What's new

Current Test teams with worst batting line-ups in their history

BreadPakoda

First Class Captain
Joined
Feb 8, 2018
Runs
5,515
Would Shaun Pollock walk into this SA batting line up as a specialist batsman?

Without ABD and with declining Amla, the line up looks horrible. Can't believe this is a team that had Andrew Hall at 9/10 back in the day and has given us the likes of Garry Kirsten, Cullinan, Kallis, Smith, Gibbs etc. I believe, Shaun Pollock would walk into this side as a specialist batsman.

Can't do worse than Theunis de Bruyn, eh?
 
What are u talking about. He wasn't better than philander and he is coming in at 8 ( so we got work to do!!)
 
What are u talking about. He wasn't better than philander and he is coming in at 8 ( so we got work to do!!)

You're underrating Pollock here. He averaged 32+ back in the day when he had to face the likes of Akram, McGrath, Walsh etc. The real star bowlers of the 90s. de Bruyn averages 21. Vern is a more than decent bat and he too averages in the 20s but he hasn't even faced a bowler of the class of say Ambrose.
 
Easily. worst SA batting lineup i've ever seen. He can easily replace specialist captain Faf lol.
 
Quite possible.He was the one of the batsmen who has better away avg. than home.
Even in ODIs, Sa often used him as a pinch hitter and he deliver more often than not.Still remember the over where he smashed Kyle Mills all over the park and in the end Nz barely scraped through.
 
Easily. worst SA batting lineup i've ever seen. He can easily replace specialist captain Faf lol.
I totally agree.

Awful South African batting line-up, shameful that Pakistan’s is even worse!
 
Very high chance. He was clearly better than Philander and averaged 32 with the bat. At times, would come to bat at 6-7 as well in different formats.

The current SA middle order will be humiliated by Shah and co in UAE.
 
Easily. worst SA batting lineup i've ever seen. He can easily replace specialist captain Faf lol.

He could be one of their best batsman. Not sure if the likes of Bavuma, de Bruyn, or de Kock are better than Pollock. That's half the batting line up! SA has really regressed.
 
He could be one of their best batsman. Not sure if the likes of Bavuma, de Bruyn, or de Kock are better than Pollock. That's half the batting line up! SA has really regressed.

All of them look better than Faf. Last 9 matches - averaging 19 with the bat. sarfaraz is better lol.
 
If Faf is their Sarfaraz, Amla is their Shafiq. One decent innings and then goes missing.

Faf is worse. Chose to bowl first on a pitch that is actually cracking on that off stump line. RSA will get smashed in 4th innings here. Talk about taking a bazooka and shooting yourself in the foot.
 
Faf is worse. Chose to bowl first on a pitch that is actually cracking on that off stump line. RSA will get smashed in 4th innings here. Talk about taking a bazooka and shooting yourself in the foot.

Yeah. Cracks doing the magic for the bowlers. Stupid call by Faf.
 
Is this the worst South African batting lineup since readmission to Test cricket?

No AB who won them the series against India and sandpaper+ Australia.

Alma is a washed-up joke at this point; averaging 25 since the start of 2018.

De Bruyn is arguably their worst top order bat ever averaging 21 after 7 matches.

Bavuma is a quota selection, gritty player but not talented enough.

QdK has been found out and is averaging 21 since start of 2018.

Elgar is SA's Azhar Ali. Decent player but nowhere near WC.

Markram averages 35 (excluding home tests against minnows) but has potential.
 
So SA, Pakistan, and Australia have their worst sides in history. We can probably add WI to the list. What about SL? England? They don't have anyone like Trueman or Willis bowling in the 170s.
 
SL are also having their worst test side since 1995,i.e. when I became aware of the fact that cricket is a sport.

At the moment, there are only three test class sides. England keep switching on and off and so are NZ.

India are the only team playing good cricket.Rest all are minnows.
 
I believe all these 6 countries currently have worst test batting line up in their history.

Australia - Suffering from ban of two best batsmen (who were ranked in top
in ICC test rankings) and another potential great test batsman in
Cameron Bancroft. Team is very demoralised and basically just
waiting for the return of banned trio. Sandpaper gate has hit
them hard.

Pakistan - Struggling a lot financially and due to lack of international cricket
at home. UAE has done heavy damage on domestic record.
Emotional countrymen who love to fantasize on past glory and
put unnecessary pressure on national players. Also being sworn
enemies of the people who run cricket does not help. Their
stubborn nature and mentality to bend their back backwards to
hurt pakistan doesn't help either. Although people from both sides
would love to see a bit more bilateral cricket between us. It would
help their ranking and help our monetary issues :D .

Sri Lanka - Still struggling to recover from the retirement of legendary trio
of Dilshan, Mahela and Sanga. Although many would argue
Sanga should have stayed a bit longer as he was in his prime
during retirement. Legends of the past are now a distant
memory as current crop of players do their best to get some
postive results for the team. Succeeding occasionally but still
disappointing on many occasions.

South Africa - Era of Graeme Smith was one of the best batting lineups for
Saffas who now struggle with the loss of worlds best- AB de
Velliers who has chosen the T20 life while having few key
players such as Hashim Amla, de Kock and Faf out of form.
The race quota has only increased uncertainties and added
to batting woes as race is given more importance than merit.

West Indies - The worst effected team from T20 revolution. Losing al key
players due to T20 league priorties took its toll. The people
also don't show the same passion for test cricket as they did
in the past. The carribean T20 league is more glitzy and
attractive. Unfortunately, we won't be seeing rush of local
supporters running into the ground, scaring the crap out of
players, after west indies wins test match against the likes of
Australia. Dominance of batsment like Viv Richards and Brian
Lara in test cricket for windies, unlikely to be seen again
although likes of Shai show some 'Hope'.

Zimbawe - Worst effected team from domestic politics. Mugabe killed
Zimbawe cricket. 1999-2003 probably golden era for the team
and now a distant memory. Only recently Zimbawe test team
survived cancellation of full membership from test cricket. Not
qualifying for next world cup took its toll. Although new ICC
funds and return of key players shower some hope.
 
Hi, guys. I made lot of effort and research for this thread so your insights- agreements and disagreements are most welcome :) .
 
India, England and New Zealand look the stable batting unit.

This has to be the worst era of batting talent
 
India, England and New Zealand look the stable batting unit.

This has to be the worst era of batting talent

Yes, also Bangladesh currently has the best batting lineup in their history imo. Thats why these four countries are not included in this list.
 
Yes, also Bangladesh currently has the best batting lineup in their history imo. Thats why these four countries are not included in this list.

But that doesn't say much. Any batsman who averages 25/30+ is an upgrade over their past. Easy really..
 
India, England and New Zealand look the stable batting unit.

This has to be the worst era of batting talent

Earlier it was Kohli or nothing.

Now it is Kohli/Pujara or nothing.

There is nothing stable about Indian batting yet.
 
But that doesn't say much. Any batsman who averages 25/30+ is an upgrade over their past. Easy really..

Just look at how Bangladeshi batsmen fared in New Zealand and how we fared. Even England got all out for about 44 odd last time they were there!
 
Just look at how Bangladeshi batsmen fared in New Zealand and how we fared. Even England got all out for about 44 odd last time they were there!

New Zealand pitches are very temperamental. On day one they behave like the greenest of minefields and the next day are the flattest of pitches. Bangladesh would have had a lucky day like that but still couldn't drag the match to 5th day. They're still very raw and not ready.
 
New Zealand pitches are very temperamental. On day one they behave like the greenest of minefields and the next day are the flattest of pitches. Bangladesh would have had a lucky day like that but still couldn't drag the match to 5th day. They're still very raw and not ready.

Bro, as much as I hate to say this, but Bangladesh currently has better test batting lineup than us. I think Bangladesh might even test India in their homeground. Their spinner Mehedy Hasan has been very impressive in spinning wickets too.
 
India, England and New Zealand look the stable batting unit.

This has to be the worst era of batting talent

But I would disagree on this part though. In test cricket, the likes of Steven Smith, Virat Kohli, Kane Williamson and Joe Root are absolute class to watch. I have also seen some magnificent innings from that young man Shai Hope from West Indies. A more realist statement might be that this is worst era of fast bowling.
 
T20 revolution and lack of priortisation for red ball cricket due to lack of money making opportunities and amount of effort and concentration required for test cricket is the main reason why these 6 mentioned countries have the worst batting line ups in their history.
 
Bro, as much as I hate to say this, but Bangladesh currently has better test batting lineup than us. I think Bangladesh might even test India in their homeground. Their spinner Mehedy Hasan has been very impressive in spinning wickets too.

Lol no. Bangladesh is still an ultra minnow. Their overrated Mehdi will be beaten into submission by both India and Pakistan.
 
India, England and New Zealand look the stable batting unit.

This has to be the worst era of batting talent

90s had 3 ATG, 2 ATG in making.

This era has will end with 4 ATG batsmen and probably few more in making.

This era is comparable to 90s.
 
Back
Top