What's new

ICC’s Double Standard? Usman Khawaja banned for Peace Dove, but Jay Shah’s Military Tribute goes unchecked

BouncerGuy

BouncerGuy

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 29, 2023
Runs
32,069


The decision by the ICC to ban Usman Khawaja from displaying a dove on his bat in 2023—symbolizing peace in the Middle East—raises serious questions about consistency in sports governance. Meanwhile, ICC chairman Jay Shah has openly shown support for the Indian military during times of conflict with Pakistan recently.

This contrast in treatment highlights a troubling double standard: why is one message considered unacceptable while the other is permitted? Should sporting organizations remain neutral, or do they inevitably take sides?
 
Very true. If Jay Shah also lobbied the ECB on behalf of India to not allow PSL in UAE then his positions should be investigated. It is one of the only times I would support the PCB taking legal action.
 
Did Jay Shah or the Indian team show their support to the Indian army during a cricket match like Usman Khwaja did?
 
Hitman said:
They were warned not to repeat it again. And they didn't. How about Misbhah and his boys doing push ups on the field showing their support for Pakistan army?
Click to expand...
Pretty cringe behavior. But still doesn't compare to a team coming out on the field in camouflage Army caps.
 
Hitman said:
So you're comparing both the acts, and judging which was more offensive?
Click to expand...

Shah should be kicked out as ICC chairman

He has shown himself to be biased against Pakistan and is openly making political statements knowing fully well that he is also represents ICC.

If he feels that he needs to make political statements against Pakistan then he should have the decency (obviously a character trait that is missing) to step down.
 
MenInG said:
Shah should be kicked out as ICC chairman

He has shown himself to be biased against Pakistan and is openly making political statements knowing fully well that he is also represents ICC.

If he feels that he needs to make political statements against Pakistan then he should have the decency (obviously a character trait that is missing) to step down.
Click to expand...
He has a pretty tainted reputation in India as well and is seen as a product of nepotism.
 
Hitman said:
So you're comparing both the acts, and judging which was more offensive?
Click to expand...
Yes. One case involved a group of players doing push-ups. As cringeworthy as that was, unless you were in the know, its not necessary that you would knew what they were doing.

I don't think there was any doubt about what the Indian players were doing when they came out in camouflage caps.

I also recall Dhoni having an Indian Army insignia on his wicketkeeping gloves that he was asked to remove by the ICC.
 
I think symbolism in sport and putting up something on social media from a personal account are two very different things. Don’t remember Usman Khawaja being barred from expressing himself on social media.

Did ICC stop Khawaja from putting up a story on Instagram?

:kp
 
MenInG said:
Shah should be kicked out as ICC chairman

He has shown himself to be biased against Pakistan and is openly making political statements knowing fully well that he is also represents ICC.

If he feels that he needs to make political statements against Pakistan then he should have the decency (obviously a character trait that is missing) to step down.
Click to expand...
I agree. This is blatant hypocrisy. But if nothing is done about it, will continue to happen. No point in complaining then.

There needs to be action. Not words. Without action it will just be status quo.

Now then, who will be the one take action?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think people are missing the point. The world is not looking at this as India vs Pakistan army battle. It is widely viewed as a battle between the terrorists and its victims, good guys vs bad people, right against the wrong. So Jay Shah supporting good guys for being victims of terrorism who are on the right side of history is highly appreciated and widely considered a right move. After all, there is a world outside this forum and in that real world people dnt often support terrorists.
 
Really. ICC should now change its name to BCCI.. Why bother with 2 different names when the things you do are biased
 
Pat Cummins posted Instagram story for Indian Armed forces for Inspiring the bravery just like Jay Shah.

This is not going well for certain fan's.

:kp
 
Devadwal said:
Pat Cummins posted Instagram story for Indian Armed forces for Inspiring the bravery just like Jay Shah.

This is not going well for certain fan's.

:kp
Click to expand...
YKW? This forum never fails to amuse me :ROFLMAO:

These guys get upset over anything & everything about India! I pray to Lord Krishna that they get something in their life to smile about and let go off their jealousy and grudge.
 
Devadwal said:
Everyone is not sellout like certain country players :kp
Click to expand...
Are you here to discuss cricket or to defend India and bashing Pakistan ,while holding Indian flag. Doesn't look like you have much interest and knowledge about cricket.
 
moghul said:
Are you here to discuss cricket or to defend India and bashing Pakistan ,while holding Indian flag. Doesn't look like you have much interest and knowledge about cricket.
Click to expand...
WHy are you crying juts because pat Cummins showed the love with india ? :kp
 
The Indian team showed themselves to be clowns when they did that move, mostly orchestrated by Dhoni. The reason they were clowns is it was a publicity stunt and not because they stand for important issues. Their silence on far more important matters of national interest or when fellow sportsmen were being ill-treated shows how many principles they actually hold lol.

Admire their cricketing ability and that's all. They are no heroes outside of sport.
 
Devadwal said:
Pat Cummins posted Instagram story for Indian Armed forces for Inspiring the bravery just like Jay Shah.

This is not going well for certain fan's.

:kp
Click to expand...

It was a pre-made promotional poster for the resumption of IPL that he is sharing, mate. The text aren't his words, they are part of the original promotional poster itself.
 
Ice Man said:
It was a pre-made promotional poster for the resumption of IPL that he is sharing, mate. The text aren't his words, they are part of the original promotional poster itself.
Click to expand...
Whatever, he posted from his Instagram account, that's what matters.

Anyway he is already condemned the Pehalgam attack Live from the ground .

Supported India by donating money during Covid crisis in India.

Came back to play 2 irrelevant IPL games from Aus before a WTC Final.

Respected the efforts of Indian army for protecting our nation.

Pat Cummins is from now on my favourite australian player ❤️

:kp
 
Shahid Afridi speaking during a TV show:

Regarding Jay Shah's post about the Indian Army being an ICC Chief:

“If one posts something from a personal account, it’s different; but when it comes from the ICC’s official account, it becomes a serious matter. The first response to it came from an Australian individual, and I believe it was an unprofessional act. Such actions should be avoided as the ICC chairman should maintain neutrality for everyone. Fortunately, wisdom prevailed, and he deleted the post after realizing the reaction it caused.”
 
Hitman said:
How about Misbhah and his boys doing push ups on the field showing their support for Pakistan army?
Click to expand...
that was for their training drill they conducted with the army prior to that UK tour and the pushup was to encourage their teammates to score 100s and do the same as challenge to stay fit
 
BouncerGuy said:
Shahid Afridi speaking during a TV show:

Regarding Jay Shah's post about the Indian Army being an ICC Chief:

“If one posts something from a personal account, it’s different; but when it comes from the ICC’s official account, it becomes a serious matter. The first response to it came from an Australian individual, and I believe it was an unprofessional act. Such actions should be avoided as the ICC chairman should maintain neutrality for everyone. Fortunately, wisdom prevailed, and he deleted the post after realizing the reaction it caused.”
Click to expand...
Wait it was from an ICC's account?
 
Devadwal said:
WHy are you crying juts because pat Cummins showed the love with india ? :kp
Click to expand...
That's OK , luckily you're the only trouble maker among very good Indian posters on this forum. Try to get over with this India-Pakistan thing and post something valuable on cricket, for a change.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top