What's new

Can the PSL be held during September instead of February?

Faisalsq092

Tape Ball Regular
Joined
Oct 19, 2015
Runs
582
Post of the Week
1
PSL 3 is about to begin and as everyone I am super excited for it. It’s a tournament which most Pakistan cricket lovers follow and enjoy and I see tremendous potential in it.
Its been a successful tournament so far and I dearly hope, being realistic, that it soon becomes the indisputable 2nd best cricket league going around (Can’t compete the IPL in the near future). Pakistan has the advantage of a massive market and knowing how passionate our population is, it just needs proper marketing to make this brand attractive.
With all the hype around, an area which I feel needs attention is the scheduling of the tournament.
PSL is now bookmarked for the month of Feb/ March. Although, it is a convenient period to play cricket in UAE, it also deprives PSL of a lot of things which can help boost the product.
I have been contemplating over it and I feel September is a much better month for PSL to be played. The merits of playing in September I find is as follows:

Star Player Availability:

Knowing that a T20 league can only succeed if it gathers attention Internationally. PSL isn’t maximizing its potential in this regard. There is no doubt that we produce enough local talent to make it exciting, but to engage the global audience, they need to associate themselves to the team to gather a following. International audience will associate itself once it finds their favorite countrymen being part of the PSL.

The top 5 countries in the world currently are (unarguably): Australia, South Africa, India, New Zealand and England. It is given that Indian players will not be a part. This leaves us with four teams to attract star players of.

Looking at the current season, all the remaining four teams are busy in international assignments. This has actually been the case since the previous seasons as it is the home season of Australia, NZ and South Africa. England too are generally busy playing away cricket during winters. The PSL has so far not attracted QDK, ABDV, Guptill, Boult, Warner, Root, Maxwell and plenty other numerous stars representing these teams. These are supposedly the best players going around in the world. PSL suddenly misses out on a lots of quality players which can only improve the quality of the tournament. The likes of ageing KP or retired MCcullum or a non international Tymal Mills will never able to match those standards.

We are even missing star Quality from the 6th best team (In T20s) which is West Indies due to many of their main players due to play in the WC qualifiers. This leaves us only with Sri Lanka and Bangladesh as credible teams from whom to extract star power and in the current state, we can only extract so much from them. It drains the pool further if either of these teams have an international commitment.

Now if the league was held in September, this would have been the schedule of the teams considering it was in 2017 (the last such schedule to provide factual assessment):
1. Australia – Busy Playing India and Bangladesh
2. South Africa – No Games until 28th September
3. New Zealand – Fully available
4. England – Available after 16th September
5. West Indies – Available after 16th September
6. Bangladesh - No Games until 28th September
7. Sri Lanka – Available after 6th September.

This suddenly opens up the overseas slots for plenty of South African and Kiwi players which can turn out to be a massive boost. Just Imagine Guptill opening for KK or QDK, Munro and other stars playing for various franchises.

No clash with any other Major League:
As the news is building around of various other T20 leagues being schedule in the Emirates which may take the sheen off PSL. Why not arrange our league right at the start of the season so that any other competing league before PSL doesn’t affect the market of the PSL. In other International Leagues BPL occurs in November and BBL too doesn’t happen until December/ January.

The biggest plus of this arrangement would be that we will be a good 6-7 months away from IPL. As we have witnessed in the past, the players have distanced themselves from PSL to stay fitter and fresher during the IPL. Realistically, we cannot compete IPL right now and it would be better to arrange ourselves accordingly to not let players slip away.

Talent in the limelight before the season begins:
Pakistan’s home season generally start during October onwards. PSL could serve as a platform which can bring the talent to the limelight (I in no way mean produce talent) just before the home season kicks odd. We can then test the players on current form in our home games to ease them into the side. Although this is marginal and can go either way, but I think this can improve planning for future with our youngsters.

I don’t know if there are any genuine reasons to not hold it during this time.
The dilemma shifting to this period will be that either another PSL is to be held again in September 2018 or they opt for a hiatus and hold PSL 4 in 2018. Both options have its Pros and Cons but I believe this is a situation which is easily manageable and a middle ground can be found.
 
It would also depend on Pakistan's Cricketing calender and how jam packed it is. Pakistani and International players are human too and would probably want a period of rest as well in an already jam packed international calender. But i agree it would be better to host the PSL in September than January to March.
 
Sept might clash with Pakistan's home season in UAE. i think Sept/Oct is the most pleasant time for playing cricket in UAE. If the PSL/Intl cricket shifts to Pakistan it might be okay provided it is not rainy season in Pakistan
 
It's fine in February. If it's not broken, don't fix it
 
It's fine in February. If it's not broken, don't fix it

You say its fine in February. But what about missing on big players from NZ, SAF, AUS and ENG. And it is a situation which will sustain itself every single season. Will we be able to establish ourselves with marginalized overseas pool?
 
Sept might clash with Pakistan's home season in UAE. i think Sept/Oct is the most pleasant time for playing cricket in UAE. If the PSL/Intl cricket shifts to Pakistan it might be okay provided it is not rainy season in Pakistan

Well actually the most pleasant time to play in UAE is December/ January. If PSL season can end by Mid October, we can still have 4 months to accommodate our home season.

Additionally, we can have players warming up and be ready for the home season through PSL.
 
It would also depend on Pakistan's Cricketing calender and how jam packed it is. Pakistani and International players are human too and would probably want a period of rest as well in an already jam packed international calender. But i agree it would be better to host the PSL in September than January to March.

Yes, right, but how busy are we. We are probably playing the least number of matches of the major teams. If we compare our number of matches in respect of the size of our market and board, then probably we are right at the end with least number of matches. So hopefully workload issue can be sorted.
 
CPL is played during same window, from this year Afghanistan Premier League and Lankan Premier League will also be played in the same window, BPL starts in October/November and whenever SA league will kick-starts, it will also be played in the same window.
So what's the need of playing in September window with so many leagues at the same time. Feb/Mar is perfect.
 
It's still too hot in September as the temperature can reach 40 degrees.
 
CPL is played during same window, from this year Afghanistan Premier League and Lankan Premier League will also be played in the same window, BPL starts in October/November and whenever SA league will kick-starts, it will also be played in the same window.
So what's the need of playing in September window with so many leagues at the same time. Feb/Mar is perfect.

We are also arranging a T10 league of our own in September in Pakistan so this idea wont work.
 
CPL is played during same window, from this year Afghanistan Premier League and Lankan Premier League will also be played in the same window, BPL starts in October/November and whenever SA league will kick-starts, it will also be played in the same window.
So what's the need of playing in September window with so many leagues at the same time. Feb/Mar is perfect.

This. And Dubai is so so hot in September
 
It's still too hot in September as the temperature can reach 40 degrees.

Well not actually as hot as Chennai is during the IPL. I have been a resident in Dubai for many years. September isn't bad for playing cricket, at least if we can push it to mid September. Yes it is hot, but not very bad.
 
Well not actually as hot as Chennai is during the IPL. I have been a resident in Dubai for many years. September isn't bad for playing cricket, at least if we can push it to mid September. Yes it is hot, but not very bad.

Can't compare Dubai weather with Chennai at any time frame of year.. Dubai is hotter always.
 
CPL is played during same window, from this year Afghanistan Premier League and Lankan Premier League will also be played in the same window, BPL starts in October/November and whenever SA league will kick-starts, it will also be played in the same window.
So what's the need of playing in September window with so many leagues at the same time. Feb/Mar is perfect.

Just checked CPL ending by mid Sep, Afghanistan League starts in October, no idea when Lankan league starts and both BPL and South African league are to be played in November. I hardly see much conflict in this window. Infact, no one is discussing the possibilities of expanding PSL with better overseas stars.

Anyway, the potential PSL has, I don't think we should be worried about either of the above leagues as we can easily attract high quality players by paying better. The only league we cannot compete with is IPL. By hosting in September, we may create a niche for ourselves and have earn more credibility for our league.
 
Maybe PSL can be a floater league.

Whenever a window opens and almost all cricketers are free it can be arranged.

And location can float too if required.
 
This February/March period is starting to not look like a great time to host a T20 competition. It's just before the IPL season. Top players won't want to risk injuries by playing in the PSL due to the riches of the IPL. Also Australia and NZ are usually involved in series during this period. So we are missing out on a lot of quality players during this period.

I would like to see the PSL played between October and November.
 
Can't compare Dubai weather with Chennai at any time frame of year.. Dubai is hotter always.

Which is correct if you look at month by month basis, but if you compare Chennai in April with Dubai in September, there wouldn't be much of a difference.
 
This February/March period is starting to not look like a great time to host a T20 competition. It's just before the IPL season. Top players won't want to risk injuries by playing in the PSL due to the riches of the IPL. Also Australia and NZ are usually involved in series during this period. So we are missing out on a lot of quality players during this period.

I would like to see the PSL played between October and November.

Exactly my point. We miss out on NZ, Aus and SAF due to there home season. England too seem to be touring somewhere during this time. India never comes. This leaves us Windies, Bangla and Lanka to extract quality from. This can hamper the league or at least not let it realise its potential.
 
Best time to arrange PSL is 1 week before IPL and finish it 2 weeks earlier, with PSL draft happening next week after IPL draft.

Only loss, as I can see is may be PSL won't get the high profile coaches like Moody, Upton ... but looks like PSL is already happy with Moin, Mo Akram, Aquib ... so not much issue either.
 
Best time to arrange PSL is 1 week before IPL and finish it 2 weeks earlier, with PSL draft happening next week after IPL draft. H

Only loss, as I can see is may be PSL won't get the high profile coaches like Moody, Upton ... but looks like PSL is already happy with Moin, Mo Akram, Aquib ... so not much issue either.

Haha! got your point. On a serious note, what do you think should be the ideal time to play PSL. I do know that you follow cricket keenly and you must have your opinion on this.
 
It doesn't matter.

T20 is enormously important to expand cricket's reach. It is also thoroughly entertaining on its day. Makes a ton of money for the boards which is important to their growth. Probably the format that has best chance of surviving in the distant future. I will attend some games to support PSL too.

Ultimately though, it is Micky Mouse cricket. Who cares who wins, who loses, which player shows up when. There are a 100 leagues around the world, no one knows their players, their winning records, their performances the next day. You know players are playing for money, and not the shirt.

To be honest, that's true for Premier League Football too - but at least in their case, they are playing the game's purest format. T20 Leagues are Football equivalent of Futsal league. Entertaining but forgettable.

So PSL should be held whenever it can be held. Make money, have fun and move on.
 
Haha! got your point. On a serious note, what do you think should be the ideal time to play PSL. I do know that you follow cricket keenly and you must have your opinion on this.

I am serious - exactly overlapping IPL, as long as PAK players are not participating IPL. The reason I have explained many times, most recently in another thread with 6/7 points - none bothered to dig in deep.

PSL's biggest competitor is not IPL .... not even BBL, EPL, CPL or BPL, rather International schedules, which can be defeated as a bi-product of IPL. If PSL keeps happening in FEB-MAR, till a week or two before IPL, once they expand that tournament to double league (16 X 8 = 128 foreigners), PSL will find very few players risking IPL, and International schedule will be even more intense between NOV-MAR, to cover that 10 weeks IPL Lock-out.

Once ECB starts their league, which I am sure will compete with IPL for the stronger currency, and top PAK players will play there, just like they are playing in BPL which pays higher than PSL, that AUG - OCT window will also be closed. Add to that SAF league & CPL - PSL has very little scope to compete for window, and if PCB has to do that on the shoulders of those Emirates, good luck.

Think carefully again - and forget that PSL is competing with IPL, you should understand.
 
With the expansion of teams we’ll see at least half a month added into the league. Considering a longer time frame for the league, we’ll be able to attract more quality international players in the coming years. Once the league comes back to Pakistan the September season would be slightly unviable due the harsh temperatures at the beginning of the PSL.
 
Back
Top