I think it depends on what sort of role Hafeez or anyone in PAK team is being given or has taken up upon himself,
If his role is to be a aggressive batsman to play more freely and to increase the scoring rate then we can judge him whether he is doing that or not,
In the last match he certainly did that but would he play the same role in every match? that is unknown
the only thing I understand is Babar is expected to play an anchor role and be there in the middle and occupy the crease and other players around him play aggressively and looks like this was the case in the 2nd T20 and Hafeez was very successful in that and was certainly looking like a match winning innings but the bowlers let it slip away
we might get a more clear picture whether Hafeez will continue to play aggressively in all situation or it depends on a particular situation ,
I think Hafeez should be given a role where he is allowed to be aggressive and not be like Babar who holds an end
he has played some nice aggressive innings in the past and if he can play such innings more consistently then he do deserves to be in the T20 WC squad.
I think Hafeez has a high strike rate anchor role similar to Babar. While Malik and Rizwan have low strike rate anchor roles.
Fakhar and Iftikhar have the roles to play as freely as possible at high strike rate.
The issue is that there are too few dashers like Fakhar and Iftikhar while Rizwan being a must have on the team means we must already keep a low strike rate anchor. This means no space for Malik.
Babar is a must have in the team and Hafeez is decent enough if Babar absolutely needs at least one senior to give him on-field advice.
That means you have 3 anchors in your batting lineup (Babar, Rizwan, and optionally Hafeez), and since Imad and Shadab can both bat, that means you have some depth as well which frees you up to play 3 dashers. Right now there are only 2 with Fakhar and Iftikhar.
Misbah’s anchor first policy results in the following team, with roles identified in parentheses:
1. Babar (140 SR anchor)
2. Fakhar (160 SR dasher)
3. Hafeez (140 SR anchor)
4. S Malik (120 SR anchor)
5. Iftikhar (160 SR dasher)
6. Shadab (???????????)
7. Rizwan (120 SR anchor)
8. Imad (150 SR dasher)
9. Amir
10. Shaheen
11. Rauf
Whereas a more balanced team might look like this:
1. Babar (140 SR anchor)
2. Fakhar (160 SR dasher)
3. Haider Ali (160 SR dasher)
4 Hafeez (140 SR anchor)
5. Iftikhar (160 SR dasher) / Khushdil (160 SR dasher)
6. Shadab (140 SR anchor)
7. Imad (150 SR dasher)
8. Rizwan (120 SR anchor, promote as needed)
9. Amir
10. Shaheen
11. Rauf