What's new

Ishaq Dar’s legacy: a heavily-indebted Pakistan

WebGuru

Senior ODI Player
Joined
Mar 4, 2013
Runs
21,339
Post of the Week
3
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan’s total debt and liabilities swelled to an alarming level of Rs25.1 trillion by June this year – with a net increase of Rs2.5 trillion in a year, exposing the country to many risks attached with repayment of mounting obligations.

While some quarters still insist that Ishaq Dar’s performance as finance minister during the last four years is up to the mark, the ground reality is quite the opposite.

The shocking elements were that the country’s total external debt and liabilities increased to roughly $83 billion by end of fiscal year 2016-17 and a sum of $8.2 billion was spent on its servicing.

In terms of the total size of the economy, the country’s debt and liabilities increased to 78.7% of the gross domestic product (GDP), which is way above the safe level for a developing country like Pakistan, according to the data released by the State Bank of Pakistan on Thursday.

Every Pakistani now owes Rs120,381 as against roughly Rs91,000 in 2013, which reflects an increase of 32% over more than four years.

By all means, Pakistan’s total debt and liabilities have crossed the dangerous mark, suggesting the country has fallen into a debt trap. The growth in total debt and liabilities was 11% last year – the second consecutive year when the country saw a double-digit growth.

“Things are not bad as we thought, they have actually gone worse,” said Asad Umar, member of the National Assembly from the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI).

As against the Rs22.57 trillion of FY 2015-16, Pakistan’s total debt and liabilities increased to Rs25.1 trillion by June 30 of this year, showing an 11% growth over the previous year, said the SBP.

The total debt includes the obligations of both the government and the private sector, although the private sector debt is minimal as compared to that of the government.

Excluding liabilities, the total debt grew to Rs24 trillion by the end of last fiscal year – a whopping 75.3% of GDP and a net increase of Rs2.43 trillion from the previous financial year.

Out of Rs25.1 trillion, the gross public debt, which is the responsibility of the government directly or indirectly, was Rs21.4 trillion, according to the SBP data. The gross public debt increased by Rs1.732 trillion or 8.8% in the last fiscal year.

In order to conceal the worsening debt picture, the federal government twice revised the definition of public debt. According to the finance ministry’s definition, the public debt was Rs19.64 trillion, but the PTI has already decided to challenge the amended definition in the Supreme Court.

The gross public debt of Rs21.4 trillion was equal to 67.2% of GDP, which was in violation of the original limit set under the Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Limitation Act, passed by parliament in 2005.

External debt

The external debt grew to Rs8.33 trillion. There was an addition of Rs960.3 billion in a single year on the back of 13% growth, according to the central bank. The government claims its external debt is Rs5.9 trillion, although it raises serious questions over the government’s definition of debt calculation.

In terms of the US dollar, the total external debt and liabilities have increased to $82.981 billion – a net addition of $9.1 billion in a single year. The increase in external debt is more than the International Monetary Fund (IMF) estimates that had put the figure at $79.1 billion in its last report.

Pakistan is now sitting on explosive mines, as the day it would let the rupee gain its actual value against the US dollar, the country’s external debt would phenomenally grow. The country spent $8.2 billion on repayment of external debt and interest on it during the last fiscal year, according to the SBP. The external debt servicing increased by another $2.8 billion or a whopping 53.4%.

The public external debt servicing stood at $6.5 billion – higher by $2.1 billion or 47.4%. The principal loans repayment by the public sector stood at $5.2 billion – up by 59.5% in a single year, thanks to reckless borrowings by the finance ministry.

The external debt as percentage of last year’s exports was alarmingly 382% – many times more than the safe limit of 175%.

Domestic debt

The government’s domestic debt also swelled to Rs14.9 trillion – higher by Rs1.24 trillion or 9% over the previous year’s level. The debt of public-sector enterprises grew at an alarming pace of 44.7% and was registered at Rs822.8 billion.

Pakistan has been borrowing heavily to meet budget demands as it remains unable to broaden its extremely narrow tax base. The government, however, instead of improving its affairs got the definition of public debt changed.

During the past three years, the PML-N government has been subject to severe criticism for acquiring expensive foreign debts, increasing the debt mountain.



Source: https://tribune.com.pk/story/1512968/dars-legacy-heavily-indebted-pakistan/
 
Munshi ji and his number games to fool the nation...
 
Tajarbati team ka aek aur tohfa.



#Aur vote do Noora ko
 
Ishaq Dar has always been a failed finance minister so this is not a surprise in any way.
 
Pakistan is a financially failed state from day 1...
We should not put finger on one person.
 
Pakistan is a financially failed state from day 1...
We should not put finger on one person.

Let's also not point fingers at dictators thn when our so called democrats are always bypassing constitution wherever they need it.
 
You can;t really call him a failure, made tons of money for his and Sharif's family. Who cares about the "nation".
 
According to media he is sending his resignation from London in next few days and will stay there...
 
DRa5kpQX4AAKjZU.jpg:small
 
LONDON: Former finance minister Ishaq Dar has said that the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) has framed a bogus case to target him — as part of a vindictive campaign against Mian Nawaz Sharif, the former prime minister who was ousted by the Supreme Court of Pakistan on the basis of an Iqama [foreign work permit].

In an exclusive interview with this correspondent here, the former finance minister said that his name was not in the Panama inquiry and his name first surfaced when the Joint Investigation Team (JIT) was formed and later the reference was filed. “This has been manipulated and maneuvered in order to target me,” said Dar, adding that one day the full truth will come out as to the real characters involved in framing him, their objectives and ambitions. “One day the people of Pakistan will know the full truth about [this] charade.”

Dar said that then Chief Justice Anwar Zaheer Jamali had said that the Panama probe will remain limited to the four Avenfield apartments [of the Sharifs] and that the court will not go beyond that. “Then it started spreading from one place to another and to the next level and whole new issues were created.”

Ishaq Dar, who is credited for turning the economy around after taking it over from the brink of collapse in 2013, said that he was a hurt Pakistani and “saddened at how things have unfolded, how mountains have been made out of molehills and how Pakistan has been damaged over political games”

He added: “With the grace of Allah and his last Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him), I have dedicated my life for Pakistan and always worked selflessly and with full dedication and delivered results for Pakistan. I challenge anyone to prove a penny’s worth of irregularity or corruption during the four tenures that I was privileged to serve in various PML-N governments. I am ready to face any punishment if it’s proven that I was ever involved in corruption, favouritism for anyone, nepotism or other undue favours. I am ready to be shot and hanged in a public square if any corruption is found against me. I have a clean track record of performance. Pakistan is our beloved motherland and I wish that it makes further progress. In 2013, when I took over the reign of Pakistan’s financial affairs, the world had declared Pakistan on the verge of collapse. Its economic outlook looked very bleak.”

“I remember that in 2013 we used to work all the time, till 4am and then back at work at 10am and it was during the same time that I had to go through the heart procedure and a stent was inserted in my heart. We worked day and night to turn around Pakistan’s economy and by the Grace of God we succeeded.”

Ishaq Dar added that within four years, Pakistan started being mentioned as a country set to become a member of the G20 and that remained the case until June 2017.

The Pricewaterhouse Coopers said in a report, maintained Dar, that Pakistan is set to enter G20; Pakistan’s ratings changed drastically and the institutions that had stopped working with Pakistan started conducting business with Pakistan again and all this hard work led us to see Pakistan’s highest GDP growth in the last 10 years.

He said that events that unfolded in the last one year or so have shown that perhaps, “We Pakistanis are sometimes Pakistan’s worst enemies and don’t want stability and progress of the country through infighting and short-sighted policies”. He said that Pakistan made tremendous progress in getting back recognition as a macro-economically stable country despite the fact that there were four dharnas [sit-ins] during this tenure, a political party tendered its resignations from Parliament but “Alhamdullilah I was able to help negotiate in all these events and played my role under the leadership of Mian Nawaz Sharif to the best ability and in the best interest of Pakistan”.

Ishaq Dar said that his conscience is clear and “I have no burden on my conscience as I delivered and the whole world recognises that fact. If few people have made it their job to criticise me for the sake of criticising, then its fine but such tendencies are not good for Pakistan and its future”.

Ishaq Dar said that he was puzzled about the reasons why his own witch-hunt started as he always supported reconciliation for the national unity. “In Dawn Leaks case, there was a stand-off between two institutions. I was in Yokohama for Asian Development Bank meeting at the time but as soon as it was over, I returned to Pakistan and played my role. This country can move forward when all institutions work together and move forward. If we pull each other’s legs then it will be Pakistan that will be harmed. And it’s obvious how Pakistan has been damaged in the last four months.”

He said that during the Dawn Leaks saga, an implementation notification was issued and there were misunderstandings and he had to step in to play his role. “The actual report should have been published first but that didn’t happen. The whole issue was based around a misunderstanding. I played my role in the best interests of Pakistan with permission from Mian Nawaz Sharif. At that time a stand-off existed between the two institutions which led to many misunderstandings that I helped to remove. I did so because it was in the national interest.” He said that he fully supported Mian Nawaz Sharif’s viewpoint that he had been ousted by the Supreme Court as part of an agenda against his government on the basis of Iqama. “I believe that Mian Nawaz Sharif’s viewpoint is correct that the receivable [money] from the son was a formality and that should never have been the basis for his disqualification. “This is my opinion. Mian Nawaz Sharif accepted the Supreme Court's decision in its entirety and the new PM was chosen.”

When asked about the recent decisions announced by the Supreme Court on Imran Khan and another respondent’s disqualification case, Ishaq Dar said that huge contradictions existed between these cases and that of Mian Nawaz Sharif. “The treatment in these cases is very different. Legal professionals have compared the two and found glaring contradictions in two decisions. On the same issue, for example, in the second respondent’s case and its part relating to the agricultural land, the court said that it was an FBR matter; with regards to insider trading, the court said it’s an SECP matter as the respondent has accepted his involvement and paid money back to SECP and that the court has nothing to do with it. In my case, my 34 years of tax returns are also with the FBR and there is no issue with my tax returns but a completely different yardstick is being applied! Why?”

Ishaq Dar said that he was eager to return to Pakistan to face the “bogus” case against him before the NAB court but stressed that he has been advised by his doctors not to travel until his full treatment is completed. “I was advised by the doctors in London in November 2017 that I shouldn’t travel. I met Mian Nawaz Sharif in Saudi Arabia on October 28 and told him about the chest heaviness and he advised that I should see my doctor in London, who, by the way, just a few weeks back had strongly recommended that I undergo angiography but against his advice I had travelled back to attend the Accountability Court’s hearing . So this time I took Mian Sahib’s advice and came to London where Coronary Angiography was initially undertaken. Subsequently, Transthoracic Echocardiogram and a Dobutamine Stress Echocardiogram were done among other tests and it was clearly established that I have issues with one of the coronary vessels, which for the time being is being treated with medication. However, recently an MRI was carried out on December 20 of the whole spine as I had been experiencing progressive neck pain that had started to radiate into my shoulders and left arm and hand. On December 21, the neurosurgeon confirmed that serious issues are present in the neck and lower back as per the said MRI report. Because of the current seasonal holidays, the neurosurgeon has advised physiotherapy and medication till early January 2018 when I will have to be admitted in the hospital where they will try to handle the neck issue with an injection. God forbid if it does not work the only solution is surgery which is a long drawn and time-consuming process. However, I am keen to return to Pakistan as soon as I can and am permitted by the doctors to undertake air-travel.”

Dar said that he had nothing to hide and run away from. He said that the NAB had already been exposed as a farce when record tampering was found in the court and that shows how low some people can stoop.

Lastly, he added that he was extremely disheartened that NAB has even gone to the extent of seizing the accounts of his two charitable institutions (Hajveri Trust and Hajveri Foundation). “Hajveri Trust manages our orphanage house named ‘Saaya’ where currently 93 orphaned children live and are provided full-time boarding, lodging and education. Some of these children have been to America, Turkey and one of the students is now doing Chartered Accountancy (CA). Hajveri Foundation on the other hand is involved in pool marriages, medical treatments for the needy, payment of education fee for the poor, food distribution in various hospitals and distributing Ramazan Rashan Packages to thousands of needy. NAB has imposed Section 23 and we have been unable to operate accounts of both these institutions. If you don’t like me that’s fine but let the work go on; don’t make the poor and needy suffer. The action by NAB shows the extent to which some people can go in order to implement revenge. Hajveri Trust and Hajveri Foundation are being targeted for political reasons. This is condemnable and highly unfortunate but my Allah is watching everything!”

https://www.geo.tv/latest/174317-being-targetted
 
Last edited:
The debt itself would not have been a problem had it been used to generate economic activity. Its the fact that this imbecile borrowed money for an enterprise that was actively weakening the economy that is the real kicker. A lot of this debt went towards keeping the Rupee's value inflated because it's a matter of ego in Pakistan and the idiotic masses see a strong Rupee as a good thing. What it actually accomplished was that it delivered the coup de gras to our already uncompetitive export sector since a strong Rupee meant higher prices for buyers.
 
The debt itself would not have been a problem had it been used to generate economic activity. Its the fact that this imbecile borrowed money for an enterprise that was actively weakening the economy that is the real kicker. A lot of this debt went towards keeping the Rupee's value inflated because it's a matter of ego in Pakistan and the idiotic masses see a strong Rupee as a good thing. What it actually accomplished was that it delivered the coup de gras to our already uncompetitive export sector since a strong Rupee meant higher prices for buyers.

A strong currency is a good thing because it normally reflects a strong economy. Where i agree with you is that if its inflated by using Loans then that will sooner or later cause immense damage.
 
Also what is Dar complaining about? His information from 1999 was what also helped Nawaz and his corruption. :))
 
I think one has to look at it subjectively and look at it from all angles. He did bring the country out of a crisis in 2013 so something's don't add up. If anything it looks like there is conspiracy going on that's trying to malign him. One person should not be under the hook for all the problems of a country. It's a collective effort. I have yet to read any independent newspapers pointing to any corruption from his side.
 
I think one has to look at it subjectively and look at it from all angles. He did bring the country out of a crisis in 2013 so something's don't add up. If anything it looks like there is conspiracy going on that's trying to malign him. One person should not be under the hook for all the problems of a country. It's a collective effort. I have yet to read any independent newspapers pointing to any corruption from his side.

Look closer instead of trolling. In the recent case against Nawaz, Dar was asked to show evidence how his wealth increase by 990% in 5 years. He provided three forged letters from a Qatari prince, all with horrible typos and mispelt names as ''official'' evidence. He showed no other evidence, no bank receipts, no documents. And in return he was disqualified.

Even I can provide all that easily if asked.

Another user on the block list I guess, thank God for that on PP. :))
 
A strong currency is a good thing because it normally reflects a strong economy. Where i agree with you is that if its inflated by using Loans then that will sooner or later cause immense damage.

A strong currency is a good thing if you're an economy like the UK that imports everything, doesn't export much and can maintain first world development indicators while doing so. For a developing country, and doubly so for one so low on the economic food chain as Pakistan, the ability to export manufactured goods is the difference between having an economic future and not having one so in Pakistan's case, a strong currency, much less one that is artificially inflated, only benefits businesses that import stuff while rapidly eroding the competitiveness of local manufacturers on whom the country's ability to move up the economic ladder hinges.
 
I think one has to look at it subjectively and look at it from all angles. (1)He did bring the country out of a crisis in 2013 so something's don't add up. If anything it looks like there is conspiracy going on that's trying to malign him. One person should not be under the hook for all the problems of a country. It's a collective effort. (2)I have yet to read any independent newspapers pointing to any corruption from his side.
(1) He did not.
(2) Irrelevant. Whether or not he's corrupt has no bearing on his disastrous economic policies. When it comes to the economy, a corrupt person with the right policies is always a vastly superior option to an honest person with the wrong policies. In his case, he's both corrupt and his policies have been disastrous for the economy, not out of ignorance and incompetence, but by design, so there's literally no redeeming features here. I would have gladly given him a pass on his corruption had he actually been good for the economy. Sadly, he was not.
 
A strong currency is a good thing if you're an economy like the UK that imports everything, doesn't export much and can maintain first world development indicators while doing so. For a developing country, and doubly so for one so low on the economic food chain as Pakistan, the ability to export manufactured goods is the difference between having an economic future and not having one so in Pakistan's case, a strong currency, much less one that is artificially inflated, only benefits businesses that import stuff while rapidly eroding the competitiveness of local manufacturers on whom the country's ability to move up the economic ladder hinges.

Britain is the 10th big exporter in the world, not bad for a country that doesnt export much. Germany had a strong currency(DM in those days, govt policy to keep it strong) and is the worlds biggest exporter using the € today. Weak currencies are consequence of weak economies and PK's problem is that beyond Rice, Textiles and agriculture, we offer little to the world that it needs.
 
Last edited:
Britain is the 10th big exporter in the world, not bad for a country that doesnt export much. Germany had a strong currency(DM in those days, govt policy to keep it strong) and is the worlds biggest exporter using the € today. Weak currencies are consequence of weak economies and PK's problem is that beyond Rice, Textiles and agriculture, we offer little to the world that it needs.

UK is the 5th largest economy so being the 10th largest exporter simply indicates that it's exporting a relatively small percentage of it's GDP, compounded by the fact that many of it's exports are service exports. Germany's economy was undergoing a crisis in the late 90s, and it only really picked up around 2003ish. It truly stood out, however, during and after the financial crisis, helped in no small part by a weak euro (on account of the PIGS nations' weak economies) that synergized beautifully with their outsized manufacturing sector (23% of GDP compared to 9-10% for the UK).

For Pakistan, even if the Rupee started appreciating on account of a strong economy, a competent finance minister would intervene and artificially suppress it, that's how important it is to export competitiveness. This phenomenon is the basis for one of the more notable economic disputes in recent times, that of China artificially keeping the Renminbi's value low, taking their cues from South Korea between the 70s and 90s, and Japan from the 50s through to the 80s. As things stand, we're having trouble even selling textiles because the strong Rupee has made our textile manufacturers uncompetitive compared to those from Bangladesh and Vietnam among others and that is due in no small part to Mr. Dar prioritizing cheap votes over good policy.
 
Last edited:
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">New revelations made by us today show the rise & rise of Dar from Sharif's munshi to millionaire to billionaire! Apart from the Dar family's 2 $200m towers in Dubai, we have uncovered Dar's 11 companies, one of which owns 52 Dubai villas;</p>— Imran Khan (@ImranKhanPTI) <a href="https://twitter.com/ImranKhanPTI/status/946760167760199680?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">December 29, 2017</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">In addition, millions have flowed into Dar's accounts in UAE from 4 sources: Switzerland, UK, Oman & Turkey. Given how Dar has been front for Sharifs, this begs the question: how much wealth have Sharifs really stashed abroad? Clearly the JIT revelations are only tip of iceberg. <a href="https://t.co/jX0RkEPwf7">https://t.co/jX0RkEPwf7</a></p>— Imran Khan (@ImranKhanPTI) <a href="https://twitter.com/ImranKhanPTI/status/946761150506643461?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">December 29, 2017</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Back
Top