India says doors open to Afghan's Sikh and Hindu minorities

[Major]

NEW DELHI, Aug 16 (Reuters) - India will help members of Afghanistan's tiny Sikh and Hindu community to come to India, the foreign ministry said on Monday.

"We are in constant touch with the representatives of Afghan Sikh and Hindu communities. We will facilitate repatriation to India of those who wish to leave Afghanistan," foreign ministry spokesman Arindam Bagchi said in a statement.

India invested millions of dollars in development projects in Afghanistan and Bagchi said the government stood by the Afghans who had partnered it in that task.

Reporting by Sanjeev Miglani; Editing by Alison Williams

https://www.reuters.com/world/india...tent&utm_medium=trueAnthem&utm_source=twitter

 

[Major]

This proves that Two Nation theory was needed.

Really shameful that India discriminates like this agaisnt Muslims

 

[Local.Dada]

This proves that Two Nation theory was needed.

Really shameful that India discriminates like this agaisnt Muslims

Wait, 2 nation theory was found on the theory that Muslims can’t co exist with other religions.

There are 2 Islamic countries in the neighborhood formed on the same principle and then there is Afghanistan a country now taken over by one of the most staunch followers of Islam like the Taliban (whatever their interpretation is a different debate)

So does 2 nation theory fail because india is giving refuge to minorities in these countries or these muslim refugees are not willing to go to Pakistan or Bangladesh?

 

[Colorblind Genius]

This proves that Two Nation theory was needed.

Really shameful that India discriminates like this agaisnt Muslims

It's actually a nice eye opener to those baighairut Afghans (in Pakistan, Afghanistan and all over the world) who pledged allegiance with India and do not leave any chance to defame and spew hate against Pakistan.

Hore Chupo .....

I am sure they will never learn cuz that's the nature of the backstabbers.

 

[Rana]

So what about the Muslims who don’t want none of it either?

 

[maverick85]

This proves that Two Nation theory was needed.

Really shameful that India discriminates like this agaisnt Muslims

it's true. the srivastava group also proves this too.

 

[Rana]

So is Pakistan and other Islamic countries going to open its doors for the liberal Muslims who want out from Afghanistan?

 

[Pakpak]

So is Pakistan and other Islamic countries going to open its doors for the liberal Muslims who want out from Afghanistan?

???? Why speak trash about liberals?

There are no Afghanistan liberals. The Kabul government fed on US dollars already left and ran like cowards.

 

[Rana]

???? Why speak trash about liberals?

There are no Afghanistan liberals. The Kabul government fed on US dollars already left and ran like cowards.

The afghans abroad, especially in England are fairly liberal and open minded. Good, decent community. I don’t think they are the type that want to be a part of an extremist regime. Most people in Afghanistan will definitely want out

 

[gazza619]

Shame on India.

They are partner of Afghanistan and should have supported Afghan muslims as well.

 

[KingKhanWC]

Lets hope Rashid Khan is not reading this.

 

[IMMY69]

I wonder how the 200 odd million Indian Muslims feel about this?

Are they not indians with equal rights?

 

[Local.Dada]

Shame on India.

They are partner of Afghanistan and should have supported Afghan muslims as well.

What about Pakistan though? Imran Khan has issues with islamophobia in France and Israel and he can’t help out the neighboring Muslims?

 

[IMMY69]

What about Pakistan though? Imran Khan has issues with islamophobia in France and Israel and he can’t help out the neighboring Muslims?

We have three million refugees already.

But how would a Muslim Indian feel about this?
Are they second class citizens

 

[Local.Dada]

I wonder how the 200 odd million Indian Muslims feel about this?

Are they not indians with equal rights?

It’s tough to reason with an intelligent person who shuts off logic on purpose but let me try. A Hindu or a Sikh or even a subcontinental Christian/Parsi etc have no where to go. On the other side there are 2 countries formed on the principle of being a haven for subcontinent Muslims and on top of that Afghanistan itself is run by a group that sees themselves as a torchbearer of Islam.

Now hit me with your logic here, really curious.

 

[Local.Dada]

We have three million refugees already.

But how would a Muslim Indian feel about this?
Are they second class citizens

How does this impact Indian Muslim if Afghanistan Muslim is not been given refugee status. ) boy this is some intellect level.

Now if it was an Indian Muslim working in Afghanistan and Indian government refused to re-admit it him you would have a strong point and I myself would condemn that.

 

[IMMY69]

It’s tough to reason with an intelligent person who shuts off logic on purpose but let me try. A Hindu or a Sikh or even a subcontinental Christian/Parsi etc have no where to go. On the other side there are 2 countries formed on the principle of being a haven for subcontinent Muslims and on top of that Afghanistan itself is run by a group that sees themselves as a torchbearer of Islam.

Now hit me with your logic here, really curious.

I think you're missing the point here.

If IK were to make a speech or an announcement that they will take Muslims from a country but not any other religions I would be quiet peeved off even though Pakistan is an Islamic country.

Here we have a country that says they will only take in certain religions even though there are already 200m Indian Muslims living there

 

[Local.Dada]

I think you're missing the point here.

If IK were to make a speech or an announcement that they will take Muslims from a country but not any other religions I would be quiet peeved off even though Pakistan is an Islamic country.

Here we have a country that says they will only take in certain religions even though there are already 200m Indian Muslims living there

Countries can pick and chose whom they consider refugees or not. That’s the way it works. You can maybe pick a country randomly and read it’s immigration policy, go ahead pick any country.

India feels the sikhs and hindus will be more displaced than Muslims who have other places of refuge and they can have their immigration policy around it. That’s how the world works.

 

[IMMY69]

How does this impact Indian Muslim if Afghanistan Muslim is not been given refugee status. ) boy this is some intellect level.

Now if it was an Indian Muslim working in Afghanistan and Indian government refused to re-admit it him you would have a strong point and I myself would condemn that.

It's discriminatory

 

[KingKhanWC]

Countries can pick and chose whom they consider refugees or not. That’s the way it works. You can maybe pick a country randomly and read it’s immigration policy, go ahead pick any country.

India feels the sikhs and hindus will be more displaced than Muslims who have other places of refuge and they can have their immigration policy around it. That’s how the world works.

Which planet, is it in this galaxy or not?

Name one other nation which has stated only people of specific religions will be given asylum?

 

[Giannis]

India shouldn't discriminate against Afghans cause of their faith, they should open their doors to Afghan Muslims as well. With India's size and economy they can easily take in 5 million+ refugees from Afghanistan. India claims to be a friend of Afghanistan, well now it's time to prove it.

 

[Local.Dada]

Which planet, is it in this galaxy or not?

Name one other nation which has stated only people of specific religions will be given asylum?

Does Pakistan allow minorities to become political
head of state? Does Islam ask to discriminate against minorities? Pakistan has its own rules and so does india.

India has its own version of secularism and for the constitutionally every citizen has equal rights.

Giving someone refuge is a charity and just like any charity it’s your money and your decision no one can force you or shame you to do what you want.

Anyways you want Taliban to take over Afghan and are celebrating it you would have to deal with the fall out too as neighbor.India has cut its losses and done the best it could by protecting minorities of this country because they would suffer even more if they go to Pakistan. As simple as that.

 

[Local.Dada]

India shouldn't discriminate against Afghans cause of their faith, they should open their doors to Afghan Muslims as well. With India's size and economy they can easily take in 5 million+ refugees from Afghanistan. India claims to be a friend of Afghanistan, well now it's time to prove it.

Prove to who? some online keyboard warriors?

 

[Giannis]

Prove to who? some online keyboard warriors?

Prove to the Afghan people that India genuinely cares about them and not just exploit their country as a strategic asset. Why not take in millions of Afghan Muslims? It's the right thing to do.

 

[Local.Dada]

Prove to the Afghan people that India genuinely cares about them and not just exploit their country as a strategic asset. Why not take in millions of Afghan Muslims? It's the right thing to do.

Before we get to that level of morality, how about addressing the source of the problem? A radical group driving away these citizens.how do you feel about that? A momentous occasion or a dangerous situation?

 

[Giannis]

Before we get to that level of morality, how about addressing the source of the problem? A radical group driving away these citizens.how do you feel about that? A momentous occasion or a dangerous situation?

I feel that those are valid reasons for India to grant them asylum.

 

[Local.Dada]

I feel that those are valid reasons for India to grant them asylum.

Ok. Fair enough. That’s your opinion. Let’s see what India does or how this situation pans out for everyone involved .

 

[KingKhanWC]

Does Pakistan allow minorities to become political
head of state? Does Islam ask to discriminate against minorities? Pakistan has its own rules and so does india.

India has its own version of secularism and for the constitutionally every citizen has equal rights.

Giving someone refuge is a charity and just like any charity it’s your money and your decision no one can force you or shame you to do what you want.

Anyways you want Taliban to take over Afghan and are celebrating it you would have to deal with the fall out too as neighbor.India has cut its losses and done the best it could by protecting minorities of this country because they would suffer even more if they go to Pakistan. As simple as that.

Yes it does, a very warped version even Indians cant understand.

You claimed this is how the world works.

Only a Hindu extremist ruling power would say only Hindus and Sikhs can see asylum, because of their hatred for Muslims. You know this so accept it.

 

[Bewal Express]

India should open its doors to all those that supported Ghani. You can't have proxies and then betray them

 

[Giannis]

Ok. Fair enough. That’s your opinion. Let’s see what India does or how this situation pans out for everyone involved .

We're already seeing what India is doing - discriminating Afghans based off religion; betray their own allies because they lost their utility.

 

[Major]

So does [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] still consider his country to be secular?

 

[Kroll]

We have three million refugees already.

But how would a Muslim Indian feel about this?
Are they second class citizens

That's been long established.

 

[OldWarHorse]

Not impressed by this but then again not unexpected

 

[JaDed]

Because seeing the history they would be first ones to be targeted, so helping the minorities of a country is an issue now?

Also you can’t have your cake and eat it too, do Pakistani feel Taliban are dangerous to Afghan Muslims ? If they don’t feel that then you shouldn’t complain.

 

[Lego20]

Because seeing the history they would be first ones to be targeted, so helping the minorities of a country is an issue now?

Also you can’t have your cake and eat it too, do Pakistani feel Taliban are dangerous to Afghan Muslims ? If they don’t feel that then you shouldn’t complain.

checkmate

 

[Lego20]

Pakistan should actually introspect if Muslims decide to come to India over Pakistan - given its proximity and its reputation of being a heaven for Muslims.

 

[KingKhanWC]

Because seeing the history they would be first ones to be targeted, so helping the minorities of a country is an issue now?

Also you can’t have your cake and eat it too, do Pakistani feel Taliban are dangerous to Afghan Muslims ? If they don’t feel that then you shouldn’t complain.

Not sure what history is taught in Bombay but in the present reality the Taliban are attacking those who worked with the occupiers, almost every single one is a Muslim. They have also said Sikhs and Hindus will be not harmed.

Indians are fooling nobody, your RSS government hates Muslims, this is why it wants only others as refugees. Such a lame nation.

 

[Major]

Pakistan should actually introspect if Muslims decide to come to India over Pakistan - given its proximity and its reputation of being a heaven for Muslims.

India has been bringing in Afghanis for free health care, so why is the religion now an issue?

 

[Major]

It's actually a nice eye opener to those baighairut Afghans (in Pakistan, Afghanistan and all over the world) who pledged allegiance with India and do not leave any chance to defame and spew hate against Pakistan.

Hore Chupo .....

I am sure they will never learn cuz that's the nature of the backstabbers.

very pathetic post.

Afghanis do have reasons to support India over Pakistan for what the pakistan and its agencies have done to their country. Backing al qaeda and the talibs.

Yes Pakistan provided refuge, but underneath Pakistan damaged them through supporting such groups as the Taliban..

Calling every single afghani a backstabber shows ur racism against them

 

[JaDed]

Not sure what history is taught in Bombay but in the present reality the Taliban are attacking those who worked with the occupiers, almost every single one is a Muslim. They have also said Sikhs and Hindus will be not harmed.

Indians are fooling nobody, your RSS government hates Muslims, this is why it wants only others as refugees. Such a lame nation.

“For example, we’re expanding our partnership with the Manmeet Singh Bhullar Foundation to resettle hundreds of persecuted Afghan Sikhs and Hindus”

https://www.canada.ca/en/immigratio...-program-to-bring-more-afghans-to-safety.html

Lol sure sparky

 

[Lego20]

India has been bringing in Afghanis for free health care, so why is the religion now an issue?

Religious persecution based refugee is different from other immigration. CAA was institutionalized on the basis that the Hindu/Sikh/Jain etc minorities have no other countries to go if they face religious persecution. There is no use case for a neighboring muslim citizens to face religious persecution

Take the current scenario - where can the Sikhs and Hindus from Afghanistan go now that are likely to face religious persecution (asked to change/curtail their religious practices)? Muslims running away from Afghanistan at this point is not out of religious persecution (no one is/will ask them to change/convert their religion).

 

[KingKhanWC]

“For example, we’re expanding our partnership with the Manmeet Singh Bhullar Foundation to resettle hundreds of persecuted Afghan Sikhs and Hindus”

https://www.canada.ca/en/immigratio...-program-to-bring-more-afghans-to-safety.html

Lol sure sparky

lol Sure Canada know it all. Indians are great at I.t and googling but not so good at understanding reality.

You claimed India wants to help those in most need. Taliban are arresting/taking Muslims mostly.

Their spokesman has said Sikhs/Hindus will not be attacked. So your logic is no different to Modis. Its best India brings its own people back to Bollywood, they've done enough damage in Afghanistan, time to go f back home now.

 

[Bhaag Viru Bhaag]

While we are at it can we also send the afghan refugees living in India back to Afghanistan now? There are too many of them roaming around freely in India. I am pretty sure they will betray and abuse India just like they do to Pakistan.

 

[JaDed]

lol Sure Canada know it all. Indians are great at I.t and googling but not so good at understanding reality.

You claimed India wants to help those in most need. Taliban are arresting/taking Muslims mostly.

Their spokesman has said Sikhs/Hindus will not be attacked. So your logic is no different to Modis. Its best India brings its own people back to Bollywood, they've done enough damage in Afghanistan, time to go f back home now.

Aww ... you remain a goal post changer keep at it bruh!

I just showed you Canada is doing the same and they have the most Liberal govn in their history, I didn't have to google it was in news not my issue that you subscribe to Taliban times.

 

[KingKhanWC]

Aww ... you remain a goal post changer keep at it bruh!

I just showed you Canada is doing the same and they have the most Liberal govn in their history, I didn't have to google it was in news not my issue that you subscribe to Taliban times.

lol. Canada dont have a extremist RSS Hindu government who hates Pakistan. Its a simple but key difference. Just accept the reality of hate of your rules for Muslims. Do you think the RSS stands for ReallySoundSirs

 

[cricketjoshila]

I wonder how the 200 odd million Indian Muslims feel about this?

Are they not indians with equal rights?

Are Afghans Indian muslims?

How is this related to the rights of Indians?

 

[DeadlyVenom]

Its understandable.

India is only secular for Hindus and sikhs. When it comes to muslims their blood starts to boil.

Even on this site joshila etc call muslims invaders and theives.

 

[Ahmad-GERMANFC]

What about Pakistan though? Imran Khan has issues with islamophobia in France and Israel and he can’t help out the neighboring Muslims?

Lol clearly you don’t know much about Pakistan. Pakistan is already overrun with Afghan refugees

 

[Giannis]

Are Afghans Indian muslims?

How is this related to the rights of Indians?

Are Afghan hindus & sikhs, Indian citizens?

 

[Colorblind Genius]

very pathetic post.

Afghanis do have reasons to support India over Pakistan for what the pakistan and its agencies have done to their country. Backing al qaeda and the talibs.

Yes Pakistan provided refuge, but underneath Pakistan damaged them through supporting such groups as the Taliban..

Calling every single afghani a backstabber shows ur racism against them

No, read again, my post clearly has the word "THOSE", which means I am talking ONLY about "THOSE" Afghanis who are back stabbers ... and yes indeed, they can be found among Afghanis living in Pakistan, among Afghanis living Afghanistan and among Afghanis living anywhere else in the world.

Here in United States, we had to throw out such two Afghanis outside the masjid when they started cussing out at Pakistan with profanity INSIDE the masjid praying hall. And it happened just last week.

Yes, folks are free to express their political views... sorry but in the masjid or houses of worship.

 

[Local.Dada]

Are Afghan hindus & sikhs, Indian citizens?

No but they are the oppressed minorities of the neighboring country. Minority being the keyword. Say it 3 times so that it will hopefully stick. “Minority”

Muslims of Afghanistan,Pakistan and Bangladesh are not minorities. They should have enough laws and protections from countries that structure and follow their laws on Islam which is about brotherhood isn’t it? If not then you need to ask questions why that is not the case. Isn’t the duty of the ummah to look out for Muslims. I thought Pakistan sees itself as the torchbearer.

India itself is a country with lots of issues, why can’t it be selective where it wants to or afford to do good. It’s better than doing nothing.

You guys are clutching at straws here.

 

[Ahmad-GERMANFC]

No but they are the oppressed minorities of the neighboring country. Minority being the keyword. Say it 3 times so that it will hopefully stick. “Minority”

Muslims of Afghanistan,Pakistan and Bangladesh are not minorities. They should have enough laws and protections from countries that structure and follow their laws on Islam which is about brotherhood isn’t it? If not then you need to ask questions why that is not the case. Isn’t the duty of the ummah to look out for Muslims. I thought Pakistan sees itself as the torchbearer.

India itself is a country with lots of issues, why can’t it be selective where it wants to or afford to do good. It’s better than doing nothing.

You guys are clutching at straws here.

You are clutching at straws here lol.

Either state that india is a Hindu state and if it is then this is fine. Otherwise you make no sense

 

[Zaz]

Lol as expected from the RSS Aukaat dikadey

A big slap to all the afghans who thought india was their friend and pakistan their enemy

 

[KingKhanWC]

No but they are the oppressed minorities of the neighboring country. Minority being the keyword. Say it 3 times so that it will hopefully stick. “Minority”

Muslims of Afghanistan,Pakistan and Bangladesh are not minorities. They should have enough laws and protections from countries that structure and follow their laws on Islam which is about brotherhood isn’t it? If not then you need to ask questions why that is not the case. Isn’t the duty of the ummah to look out for Muslims. I thought Pakistan sees itself as the torchbearer.

India itself is a country with lots of issues, why can’t it be selective where it wants to or afford to do good. It’s better than doing nothing.

You guys are clutching at straws here.

See human rights reports of India's treatment of minoriites. Here is one example.

Hate crimes including violence against Dalits, Adivasi (Indigenous) communities and religious minorities were also committed with impunity. In September, a Dalit woman was allegedly raped and murdered by a group of dominant-caste men in Hathras district in Uttar Pradesh, and cremated by the Uttar Pradesh police without her family's consent. The accused men were arrested only after nationwide protests. Later, several FIRs were registered by the Uttar Pradesh police against protesters for criminal conspiracy and sedition.

https://www.amnesty.org/en/countries/asia-and-the-pacific/india/report-india/

Its like asking animals to come to poachers.

 

[KingKhanWC]

Lol as expected from the RSS Aukaat dikadey

A big slap to all the afghans who thought india was their friend and pakistan their enemy

Do you think Rashid Khan & the Afghan team will be given asylum? They were helped a lot previously by India.

 

[90MPH]

Do you think Rashid Khan & the Afghan team will be given asylum? They were helped a lot previously by India.

Rashid Khan resides in Dubai.

I doubt he will go back, probably most of them will not and live in either the Middle East or Pakistan.

Don’t see hardly any of them wanting to live in India, even if they were given asylum or leave to stay because of the current poltical climate there.

 

[KingKhanWC]

Rashid Khan resides in Dubai.

I doubt he will go back, probably most of them will not and live in either the Middle East or Pakistan.

Don’t see hardly any of them wanting to live in India, even if they were given asylum or leave to stay because of the current poltical climate there.

Makes sense. Rashid was openely attacking the Taliban.

Im sure Afghanistan will continue to have a cricket team. It might even be better! Pakistan will prob host them until things calm down in Afghanistan.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Its understandable.

India is only secular for Hindus and sikhs. When it comes to muslims their blood starts to boil.

Even on this site joshila etc call muslims invaders and theives.

I call the invaders, invaders. Be it from Central Asia or Arab or from Europe. They are all invaders and looters. Religion is immaterial.

FYI, Islam came to India long before these Invaders.

 

[cricketjoshila]

Are Afghan hindus & sikhs, Indian citizens?

Is there a country other than India in the neighborhood where these people will not be persecuted on the basis of their religion?

When a nation state was formed for Muslims in 1947, the burder to take care of the persecuted non muslims fell on India.

 

[Halaribo]

Aww ... you remain a goal post changer keep at it bruh!

I just showed you Canada is doing the same and they have the most Liberal govn in their history, I didn't have to google it was in news not my issue that you subscribe to Taliban times.

Sorry, but you have no clue what you're talking about, nor do you seem to be able to comprehend English.

In Canada, from what you yourself have posted, anybody can claim asylum. Within that process, there will be policies that will apply to various demographics, and a decision on their resettlement or granting of asylum will be made. That is the reality of most asylum systems. Examples of such instances include Syrian refugees, female Sudanese/Eritrean, Afghan Sikhs.

What India is doing is nothing like any other system. They are discriminating asylum/resettlement on religious grounds. It's as simple as that.

Who are you trying to fool?

 

[cricketjoshila]

Lol as expected from the RSS Aukaat dikadey

A big slap to all the afghans who thought india was their friend and pakistan their enemy

Lots of Afghans, muslims, landed in India yesterday.

 

[cricketjoshila]

See human rights reports of India's treatment of minoriites. Here is one example.



https://www.amnesty.org/en/countries/asia-and-the-pacific/india/report-india/

Its like asking animals to come to poachers.

Amnesty is literally banned in India. Facing various criminal cases for violating laws.

Reports by NGOs. Lol.

 

[Local.Dada]

Do you think Rashid Khan & the Afghan team will be given asylum? They were helped a lot previously by India.

Well we did give Adnani Sami citizenship even though he was a Pakistani at that point wasn’t he?

Achievers of any religion shouldn’t have a problem.

Now of course we want to do something as much as our capacity allows, so we will pick the tab on the oppressed minorities, sorry can’t afford everyone as you yourself remind us india has poor people and toilet issues. Still it is commendable that we take the initiative with the minority issue and hope and wish others take care of their brethren too. Remember we need to unite at this time against radical forces that are driving away these poor Muslims. Cmon india has done its thing, now hope Pakistan show the true meaning of Islamic brotherhood.

 

[Local.Dada]

This is a great opportunity for Imran Khan. He wanted to start a Islamic tv channel for Muslims, didnt he? I am sure bringing Malaysia and Turkey and maybe some other Islamic countries together to place these displaced Afghani Muslims would be a great intitative and more useful than a Tv channel.

Also he will show them naziesque RSS a thing or 2 about dealing with refugees.

Minorities we already got them, discrimination or not.

 

[KingKhanWC]

Well we did give Adnani Sami citizenship even though he was a Pakistani at that point wasn’t he?

Achievers of any religion shouldn’t have a problem.

Now of course we want to do something as much as our capacity allows, so we will pick the tab on the oppressed minorities, sorry can’t afford everyone as you yourself remind us india has poor people and toilet issues. Still it is commendable that we take the initiative with the minority issue and hope and wish others take care of their brethren too. Remember we need to unite at this time against radical forces that are driving away these poor Muslims. Cmon india has done its thing, now hope Pakistan show the true meaning of Islamic brotherhood.

India cannot pretend to care about minorities when it has one of the worst records in history towards minorities. Not just Muslims or Christians, but Hindu Dalits. Not just a few but millions have been abused, disriminated against for generations. If India had a better record & wasnt run by RSS extremists, people might take this more seriously.

Adnan Sami is ISI and I thought your toilet issues were a thing of the past now.

 

[KingKhanWC]

Amnesty is literally banned in India. Facing various criminal cases for violating laws.

Reports by NGOs. Lol.

OF course RSS would ban it. You can try multiple other human rights groups, they all say the same.

When millions of Dalits are discriminated against, Afghan Sikhs and Afghan Hindus will meet a similar destiny.

 

[Pakpak]

The afghans abroad, especially in England are fairly liberal and open minded. Good, decent community. I don’t think they are the type that want to be a part of an extremist regime. Most people in Afghanistan will definitely want out

Not sure which Afghans you've met, the ones I have seen abroad might be abroad but they are still the same when it comes to mentality.

Another poor jab at liberals absolutely needlessly.

 

[Kroll]

Well we did give Adnani Sami citizenship even though he was a Pakistani at that point wasn’t he?

Achievers of any religion shouldn’t have a problem.

Now of course we want to do something as much as our capacity allows, so we will pick the tab on the oppressed minorities, sorry can’t afford everyone as you yourself remind us india has poor people and toilet issues. Still it is commendable that we take the initiative with the minority issue and hope and wish others take care of their brethren too. Remember we need to unite at this time against radical forces that are driving away these poor Muslims. Cmon india has done its thing, now hope Pakistan show the true meaning of Islamic brotherhood.

Remember Sami was born in London, whilst his father was Pakistani, his mother was Indian so that's why he didn't form the strongest of bonds with Pakistan. Not to mention, he's main earning was coming from Bollywood so he had to keep the Indians sweet.

However young man, you have a lot to learn: Sami is a spy working for the Pakistani intelligence services and this is a well established fact.

The Pakistani authorities have to continuously give him a dressing down due the OTT and frequency of his bitter rants on social media as this may give the game away.

 

[Colorblind Genius]

Well we did give Adnani Sami citizenship even though he was a Pakistani at that point wasn’t he?

Achievers of any religion shouldn’t have a problem.

Now of course we want to do something as much as our capacity allows, so we will pick the tab on the oppressed minorities, sorry can’t afford everyone as you yourself remind us india has poor people and toilet issues. Still it is commendable that we take the initiative with the minority issue and hope and wish others take care of their brethren too. Remember we need to unite at this time against radical forces that are driving away these poor Muslims. Cmon india has done its thing, now hope Pakistan show the true meaning of Islamic brotherhood.

Adnan Sami's case was primarily based on his mother's citizenship, no?

And did you forget the kind of pleas and court cases he had to go through? I think it was an outlier.

 

[Giannis]

Adnan Sami's case was primarily based on his mother's citizenship, no?

And did you forget the kind of pleas and court cases he had to go through? I think it was an outlier.

No his mother was Pakistan, a refugee of the Jammu massacre where Muslims were turned into a minority.

 

[Giannis]

Well we did give Adnani Sami citizenship even though he was a Pakistani at that point wasn’t he?

Achievers of any religion shouldn’t have a problem.

Now of course we want to do something as much as our capacity allows, so we will pick the tab on the oppressed minorities, sorry can’t afford everyone as you yourself remind us india has poor people and toilet issues. Still it is commendable that we take the initiative with the minority issue and hope and wish others take care of their brethren too. Remember we need to unite at this time against radical forces that are driving away these poor Muslims. Cmon india has done its thing, now hope Pakistan show the true meaning of Islamic brotherhood.

india is also an extremely classist and castiest society, they would prefer giving citizenship to rich celebrities like Adnan Sami rather than destitute Afghan refugees.

 

[guna]

India should also allow all progressive Afghanis irrespective of religion.

 

[Local.Dada]

india is also an extremely classist and castiest society, they would prefer giving citizenship to rich celebrities like Adnan Sami rather than destitute Afghan refugees.

I can tell this with 100% utmost faith, that none of the Afghan minorities will be affluent families.

Yes rich celebrities sure. Which country doesn’t want more rich and successful people as citizens?

 

[Colorblind Genius]

No his mother was Pakistan, a refugee of the Jammu massacre where Muslims were turned into a minority.

His mother technically had Indian citizenship by birth if I remember correctly. And that was the base on Adnan Sami's case in the court to get Indian citizenship.

 

[Giannis]

I can tell this with 100% utmost faith, that none of the Afghan minorities will be affluent families.

Yes rich celebrities sure. Which country doesn’t want more rich and successful people as citizens?

The entire Western and Muslim world takes poor refugees. You're admitting that India is a classist society and Afghan Muslims can only get asylum in India if they can buy it.

 

[KingKhanWC]

India should also allow all progressive Afghanis irrespective of religion.

As a staunch supporter of secularism, why would you want an religious exremist government to take care of minorities lol.

 

[guna]

As a staunch supporter of secularism, why would you want an religious exremist government to take care of minorities lol.

I don’t care about BJP or Congress or whoever is sitting in Delhi. I would definitely want educated progressive Afghans in India. You can always use doctors, physicians, teachers and professors. They should al be welcomed.

 

[KingKhanWC]

I don’t care about BJP or Congress or whoever is sitting in Delhi. I would definitely want educated progressive Afghans in India. You can always use doctors, physicians, teachers and professors. They should al be welcomed.

You seem to be concerned for India not the refugees. You're ok with Hindu extremists who hate their own Dalit Hindus taking in people who not even Indian.

Now you only want highly skilled proffessionals to enter. If you need medical help I understand but you dont care about people from war torn countries and I think you are being an apologist for RSS extremists. Funny guy

 

[PakLFC]

India should worry about it's own minorities. Non Muslim's of Afghanistan will be fine under Taliban rule. The Talibs would have learnt from mistakes made from their previous rule. Afghan's need to keep their educated people to progress not letting them go to other countries.

 

[Technics 1210]

LOL at India wants highly skilled professionals; skilled Indians are fleeing 'incredible' India in their droves as it is!