What's new

Horror Of Guantanamo Revealed In Inmate Diary

Saj

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Jun 1, 2001
Runs
96,138
A diary written by a Guantanamo Bay prisoner has been published, revealing the mistreatment inflicted on inmates at the high-security jail.


It is remarkable that Mohamedou Ould Slahi managed to write his memoirs at all – and even more remarkable that the world is getting to read of his experiences.

Everything written by "gitmo" inmates is impounded as an official secret by the US Government.

The litany of mistreatment and "torture" Mr Slahi experienced at the hands of American authorities is both shocking and appalling, as you can see from this extract.

Most remarkable of all is how Mr Slahi is still in prison in Guantanamo, illegally and without charge, after 13 years in US custody – 12 of them within the detention camp.

He was born in Mauritania, West Africa, 35 years ago. At the age of 18, he won a scholarship to study electrical engineering in Germany.

As a young man, he spent a year or so in Afghanistan with the mujahideen, who were allies of the US at the time, fighting against the Soviet invasion.

He pledged his allegiance to al Qaeda in 1991 but claims he cut all ties with the group when he left a year later. The US insisted he had acted as a recruiter and supporter for the organisation in the years since then.

In 1992, he returned to Germany – subsequently working there, in Canada, and Mauritania. Following 9/11, he turned himself in to the Mauritanian authorities at their request.

The US authorities subjected him to rendition in Jordan, then, after the Jordanians found no case to answer, to Bagram military base in Afghanistan.

In August 2002, he was transferred to Guantanamo Bay and has been held there since.

While there, he underwent torture by sleep deprivation, freezing, isolation and diet manipulation, as well as physical and psychological humiliation. These experiences are described in his diary, and have been subsequently verified in declassified documents released to US investigators.

The diary was written in 2005, and it has taken a decade of legal battles to bring it to publication now.

In 2007, the FBI, CIA and military intelligence conceded they could not link Mr Slahi to acts of terrorism.

And while a US District Court judge ordered his release in 2010, he is still imprisoned in Guantanamo Bay with no obvious prospect of freedom.

Before his election in 2008, President Barack Obama pledged to shut down the prison camp but has failed to do so. Around 200 inmates are still detained there.

Even with the blacked out lines redacted by the authorities, Guantanamo Diary is a vivid and moving personal testimony.

Mr Slahi is still bearing witness to what many regard as one of the most shameful and evil chapters of US history.

This true-life account is, as the writer John le Carré puts it in his endorsement of the book: "A vision of hell, beyond Orwell, beyond Kafka."

http://news.sky.com/story/1411023/horror-of-guantanamo-revealed-in-inmate-diary
 
What an absolute disgrace Guantanamo and the US are. Absolutely appalling stuff to read.
 
As terrorist shouldn't have expected first class treatment. Kudos to US to beat the hell out of these scums.
 
As terrorist shouldn't have expected first class treatment. Kudos to US to beat the hell out of these scums.

"Terrorist" ?

Most remarkable of all is how Mr Slahi is still in prison in Guantanamo, illegally and without charge, after 13 years in US custody – 12 of them within the detention camp.

Looks less terroristic to me than Western soldiers stationed in the Middle East.
 
As terrorist shouldn't have expected first class treatment. Kudos to US to beat the hell out of these scums.

Did you even bother reading the article ? There was no evidence against him whatsoever.

I wonder if you have this same hatred against the extreme scums in your country as well.
 
Some people need to read the article before opening posting stuff, seriously!

He's been found innocent for some time, yet is still incarcerated in Gitmo, absolutely disgraceful stuff.

He isn't the only one either.

US condemns other nations about their appalling human rights, yet condone this crap. Obama is as useful as G W Bush at a spelling bee.
 
Did you even bother reading the article ? There was no evidence against him whatsoever.

I wonder if you have this same hatred against the extreme scums in your country as well.

No admissible evidence doesnt mean innocence. Its cute how u guys are willing to let go his previous links with al-qaida.

Fortunately we have managed to control radicalization much better then western world so not much scums in my country. Kudos to my fellow Indians who happen to be Muslims.
 
No admissible evidence doesnt mean innocence. Its cute how u guys are willing to let go his previous links with al-qaida.

Fortunately we have managed to control radicalization much better then western world so not much scums in my country. Kudos to my fellow Indians who happen to be Muslims.

Yes I'll bet your fellow Indian Muslims will be thrilled with your approval. It's like when a bigot says I'm not racist I have this black friend..
 
No admissible evidence doesnt mean innocence. Its cute how u guys are willing to let go his previous links with al-qaida.

Fortunately we have managed to control radicalization much better then western world so not much scums in my country. Kudos to my fellow Indians who happen to be Muslims.

Really ? Shiv Seena Goons and RS Hindu extremists riot, loot burn and hack whenever they feel like it. They are radical scums as well, are they not ?

Stop talking baloney regarding no admissible evidence, there has not been even a shred of evidence against him. The reason they don't want to release him now is because of the horrendous torture they have inflicted him. Remember this particular guy handed him self in.

Anyway you have a fixated view, no point going further.
 
During the Question House in the Senate meeting held under the chairmanship of Sadiq Sanjrani, Jamaat-e-Islami (JI) Senator Mushtaq Ahmed had asked that despite the seventy-three-year-old being cleared by the prison review board earlier this year, Paracha had not returned to Pakistan.

Replying to his query, Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs Ali Muhammad Khan said that the government was coordinating with the US authorities for the repatriation of Paracha and some other Pakistanis from Guantanamo Bay.

In a written reply to the Senate, the US State Department stated that Washington was in contact with Islamabad and the two countries were completing the necessary formalities for Paracha’s extradition to Pakistan.

Stating that Paracha was acquitted by the US court, PPP Senator Taj Haider questioned: “Is the Pakistani government seeking compensation from the US for Saifullah Paracha? Will this improve Pakistan's foreign reserves?”

Moreover, Senator Ahmed also condemned the extra-judicial killing of Kashmiris on Thursday in the Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir (IIOJK).

“Their bodies were not allowed to be buried. Even the funereal prays were not allowed," said the JI senator, adding that when all this was happening, the parliament was passing bills regarding Kulbhushan Jadhav.

Earlier in May, it was reported that Paracha’s family excitedly awaits his return after more than 17 years as the US government approved his release.

The family which lives at a high-end locality of the southern port city of Karachi received the news with delight of the proposed release of Paracha, who had been arrested by US intelligence personnel from Thailand in 2003 on the charge of having links to Al-Qaeda.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/233014...RCMHZFeS1HVnpTSTdlOXdJV19VSmJRbzRROVktUFZYUlI
 
I read his book. Was deeply moving, you could see he had strayed to the bad path but then course corrected afterwards, only to get punished severely and disproportionately for his past.

I remember one interesting bit catching my attention when I read his book. Pakistan has been perennially accused by the US for not doing enough in the fight against terror and they have been accused of helping the "bad guys" or the jihadis back door. But I remember one chapter in the book when Slahi talks about his stay in Pakistan while being part of the Al Qaeda (I think, might be some other Arab group too), and he says the fighters were distrustful of the Pakistani military because they were known to play a double game for their interests and so the islamist fighters were generally very wary of the Pak military during their stay in Pakistan.

So while Pakistan did play a double game for its own geopolitical interests (and tbf, it has paid off given what has happened in Afghanistan in the last few months, so you can't fault their strategy), what that ended up doing is that Pakistan ended up earning the wrath of both the US and the jihadis, the latter one being significant in the rise of TTP against the Pakistani state.
 
Pakistani prisoner Saifullah Paracha released from Guantanamo Bay after 18 years

Saifullah Paracha, a Pakistani prisoner detained at the Guantanamo Bay detention centre, arrived in Pakistan on Saturday following his release from the US military prison after more than 18 years, the Foreign Office (FO) said in a statement.

The 75-year-old was the oldest prisoner at Guantanamo Bay and was held on suspicion of ties to Al Qaeda but never charged with a crime. His release was approved in May last year after more than 16 years in custody at the US base in Cuba.

“The foreign ministry completed an extensive inter-agency process to facilitate the repatriation of Paracha.

“We are glad that a Pakistani citizen detained abroad is finally reunited with his family,” the FO statement said.

Separately, Foreign Minister Bilawal-Bhutto Zardari also tweeted about his release.

Paracha, who lived in the US and owned property in New York City, was a wealthy businessman in Pakistan.

The US captured Paracha in Thailand in 2003 and had detained him at Guantanamo since September 2004.

Authorities alleged he was an Al Qaeda “facilitator” who helped two of the conspirators in the September 11 plot with a financial transaction. But Paracha, who suffers from a number of ailments including diabetes and a heart condition, has denied his involvement in terrorism, saying he did not know the men he was dealing with were Al-Qaeda members.

However, the US has long asserted that it can hold detainees indefinitely without charge under the international laws of war.

Paracha’s son had also been arrested on the charge of helping suspected militants to get into the US through faulty documents months before his father’s arrest.

He was sentenced to 30 years in jail in 2005 by the federal court in New York, however, a judge threw out witness accounts in March 2020.

Uzair Paracha, a graduate from Pakistan’s prestigious Institute of Business Administration, was sent back to Pakistan in 2021 after the US government decided not to seek a new trial.
 
Sad to read. Glad the man is out and can live in freedom.

And these nations have the audacity to call out others for human rights abuses.
 
Sad to read. Glad the man is out and can live in freedom.

And these nations have the audacity to call out others for human rights abuses.

They will defend their values on the Ukraine thread while belittling ours and yet they don't talk of the above..
 
They will defend their values on the Ukraine thread while belittling ours and yet they don't talk of the above..
[MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] [MENTION=732]Gilly[/MENTION]

Should we boycott US events, their human rights abuses in G-bay have been criminal to be nice?
 
Gitmo is a disgrace for the US government. But comparing it to Auschwitz’s is too much.
 
[MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] [MENTION=732]Gilly[/MENTION]

Should we boycott US events, their human rights abuses in G-bay have been criminal to be nice?

Western liberals will claim Gbay was legal and a necessity, when in actual fact they are nothing but hypocrites, duped by MSM.

Innocent until proven guilty doesn't apply to non-whites living in the West.

If it's white, it's right.

One rule for the West, another rule for the rest.
 
US transfers two Guantanamo Bay detainees to Pakistan

The United States has transferred two brothers from the Guantanamo Bay U.S. detention facility in Cuba to Pakistan, bringing the total number of people held at Guantanamo down to 32, the Pentagon said on Thursday.

The Guantanamo camp was established by Republican President George W. Bush in 2002 to house foreign terrorism suspects following the 2001 hijacked plane attacks on New York and the Pentagon that killed about 3,000 people.

It came to symbolise the excesses of the US “war on terror” because of harsh interrogation methods that critics have said amounted to torture.

There were 40 detainees when President Joe Biden, a Democrat, took office in 2021. Biden has said he hopes to close the facility. The federal government is barred by law from transferring Guantanamo detainees to US mainland prisons.

On Thursday, the Pentagon announced the repatriation of Abdul Rabbani and Mohammed Rabbani to Pakistan.

Both were arrested in 2002. Abdul Rabbani was an al Qaeda facilitator while Mohammed Rabbani was a financial and travel facilitator for prominent al Qaeda leaders, according to the Pentagon’s website.

“The United States appreciates the willingness of the Government of Pakistan and other partners to support ongoing US efforts focused on responsibly reducing the detainee population and ultimately closing the Guantanamo Bay facility,” the Pentagon said in a statement.

A total of 32 detainees remain, of whom 18 are eligible for transfer, the Pentagon said in its statement.

DAWN
 
GITMO was a weird thing.

Some of the guys and women (afia the terrorist) deserved what happened to them there and I would only wish worst on them.

While there is no secret that there were some that were innocent and had to face the brutality and human rights violation for no reason.

While GITMO was very effective in catching bin ladin and shooting the guys face off, but it is also a very good case study about why we need laws.

Laws protect the innocent. Extra judicial killing and torture are easy way, and often its a kind of justice that people carry out thinking that the guilty deserves it, but issue is in this kind of justice system innocent also get caught in between.
 
[MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] [MENTION=732]Gilly[/MENTION]

Should we boycott US events, their human rights abuses in G-bay have been criminal to be nice?

If you want. That place is a disgrace to the USA.

It’s difficult to know where to put captured enemy combatants who do not represent a nation state and where no state of war has been declared. A similar situation to Britons who choose to fight for Ukraine. They are not protected by the Geneva Conventions and so Russia has no imperative to afford them decent treatment if captured.

HM Gov chose to treat IRA captives as criminals and put them in Long Kesh jail. That created another set of problems as Bobby Sands and nine others refused to be treated as criminals, starved themselves to death in protest, and became martyrs leading to more unrest and IRA recruitment.

So instead of Gitmo, the US could put stateless enemy combatants in a supermax jail and afford them relatively humane treatment.
 
Last edited:
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Good news:Ahmed Rabbani & his brother returning home after 20 yrs imprisonment in Gitmo. I had raised my voice against his being handed to US, his wrongful incarceration & had sought his release incl as PM. So many like him have been victims of grave injustice in US War on Terror</p>— Imran Khan (@ImranKhanPTI) <a href="https://twitter.com/ImranKhanPTI/status/1629391131891978245?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 25, 2023</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Gitmo is a disgrace on the US reputation . I hope it finally closes its door and compensates the people it wrongfully imprisoned.
 
In India and Pakistan whenever we hear about a ghastly incident of rape, murder etc our immediate reaction is to hang the criminal or police encounter him on the spot.

We react emotionally like that because we know there are lot of legal loopholes in our system. That is why we desire swift Justice. Many times we don’t even think through if the right criminal was caught or even if the incident has been proven.

Gitmo is a similar reaction by America which was shaken up by 9/11. The people especially were shocked because these kind of things don’t happen in the so called first world.

In that emotion they captured a lot of terrorists and some innocent by guilty of association.

I am not endorsing this because I believe in the philosophy that rather let 10 guiltily people free than torture one innocent soul.

However thankfully these innocent people are let go now.Hope they start a new life and positively contribute to Pakistan going forward and become outstanding citizens like they used to be before this unfortunate and terrible incident.
 
Guantanamo is one of the most horrific "accomplishments" of Western intelligence community. The fact that they have kept it still open for the last 21 years in an apparently morally advanced and transparent democratic society really is impressive.

All nations, countries, empires are the same, whether openly or in secret, when they possess such power and resources.
 
Inmates who have been held for years in the Guantanamo Bay US detention facility in Cuba are showing signs of “accelerated ageing”, a senior official of the International Committee of the Red Cross has said.

“We’re calling on the US administration and Congress to work together to find adequate and sustainable solutions to address these issues,” Patrick Hamilton, the ICRC’s head of delegation for the United States and Canada, said on Friday.

“Action should be taken as a matter of priority.”

https://www.dawn.com/news/1748992/guantanamo-inmates-showing-signs-of-accelerated-ageing-red-cross
 
Back
Top