What's new

[EXCLUSIVE] "You cannot play a world cup with a non-regular wicketkeeper": Atiq-Uz-Zaman

The Bald Eagle

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Nov 25, 2023
Runs
24,089
In this exclusive interview, former Pakistan wicketkeeper and current head coach of Germany Cricket, Atiq-uz-Zaman, provides a candid assessment of Pakistan's turbulent 2025 season and the road ahead. Atiq discusses the critical need for stability, the risky selection policy regarding wicketkeepers, his data-driven selection model implemented in Germany, and Pakistan's chances at the upcoming T20 World Cup.

Key Revelations from Atiq-uz-Zaman​

  • Unpredictable Pakistan: "Pakistan team is a very unpredictable side. You never know which team will turn up."Atiq highlighted the historical inconsistency of the national team, noting that they can defeat the world’s best on one day and lose to an associate nation the next. This lack of stability, he argues, stems from a fluctuating team environment.
  • Wicketkeeper Warning: "You cannot play a World Cup with a non-regular wicketkeeper."Drawing from his own experience as a specialist keeper, Atiq emphasized that "makeshift" options are a recipe for disaster in high-pressure tournaments. He believes that a dropped catch or a missed stumping from a part-timer can shift the momentum of an entire World Cup campaign.
  • Selection System Critique: "I have not understood the criteria of selection, to be honest" He expressed frustration over the "musical chairs" within the selection committee. Atiq pointed out that players are often picked or dropped without clear communication regarding their performance metrics, leading to confusion for both fans and the athletes themselves.
  • Accountability Issue: "The problem with Pakistan cricket: there is no accountability."Atiq noted that while players are frequently scapegoated for losses, the board members and coaches responsible for strategy and selection rarely face consequences. He argued that until the management is held to the same standards as the players, the cycle of failure will continue.
  • The Rizwan Argument: "Rizwan is my first choice. He offers quality behind the stumps and leadership."For Atiq, Mohammad Rizwan isn't just a keeper-batsman; he is the "engine room" of the team. He praised Rizwan's work ethic and his ability to read the game, suggesting that his presence provides a psychological safety net for the bowlers.
  • Holistic Selection Model: "Create a holistic selection process. Players should go through it and create a point system."Explaining his objective method for Germany, Atiq detailed a data-driven approach. Instead of relying on "gut feeling," he advocates for a system where technical proficiency, fitness levels, and match impact are assigned points, ensuring that the most deserving players are selected based on merit rather than favoritism.
Watch the lastest interview with Saj below:

 
Every country in the world plays with make shifts..Rahul ans Butler are prime examples that is tey way forward and also picking bowlers who can bat because every good bowlers will get smacked in shorter format anyways. In red ball i completely agree need a specialist keepers n bowlers
 
In a t20 world cup you can play with a makeshift keeper who is capable of scoring some fast runs in a longer format you need a proper keeper
 
How can we talk about keepers when PCB has a habit of messing up developing guys with serious potential?

E.g Shawaiz Irfan comes to mind. He showed real promise in the PJL—Rashid Latif even praised his keeping technique. Picked by Lahore as an emerging player, he got just one chance, faltered under pressure, and then vanished. Since then, only two FC games in October 2023, and nothing for nearly three years. That’s the reality of our system.
 
while a poorly prepared makeshift keeper can hurt a campaign, the real issue isn’t whether the keeper is “regular”. It’s whether the player is well-trained, match-ready, and trusted.
 
You can get away with it in T20 if the makeshift makes up for any errors by scoring runs. No point in playing a makeshift keeper if he is going to sky one to mid off after scoring 7 off 11 though..
 
Every country in the world plays with make shifts..Rahul ans Butler are prime examples that is tey way forward and also picking bowlers who can bat because every good bowlers will get smacked in shorter format anyways. In red ball i completely agree need a specialist keepers n bowlers
Exactly.. Goes to show how rotten these old minds are , resisting to adapt the new and embrace the current game of cricket played with the standards of this era.. This is why Pak shouldnt take the old minds as coaches in the dressing room, im not saying about old people... A guy who wants his team to follow the old rules and standards of cricket and be happy with that but win no games or tournaments...

Look at the successful teams they all dont have specialist keepers , they take hard hitters who can keep for 20 overs... with 8 or 12 overs of spin or pace at the max... They play the moderan day game and are successful..
 
  • The Rizwan Argument: "Rizwan is my first choice. He offers quality behind the stumps and leadership."For Atiq, Mohammad Rizwan isn't just a keeper-batsman; he is the "engine room" of the team. He praised Rizwan's work ethic and his ability to read the game, suggesting that his presence provides a psychological safety net for the bowlers.
Then why did he lose the Asia cup playing slow against SRL , he played slow and lost an easy target of 115 against India in the last WT20 , recently got embarassed in BBL for playing slow by getting retired out :ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:

When he is hogging on to that middle order spot of no.4 in ODIs for a very long time , show his performances in WC or ICC champions trophy or any serious tournament where he took on the strong bowling attack (i.e not a C or Z team of bowling line up) and won matches for Pak...I agree Pak doesnt have Gilchrist or Dhoni waiting in the backyard but that doesnt justify the intent of Rizwan with the bat,
 
In this exclusive interview, former Pakistan wicketkeeper and current head coach of Germany Cricket, Atiq-uz-Zaman, provides a candid assessment of Pakistan's turbulent 2025 season and the road ahead. Atiq discusses the critical need for stability, the risky selection policy regarding wicketkeepers, his data-driven selection model implemented in Germany, and Pakistan's chances at the upcoming T20 World Cup.

Key Revelations from Atiq-uz-Zaman​

  • Wicketkeeper Warning: "You cannot play a World Cup with a non-regular wicketkeeper."Drawing from his own experience as a specialist keeper, Atiq emphasized that "makeshift" options are a recipe for disaster in high-pressure tournaments. He believes that a dropped catch or a missed stumping from a part-timer can shift the momentum of an entire World Cup campaign.
Watch the lastest interview with Saj below:

Ridiculous argument!

Every major team has experimented and succeeded with a makeshift keeper, it all depends on what else does the makeshift keeper bring to the table!
 
I am waiting for Pak to have our first ATG material all-format keeper. Every team other than us has unearthed keepers who are there but we just haven't that. Just look at the names below.

Gilchrist. Wade. Paine. Carrey.
Boucher. AB. De Kock. Klassen.
Sangakkara.
Hope.
Bairstow. Prior. Butler.
MS. Rahul.
McCullum.
Mushfiq.

Gilchrist literally changed the way Australia played cricket. AB is probably one of the greatest all-format players to ever step into the cricketing field. Even tier-2 teams like WI and BD have keepers who are really good.

Then we have Pakistan where keepers are just not there. The Akmal family was okay to start but then became a proper disease for the team. Sarfraz while handy never really had the IT factor & Rizwan has gone from okay to mediocre to eventually terrible. No hate on Rizwan but I hope he gets his mojo back because the other options Usman, Azam, Nafay, Haris, etc. are just not up to the standard of international cricket. Even the U19 keepers of the teams are so good while ours is so mediocre.
 
Usman Khan is going to be PCT's first choice wicket-keeper hopefully he doesn't blew it for the side with typical fumbles associated with part time keepers.
 
Back
Top