What's new

Is Umar Akmal the Mohammad Sami of batting?

Savak

World Star
Joined
Feb 16, 2006
Runs
50,161
Post of the Week
3
Over the last 4 years or so, his batting has deteriorated so badly and pathetically, he does not even look international class in Domestic Cricket either. He looks much fitter now and has lost weight but apart from that, i think he is just content with playing domestic cricket, international T-20 leagues but doesn't really have the hunger to play cricket for Pakistan anymore in any format.
 
Atleast Mohammad Sami has a hattrick
 
Last edited:
Waiting for a Rohit Sharma like resurgence for Umar Akmal. Haters , humble pies are ready backstage.
 
Fair comparison.

Both relied on their talent coming into international cricket and never changed their ways. Sami's pace dropped and Akmal's weaknesses were found out.

In Sami's defence, only his cricketing IQ was low. Akmal's IQ on and off the field is low.
 
Last year he averaged 75+ in PSL and National t20 has had fitness issues this year been more inconsistent but the next PSL is crucial for his international career and also depends on Mickey and Sarfraz whether they give him backing.
 
Last year he averaged 75+ in PSL and National t20 has had fitness issues this year been more inconsistent but the next PSL is crucial for his international career and also depends on Mickey and Sarfraz whether they give him backing.

If a guy who has been playing international cricket for the better part of a decade still needs 'backing' like a school kid then we know that we are wasting our time and money on a useless player. 9 years are more than enough time to assess a player. Umar Akmal has a grand total of two or three innings of note to show for his entire career. Heck constant flopper Shahid Afridi had better output in a year than Akmal had in his career.
 
If a guy who has been playing international cricket for the better part of a decade still needs 'backing' like a school kid then we know that we are wasting our time and money on a useless player. 9 years are more than enough time to assess a player. Umar Akmal has a grand total of two or three innings of note to show for his entire career. Heck constant flopper Shahid Afridi had better output in a year than Akmal had in his career.

Don't insult Lala by that comparison.
 
Pace dropped? Sami's pace was never an issue at any point...

Absolutely was.

He came in hitting 155 KPH+.

As his career went on, he settled into the mid 140s. Quick but not rapid enough to overcome his inability to have a controlled line and length.
 
Sami's pace was not the issue, it was his loss of swing with the new ball and loss of reverse swing with the old ball. When he first started his career from 2001 to 2003, you see him operate at 136-140 km/hr but he could swing the new ball and then reverse swing the old ball and that was when he was a threat to the batsman. It was 2003 onwards that Sami started to crank it up to around 144-155 km/hr and unfortunately that was his downfall where he focused more on speed and completely forgot how to swing the new ball and reverse swing the old ball.

I compared his bowling action from 2001 to 2003 and from 2004 onwards and its like he literally developed "hips" similar to Steven Finn where he forgot how to use his wrists to get swing and with the loss of his swing, his pace whether he was bowling at 136 or 148-150 km/hr plus became irrelevant. Plus he was not consistently quick like an Akhtar or Lee anyways. He didn't have a good consistent bouncer and the loss of swing killed his bowling and ofcourse being mauled every day in International Cricket, habitual failure takes a big toll on your confidence and self belief.

He confirmed to Pakpassion in an interview that he himself decided to cut down on his run up to stay injury free. I remember an Osman Samiuddin article where he made a very telling point where he mentioned that Sami never really had the desire to be a succcessful international cricketer, he was someone who just liked to go with the flow and treat things like a day to day job, most Pakistani players when they get dropped from the team, they either whine in the media, lobby with their favorite sports journalists, go to meet the PCB chairman, the selectors, lobby with their domestic coaches as part of efforts to get back in favor and into the team, while it was commendable that Sami who never did these activities ever and went back to Domestic Cricket, it is also proof that perhaps being dropped from the national team never really hurt him, that he was not hungry enough to be successful in the game and that he felt that he was good for nothing but domestic cricket basically.

Biggest tragedy in Pakistan Cricket. Even Imran Khan tried his best to help him but to no avail.
 
Mental fragility can also be mentioned as a reason for Sami's downfall.

"He has been playing for 11 years but if you tick [Sami] off once he loses focus and comes under pressure" - Shoaib Akhtar.

Maybe a good sports psychologist could have helped.
 
Absolutely was.

He came in hitting 155 KPH+.

As his career went on, he settled into the mid 140s. Quick but not rapid enough to overcome his inability to have a controlled line and length.

No bowler in history has consistently clocked 155+, Sami might have bowler mid to upper 140s but always was able to dip into the 150s which is as fast as practically anyone so I'll repeat, unless you think he was bowling every delivery in domestics at 160, that his speed was not an issue
 
No bowler in history has consistently clocked 155+, Sami might have bowler mid to upper 140s but always was able to dip into the 150s which is as fast as practically anyone so I'll repeat, unless you think he was bowling every delivery in domestics at 160, that his speed was not an issue

I'm talking about top speed.

Sami was never able to get back to his top speed (barring the odd delivery) after that initial burst in international cricket. It was the fact he could dip into the mid 150s that let him get away with a lack of control.

Similar to Shaun Tait in his prime.

I'm not suggesting speed was the main issue but it was the reason he eventually couldn't mask his inefficiencies. The lack of control was always there even when he was young. The top speed dropped by 5-8 KPH and everything fell apart for him.

Unless you think Sami had control and then lost it, a drop in speed was the thing that killed his career.
 
Last edited:
Umar can still come back and make some runs , he still has some chance , but time is running out. He needs to sort out his mental state , and put in some effort. talent he still has to score big runs.
 
No chance, Junior can only dream of averaging 50+ in tests :sami
 
A prime Sami was a good bowler in ODI's and was unfairly treated at times in that format due to his performances in Tests.
 
Not at all. Sami at least came across as a nice guy who just had poor mental strength and wasn't able to do justice to his natural talent.

Umar on the other hand has attitude issues and come across as a "shoha bacha". How many controversies has he been involved with? Too many to count. Just recently after being dropped he tried to take down the head coach.

Umar behaves like as if he is entitled to a spot in the team.

The only common thing is that both failed to improve on their shortcomings but looking at the bigger picture there is no commonality.

As a fan the emotions are different upon hearing the name Sami in contrast to Umar Akmal.
 
Having said that Sami helped win a few matchces, he also helped lose lot of matches. You just have to revisit the very old match threads where he played
 
As some what a Sami fan early on & a Umar fan too again early years but i feel Sami (a massive underachiever internationaly) still way better then this clown
 
Talent wise!! Both are same!! Both are massive underachiever,but umar still can turnaround his fortunes,he is still young!!
 
Umar is a combination of arrogance and lack of confidence. If I had that guy in my team, I would have made him perform way better than this by playing him to his strength.

Sami however got the eternal problem of throwing an over ruining banana after ever 4 5 balls.
 
What an insult for Sami!!! Sami still have talent to make it to our side. Umar Akmal was never a reliable batsman. Even Mohammad Rizwan or Anwar Ali or Hammad is better batsman than him. Only in Pakistan player like him can get so many chances.
 
Back
Top