What's new

How great was Everton Weekes? All-time West Indies XI and 12 best of all time?

Harsh Thakor

First Class Star
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Runs
3,519
Post of the Week
2
On July 1st the legendary Everton Weekes left for his richly deserved heavenly abode.His exploits on a cricket field will never be forgotten till the game exists.His domination in the middle was reminiscent of an invincible army conquering territory after territory or an emperor dictating his kinghts.



Weekes took domination of bowling or pugnacity to merciless levels .He made opposing bowlers look like cattle walking to a slaughterhouse making a cricket bat resemble a lawn mower..Unorthodox and principally a back foot player who would step away from the crease as none could and punish deliveries.He cut,pulled and hooked in manner none did in his time and to many critiques he played more like Bradman than anyone.With Clyde Walcott and Frank Worrel he constituted the 3 W's.a trio whose class ws unmatched in the history of the game.In total contrast to Worrell Weekes was brutal and savage ,but still very clinical.No batsmen in his time looked as much as a cricketing machine in enforcing a demolition job.In full flow more than any batsmen he resembled flour or powder being grinded in a mill more than anyone,with his clinical execution of strokes.



In 1948-49 he plundered runs more than anyone after Bradman on the tour of India where he scored 5 successive test centuries and averaged over 111.It is hard even envisaging Bradman surpassing Weeke's performances on turning pitches in India.In England his 1st class averages were over 79 including a 304 he scored at Fenners v Cambridge.Fw batsmen ever displayed such skill agaisnt the moving ball as Everton.Arguably no batsmen dominated bowling in New Zealand with such remorseless ease as Weekes who averaged over 100 there.In the modern era possibly he may have even done more justice to his contempt for bowling surpassing the domination of the likes of Sehwag.Gilchrist or Devilliers.



To me the most memorable innings of Weekes was his 90 at Lords where he revealed batting prowess at regions of the sublime.



Pertinent that Don Bradman and Gary Sobers ranked Weekes as the best batsmen ever from West Indies.Bradman preferred Weekes to Headley just as Sobers rated Everton above Kanhai,Viv or Lara.Weekes averaged 58.61 which is more than Lara ,Sobers or Viv but he did not score as many runs pr play as many test matches.Weekes also averaged 49 runs away ,39.66 against Australia and 45.27 against England.In Australai he avergae a mere 24 and in England 33.His main runs were staggered against India and New Zealand unlike greats like Viv or Sobers. Still remember his great first class performances .Sad we did not see Weekes against the likes of Lillee,Thomson,Mcgrath,Wasim or Warne but bowlers like Subash Gupte and Ray Lindwall rate him at the very top.To be fair Weekes did not play enough test cricket to show whether the likes of Sobers,Viv or Lara were ahead.No batsmen played Subash Gupte better,considered by Gary Sobers as the best spinner he ever saw.

To me in full flow only Rohan Kahnai batted more like Bradman amongst Calypso stars.Both Kanhai and Hadley were arguably more complete.Ritchie Benaud felt Weekes re-incarnated Bradman more than any one.

Arguably considering leadership qualities and batting overseas Frank Worrel by a whisker overshadowed Weekes.Worrell was more stylish or elegant and technically better.However for sheer domination he could never equal Weekes.



Would Weekes make the all-time West Indies test XI ?I feel he may just be displaced by Viv,Lara and Headley in the middle.To me in the history of the game the batsmen who came closest to Weekes was Walter Hammond.,who averaged about the same .Overall amongst batsmen to me he would just edge out the likes of Javed Miandad,Alan Border, Greg Chappell and Graeme Pollock in test cricket.To me amongst the 30 best cricketers,12 best batsmen in test cricket and 20 best batsmen overall.Opinions in cricket are at such variance that to to some experts thee is case to place him as the best ever West Indies batsmen and amongts the 5 best test batsmen of all.In the end it may be so unfair to compare batsmen of diffident eras and thus asess who was better between Weekes,Sobers,Viv or Lara .John Woodcock Geoff Armstrong and Christopher Martin . Jenkins rank Weekes amongst the 15 best batsmen of al time .Eight cricketers selected Weekes in their all-time test XI,Including Alan Davidson nad Geoff Boycott.





Above all he radiated the spirit of the game above everything and gave back all to the game it had given him as a coach and manger.He never engaged in politiking like so many of the recent past.



His grave should be preserved as a monument of his memory.Even if physically dead and buried his memories will shimmer in our minds forever like an inextinguishable light flashing.Few more beholding sights in sport than see Everton Weekes in full flow out in the middle,as though God had sent him to bat.A true apostle to cricket.
 
GOAT West Indies team:

1. Sir Gordon Greenidge
2. Desmond Haynes
3. Sir Frank Worrell (c) - Clive Lloyd was the alternative skipper
4. Brian Lara
5. Sir Vivian Richards
6. Sir Everton Weekes
7. Jeff Dujon (wk)
8. Malcolm Marshall
9. Michael Holding
10. Sir Andy Roberts
11. Joel Garner (ahead of Ambrose)
 
GOAT West Indies team:

1. Sir Gordon Greenidge
2. Desmond Haynes
3. Sir Frank Worrell (c) - Clive Lloyd was the alternative skipper
4. Brian Lara
5. Sir Vivian Richards
6. Sir Everton Weekes
7. Jeff Dujon (wk)
8. Malcolm Marshall
9. Michael Holding
10. Sir Andy Roberts
11. Joel Garner (ahead of Ambrose)

Instead of Haynes,I will pick Conrad Hunte.
 
GOAT West Indies team:

1. Sir Gordon Greenidge
2. Desmond Haynes
3. Sir Frank Worrell (c) - Clive Lloyd was the alternative skipper
4. Brian Lara
5. Sir Vivian Richards
6. Sir Everton Weekes
7. Jeff Dujon (wk)
8. Malcolm Marshall
9. Michael Holding
10. Sir Andy Roberts
11. Joel Garner (ahead of Ambrose)

Wah, no Sobers in an all-time greatest WI eleven? Ok then :))
 
Everton Weekes was great batsman but his stats were a bit inflated by his heavy scoring against India - who were basically minnows level in those days

Of the 3 Ws, - Clyde Walcott was best batsman while Worrel was most elegant
 
Gordon Greenidge
Conrad Hunte
George Headley
Viv Richards
Brian Lara
Garry Sobers
Jeff Dujon
Malcolm Marshall
Michael Holding
Curtly Ambrose
Lance Gibbs
 
Everton Weekes was great batsman but his stats were a bit inflated by his heavy scoring against India - who were basically minnows level in those days

Of the 3 Ws, - Clyde Walcott was best batsman while Worrel was most elegant

Why Walcott?Weekes had a better record consistently.Weekes demolished Subhas Gupte like noone and overshadowed Walcott in England and India.
 
GOAT West Indies team:

1. Sir Gordon Greenidge
2. Desmond Haynes
3. Sir Frank Worrell (c) - Clive Lloyd was the alternative skipper
4. Brian Lara
5. Sir Vivian Richards
6. Sir Everton Weekes
7. Jeff Dujon (wk)
8. Malcolm Marshall
9. Michael Holding
10. Sir Andy Roberts
11. Joel Garner (ahead of Ambrose)

No Gary Sobers?Unbelievable.Please explain.
 
Please stick to commenting on the merits of Everton Weekes and not just post XI.
 
Gordon Greenidge
Conrad Hunte
George Headley
Viv Richards
Brian Lara
Garry Sobers
Jeff Dujon
Malcolm Marshall
Michael Holding
Curtly Ambrose
Lance Gibbs

how great was Weekes in Your view?Also why no Andy Roberts who was the most complete of paceman?
 
how great was Weekes in Your view?Also why no Andy Roberts who was the most complete of paceman?

As someone else said earlier, most of Weekes's centuries came in India who were minnows back then.

Chose Ambrose ahead of Roberts, was a tough choice but I have grown up watching Ambrose bowl, never seen Roberts in action.
 
One of the best ever from Windies.

My all-time Windies XI:-

Gordon Greenidge
Desmond Haynes
Viv Richards
Brian Lara
Clive Lloyd (c)
Garfield Sobers
Jeff Dujon(wkt)
Malcolm Marshall
Curtly Ambrose
Michael Holding
Joel Garner
 
GOAT West Indies team:

Roy Fredericks
Sir Gordon Greenidge
George Headley
Sir Vivian Richards
Brian Lara
Sir Garfield Sobers (c)
Sir Clyde Walcott (w)
Malcolm Marshall
Sir Curtley Ambrose
Michael Holding
Joel Garner
 
Makes a 2nd WI all time team for me. Would make any other AT team 1st xi apart from Aus.
Great, but not a great as his 58 average would make it seem as he was a bit of a home track bully
 
GOAT West Indies team:

Roy Fredericks
Sir Gordon Greenidge
George Headley
Sir Vivian Richards
Brian Lara
Sir Garfield Sobers (c)
Sir Clyde Walcott (w)
Malcolm Marshall
Sir Curtley Ambrose
Michael Holding
Joel Garner

How great was Weekes in your view?
 
Where do you put Sobers?Why Weekes better than Lara or Viv?
Greatest West Indian batsmen?

1. Richards - mentally the strongest, refused to lose!
2. Weekes
3. Sobers
4. Lara

Sobers was the greatest cricketer for the same reason that Kallis was greater than Tendulkar - the sun of the parts.
 
Would Weekes rank ahead of Greg Chappell,Alan Border,Javed Miandad , Graeme Pollock,Rahul Dravid and Ricky Ponting as a test batsmen?Amongst the top 10 test batsmen of all?
 
Greatest West Indian batsmen?

1. Richards - mentally the strongest, refused to lose!
2. Weekes
3. Sobers
4. Lara

Sobers was the greatest cricketer for the same reason that Kallis was greater than Tendulkar - the sun of the parts.

Kanhai not right up there with Lara or Sobers?
 
No
Sobers played in the same era and was clearly much better

Kanhai was still great though

I dont' agree.Kanhai batted at one down which was more challenging and better than Sobers at his best.Many felt Kanhai was more complete.Gavsakar ranked hi as the best he ever saw,ahead of Sobers.
 
I dont' agree.Kanhai batted at one down which was more challenging and better than Sobers at his best.Many felt Kanhai was more complete.Gavsakar ranked hi as the best he ever saw,ahead of Sobers.

The vast, vast majority vote Sobers as greater, Kanhai often isn't mentioned. ;The one-down doesn't make much of a difference, especially given that Sobers also had to shoulder a bowling workload
 
GOAT West Indies team:

1. Sir Gordon Greenidge
2. Desmond Haynes
3. Sir Frank Worrell (c) - Clive Lloyd was the alternative skipper
4. Brian Lara
5. Sir Vivian Richards
6. Sir Everton Weekes
7. Jeff Dujon (wk)
8. Malcolm Marshall
9. Michael Holding
10. Sir Andy Roberts
11. Joel Garner (ahead of Ambrose)

It lacks genuine spinner , one dimensional attack.
 
West Indian batting legend Brian Lara will be among the pallbearers at cricket great Sir Everton Weekes's funeral at the Kensington Oval in Barbados on July 30.

Weekes, 95, passed away on July 1. Other pallbearers will be sons David Murray (former WI wicketkeeper) and Eareal Johnson; godson Adrian Donovan, former West Indies cricketers Sir Charles Griffith and Ian Bradshaw, revealed Jeffrey Gibson, the dean at The Cathedral Church of Saint Michael and All Angels.

"The procession will enter Kensington Oval through the Pickwick Gate (Sir Everton was born and raised in Pickwick Gap). The funeral service will comprise the singing of hymns and the reading of three passages from the Bible. The eulogy will be delivered by Sir Hilary Beckles, who collaborated with Weekes for a book.

"Sir Everton's funeral will be the fourth one held at the Kensington Oval. The others were former Prime Minister David Thompson, former President of the Barbados Cricket Association, Stephen Alleyne and former WI batsman Seymour Nurse," said Gibson, a life member of the Barbados Cricket Association and a lower grade cricketer.

Anti-Coronavirus protocol will be in place at the service—face masks, temperature checks, sanitisation of hands on entry and one-metre distancing by the attendees.

https://www.mid-day.com/articles/brian-lara-to-be-pallbearer-at-sir-everton-weekess-funeral/22905226
 
Toady the genius Everton Weekes turns 100.He died in 2020 in July at age of 95.

When batting, Everton Weekes often exuded vibrations of an incarnate of Donald Bradman, with a striking similarity: in the manner he pulverised the bowling. Bradman, and with similar effect, even if with a slightly less spectacular (though still highly impressive) average of 58.61. At best, possibly no batsman came more within striking distance of Bradman, as Weekes. No Caribbean batsmen arguably executed attacking aggression in such a methodical, calculating or clinical manner, or was more pugnacious. Hard to visualise any batsman more mercurial, displaying more breathtaking exuberance, or plundering runs more mercilessly.

His batting, was unorthodox in nature, revelling off the backfoot. He cut, hooked and drove with incredible power of either foot facing the fastest bowlers of his time. He drove hard in many directions, frequently giving himself room to lace the ball to penetrate the offside. No Caribbean batsmen arguably executed attacking aggression in such a methodical, calculating or clinical manner ,or was more pugnacious. Weekes could dance down the pitch, before you said ‘Jack Robinson’ to the spinners.



Weekes retired, scoring 4455 runs, at an average of 58.61, scoring 15 centuries, in 81 test innings and 48 test matches. Weekes averaged 69.14, scoring 2420 at home and 49.63 overseas, scoring 2035 runs Weekes averaged 111.28.i n India, and overall 106.78 against India. He averaged 39.66 against Australia and 45.27 against England. In England he averaged33.31 while in Australia, 24.50.



What went against Weekes being rated as the best ever Calypso batsmen or amongst the best 5 batsmen of all time, was his premature retirement at age of 32, and not as impressive record overseas. In my view, considering all factors Weekes ranks just a whisker below Gary Sobers, George Headley, Viv Richards and Brian Lara. Although more consistent than them Viv Richards and Brian Lara were proven against more diverse bowling and conditions, more innovative and at best turned games more. Gary Sobers was more tested and impactful. George Headley rates ahead because he championed the cause singlehandedly, like a one-man army.

Cristopher Martin Jenkins placed Weekes at 32nd place in his top 100 cricketers ever and Geoff Armstrong at 35th place. With a gun on my head, Weekes may just scrape into my list of 5 best Caribbean batsmen ever, best dozen batsmen ever and best 50 cricketers ever.
 
Back
Top