What's new

If ball tampering is illegal, so is bat tampering: Geoff Lawson

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,977
When you talk about a cricket coach sharing an uneasy relationship with his team, quite a few examples come to mind. Geoff Lawson’s tumultuous stint with the Pakistan national team between 2007 and 2008 was one such example. Yet, talk to the former Australian pacer about that chapter in his career and the last thing he’ll be found doing is ranting about the bunch of cricketers who played under his tutelage. “Oh, they were a fantastic bunch. Some very good, very talented cricketers,” he says.

The personal differences notwithstanding, Lawson — who was abruptly dismissed by the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) following a chaotic 2008 Asia Cup campaign — doesn’t hold grudges. But talk to him about the prevailing Australian cricket culture and he starts to cringe. “As Don Bradman said, you can be very competitive but you can be modest too,” he says.

In Mumbai to deliver the Raj Singh Dungarpur memorial lecture, Lawson refuses to blame Steve Smith for the scandalous ball tampering episode. “He’s very shy and naive. He’s a nice guy,” he says

Lawson’s peeve is the prevailing culture, one he doubts will remain shelved for long despite the sequence of events in South Africa and thereafter.

“It’s that thing, about winning at all costs. At what cost?” he says. The former cricketer’s grouse with the ball-tampering episode has more to do with the ICC’s inefficiency to do the same with bat tampering, an ill eating into the.

“The ICC checks for ball-tampering. But is there a rule in place to check bats, see if sizes, weights, thickness and other factors are being adhered to? Is there a code in place? Worse, they’re now scurrying to put a code in place for what constitutes player behaviour. That shows a lot of work hasn’t been done,” says Lawson. In his view, if ball-tampering is illegal, then so is bat-tampering, except that the game — he believes — is way too skewed in favour of the willow. The 60-year-old is clear Cricket Australia (CA) won’t change the period of ban for Smith, Warner and Bancroft. “Let’s move on,” he says.

https://m.timesofindia.com/sports/c...bat-tampering-lawson/articleshow/63889528.cms
 
Last edited:
Great point made by Lawson.Bat sizes need to be curbed , these bats are making ordinary players into some six hitting machines.

Hitting six was an exciting event once, guys like Richards and Clive Lloyd who had massive back lifts and strength were hitting sixes.

Ponting started this tampering of bats by using graphite covered bats.
 
Last edited:
I gotta say when a bowler is about to run-in and sees Gayle/Afridi/Russell and players of that ilk holding a bat that looks more suitable to be rooted underground, in some woodland, I wonder what they must be thinking too.

I thought ICC minimised the usage of such bats? What happened there then?
 
I gotta say when a bowler is about to run-in and sees Gayle/Afridi/Russell and players of that ilk holding a bat that looks more suitable to be rooted underground, in some woodland, I wonder what they must be thinking too.

I thought ICC minimised the usage of such bats? What happened there then?

The ICC did put a restriction on bat sizes but from what I can remember the limit was basically as big as the biggest bats players use now.

So they were just trying to stop bats from getting any bigger.
 
Ricky Ponting broke a bunch of records while using a Graphite bat for 2 years. When caught, they used the excuse that it was a Graphite "sticker". A sticker is made from paper, not from material that strengthens the bat to the point where it seriously magnifies the bat's hitting power.

Guess what? No suspension. No fine. Nothing.
 
Ricky Ponting broke a bunch of records while using a Graphite bat for 2 years. When caught, they used the excuse that it was a Graphite "sticker". A sticker is made from paper, not from material that strengthens the bat to the point where it seriously magnifies the bat's hitting power.

Guess what? No suspension. No fine. Nothing.

Nathan Astle and Sanath Jayasuriya are some of the batsmen who used the same graphite bat as Ponting.

It was truly amazing that the ICC caught them after advertising these bats for two years nobody noticed that batsmen were using the bats. Some people were gullible and think that a graphite strip on the back of a bat makes it magical makes the ball go further.
 
The ICC did put a restriction on bat sizes but from what I can remember the limit was basically as big as the biggest bats players use now.

So they were just trying to stop bats from getting any bigger.



When will they learn... :facepalm:
 
He's right. But also, the ball technology didn't keep up with the bat technology. Ball loses shine too soon and does absolutely nothing for the rest of the game. Give the umpires a sand paper and a few official scratches to the ball once every 3 or 5 overs once it gets old. The pitches are already batsman friendly.
 
So Lawson wants to ban Warner for ball and bat tampering?

I know he has a bad rep but leave the poor guy alone eh.
 
Back
Top