Has Naz Baloch's ouster finished the chances of a PTI revival in Sindh?

[coooolali]

Well to be honest, I m very disappointed with Naz Baloch leaving PTI. She was so well spoken and was someone who always supports her arguments with logic. There were expectations from PTI especially in Karachi to became a main party there but call it nikamapan of PTI Sindh Leadership they have become bad to worse in Sindh region in last 4 years. The ouster of Naz baloch has seriously dented their chances in Sindh. What more worse is PTI leadership is dismissing her ouster by merely calling her an ordinary loss for PTI which is far from true she was VC of PTI from Karachi region. The onus was on PTI karachi leadership to resolve her issues. On one hand PTI recruits corrupt people like Firdos Aashiq Awan and lose people who are devoted like Naz. Terribly disappointed since yesterday.
PTI Politics is finished? And if not how can PTI be revived for 2018 Elections? Discuss.

 

[King-Misbah]

Naz Baloch seemed like a good person so a loss for PTI. However, her not being in PTI will not dent PTI. PTI unfortunately has not focused much on Karachi. I believe PTI'S strategy is Punjab centric now as they realise that the power to Pakistan goes through Punjab. I dont really blame them taking this strategy to be honest.

Naz really needs to do some self analysis. How can you go from PTI to PPP and justify it by saying that PTI had changed now. We all know PPP record and what is stands for. Even if we agree with Naz's opinion, even then PPP is a lot worse.

To conclude, she wasn't holding any significant power as she wasn't an elected member. I also think that her family hold firm links with PPP so that would have been a factor too.

 

[Waseem]

Her father is PPP leader which may have something to do with her decision but quite shocking to be honest. Regardless of the fact that her departure will make no difference to PTI at all but not sure how someone can leave party after defending it couple of days ago and criticising her new party and it's entire leadership. I had never seen one word from her against PTI or in favour of PPP ever before.

Lastly, i am leaving a party because it doesn't spend as much time as it should in Sindh (fair enough) so i will join a party that i wholeheartedly believe is corrupt and incomptent and whose leadership spends no time in Pakistan let alone Sindh??? ZERO SENSE!

 

[srh]

Her father is PPP leader which may have something to do with her decision but quite shocking to be honest. Regardless of the fact that her departure will make no difference to PTI at all but not sure how someone can leave party after defending it couple of days ago and criticising her new party and it's entire leadership. I had never seen one word from her against PTI or in favour of PPP ever before.

Lastly, i am leaving a party because it doesn't spend as much time as it should in Sindh (fair enough) so i will join a party that i wholeheartedly believe is corrupt and incomptent and whose leadership spends no time in Pakistan let alone Sindh??? ZERO SENSE!

she basically switch from one corrupt party (PTI) to another corrupt party (PPP). May be she thinks that new leadership of PPP will not be as corrupt as existing leadership of PTI?

 

[King-Misbah]

she basically switch from one corrupt party (PTI) to another corrupt party (PPP). May be she thinks that new leadership of PPP will not be as corrupt as existing leadership of PTI?

Please highlight PTI corruption scams.

 

[WebGuru]

Naz had to delete a few hundred tweets against PPP,Bilawal and Zardari from his Twitter account yesterday )

Not any surprise because her whole family is in PPP so there was always a chance of her joining PPP because PPP is the most popular party of Sindh and Layari in Karachi. She is from Layari so she got more chance with PPP thn PTI.

 

[IAJ]

No matter what party, when someone leaves it the supporters/voters/members will allways say it isn't a big loss, good riddance bla bla...

 

[Bewal Express]

Please highlight PTI corruption scams.

He cant, but he will say it anyway.

 

[Asim_khan]

A bit of a shame, as from what little I'd seen of her, she made sense, but she's got her reasons.

Hopefully PTI put forward another decent female candidate to off set her departure.

 

[Slog]

She is a political nobody.

Has no worth in terms of standing

However her reservations regarding PTI activities in Sindh are correct

 

[Slog]

she basically switch from one corrupt party (PTI) to another corrupt party (PPP). May be she thinks that new leadership of PPP will not be as corrupt as existing leadership of PTI?

yes her final destination should be PML-N the party of Kings of Corruption

 

[Mian]

You know what's so funny? PTI is bashed when someone from other parties join them and bashed again when someone from their party leaves.

So basically a case of damn if you do damn if you don't for PTI

 

[Syed1]

You know what's so funny? PTI is bashed when someone from other parties join them and bashed again when someone from their party leaves.

So basically a case of damn if you do damn if you don't for PTI

As per this corrupt tola and their supporters all of Pakistan's ills are due to PTI and Imran Khan.

 

[Arham_PakFan]

She is a political nobody.

Has no worth in terms of standing

However her reservations regarding PTI activities in Sindh are correct

I quite agree.PTI needs to focus a bit more on Sindh,esp Karachi,where the elite and upper-middle classes largely support them.

 

[Syed1]

I quite agree.PTI needs to focus a bit more on Sindh,esp Karachi,where the elite and upper-middle classes largely support them.

Karachi they have support from elite class and upper middle class. That is why they win from Defense/Clifton and gave a run for the money in other affluent areas. Unfortunately majority of Karachi's population comprises of people belonging to the middle and lower income classes. These folks support MQM or PPP and that trend is likely to continue.

As for interior Sindh, nobody can beat PPP. Unless PTI manages to find someone with a Bhutto sirname.

 

[Arham_PakFan]

Karachi they have support from elite class and upper middle class. That is why they win from Defense/Clifton and gave a run for the money in other affluent areas. Unfortunately majority of Karachi's population comprises of people belonging to the middle and lower income classes. These folks support MQM or PPP and that trend is likely to continue.

As for interior Sindh, nobody can beat PPP. Unless PTI manages to find someone with a Bhutto sirname.

I have no idea why people continue to support PPP,they have been exposed as corrupt and ineffecient.Their era of government was one of the worst in our history.

I hate Altaf Hussain but I kind of understand MQM and the ideology (of their supporters),as flawed as it may be.They have a lot of Urdu-Speaking and Muhajirs voting for them as they have played the victim card.2018 will be a bit different though with the party split into 3.

 

[Black Zero]

You know what's so funny? PTI is bashed when someone from other parties join them and bashed again when someone from their party leaves.

So basically a case of damn if you do damn if you don't for PTI

And rightly so as PTI claims to be different from other parties and takes pride that it has some core principles etc.

 

[coooolali]

I agree with you mostly. This is good stategy by PTI to have focus on Punjab but in doing that they should not forget about other provinces say Sindh especially Karachi city where there is a possibility for them to get a good number of seats. PTI position is becoming weak in Karachi with each coming day.

 

[coooolali]

Forgot to mention [MENTION=142765]King-Misbah[/MENTION] in my above comment.

 

[coooolali]

Her father is PPP leader which may have something to do with her decision but quite shocking to be honest. Regardless of the fact that her departure will make no difference to PTI at all but not sure how someone can leave party after defending it couple of days ago and criticising her new party and it's entire leadership. I had never seen one word from her against PTI or in favour of PPP ever before.

Lastly, i am leaving a party because it doesn't spend as much time as it should in Sindh (fair enough) so i will join a party that i wholeheartedly believe is corrupt and incomptent and whose leadership spends no time in Pakistan let alone Sindh??? ZERO SENSE!

My comment was more towards deteriorating position of Pti in Karachi. No doubt Pti All Pakistan will totally be uneffected by her leaving Pti.

 

[coooolali]

Naz had to delete a few hundred tweets against PPP,Bilawal and Zardari from his Twitter account yesterday )

Not any surprise because her whole family is in PPP so there was always a chance of her joining PPP because PPP is the most popular party of Sindh and Layari in Karachi. She is from Layari so she got more chance with PPP thn PTI.

Haha she had to change her twitter handle as well.
PTI leadership should also focus on Karachi as well it will most likely get them some valuable seats in 2018 elections.

 

[corneredtiger85292]

Leaves PTI and goes to PPP ?

any sort of discussion regarding this topic ends before it starts when people see that.

Good luck with things after that decision ! LOL

 

[TOP SPINNER_01]

 

[farhan]

Karachi they have support from elite class and upper middle class. That is why they win from Defense/Clifton and gave a run for the money in other affluent areas. Unfortunately majority of Karachi's population comprises of people belonging to the middle and lower income classes. These folks support MQM or PPP and that trend is likely to continue.

As for interior Sindh, nobody can beat PPP. Unless PTI manages to find someone with a Bhutto sirname.

PTI needs to change their policies and the working style in karachi/sindh. If things remains the same in 2018, it will be difficult to retain the defense/clifton seat. I live in NA-250 and arif alvi and other elected mpa's have some bad repos here. Even in punjab colony area, many people have complaints about the non availability from their elected members. Only khurram sher zaman has some credibility in the area.

 

[Mian]

PTI needs to change their policies and the working style in karachi/sindh. If things remains the same in 2018, it will be difficult to retain the defense/clifton seat. I live in NA-250 and arif alvi and other elected mpa's have some bad repos here. Even in punjab colony area, many people have complaints about the non availability from their elected members. Only khurram sher zaman has some credibility in the area.

What about Samar?

 

[farhan]

What about Samar?

He is a educated guy and the husband of tv actress attiqa odhu, but in politics you need to be on the street with your workers and local population. Seems like too elitist for being a politician.