Animal urine fetishes
Can people obsessed with urine consumption discuss their issues in this thread properly.
Cow urine consumption is a well established practice among certain Hindus.
Recently I read sentiments by PP's scholar on Islam and expert in Hadith [MENTION=141520]troodon[/MENTION] mention that
I see what you are posting about cow urine in every post of yours. I know what Muslims drink. So don't act all clean when Muslims do the same with a different animal.
In another deleted post he also claimed that this practice is part of Muslim culture. I replied to his claim but the whole interaction was deleted.
We all know which of Muslim's favorite beverage he is referring to. No it's not the Lassi or Zam Zam water.
It's camel urine which he claims is part of Muslim culture and practiced by Muslims just like how cow urine is consumed by Hindu groups.
Now I may not be a practicing Muslim anymore but my lifestyle and culture is heavily influenced by Islamic upbringing and Muslim culture. When I hear about such exaggeratd claims about importance of this special beverage among Muslims and in Muslim culture I can't help but cringe.
There is indeed a narration of Prophet Muhammad where he told a group of travelers to consume camel urine mixed with camel milk to relieve them of their symptoms but that's about it. There are no Quran verses about this nor are there many other accounts of it being a regular practice of the Prophet or his companions.
It's most likely an Arab Bedouin tradition predating Islam. At best Islam tolerates the practice.
From my life and experience this practice is almost non-existent among Muslims.
I have been to countless Islamic sermons and heard about endless remedies promoted by Islamic scholars to help treat a disease and gain relief from pain. Most of them include many prayers and ridiculous amount of verses to be repeated for some arbitrary number of time and perhaps here and there consumption of certain herbs and fruits. In none so far I have come acorss advice to consume the special beverage.
I haven't even seen the most jahil of the jahil recommend this. Even the extremist groups like IS have not been seen promoting it and destroying hospitals and medicine in favor of this treatment.
This special beverage although tolerated in Islam is by no stretch of the imagination part of Muslim culture and is not a household item. No one in mosque is discussing the consumption of this beverage and most spend their whole lives without ever hearing about this practice.