What's new

England's tour of South Africa called off after a number of a positive COVID-19 tests

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
218,133
Cricket South Africa (CSA) and the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) have agreed to postpone the remaining matches in the current men’s ODI Series.

The decision was taken jointly by the two Boards to ensure the mental and physical health and welfare of players from both teams.

The CSA and ECB will now work together to determine when the three-match Series, which forms part of the ICC Cricket Men’s Super League, can take place in the future.

CSA Acting CEO, Kugandrie Govender said: “The concern over the mental health impact of recent events on all involved is not one that we as CSA or the ECB take lightly, and the decision to postpone the tour is the most responsible and reasonable course of action for us.

“I would like to thank the ECB for the continued positive relations, and we look forward to hosting the England men’s team in the near future.”

Tom Harrison, ECB Chief Executive Officer, said: “We have always maintained that the welfare of our players and management is paramount. We were concerned about the potential impact that recent developments might have on the wellbeing of the touring party, and so after consultation with Cricket South Africa, we have jointly made the decision to postpone the remaining matches in this Series, in the best interest of the players’ welfare.

“I would like to thank Cricket South Africa for their support and understanding on this matter and look forward to working with them to identify a time when we can return to play these fixtures in the future.”
 
It turns out that the England team practised in an off-limits non-Biosecure area of Newlands at their own risk.

The hotel staff were blameless - they hadn’t been home since 16 November.

It was England who breached the bubble.
 
It turns out that the England team practised in an off-limits non-Biosecure area of Newlands at their own risk.

The hotel staff were blameless - they hadn’t been home since 16 November.

It was England who breached the bubble.

Neglecting to mention the fact that CSA gave them permission to use those nets...
 
Neglecting to mention the fact that CSA gave them permission to use those nets...

They were not given permission but practised as the alternative was not to the standard they wanted.
Also hotel staff could have also contributed, in England it was same but we got lucky then.
 
They were not given permission but practised as the alternative was not to the standard they wanted.
Also hotel staff could have also contributed, in England it was same but we got lucky then.

The ECBs statement on the matter says they requested permission from CSA to use the facilities.
 
England's tour of South Africa has been abandoned after a number of a positive coronavirus tests.

A South Africa player and two members of hotel staff tested positive, while England say two members of their party returned "unconfirmed positive tests".

A three-match Twenty20 series was completed, but a three-match one-day series has been postponed.

A statement said the tour was called off to "ensure the mental and physical health and welfare of players".

England are still waiting for ratification of their positive tests, with the two people affected set to be tested again on Monday.

The results will not come before Tuesday at the earliest and the tourists will not leave South Africa before they have been received.

The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) and Cricket South Africa (CSA) said they will look to reschedule the ODIs, which form part of the International Cricket Council Super League.

ECB chief executive Tom Harrison said: "We have always maintained that the welfare of our players and management is paramount.

"We were concerned about the potential impact that recent developments might have on the wellbeing of the touring party, and so after consultation with Cricket South Africa, we have jointly made the decision to postpone the remaining matches in this series, in the best interest of the players' welfare."

Acting CSA chief executive Kugandrie Govender said: "The concern over the mental health impact of recent events on all involved is not one that we as CSA or the ECB take lightly, and the decision to postpone the tour is the most responsible and reasonable course of action for us."

England also released a statement rejecting any suggestion that their use of nets at Newlands in Cape Town was a factor in the outbreak, saying their decision to practice in the nets came as a result of "unacceptable" facilities.

England used the nets on Thursday, the day before Friday's first ODI, which was called off after a South Africa player tested positive for coronavirus.

The nets are next to a building site at the Kelvin Road End of the ground and were not designated for use during the series.

"On arrival at Newlands on 3 December, we advised the venue the three nets provided on the main pitch were not of a standard for conducive practice," read an England statement.

"We requested with Cricket South Africa we would like to use the practice nets and that we would create a security cordon to ensure the players and coaches could enter the facility safely, as done previously on 28 November.

"This was confirmed by England's security team, the team operations manager and the team doctor. We were satisfied with this outcome and we were able to practise in the net facility safely."

From positive tests to abandoned tour - how it all unfolded
As of Monday morning, the two unnamed members of the England party who tested positive for Covid-19 were self-isolating in their rooms at their hotel in Cape Town.

Whereas there was a time on Sunday when all players and staff were in isolation, those with negative tests were allowed to use the open spaces of the hotel's grounds on Monday.

The hotel forms part of the 'bubble' in which the series was being held, with players only leaving to train and play.

All three matches in the T20 series were unaffected, despite two South Africa players testing positive for coronavirus and another two being placed in isolation.

However, Friday's first one-day international was postponed when it emerged an unnamed South Africa player had returned a positive test, with Sunday's game called off after the hotel staff tested positive.

Later on Sunday, England announced two members of their touring party had given positive tests.

At the time, England said a decision on the rest of the matches in the series would be taken after the positive tests had been independently ratified.

However, Monday's game was cancelled on Sunday, and the tour was abandoned on Monday.

This was England's first overseas trip since their tour of Sri Lanka was cut short in March because of the spread of the pandemic.

England were able to fulfil their entire home summer schedule by playing matches in a bio-secure environment at grounds in Manchester and Southampton.

They are due to tour Sri Lanka and India in the new year, with the squad for Sri Lanka departing the UK on 2 January.

https://www.bbc.com/sport/cricket/55209140
 
There were occasional but definitive racial and cultural undertones towards the Pakistani players on various social media outlets when it was reported that they had breached COVID regulations in NZ. We all know what was said and suggested without me needing to go into it.

And now look. Pakistan are all clear and it is England who are going home.

Will the English bear the brunt of 'embarassment and shame' in the same way that a supposed poorer nation like Pakistan will? Of course they won't.

Pakistan would have been hung out to dry had this happened to us. And that is really sad.
 
So it was England who messed up or South Africa? Who is at fault here?
 
They were not given permission but practised as the alternative was not to the standard they wanted.
Also hotel staff could have also contributed, in England it was same but we got lucky then.

How can you catch COVID from using some nets?
 
So england breached the bubble Hitthestumps is right

If this was pakistan they wouldve been slaughtered in the media and by the home board like they have in Nz
 
I’m trying to make sense of this...

South Africa prepared a covid secure training facility for England, but England did not want this facility as it did not meet their training requirements.

Hence England were offered another training facility in Newlands and this was not covid approved by CSA...

So who is at fault here?
 
So SA are scheduled to tour Pakistan in January. I wouldn’t be surprised if CSA look to use this window to reschedule its home fixtures against England.
 
This was a misunderstanding by both boards. No point in blaming either of them.
 
This was a misunderstanding by both boards. No point in blaming either of them.

Fact is that this is a mess up of gigantic proportions.

Players are angry
Fans are angry
and CSA are looking like idiots that they couldnt arrange a simple bio-secure environment.
 
I’m trying to make sense of this...

South Africa prepared a covid secure training facility for England, but England did not want this facility as it did not meet their training requirements.

Hence England were offered another training facility in Newlands and this was not covid approved by CSA...

So who is at fault here?

Was this facility not in the same ground? How does using diffferent nets suddenly make you catch covid?Makes no sense..

Looks like some of hte hotel staff have sneaked out and caught the disease imo.

England can hardly talk themselves- Joffra archer did the same and wasnt punished
 
Apart from self-hating Pakistanis, England (UK) is the laughing stock of the world when it comes to handling Covid. We (UK) have one of the highest death rates and despite this have broken Covid guidelines in 3 separate sporting occasions. One was the football team, then Jofra and now this.

Despite this, self hating Pakistanis will call their players all the names under the sun, despite thankfully having a good record in their sporting tours so far.
 
England's one-day international series in South Africa has been postponed on medical grounds after a series of coronavirus cases.

The first ODI was scheduled to take place on Friday but was postponed after a South Africa player tested positive. The teams tried again on Sunday but the match was abandoned due to two members of staff at the England hotel testing positive for Covid-19, with the tourists also announcing two unconfirmed positive tests among their party later in the day.

While England are still waiting for the results of those tests to be confirmed, Cricket South Africa and the England and Wales Cricket Board have made the decision to call off the series and try to rearrange it at a later date.

Sky Sports pundits and former England captains Nasser Hussain and Mike Atherton gave their views on the postponement and the impact it could have on international cricket as the pandemic continues...

Nasser Hussain

It's obviously a massive, massive shame. When you think of the amount of money, effort, and time to put up that secure bubble - well, it doesn't seem quite so secure now.

Everything that had to be put in place to get a tour like this on in Covid times and the players hanging around waiting to play, everyone at home waiting, everyone in South African cricket waiting with the money that they're going to lose through broadcast rights, it's a huge shame.

But as the ECB has always said, they will put the wellbeing and the health of their players at the forefront. They will not risk that and if the bubble has been breached, then they will not risk a single player's health or more importantly, taking that home to England and risking other people's health. So it's probably the right thing.

There is a little part of me that says those other countries did it for us - Pakistan came over when we were at the height of our risk of Covid infections, and there is a little bit of me saying we should have done that for CSA as well because they'll be hit hard by this setback.

We've not heard anything about those (unconfirmed positive) tests at all. If they do come back negative, then the players and the ECB might think, 'well, let's get out while everyone is safe and no-one does have Covid', as opposed to hanging around for two or three days and risk one person picking it up.

If one person picks it up and tests positive, then they have to stay 10 days or others take it home, so that may be why they're doing it that way.

Everyone (in world cricket) will start looking at their Covid protocols, and their bio-secure protocols. It's a bit of give and take really, because if you make it so stringent as it was in the summer in England with the Ageas Bowl and Old Trafford, then you start getting concerned about the mental wellbeing and health of the cricketers. They're on top of them all the time; a few of them really struggled with that.

What they've done out here is that they've been a little bit more accommodating and said to players that they can go out, but they must make sure they travel only with people who are in the bubble. You can go out and play golf but come straight back and you're not compromising anything.

They've tried to look after their players' mental wellbeing and that may have backfired a little bit. You're always trying to get that balance between making a bubble so stringent that Covid cannot, or should not, get in but then have the players saying 'I'm not sure I can do this for much longer'. We've already had Tom Curran and Tom Banton pull out of the Big Bash so there are a lot of issues.

A lot of those players would have had a lot of bubbles beforehand, whether it be in the summer with England or the IPL or they have bubbles to come with Big Bash or in Sri Lanka. They would have had this window to either sit in quarantine in Australia or a window of getting home and seeing family and having a bit of time of not passing Covid tests, not having everything on top of you.

I think it was the final straw when that bubble was breached - the players must have gone "enough". The ECB and CSA are absolutely right to look after the mental wellbeing of their players. It's the timing. If this bubble breakdown had happened right at the start of the tour, they could have fixed it and the players could have had a week of doing nothing and then carried on.

The last thing any of those players want is to pick up Covid from a bubble that has been breached and take that home or take it to Australia - that's their worst-case scenario.

There is no good time to get Covid but getting it now and taking it back home to relatives is an absolute nightmare. They weren't willing to risk it. It probably wouldn't have happened but in the back of their hotel room, they were probably thinking 'can we get out now please?'

Mike Atherton

(The England players) have lost confidence in the security of the arrangements and the protocols designed to keep the hotel virus-free. I'm sure they've become increasingly concerned. South Africa's chief medical officer was fairly up front when he said they don't know how the bubble had been breached and that England were concerned, and right to be concerned.

The only thing is that we were waiting for these Covid results, these two unconfirmed positive cases. If they come back negative, then people will think that England have slightly jumped the gun. But it is clearly the players pushing this and they've lost confidence in South Africa to keep that area at the vineyard Covid-free.

If the tests come back positive, then the two have to stay behind but not only that, you also have a frantic search to find out who was in their vicinity, which I think is defined as within two metres for 15 minutes indoors.

In a bubble and in a team environment, you'd think that would include quite a lot of players. So that was always the fear, that these players who have got a short window of bubble-free life - given that Sri Lanka is coming, India, the IPL too - that then would be curtailed because they'd have to stay here for an extra amount of time.

Atherton and Mark Butcher discuss a remarkable - and completely unique - English summer of cricket
You have to throw things forward. We hope that the vaccine gets life back to normal from Easter but if it doesn't and England have to go through this situation again next summer of creating bio-secure environments for their cricketers, they won't want the precedent set where it is easy for the players not to fulfil the fixtures, so we will have to wait and see. But you can imagine things getting very messy as we come out of this situation.

We always felt that today was going to be a waiting day, to wait for the verification of those two tests that were sent away and then the players were tested again. I would like to wait and see what those tests say but if they were positive - and we'll find out in due course - I find it very difficult to see how the tour could go on and I said that right from the outset.

You've then got this situation where you're leaving players behind, and other players may have to stay. But if those tests are negative, then that is a wholly different situation and you feel there is more of a chance that those games could have and should have gone ahead.


https://www.skysports.com/cricket/n...ds-odi-series-in-south-africa-being-postponed
 
This is a huge car crash of a tour and that's beyond any doubt, no matter what excuses people come up with. Even the statement seems like a complete cop out. The tour wasn't abandoned for "mental health" reasons! Thats a shambolic excuse. It was abandoned because either England broke the Covid Bubble or the Saffers didn't set up one up correctly and that is the fact of the matter. No sugar coating needed.
 
This was a misunderstanding by both boards. No point in blaming either of them.

Someone breached the bubble and CSA dont have a clue what has happened. Where is the misunderstanding? Also, England are trying to run home before they have to stay back and quarantine for 10 more days, they could possible be brining false positives back into England!
 
Someone breached the bubble and CSA dont have a clue what has happened. Where is the misunderstanding? Also, England are trying to run home before they have to stay back and quarantine for 10 more days, they could possible be brining false positives back into England!

^ Muralidharan at the peak of his powers on a 5th day last session Galle pitch wouldn't be able to spin as much as this "misunderstanding" post tbh.

An unfortunate set of events overall though but the way this South African board is run, I have no sympathy for them.
 
I dont understand. If England or South Africa mess up, it is a misunderstanding and the boards should not be criticised. But if Pakistan mess up, they are undeserving of the privilege to be in New Zealand. Surely they also have been victims of a misunderstanding?
 
Last edited:
I think this incident will expose the vast hypocrisy and double standards that Pakistan had to face, often from Pakistanis themselves. The main concern brought up with NZ making public statements about deporting Pakistan and how much it is a privilege to visit NZ is that could have been privately instead of making a public scene out of it. And now in this case, there were no public mockery or statements made by SA. This is how it should be dealt with, and how NZ should have dealt with the situation.
 
Someone breached the bubble and CSA dont have a clue what has happened. Where is the misunderstanding? Also, England are trying to run home before they have to stay back and quarantine for 10 more days, they could possible be brining false positives back into England!

You can't expect him to apply equal standards when it comes to anything Pakistan. There will always be a reason why anything to do with Pakistan is a complete unmitigated disaster.
 
Someone breached the bubble and CSA dont have a clue what has happened. Where is the misunderstanding? Also, England are trying to run home before they have to stay back and quarantine for 10 more days, they could possible be brining false positives back into England!

The misunderstanding happened because of the lack of communication between both boards. England thought that the other training facility was part of the bio-secure bubble but South Africa failed to incorporate it in spite of ECB informing them that they were not satisfied with the current training facility.

But what PCB did was far more ridiculous and the epitome of carelessness. Two days before the team boarded the flight towards their humiliation in New Zealand, Fakhar showed blatant COVID symptoms.

PCB isolated him alone and once he produced a negative result, they wrongly assumed that there was no possibility of a false negative result.

As a result, they sent the squad to New Zealand without isolating the other players who were exposed to Fakhar and without testing them again.

Fakhar transmitted the virus to several players in the squad and they tested positive when New Zealand tested them on their arrival.

When a person shows blatant COVID symptoms, the standard protocol is to not only isolate that person but to also isolate everyone who has been in contact with that person regardless of whether the test produces a negative or a positive result.

I repeat - this period of isolation is mandatory when you have COVID-like symptoms or when you have been in contact with someone with the said symptoms.

PCB should have isolated the entire squad instead of sending them to New Zealand two days after isolating Fakhar. Had they done that, they would have prevented the embarrassment and the spared the shame of New Zealand government threatening to throw them out.

You can expect minor slip ups like the one that happened in South Africa. However, what PCB did is something that no other board will do. If any South African or English or Australian or Indian player shows blatant COVID symptoms, you can guarantee that they will immediately isolated the entire squad instead of blindly trusting test results.
 
This was a misunderstanding by both boards. No point in blaming either of them.
Why is your parameter so different when you are judging non Pakistani boards?

ECB were plain stupid here, and so were CSA.
 
The misunderstanding happened because of the lack of communication between both boards. England thought that the other training facility was part of the bio-secure bubble but South Africa failed to incorporate it in spite of ECB informing them that they were not satisfied with the current training facility.

But what PCB did was far more ridiculous and the epitome of carelessness. Two days before the team boarded the flight towards their humiliation in New Zealand, Fakhar showed blatant COVID symptoms.

PCB isolated him alone and once he produced a negative result, they wrongly assumed that there was no possibility of a false negative result.

As a result, they sent the squad to New Zealand without isolating the other players who were exposed to Fakhar and without testing them again.

Fakhar transmitted the virus to several players in the squad and they tested positive when New Zealand tested them on their arrival.

When a person shows blatant COVID symptoms, the standard protocol is to not only isolate that person but to also isolate everyone who has been in contact with that person regardless of whether the test produces a negative or a positive result.

I repeat - this period of isolation is mandatory when you have COVID-like symptoms or when you have been in contact with someone with the said symptoms.

PCB should have isolated the entire squad instead of sending them to New Zealand two days after isolating Fakhar. Had they done that, they would have prevented the embarrassment and the spared the shame of New Zealand government threatening to throw them out.

You can expect minor slip ups like the one that happened in South Africa. However, what PCB did is something that no other board will do. If any South African or English or Australian or Indian player shows blatant COVID symptoms, you can guarantee that they will immediately isolated the entire squad instead of blindly trusting test results.

What a load of horse....

What proof do you have Fakhar had a false negative turn positive? The New Zealand board were fully aware of Fakhar‘s situation and they did not stop PCB from going ahead so they are equally to blame if that’s the case.

And what do you mean about a minor slip up? What exactly is a minor slip up? Sharing food with your friends/bubble or allowing an entire squad to train in a non secure bubble venue?????
 
Now where are the racists who are going to blame the English and their culture? It's funny how the narrative changes based off the color of your skin and heritage.
 
Two things.

Firstly, the England team has breached the bubble, there’s no getting away from the fact.

Secondly, those of us in the medical profession in Australia and New Zealand know exactly what this looks like. Late Covid.

In Australia and New Zealand we contact trace every case, so we know much more precisely how this condition is transmitted than our overwhelmed colleagues in the UK or USA who have no such luxury.

And two odd cases stick out.

An elderly woman in Cairns fell ill with Covid on 25 May. But the condition is generally only transmissible for less than ten days. Nobody had tested positive within 600 miles for seven weeks. And she had been a passenger on the notorious Ruby Princess cruise ten weeks earlier - the cruise that caused the first wave across Australia.

Similarly, the Americold cluster in New Zealand in mid-August has never been solved.

There appears to be a subgroup of people who have an incredibly slow and prolonged incubation period for Covid, similar to rabies or Bat Lyssavirus. The only alternative is that the Cairns lady’s husband brought it back from the cruise and it transmitted via multiple dogs or cats before she caught it ten weeks later.

I strongly suspect that the Cape Town cases are due to a player or hotel staff member being in the rare slow incubation group. We can look for who breached the bubble, but this will be a slow incubation case.
 
Now where are the racists who are going to blame the English and their culture? It's funny how the narrative changes based off the color of your skin and heritage.

It was a misunderstanding...
 
What a load of horse....

What proof do you have Fakhar had a false negative turn positive? The New Zealand board were fully aware of Fakhar‘s situation and they did not stop PCB from going ahead so they are equally to blame if that’s the case.

And what do you mean about a minor slip up? What exactly is a minor slip up? Sharing food with your friends/bubble or allowing an entire squad to train in a non secure bubble venue?????

It's like a completely opposite parallel universe for him. What should be a minor slip up is a complete humiliation for him, and what should be complete humiliation is a minor slip up.
 
The misunderstanding happened because of the lack of communication between both boards. England thought that the other training facility was part of the bio-secure bubble but South Africa failed to incorporate it in spite of ECB informing them that they were not satisfied with the current training facility.

But what PCB did was far more ridiculous and the epitome of carelessness. Two days before the team boarded the flight towards their humiliation in New Zealand, Fakhar showed blatant COVID symptoms.

PCB isolated him alone and once he produced a negative result, they wrongly assumed that there was no possibility of a false negative result.

As a result, they sent the squad to New Zealand without isolating the other players who were exposed to Fakhar and without testing them again.

Fakhar transmitted the virus to several players in the squad and they tested positive when New Zealand tested them on their arrival.

When a person shows blatant COVID symptoms, the standard protocol is to not only isolate that person but to also isolate everyone who has been in contact with that person regardless of whether the test produces a negative or a positive result.

I repeat - this period of isolation is mandatory when you have COVID-like symptoms or when you have been in contact with someone with the said symptoms.

PCB should have isolated the entire squad instead of sending them to New Zealand two days after isolating Fakhar. Had they done that, they would have prevented the embarrassment and the spared the shame of New Zealand government threatening to throw them out.

You can expect minor slip ups like the one that happened in South Africa. However, what PCB did is something that no other board will do. If any South African or English or Australian or Indian player shows blatant COVID symptoms, you can guarantee that they will immediately isolated the entire squad instead of blindly trusting test results.

If Pakistan had made that minor slip-up you would have broken your keyboard by now proving how humiliating it is and how Pakistan should be banned from Playing cricket.

I am not saying PCB is free of any blame in managing Pakistan traveling to NZ but you trying to prove this was a minor slip up just gives away how bias and ridiculous your rationale is
 
If Pakistan had made that minor slip-up you would have broken your keyboard by now proving how humiliating it is and how Pakistan should be banned from Playing cricket.

I am not saying PCB is free of any blame in managing Pakistan traveling to NZ but you trying to prove this was a minor slip up just gives away how bias and ridiculous your rationale is

This ‘minor slip up’ is of epic proportions! They have had to cancel 3 ODIs during a period where nearly everyone have found a way to host international cricket.

Just imagine the money CSA will lose especially in a period where they are on the brink of going down the same path as Zimbabwe! How can this slip up be so minor that the English players completely lost trust in Cricket South Africa’s management skills?
 
The misunderstanding happened because of the lack of communication between both boards. England thought that the other training facility was part of the bio-secure bubble but South Africa failed to incorporate it in spite of ECB informing them that they were not satisfied with the current training facility.

But what PCB did was far more ridiculous and the epitome of carelessness. Two days before the team boarded the flight towards their humiliation in New Zealand, Fakhar showed blatant COVID symptoms.

PCB isolated him alone and once he produced a negative result, they wrongly assumed that there was no possibility of a false negative result.

As a result, they sent the squad to New Zealand without isolating the other players who were exposed to Fakhar and without testing them again.

Fakhar transmitted the virus to several players in the squad and they tested positive when New Zealand tested them on their arrival.

When a person shows blatant COVID symptoms, the standard protocol is to not only isolate that person but to also isolate everyone who has been in contact with that person regardless of whether the test produces a negative or a positive result.

I repeat - this period of isolation is mandatory when you have COVID-like symptoms or when you have been in contact with someone with the said symptoms.

PCB should have isolated the entire squad instead of sending them to New Zealand two days after isolating Fakhar. Had they done that, they would have prevented the embarrassment and the spared the shame of New Zealand government threatening to throw them out.

You can expect minor slip ups like the one that happened in South Africa. However, what PCB did is something that no other board will do. If any South African or English or Australian or Indian player shows blatant COVID symptoms, you can guarantee that they will immediately isolated the entire squad instead of blindly trusting test results.


FZ had non specific symptoms but was COVID negative. To the best of my knowledge he has not tested positive and was playing in the QEA tournament. How can one assume that FZ was the source of transmission? How reliable was the testing prior to the departure? The players should have been quarantined for the desired duration ( 2 weeks) prior to departure to ensure that there was no infection . The players should have been tested on multiple occasions as per protocol. The travel should also have been secure. The travel may have been the source of the infections as there were multiple sites and sources of contamination. The reason NZ made such an issue is because they have been able to contain the virus on their shores because of preventative measures . They do not want COVID positive patients introducing the virus. I cannot blame them! Unfortunately, this is a failure of the PCB and their Medical Consultants.
 
It was very, very ambitious to try and play a series in a country where there are 3000. 4000, 5000 cases per day. The levels around & risk are so high.

Oz & NZ have single figure cases numbers & it is still hard to achieve.

CSA have been a bit of a basket case for a while now- mass resignations, govt interference, corruption issues. A board that resigned en mass just two months ago does not instill confidence. The English attitude to covid safety is reflected in what is happening in England right now. It was a toxic combination.
 
MELBOURNE, Dec 8 (Reuters) - Cricket Australia are still planning for the tour of South Africa to go ahead in February but are monitoring the health situation after a insecurity failure in the country forced the postponement of England’s one-day international series.

England and South Africa’s cricket boards called off the series after the players were subjected to a number of COVID-19 scares inside the teams’ biosecure bubbles in Cape Town.

The breaches have cast doubt on South Africa’s ability to host touring teams, including Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Australia who are all set to play there in coming months.

Australia are scheduled to play three tests in South Africa in February but have yet to fix dates with South African authorities.

“The tour of South Africa is part of the World Test Championship and the Future Tour Program,” a CA spokesman said on Tuesday. “We will continue to plan for the tour and monitor the biosecurity situation.”

South Africa has recorded more than 800,000 coronavirus infections and more than 21,000 deaths related to COVID-19, the most in Africa.

International tours have gone ahead with players confined to biosecure hubs since elite cricket resumed mid-year after a months-long shutdown due to COVID-19.

England successfully hosted Australia, Pakistan and West Indies from July-September, while India’s tour of Australia has proceeded without incident so far.

In New Zealand, eight members of Pakistan’s 53-person touring party tested positive for COVID-19 while in quarantine but the team was cleared to leave their managed facility in Christchurch on Tuesday after no positive results from a fifth round of testing.

https://www.reuters.com/article/cri...urity-situation-in-south-africa-idINL4N2IO074
 
The misunderstanding happened because of the lack of communication between both boards. England thought that the other training facility was part of the bio-secure bubble but South Africa failed to incorporate it in spite of ECB informing them that they were not satisfied with the current training facility.

But what PCB did was far more ridiculous and the epitome of carelessness. Two days before the team boarded the flight towards their humiliation in New Zealand, Fakhar showed blatant COVID symptoms.

PCB isolated him alone and once he produced a negative result, they wrongly assumed that there was no possibility of a false negative result.

As a result, they sent the squad to New Zealand without isolating the other players who were exposed to Fakhar and without testing them again.

Fakhar transmitted the virus to several players in the squad and they tested positive when New Zealand tested them on their arrival.

When a person shows blatant COVID symptoms, the standard protocol is to not only isolate that person but to also isolate everyone who has been in contact with that person regardless of whether the test produces a negative or a positive result.

I repeat - this period of isolation is mandatory when you have COVID-like symptoms or when you have been in contact with someone with the said symptoms.

PCB should have isolated the entire squad instead of sending them to New Zealand two days after isolating Fakhar. Had they done that, they would have prevented the embarrassment and the spared the shame of New Zealand government threatening to throw them out.

You can expect minor slip ups like the one that happened in South Africa. However, what PCB did is something that no other board will do. If any South African or English or Australian or Indian player shows blatant COVID symptoms, you can guarantee that they will immediately isolated the entire squad instead of blindly trusting test results.

Based on your explanation, looks like both boards displayed massive incompetence - a simple phone call would have been good enough, no?

If a corporate entity does it, heads would surely roll.

Lack of communication is just the worst thing people in positions of responsibility should do - because it is so avoidable with little common sense.
 
[MENTION=131701]Mamoon[/MENTION] where is your consistent attacks on board management/directors this time? Where is your racist remarks about culture and incompetence this time?
 
Would NZ dare use similar words for the English team, if it was England and not pakistanis.
 
Can’t see the hypocrite anywhere guys? Not sure where he has gone missing? Can anyone find him?
 
[MENTION=131701]Mamoon[/MENTION] where is your consistent attacks on board management/directors this time? Where is your racist remarks about culture and incompetence this time?

I have already explained why it is not a valid comparison. Do you want to force me to agree with you or what?
 
I have already explained why it is not a valid comparison. Do you want to force me to agree with you or what?

I want you to admit that you are a hypocrite with extreme double standards.
 
I want you to admit that you are a hypocrite with extreme double standards.

If that is what you feel about me I do not have a problem. I do not decide how you perceive me - that is your call not mine.
 
Don’t waste your time on this clown. He will always find a way to make a fool out of himself.

No if he can waste time by consistently trolling Pakistani fans and writing highly obscene, racist and offensive stuff about the team or the country they affiliate with, then he deserves to be called out crucified when his hypocrisy is exposed.
 
No if he can waste time by consistently trolling Pakistani fans and writing highly obscene, racist and offensive stuff about the team or the country they affiliate with, then he deserves to be called out crucified when his hypocrisy is exposed.
He’s done it so many times it’s old news. I’ve gotten bored of his predictable trolls. He’s run out of ideas it seems.
 
*Official Statement - Issued by ECB Chief Medical Officer Professor Nick Peirce*

Following the independent ratification of the two unconfirmed positive COVID-19 tests from the England camp in South Africa, the England and Wales Cricket Board can confirm that, following further testing and analysis, in the opinion of the independent virologists based in Cape Town and London, the two individuals are not infected, and do not pose any risk of passing on the infection to the rest of the party.

As such, the advice is they are now free to join the rest of the group and are no longer self-isolating.

The England party, returning to the UK, will depart Cape Town on Thursday morning.
 
I’m trying to make sense of this...

South Africa prepared a covid secure training facility for England, but England did not want this facility as it did not meet their training requirements.

Hence England were offered another training facility in Newlands and this was not covid approved by CSA...

So who is at fault here?

Defonitely england
 
Defonitely england

I think they are both at fault here. CSA should not have been this weak with their covid secure bubbles and protocols. Let these poms cry as much as they want. Nobody forced them to stay in a bubble for 6 weeks in the IPL when they were picking up paid holiday cash!
 
Would NZ dare use similar words for the English team, if it was England and not pakistanis.
You're confusing NZC and the NZ government - NZ government wouldn't give damn and would rightfully blast them for not being able to follow rules and warn them.

NZ government wouldn't care if the series is cancelled because they do not want COVID back in the community.
 
As i see its completely CSA’s fault. Their bio-secure environment wasn’t so secure after all- they had 3 positives in 10 days. An article in cricinfo mentioned that CSA was pretty easy-going with the covid protocols - SA players were having barbecue party & stuff as soon as they came together & soon they had a positive case from someone attending that party. The third positive player was found roaming the hotel after his positive tests came in. And a couple of hotel staff were found positive too.

To top it all, the SA authorities tried to pin the blame on the English players. Clearly the players & ECB were not amused nor confident that SA was in a position to maintain the bio-bubble & nobody should blame them for that!

This doesnt sound good for CSA, coming on the heels of yet another board rebellion.. hope the Australians are not spooked by this!
 
Hang on just a cotton pickin' minute.

https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/...cleared-fly-home-confirmation-false-positives

So it seems that the England's team folks who tested positive were not in fact positive (false positive).

England have announced that the two suspected cases of Covid-19 within their touring party were false positives, following independent ratification of the tests.

Which means that one of the core reasons for cancellation was in fact without foundation.

Yet the tour stands cancelled because of concerns about the bubble.

Giles told British newspapers in Cape Town last night that the call had been taken in recognition of the fact that the squad felt distracted and had been unsettled by news of the initial positive results.

And the argument on PP continue sui generis as if none of the above happened.

You couldn't make this stuff up. :))) :)))
 
I think they are both at fault here. CSA should not have been this weak with their covid secure bubbles and protocols. Let these poms cry as much as they want. Nobody forced them to stay in a bubble for 6 weeks in the IPL when they were picking up paid holiday cash!

Depends if they gave them secured buble were they can practise and they refused then the responsbility should be on england
 
Back
Top