What's new

"If Sharjeel & Latif are handed life-time bans, then they will demand same for Amir" : Mohsin Khan

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,977
"If Sharjeel & Latif are handed life-time bans, then they will demand same for Amir" : Mohsin Khan

http://nation.com.pk/sports/17-Mar-2017/mohsin-lambasts-pcb-over-fixing-row

ISLAMABAD - Former chief selector Mohsin Hssan Khan lambasted the PCB and held them responsible for bringing Pakistan cricket into dispute and inflicting huge damages on national cause.

Talking to The Nation on Thursday, Mohsin said: “I have no sympathy with Sharjeel and Khalid Latif, but they are not whole-solely blamed for their alleged role in the spot-fixing, as they had witnessed two tainted persons sitting in the Islamabad United dug out and their crime was higher than theirs, who had sold national integrity, while Sharjeel and Khalid, if proven guilty, had just fixed a match and that too of a private league, which had no impact on overall results.”

He said he had time and again pleaded with the PCB that they should have implemented ‘Justice Malik Qayyum Commission Report’ in a true letter and spirit. “It was stressed in the report not to involve these players in any capacity and role in the PCB, but no heed was paid, and the players, who were nominated and held responsible for their roles in spot-fixing, were not only fully entertained but also given top roles with PCB and franchises. Had Justice Qayyum report was implemented and the players given tough punishments, England episode could have easily avoided and no player could even think about involvement in any fixing.”

Mohsin said he was quite sure that the PCB would let both the players either off the hook or give them soft punishments just to hush up the things. “If these players are handed over life time bans, they will demand same for other players like M Aamir and those, who are waiting in the wings to represent Pakistan again, and I believe they are not demanding anything out of bound. All the players, who inflicted damages on national cause and had some any role in fixing, must face the music.”

He said he had always made his point clear that the PSL was Pakistan’s league not the UAE league. “Playing bilateral series at neutral venue is something different, but when it comes to hold a private league, it must be hosted in our own country, because it’s our private entity.

“All the international players involved in the PSL were either retired from international cricket or struggling to find their ways into their national teams. When PCB made up their minds of conducting the PSL final in Pakistan, they should have conveyed it to the foreign players and all those players, who didn’t want to come and play in Pakistan, should have been released,” he added.

He said that the international players, who did come to Pakistan especially for Quetta Gladiators were ‘C class’ players, while not a single major player arrived with the exception of West Indian players, who just arrived due to personal links. I always pleaded that the PCB should conduct all the PSL matches on Pakistani soil, if not possible then at least 4 matches should have been played here.

“If I was at the helm of affairs, I would have constituted four teams based on local players and matches would have been held at Quetta, Lahore, Karachi and Peshawar. I can guarantee that not only PCB would have find fresh talent, but all the venues would have been packed to capacity,” he added.

He said that Pakistan security forces gave a very clear message to the international community by holding the PSL final in a complete safe and sound environment. “We are capable of hosting events in highly peaceful and cordial manner. Our security forces can handle any given situation, so international community must step forward and lend a helping hand to Pakistan cricket to host international events here.”

He said Australia, South Africa and India conducted the leagues because they were top 3 sides of the world and they had complete sound domestic and international cricket structure that’s why they managed to produce fresh players every year on regular basis. “On the other hand, I want to know what was the reason the PCB started the PSL in UAE.

“The PCB should have waited for a year or so and should have conducted the PSL at Pakistani soil, which would have far better and positive impact on Pakistan cricket,” Moshin concluded.
 
And they will have no grounds to do so. It was always obvious that if anyone offended after the trio, that their punishment would be much more severe due to the already present example they presented and the increased anti corruption education
 
Is he serious? :))

That only makes sense if they committed the act before the trio but were convicted after.

However these two allegedly committed the act years after the trio. It only makes sense to give them a life ban.
 
Should be same punishment for everyone, hopefully Sharjeel will be fit and can serve us after 5 years...
 
Makes sense. The trio committed the offence after Saleem Malik and the Qayyum report. The trio still got off easy, infact they had PCB in their corner all through. If someone can be retried after fixing in an international game, no reason why anyone should get a harsher punishment for fixing in a domestic one
 
If Sharjeel and Khalid were "innocent 19-year old snowflakes", then sure they will not get life bans. Knowing PCB, they probably will not anyway.
 
agree with Mohsin Khan that if Sharjeel and Khalid are giving life-time bans then Amir, Butt and Asif should also be given life-time bans.
 
No where in the world there is space in the law to double punish someone for the same crime.

Amir committed a crime, he was punished for it, he completed his sentence and now he is back.
 
These comments show a lack of understanding of the dynamics behind the fixing saga since famous Lords expose. Quite illuminating on Mohsin Khan as a senior figure in Pakistan cricket. I wouldn't give him any important role in the near future if this is his level of understanding.
 
"If Sharjeel & Latif are handed life-time bans, then they will demand same for Amir" : Mohsin Khan

I feel for the PCB here. Although Amir has been good since his comeback, and there´s a whole case to be made for him based on the number of catches dropped on his bowling, but the PCB didn´t bring him back, provide him the support or treat him like a favoured child for him to be just "good". He was brought back to be the man of miracles, to be as threatening and as world class bowler as he was before he did the deed. If things had happened that way, then this criticism on Amir´s comeback would´ve been worth the pain. But that hasn´t happened so far either, and a a new set of players are caught committing the same crime that Amir did years ago.

A man was once caught committing a crime and the villagers gave him the option of either eating hundred onions as a punishment, or receiving hundred shoe blows. He opted for onions, but after a couple he hated the taste and changed to go for the blows. After three to four, he asked to switch back to the onions. He kept switching between the two till finally he´d eaten hundred onions as well as hundred blows!
 
Last edited:
Is he serious

First of all, these two clowns are in no position to demand anything!

Mohsin uncle should stick to drinking chai
 
Amir should have been banned for life, we made a mistake.
 
I feel for the PCB here. Although Amir has been good since his comeback, and there´s a whole case to be made for him based on the number of catches dropped on his bowling, but the PCB didn´t bring him back, provide him the support or treat him like a favoured child for him to be just "good". He was brought back to be the man of miracles, to be as threatening and as world class bowler as he was before he did the deed. If things had happened that way, then this criticism on Amir´s comeback would´ve been worth the pain. But that hasn´t happened so far either, and a a new set of players are caught committing the same crime that Amir did years ago.

A man was once caught committing a crime and the villagers gave him the option of either eating hundred onions as a punishment, or receiving hundred shoe blows. He opted for onions, but after a couple he hated the taste and changed to go for the blows. After three to four, he asked to switch back to the onions. He kept switching between the two till finally he´d eaten hundred onions as well as hundred blows!

Great story! :91:
 
Rubbish.

1) Past punishments have nothing to with punishments for future crimes. However, PCB should have or in the future should make the rules clear to all players, if you fix, your career is over

2) No matter what Amir deserved or did not deserve, you do not bring a player back and then suddenly ban him again without him doing anything again. That is unfair and defies all logic
 
Back
Top