What's new

India says doors open to Afghan's Sikh and Hindu minorities

India should take in Muslims from Afghanistan as well. Most people in Afghanistan, especially the Kabul elite, like India. They are your friends, dont abandon them in their time of need.
 
Should India let the fleeing puppet ANA land their helicopters in India?

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Afghan air force flees en masse: Uzbekistan SHOOTS DOWN one fighter plane and forces another FORTY SIX helicopters and planes to land carrying 600 Afghan soldiers <a href="https://t.co/e8hQSjaTcJ">https://t.co/e8hQSjaTcJ</a></p>— Jack Posobiec &#55356;&#56826;&#55356;&#56824; (@JackPosobiec) <a href="https://twitter.com/JackPosobiec/status/1427408200207372289?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">August 16, 2021</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
KingKhanWC said:
India cannot pretend to care about minorities when it has one of the worst records in history towards minorities. Not just Muslims or Christians, but Hindu Dalits. Not just a few but millions have been abused, disriminated against for generations. If India had a better record & wasnt run by RSS extremists, people might take this more seriously.

Adnan Sami is ISI and I thought your toilet issues were a thing of the past now.
Click to expand...

Still Rohingyas, Bangladeshis, Afghans all want to come to India. Wonder why!

How are the toilet issues in pakistan?
 
Rather than telling Indians what we should do, why dont pakistanis ask imran to take in refugees from afghanistan

Another islamic nation, BD just refused to take any refugees.
 
There are 56 Islamic countries in the world. Weird that Pakistanis want fellow Muslim refugees to live under a Hindutva government.

So is there a real concern for Afghan Muslims or is this a chance of point scoring against India?

I mean Pakistan has a refugee issue and economic problems but they want Kashmir another area we’re they won’t get ready made intellectual Muslims but a lot of backward types who have been pushed back due to years or conflict. They see no issues with Uyghur Muslims because it is Chinas problem.

Now suddenly the advocacy for Afghan Muslims seems like it is always about point scoring from a india centric POV than actual care for the ummah I guess.

Now on the flip side we see a lot of Taliban support posts as well.

Make whatever of that :)
 
KingKhanWC said:
You seem to be concerned for India not the refugees. You're ok with Hindu extremists who hate their own Dalit Hindus taking in people who not even Indian.

Now you only want highly skilled proffessionals to enter. If you need medical help I understand but you dont care about people from war torn countries and I think you are being an apologist for RSS extremists. Funny guy :)
Click to expand...

You cannot take in any random Afghan from tribal areas as many of them could be Taliban themselves and there will be no way to verify those people. India will never invite a messy situation which can hurt them for decades.

No one hates Dalits in India. They have a stigma attached to them as they are considered impure as they are not considered part of caste system.

India should take all Afghan people who worked with India in various projects. Those guys will not be safe under Taliban. India is not a rich country which can take millions of refugees. The incoming refugees need to be skilled enough to work and support themselves. If you bring unskilled and illiterate refugees, it will lead to crime and exploitation. Young women will be exploited the most.

Pakistan already has KPK which has the same culture as Afghans and they also speak the same language. It is natural for these refugees to adjust easily in KPK.
 
One more thing is, if Taliban are freedom fighters and enjoy so much public support like you try to portray them, then why are Afghan civilians fleeing the country? That makes no sense.
 
guna said:
One more thing is, if Taliban are freedom fighters and enjoy so much public support like you try to portray them, then why are Afghan civilians fleeing the country? That makes no sense.
Click to expand...

Probably for the same reason that India is allegedly shining but people still flee in droves.

When it comes to 3rd world countries any opportunity for a way out is taken
 
DeadlyVenom said:
Probably for the same reason that India is allegedly shining but people still flee in droves.

When it comes to 3rd world countries any opportunity for a way out is taken
Click to expand...

So all Afghan refugees are economic migrants? Nothing to do with Taliban then :)))
 
India announces emergency e-visa for Afghans

All Afghans, irrespective of their religion, can apply for the ‘e-Emergency X-Misc Visa’ online and the applications will be processed in New Delhi
India on August 17 announced that it will issue an emergency e-visa to Afghan nationals who want to come to the country in view of the prevailing situation in Afghanistan after the Taliban captured power there.

All Afghans, irrespective of their religion, can apply for the ‘e-Emergency X-Misc Visa’ online and the applications will be processed in New Delhi.


The announcement came two days after the Taliban captured power in Afghanistan.

“The MHA reviews visa provisions in view of the current situation in Afghanistan. A new category of electronic visa called ‘e-Emergency X-Misc Visa’ introduced to fast-track visa applications for entry into India,” a Home Ministry spokesperson said.

Officials said since Indian missions in Afghanistan are shut, the visa can be applied online and applications will be examined and processed in New Delhi.

The visa will initially be valid for six months, they said.


Security issues will be looked into while processing the applications and granting the visa to Afghan nationals, the officials said.

All Afghans, irrespective of their religion, can apply for the travel document.

Thousands of Afghans rushed into Kabul’s main airport on August 16, some so desperate to escape the Taliban that they held onto a military jet as it took off and plunged to their deaths.

At least seven people died in the chaos, U.S. officials said, as America’s longest war ended with its enemy the victor.

The crowds came while the Taliban enforced their rule over the capital of five million people after a lightning advance across the country that took just over a week to dethrone the country’s Western-backed government.

There were no major reports of abuses or fighting, but many residents stayed home and remained fearful after the insurgents’ advance saw prisons emptied and armories looted.


https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/india-announces-emergency-e-visa-for-afghans/article35952475.ece
 
Good move, anyone needing assistance irrespective of their religion should be given asylum
 
Haha.. How are they planning to help them once they are here? Unemployment rate is growing and they want to dump more poor people here? It's not like their life is going to change drastically in India.
 
Balthazar said:
Haha.. How are they planning to help them once they are here? Unemployment rate is growing and they want to dump more poor people here? It's not like their life is going to change drastically in India.
Click to expand...

Its going to be a huge mess. Hope the incoming Afghan refugees are not exploited by local goons.
 
guna said:
So all Afghan refugees are economic migrants? Nothing to do with Taliban then :)))
Click to expand...

Were people fleeing under the US administation in Afghanistan?

Taliban have given people an excuse to flee and who can blame them? But they are fleeing for better opportunities and will continue whether its Taliban, Ghani, Hamid Karzai or if Biden himself takes over.
 
DeadlyVenom said:
Were people fleeing under the US administation in Afghanistan?

Taliban have given people an excuse to flee and who can blame them? But they are fleeing for better opportunities and will continue whether its Taliban, Ghani, Hamid Karzai or if Biden himself takes over.
Click to expand...

People flee when there are atrocities committed on them and they see no hope in the future. Taliban are not an excuse. They are the reason for all this mess.
 
guna said:
People flee when there are atrocities committed on them and they see no hope in the future. Taliban are not an excuse. They are the reason for all this mess.
Click to expand...

People are running in droves from Asia. Asylumn seekers from India are 1000% per higher in the past 10 years and every second Pakistani claims to be ahmedi or Christian to get to the UK.

This is the reality of the subcontinent and is overly simplistic to blame the Taliban for people leaving Afganistan.
 
DeadlyVenom said:
People are running in droves from Asia. Asylumn seekers from India are 1000% per higher in the past 10 years and every second Pakistani claims to be ahmedi or Christian to get to the UK.

This is the reality of the subcontinent and is overly simplistic to blame the Taliban for people leaving Afganistan.
Click to expand...

Not like the way they are trying to flee Afghanistan. Poor Afghans were trying to hang on to the wheels of US Aircraft carrier and fell to their death from thousands of feet in the sky. No economic immigrant is that desperate even though they know that death is 100% guaranteed.
 
I think India should take care of its own minorities first and try to improve their life rather than worrying about minorities of other countries. Even if Hindus and sikhs from Pakistan or Afghanistans come to India they will be treated no better than dalits here in India. :inti
 
India is allowing muslims as well. Probably only those who were working with Indian embassy and friendly leaders to India and students who are studying in india.
 
Rana said:
So what about the Muslims who don’t want none of it either?
Click to expand...
I think india should open their borders to all who wish to flee the hell hole. As much United States. I can’t speak for Pakistan as I am not a sovereign of that state.
 
cricketjoshila said:
Still Rohingyas, Bangladeshis, Afghans all want to come to India. Wonder why!

How are the toilet issues in pakistan?
Click to expand...

All? lol. Those escaping death/war will go anywhere.

If you dont care about your own Dalit Hindus, you wont care about anyone else.

No toilet issues esp in the rivers of Pakistan.
 
At times like these one realizes the importance of CAA/NRC bills. Cant believe liberals were arguing against it. Their stupidity has been proven again but its something we are used to it.

Ofcourse we cant take many refugees as India is a hugely populated country but India should help Hindus/Sikhs from Afg as much as they can. It is our moral responsibility and one expect the present govt to do the right thing (as always).

As far as muslims are concerned, I have total sympathy with them. But there are many islamic countries in the world where they can go and settle in. India is intolerant country anyway. But Hindus/Sikhs have no where to go and India must help them.
 
Off Topic. Will India at any stage recognise Taliban Government? As per news they had backdoor contacts just recently. But I believe they had made some kind of law that they will never recognise them after Indian plane hijack incident. Correct me if I am wrong.
 
Rajdeep said:
At times like these one realizes the importance of CAA/NRC bills. Cant believe liberals were arguing against it. Their stupidity has been proven again but its something we are used to it.

Ofcourse we cant take many refugees as India is a hugely populated country but India should help Hindus/Sikhs from Afg as much as they can. It is our moral responsibility and one expect the present govt to do the right thing (as always).

As far as muslims are concerned, I have total sympathy with them. But there are many islamic countries in the world where they can go and settle in. India is intolerant country anyway. But Hindus/Sikhs have no where to go and India must help them.
Click to expand...

CAA has a cut of date of December 31, 2014. So it would not help Hindu and Sikhs in Afghanistan.
 
Local.Dada said:
There are 56 Islamic countries in the world. Weird that Pakistanis want fellow Muslim refugees to live under a Hindutva government.

So is there a real concern for Afghan Muslims or is this a chance of point scoring against India?

I mean Pakistan has a refugee issue and economic problems but they want Kashmir another area we’re they won’t get ready made intellectual Muslims but a lot of backward types who have been pushed back due to years or conflict. They see no issues with Uyghur Muslims because it is Chinas problem.

Now suddenly the advocacy for Afghan Muslims seems like it is always about point scoring from a india centric POV than actual care for the ummah I guess.

Now on the flip side we see a lot of Taliban support posts as well.

Make whatever of that :)
Click to expand...

Perhaps they want the Muslim population in India to increase, so Hindutva governments cant come into power in the future.
 
Gharib Aadmi said:
CAA has a cut of date of December 31, 2014. So it would not help Hindu and Sikhs in Afghanistan.
Click to expand...

That cut of date can be changed anytime. Its not as if its written in stone and cant be changed. Amendement to bills is just a parliament session away.
 
Gharib Aadmi said:
Perhaps they want the Muslim population in India to increase, so Hindutva governments cant come into power in the future.
Click to expand...

That’s one of the dumbest things I have heard.:)))

Let me understand this, as per you People in Pakistan want India to take Afghan Muslim refugees so that in few years time they can become citizens or have kids who grow up and after 18 years throw BJP government by voting :))

Get a life would be a good advice to start with right there.
 
Whichever power was supporting Taliban in taking over Afghanistan has blood on its hands. Thousands have died due to their actions.
 
Rana said:
The afghans abroad, especially in England are fairly liberal and open minded. Good, decent community. I don’t think they are the type that want to be a part of an extremist regime. Most people in Afghanistan will definitely want out
Click to expand...

That’s just simply not true.

The vast majority of Afghans in the UK are Pashtuns and they tend to be very conservative overall. I’ve met many of them and they don’t hide about their views either.

However there are non Pashtun Afghans who are generally more educated and have a much more liberal mindset but I have seen only a handful of them in the UK.
 
Ask the Pakistani Hindu's who went to India how poorly they were treated. So many have returned and are happy to be back.
 
guna said:
Whichever power was supporting Taliban in taking over Afghanistan has blood on its hands. Thousands have died due to their actions.
Click to expand...

Don't be daft! America and NATO have killed in one day what the Taliban did during their entire previous rule. Real thing is you wanted America to remain in Afghanistan because it suited India. Many countries have interests in Afghanistan. Ultimately, no one could support the Talib's if they didn't want to be.
 
PakLFC said:
Don't be daft! America and NATO have killed in one day what the Taliban did during their entire previous rule. Real thing is you wanted America to remain in Afghanistan because it suited India. Many countries have interests in Afghanistan. Ultimately, no one could support the Talib's if they didn't want to be.
Click to expand...

So since Nayo and US killed a few thousand people, it’s okay for Taliban and their bosses kill a few thousands too.

At least NATO and US target Taliban terrorists. They get their target wrong and kill some innocents too. But look at Taliban who attack innocent Afghans by blowing themselves up in crowded places.

Before calling someone daft, think about what would be better for future generations of Afghans. A democracy and secular society which encourages science and talent or some illiterate mullah running the country and making people suffer.
 
cricketjoshila said:
Amnesty is literally banned in India. Facing various criminal cases for violating laws.

Reports by NGOs. Lol.
Click to expand...
That’s Modi for you. Be critical of him and his cult of inbred imbeciles descend upon you. The day this totalitarian leader buys the farm will be a day finally india can emerge from the shadow of pseu democracy and rejoin the rest of the democratic world.
 
guna said:
So since Nayo and US killed a few thousand people, it’s okay for Taliban and their bosses kill a few thousands too.

At least NATO and US target Taliban terrorists. They get their target wrong and kill some innocents too. But look at Taliban who attack innocent Afghans by blowing themselves up in crowded places.

Before calling someone daft, think about what would be better for future generations of Afghans. A democracy and secular society which encourages science and talent or some illiterate mullah running the country and making people suffer.
Click to expand...

It is not a few thousands but much more that the Americans have killed if we start counting the 70 thousand Pakistanis that died after the USA invasion of Afghanistan. Taliban killed very few if any by comparison.

The terrorists and invaders were NATO and the Americans not the sons of the soil. You do realise that America plays on both sides as liberator then attacks innocents to further its own agenda. The idea being an excuse to remain in the country by instigating and planning more attacks.

I have thought about it that let the Afghans decide what they want not Pakistan, India or America. Other then the occupational forces and their supporters no one else is leaving Afghanistan, there is no refugee crises in Pak or blood on the streets of Kabul. Why do you have a problem with an Islamic system if that is what they want to implement when you know nothing about what it is??. Islamic encourages progress on every level too, if you want an illiterate then look no further then your own Modi. The problem you have is the Taliban reject westernization of their society.

Talk sense if you don't want me to call you such things.
 
Last edited:
Time for Pro Indian Afghanis arriving into India to face the reality

The anti Muslim CAA law passed in 2019, now bars these Muslims (by name) pro Indian Afghanis to pursue Indian Citizenship.

India also does not have any specific constitutional policy or obligation towards a refugees.

India is only among the very few countries that do not have any national refugee protection frame work, nor does it have immigration policy.

India is under no obligation to provide rights set out to refugees. They only have an option to provide visas to refugees on ad-hoc basis, and that's it.

Let these Afghan refugees wreck havoc in India cuz that's what many of them are good at.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Bhaag Viru Bhaag
‘Protection of Muslim minorities in majority Hindu India worth mentioning’: Obama to Biden
Replies
3
Views
742
Champ_Pal
C
MenInG
US says some Indian officials ignoring or supporting attacks on minorities
Replies
1
Views
495
MenInG
MenInG
Hitman
India home to great diversity of faiths; will continue to encourage to uphold religious freedom: US
Replies
12
Views
2K
BouncerGuy
BouncerGuy
cricketjoshila
Abducted, shackled and forced to marry at 12
Replies
32
Views
2K
BouncerGuy
BouncerGuy
A
Britain to take up ‘persecution’ of religious minorities in India
Replies
67
Views
3K
Cpt. Rishwat
Cpt. Rishwat
Back
Top