Got to give Kamran Akmal credit, he shouldn't be in the team but unlike Umar he has a work ethic

[shaz619]

Kamran has a love hate relationship with Pakistan fans, he has played some of the greatest knocks ever in the country's history but has also been a part of some the biggest debacles ever seen on the cricket pitch.

And now his time has come and gone but unlike his bro he doesn't feel sorry for himself, overly blame others and lack accountability for his performances; time and time again he works very hard, dusts himself off and scores runs in domestic cricket to give himself the best possible chance to get selected.

Umar Akmal on the other hand blames everyone else and their dog but himself, it's never Umar's fault on any remote level, it's not his fault that he's fat, it's not his fault that he never uses his brain and it's never his fault that he doesn't demand respect amongst his colleagues across a wide range of teams. Quiet frankly he lacks a work ethic and he only got himself to blame when others point in his direction when the results don't go their way, he's an extremely toxic individual and he might be one man, but you only need a little poison to take someone out and that's what Umar Akmal has been, POISON for the Lahore Qalanders.

 

[Raja Sab]

If I were to chose to pick on Akmal that would play for Pakistan before Akmals were born, I would pick Kamran Akmal. Despite knowing he would drop crucial catches, miss certain run outs and be seen with bookies all over the world

why ? because he's the only Akmal that has a mature brain, doesn't behave like he's some big shot, has been humble and from what I've heard a really nice person. Yes he dropped those chances but he's not his younger brother Umar

 

[shaz619]

If I were to chose to pick on Akmal that would play for Pakistan before Akmals were born, I would pick Kamran Akmal. Despite knowing he would drop crucial catches, miss certain run outs and be seen with bookies all over the world

why ? because he's the only Akmal that has a mature brain, doesn't behave like he's some big shot, has been humble and from what I've heard a really nice person. Yes he dropped those chances but he's not his younger brother Umar

He is certainly a lot more mature, I think mentally Umar is still a child

 

[Savak]

Kamran has played a lot more meaningful and important knocks for Pakistan compared to Akmal. It is sad that he took his place in the team for granted and stopped working hard, put on weight, his wicketkeeping declined to the point where he became a complete liability for the team

 

[shaz619]

Kamran has played a lot more meaningful and important knocks for Pakistan compared to Akmal. It is sad that he took his place in the team for granted and stopped working hard, put on weight, his wicketkeeping declined to the point where he became a complete liability for the team

It all ended like that for him, but he's still busting his behind in domestic cricket and working hard after being dropped, Umar on the other hand has been behaving like a kid

 

[ads101]

lol they are the same. both very talented (umar more so), but underachievers and not dedicated enough. kamran hasnt bothered to lose weight or really improve his fielding skills even now. At least umar at one stage was fit and one of our best fielders.

Umar I feel will be similar to Kamran at his age too. Domestic is much easier often for experienced international players as its a step down from what they’re used to. Why its important to give international experience to young/upcoming players in t20s/ dead rubber matches, it will show them whats required at international level and the holes in their game. Our best talent really should be combining the use of domestics and the off international games to improve not just one or the other.

 

[Savak]

It all ended like that for him, but he's still busting his behind in domestic cricket and working hard after being dropped, Umar on the other hand has been behaving like a kid

Nah Umar Akmal just stopped caring about his cricket a long while ago. Besides i don't really think he was ever that talented to begin with.

 

[ads101]

to add to kamran never showed this work ethic even to his batting until the end of his career. kamran was pretty mediocre even in domestic until he got dropped for good rather than for the odd series or teo before the the recoil. dropping him for a long time is whag he needed, but too late now.

 

[shaz619]

to add to kamran never showed this work ethic even to his batting until the end of his career. kamran was pretty mediocre even in domestic until he got dropped for good rather than for the odd series or teo before the the recoil. dropping him for a long time is whag he needed, but too late now.

The comparison was mostly made with regards to how the two have responded / behaved after being dropped, Kamran took it on the chin may have said a few words here and there but he worked hard and has been scoring runs at the domestic level, he's obviously past his prime now but his attitude towards rejection has been a lot better then Umar Akmals

 

[shaz619]

Nah Umar Akmal just stopped caring about his cricket a long while ago. Besides i don't really think he was ever that talented to begin with.

You don't just stop caring about something, it's like waking up one morning and saying you know what wifey? I don't love you anymore, it's a bit weird isn't it. Umar Akmal suffers from the worst kind of victim mentality, am sure the passion and love for cricket is still there but he's just not equipped mentally to grind it out, take a long hard look in the mirror and prove your doubters wrong through your shear will, hard work and never say die attitude

 

[Big A]

Umar Akmal would never have made his debut for Pakistan if it wasn't for his older brother. Leech.

 

[Saj]

There is a difference in attitude from the brothers.

One wants to work hard, the other thinks he's a superstar and doesn't need to work hard.

 

[shaz619]

There is a difference in attitude from the brothers.

One wants to work hard, the other thinks he's a superstar and doesn't need to work hard.

Nicely summarised

 

[Rishta Aunty]

Kamran's dedication to batting was never in question; his problem was his dedication to his keeping which is what finally forced his out of the team. Makes me wonder what might have been. I saw his Karachi knock live, and I can say without doubt it was the best Pakistani innings I have watched.

 

[Rana]

He has work ethic but he has a big mouth ethic the way Umar has.

Always giving interviews and hinting towards being selected or deserving a chance.

 

[Zaz]

There is a difference in attitude from the brothers.

One wants to work hard, the other thinks he's a superstar and doesn't need to work hard.

Saj the only real difference is kami has said the right things in the media and made runs in domestics

He still hasnt worked on or improved his weight or his fielding

However its a lot better than umar who has nothing but a long list of excuses and people other than himself to blame

 

[msb314]

Kammy has always been a good LOI batsman but his shoddy wicket keeping has led to his downfall.

I for one am extremely pleased he is doing well in the PSL and still has the passion for the game like he did back in 2005-2009.
Hope he earns a recall soon for the ODI and T20 squads.

 

[Hasan123]

Kamran certainly played more impactful knocks than his brother that's for sure.

 

[shane]

What ever happened to Adnan Akmal? He seemed to be the best of a very bad bunch.

 

[Deewana Mastana]

The Akmals - you can't hate them and you can't love them.

 

[Suleiman]

What ever happened to Adnan Akmal? He seemed to be the best of a very bad bunch.

The lad couldn’t hold a bat if his life depended on it

 

[Josh]

People gave Umar super star and talented status and now he think he is talented and naturally gifted so he doesn't need to work hard.

 

[backfootpunch]

Good post from the OP. He is past his sell by date to be considered for internationals but one innings that as a Pakistan fan I'll always cherish was that memorable ton against India in Karachi 06 in very difficult batting conditions when the team was in match losing situation following Pathan's opening over hat trick.

 

[shane]

The lad couldn’t hold a bat if his life depended on it

My point stands.

 

[B_Positive]

Kamran should be given a run again in national team. He might turn up like Karthik.

 

[NauV]

You make a good point. Primarily from a batting stand point, Kamran Akmal has proved his worth time and again (in domestic cricket). He has gone back and worked hard and churned out the runs. He was the batsman of the tournament last PSL and is up there this time around as well. You can just see in his performances.

When was the last time Umar Akmal did anything special even on the domestic circuit? I was a huge supporter of Umar Akmal until about 2 years ago, when almost the entire world had turned against him . . but honestly, I don't even think he should be any where near first class teams either for the poison he spreads not just on himself but those that are surrounded by him. . I fear for the talented, young and impressionable players that are around Umar Akmal . . There's nothing that's right about Umar Akmal unfortuntaely. and you can not live only based on 'talent' for 10 years!!

 

[hadi123]

Great work ethic today for his duck.

 

[Zaz]

Typical kamran gets a duck The same issues are there years later ie lack of strike rotation no consistency in scores

Hence why he avges in the 20s in limited overs cricket for pakistan