ruled himself out of captaincy contention with this display.
 
Very good write up.

Number 5 is a key point. For Azam Khan to be in the side he needs to be performing at a level which compromises for his lack of fitness. He is nowhere near that.

Number 6 i am torn on. Pakistan lack decent aggressive batsmen and Haris has shown strong indications of talent. However he is massively undercooked and i feel he needs a lot of focus on red ball cricket to prevent him going down the Haider Ali route. That means sacrificing on 2-3 years of him now but potentially reaping bigger rewards down the line.
 
One can safely say that Shadab Khan is unlikely to captain Pakistan again!
 
sorry [MENTION=147314]topspin[/MENTION] , while it is a well written article, but i disagree on the captaincy point.

Shadab lead the side well. Made good bowling changes. He was given an inexperienced team and it was for sure he was not consulted on team selection. Thus, this result was expected.

As captain, he made very good changes. People often cry about slip, but you dont judge captaincy on the basis of one slip fielder not being there. The slip standard has been an old south asia standard to judge captains. If a ball goes to slip and there isnt a fielder people whine about it.

However slip is only needed when there is certain movement in the ball off the pitch. The chances of ball going to slips are very slim and you cant have a slip fielder at all times.
 
One can safely say that Shadab Khan is unlikely to captain Pakistan again!

depends how PCB sees Shadab Khan's captaincy. His captaincy was good, and was not bad. He had a weak team and a small score to defend.
 
sorry [MENTION=147314]topspin[/MENTION] , while it is a well written article, but i disagree on the captaincy point.

Shadab lead the side well. Made good bowling changes. He was given an inexperienced team and it was for sure he was not consulted on team selection. Thus, this result was expected.

As captain, he made very good changes. People often cry about slip, but you dont judge captaincy on the basis of one slip fielder not being there. The slip standard has been an old south asia standard to judge captains. If a ball goes to slip and there isnt a fielder people whine about it.

However slip is only needed when there is certain movement in the ball off the pitch. The chances of ball going to slips are very slim and you cant have a slip fielder at all times.

He made 3 blunders as captain during the lost matches:

1. Chose to bat first in the first T20I on a slow dry surface
2. Made the same mistake in the next match on another wicket where he should've bowled first
3. Gave Imad one over in the second T20I on a wicket which was conducive to the spinners

You claim he led the side well, I would argue his blunders may have cost Pakistan the series.
 
He made 3 blunders as captain during the lost matches:

1. Chose to bat first in the first T20I on a slow dry surface
2. Made the same in the next match on another wicket where he should've bowled first
3. Gave Imad one over in the second T20I on a wicket which was conducive to the spinners

I would argue his blunders may have cost Pakistan the series.

This one, I will put down to a collective management failure.
 
This one, I will put down to a collective management failure.

It certainly is a collective management failure as you say but Shadab should have the final say as captain. He has played 140 white ball matches for Pakistan. 34 of these matches were in the UAE, so he should know better than anyone, especially when you consider the fact that he's also captained Islamabad United in the last four editions of the PSL (since 2020).

There were other big mistakes he made which I didn't categorise as blunders. He was defensive with his fields but more importantly, Pakistan had just selected two frontline spinners for the first game. For someone who is a relatively experienced spinner himself and has played 34 matches in the UAE, he has to be accountable for this as well because it's beyond unacceptable.

I appreciate Pakistan cricket isn't exactly blessed with astute tacticians but there's a fine line between not possessing tactical nous and the lack of common sense, which was a regular occurrence for Shadab as captain during this series against Afghanistan.
 
Last edited:
We lost because of our batting the top order batsmen were inept .

If batsmen had posted 150+ in the first 2 games we would have won comfortably.

The batting talent emerging is the worry how the likes of tape ball players like tayyab get selected is the problem and then an obese wicketkeeper who keeps fluffing almost every ball coming through doesn't help .
 
Losing to Afghanistan , even without some senior players is embarrassing but I'm happy with the failure of some players who had no business in playing for Pakistan and hopefully will never play for the national team again . I'm talking about Faheem, Azam and Tayyab in Particular.

Series has also proved than Shadab is not at all ready to lead the team , even occasionally , needs at least two more years to take that role for T20 team . Imad should take over the captaincy of T20 team , if Babar is removed from the role, and he should be.

Saim has enhanced his reputation ,Zaman did the same, Harris missed a golden chance but should be persisted with. Ihasannulah didn't disappoint anyone , he is a star in making.

Wasim Jr keeps on improving .
 
sorry [MENTION=147314]topspin[/MENTION] , while it is a well written article, but i disagree on the captaincy point.

Shadab lead the side well. Made good bowling changes. He was given an inexperienced team and it was for sure he was not consulted on team selection. Thus, this result was expected.

As captain, he made very good changes. People often cry about slip, but you dont judge captaincy on the basis of one slip fielder not being there. The slip standard has been an old south asia standard to judge captains. If a ball goes to slip and there isnt a fielder people whine about it.

However slip is only needed when there is certain movement in the ball off the pitch. The chances of ball going to slips are very slim and you cant have a slip fielder at all times.

I agree. Getting pitches like this in a format where everyone is psychologically primed to think the pitches will be a batting feast is a huge challenge in your first series as a captain.

And, once again, it was his first full series as captain. Surely we can have some empathy and hold off on ruling him out in the future in what is his literal first try…
 
sorry [MENTION=147314]topspin[/MENTION] , while it is a well written article, but i disagree on the captaincy point.

Shadab lead the side well. Made good bowling changes. He was given an inexperienced team and it was for sure he was not consulted on team selection. Thus, this result was expected.

As captain, he made very good changes. People often cry about slip, but you dont judge captaincy on the basis of one slip fielder not being there. The slip standard has been an old south asia standard to judge captains. If a ball goes to slip and there isnt a fielder people whine about it.

However slip is only needed when there is certain movement in the ball off the pitch. The chances of ball going to slips are very slim and you cant have a slip fielder at all times.
I agree the post from topspin is a good analysis but strongly disagree about Shadab captaincy being exposed. I found it quite refreshing and he made tge team fight well in all three games, and always made good bowling changes as well as changing team each time on merit, whilst not dropping youngster like Azam without proper opportunity. Batting first after winning toss is normally combined decision which includes team management, and bating second would had added pressure on the youngsters as even Afghanistan expereinced side demonstrated in all three games, albeit they won first two but not without drama. Shadab also put his ego behind him by allowing Imad to bat above him and even at 4. Shadab bowling was not great in first two games but came back well in the third.
Usama is a must in this team perhaps ahead of Nawaz, now that Imad has shown maturity in his batting, although his bowling will not be as effective as Nawaz's.
 
He made 3 blunders as captain during the lost matches:

1. Chose to bat first in the first T20I on a slow dry surface
2. Made the same mistake in the next match on another wicket where he should've bowled first
3. Gave Imad one over in the second T20I on a wicket which was conducive to the spinners

You claim he led the side well, I would argue his blunders may have cost Pakistan the series.

Batting second or first can go either way, wont look into that too much. His teams batting failed massively, and he was being forced to play all juniors.

IMad bowls mostly darters, no spin at all, he is just a slow arm pace bowler
 
Usama Mir looks like a better replacement for Shadab. Shadab isn't at his best these days.

Pakistan can build a very good ODI squad for the WC.

Given that it's in Asia,

Opening slot and one down :

Fakhar Zaman, Imam ul Haq, Babar Azam, Saim Ayyub (or Mohammad Harris)

Middle order 4,5,6 :

Sarfaraz Ahmed, Rizwan, Imad Wasim, Shan Masood (I don't like him but I know Pakistan will have him)

Bowlers who can bat (7,8,9) : (Mohammad Nawaz/Usama Mir/Ifthikar Ahmed), Shadab Khan, Mohammad Wasim

No. 10&11 : Shaheen Afridi, Ihsanullah, Naseem Shah, Harris Rauff

I wouldn't mind swapping Shan Masood with an Azam Khan or someone who can do what Umar Akmal used to do those days...someone who can hold a bat and score quickly. But that'll never happen.

I also wouldn't mind swapping Amir for one of Naseem or Harris.

Mohammad Harris can be given the finisher job in a low key match, just to see how he performs.
 
His captaincy was exposed. But, he also didn't have a good team to lead. Pakistan fielded some rookies.
 
Batting second or first can go either way, wont look into that too much. His teams batting failed massively, and he was being forced to play all juniors.

If you're batting first on an unusual T20 pitch (like we saw in the first 2 x T20Is) which is clearly providing a lot more assistance to the bowlers, you always bowl first because it's hard to judge what total you need to put up for the opponent required to chase.

As I mentioned earlier in this thread, Shadab has played 140 white ball matches for Pakistan. 34 of them were in the UAE, so he should know better than anyone else, especially with his experience as captain in the last four editions of the PSL for Islamabad United.

He also made other mistakes which I didn't deem for these to be classed as blunders. He was defensive with his fields. When you're defending a low total, you need to be more proactive.

In the first match, Pakistan only played 2 x spinners. For someone who is a spinner himself and has numerous games in the UAE, he has to be held accountable for that as well.

We all know Babar lacks tactical nous but Shadab brought Pakistan captaincy to a new low because he lacked common sense. Also the way he threw his players under the bus after the series just shows he's not captaincy material.

IMad bowls mostly darters, no spin at all, he is just a slow arm pace bowler

I don't know what kind of logic is this. In the first game, Imad bowled his full set of 4 overs taking 1 for 11. It would've been 2 for 7 if it wasn't for Azam Khan's dropped catch and the 4 byes he conceded. To give him just one over in a spin friendly wicket was unforgivable.

I've taken notice of your recent posts relating to Imad. I know you dislike him like all the other Babar/Rizwan fans do but at least make it make sense.

It's obvious you only like Shadab because he's part of Misbah's clique. I'm glad Imad doesn't belong to this cake cutting beta boy band of softies.

News has come in that Shadab is due to be replaced as vice-captain (and Imad might replace him). Everyone can see how badly his captaincy was exposed.
 
Afghanistan cricketer, Najibullah Zadran, has undergone a successful operation at a private hospital in Peshawar.

The all-rounder was admitted in the hospital for his tonsils operation.

After the surgery, the hospital administration presented flowers to the cricketer.

Zadran has been discharged from the hospital and has left for his home country along with his brother.

During the final match of T20I series between Afghanistan and Pakistan in Sharjah, Ihsanullah delivered a fierce bouncer that rose steeply and hit Najibullah in the area between his neck and the helmet grill.

Fortunately, Najibullah did not suffer a serious injury, but he was unable to continue batting when Afghanistan was struggling at 71 for 4 in the 11th over of their chase of 183. Concussion substitute Azmatullah Omarzai replaced Najibullah and scored the highest runs with a 20-ball 21, but was unable to win the game for Afghanistan.
 
Going back to talking about his captaincy, agree that the team was not stellar but he just didn't lead well. You can take a loss, but he just didn't come across as an astute captain at international level, and it seemed more than just nerves. While I was never high on him ever being in the running, yet wasn't against it, however seeing him, the decisions he made, how he over values his own batting when he just should never come in top 6 , really made Babar seem like a 10x better captain and that's saying a lot.
 
Shadab has no leadership skills. His captaincy was exposed not just against Afghanistan. What has he achieved for Islamabad United as captain !!!!
 
Shadab has no leadership skills. His captaincy was exposed not just against Afghanistan. What has he achieved for Islamabad United as captain !!!!
Some great action reels of him in the dug out when someone plays an extraordinary shot
 
Back
Top