I'm not sure whether anyone has noticed, but the revised itinerary for the Indian tour of Australia has ended up being completely defined by state Coronavirus policy.
If we exempt Victoria (Melbourne) which has done better than any other place in the world at taming a major outbreak of Coronavirus (100+ days of lockdown leading to barely any daily community transmission),then there is a clear pattern in Australia:
LABOUR STATES (Western Australia and Queensland) have set a goal of complete elimination of Coronavirus. They have not just got closed international borders, but closed domestic borders too, and the result is that life and economic activity are practically normal. Masks are neither required nor worn, and only the international and interstate tourism sectors of the economy are damaged. Sports events such as the recent AFL Grand Final take place with virtually fully stadia, like in New Zealand, but minimal risk.
LIBERAL STATES (South Australia, New South Wales and Tasmania) have aimed only to suppress rather than eliminate the virus. Like the other states, they rely upon mandatory 14 day $2800 supervised hotel quarantine from overseas arrivals to keep the virus out of the community, and they then leave interstate travel largely intact, and rely upon aggressive testing and contact tracing to put out outbreaks before they spread.
The theory is that the Liberal states would suffer less economic damage but the Labour states would have fewer Coronavirus outbreaks. The reality is that the Labour states have actually suffered less economic damage, and that their tourist sectors have done better than most overseas. This is because Australians are banned from overseas travel until the Pandemic ends, and in the WA tourist hub of Broome and the Queensland tourist hub of Cairns, travelers from the state capital are taking holidays there because they can't travel overseas or even interstate and so Broome and Cairns are relatively OK considering a pandemic is in full swing.
This has now determined how the itinerary for the Indian tour has had to be rewritten.
Australia requires mandatory 14 days supervised hotel quarantine for all arrivals from overseas - including the IPL. The one place where this was executed laxly was Melbourne, which led to a second wave which caused 90% of the country's Coronavirus deaths.
The traditional starting points of tours to Australia are Perth and Brisbane. Both states told Cricket Australia and the BCCI that their teams are welcome to arrive there but would be required to undertake their 14 days of mandatory hotel quarantine, with no exemption to leave the hotel premises until their quarantine was complete.
New South Wales and South Australia have offered less strict quarantine, including the right to travel to and train at cricket grounds during the quarantine period, and so the tour's itinerary has been changed, with Queensland ceasing to host the beginning of the tour.
There are now:
7 matches in New South Wales (and its enclave the Australian Capital Territory).
1 Test in Adelaide
1 Test in Melbourne
1 Test in Brisbane (which may not take place, as the border to New South Wales is currently closed, with 14 days mandatory hotel quarantine upon arrival in Queensland) The Sydney Test ends on 11 January and the Brisbane one is scheduled for 15 January - the Brisbane one will clearly not take place unless NSW improves its performance in eliminating community transmission of Coronavirus.
If we exempt Victoria (Melbourne) which has done better than any other place in the world at taming a major outbreak of Coronavirus (100+ days of lockdown leading to barely any daily community transmission),then there is a clear pattern in Australia:
LABOUR STATES (Western Australia and Queensland) have set a goal of complete elimination of Coronavirus. They have not just got closed international borders, but closed domestic borders too, and the result is that life and economic activity are practically normal. Masks are neither required nor worn, and only the international and interstate tourism sectors of the economy are damaged. Sports events such as the recent AFL Grand Final take place with virtually fully stadia, like in New Zealand, but minimal risk.
LIBERAL STATES (South Australia, New South Wales and Tasmania) have aimed only to suppress rather than eliminate the virus. Like the other states, they rely upon mandatory 14 day $2800 supervised hotel quarantine from overseas arrivals to keep the virus out of the community, and they then leave interstate travel largely intact, and rely upon aggressive testing and contact tracing to put out outbreaks before they spread.
The theory is that the Liberal states would suffer less economic damage but the Labour states would have fewer Coronavirus outbreaks. The reality is that the Labour states have actually suffered less economic damage, and that their tourist sectors have done better than most overseas. This is because Australians are banned from overseas travel until the Pandemic ends, and in the WA tourist hub of Broome and the Queensland tourist hub of Cairns, travelers from the state capital are taking holidays there because they can't travel overseas or even interstate and so Broome and Cairns are relatively OK considering a pandemic is in full swing.
This has now determined how the itinerary for the Indian tour has had to be rewritten.
Australia requires mandatory 14 days supervised hotel quarantine for all arrivals from overseas - including the IPL. The one place where this was executed laxly was Melbourne, which led to a second wave which caused 90% of the country's Coronavirus deaths.
The traditional starting points of tours to Australia are Perth and Brisbane. Both states told Cricket Australia and the BCCI that their teams are welcome to arrive there but would be required to undertake their 14 days of mandatory hotel quarantine, with no exemption to leave the hotel premises until their quarantine was complete.
New South Wales and South Australia have offered less strict quarantine, including the right to travel to and train at cricket grounds during the quarantine period, and so the tour's itinerary has been changed, with Queensland ceasing to host the beginning of the tour.
There are now:
7 matches in New South Wales (and its enclave the Australian Capital Territory).
1 Test in Adelaide
1 Test in Melbourne
1 Test in Brisbane (which may not take place, as the border to New South Wales is currently closed, with 14 days mandatory hotel quarantine upon arrival in Queensland) The Sydney Test ends on 11 January and the Brisbane one is scheduled for 15 January - the Brisbane one will clearly not take place unless NSW improves its performance in eliminating community transmission of Coronavirus.
