Jos Buttler vs Umar Akmal

[FasihHeadtickler]

Who is better player in both aspects Keeping and batting?
I would go for Buttler in keeping and Akmal Slightly better than Buttler.Buttler have the qualities of being Test keeper and Akmal does not,Akmal used to bowl in U19 and he should focus on his batting

 

[PakistanKnight]

Akmal,no doubt. Akmal is averaging 35+ in both forms after so many games while Butler is living of one Afridi-esque innings. That 40 odd of 15 balls took his career off and after that we have only seen some glimpses. His career may go Afridi's way,that innings will increase the expectations and if he doesn't live upto them he might be bashed. But then we are talking of English supporters here,who are more professional than us.

 

[indian_sap]

Hameshase Umarko Kohlise compare kiya jata tha aur kayi friends here on PP kehteki Umar is better than Kohli etcetc aur abhi Jos Butlerse compare karrahe ho Umarko; kya Umar AKmalke itne burey din agaye??? Feel sorry for Umar

 

[Bullet Drive]

Thread should be deleted.

 

[leatherface58]

Umar Akmal vs Bradman, Sachin, Kohli, Raina, Talunted Rohit and now Buttler ). Dude's stock is dropping faster than Hafeez's test average.

 

[indian_sap]

Umar Akmal vs Bradman, Sachin, Kohli, Raina, Talunted Rohit and now Buttler ). Dude's stock is dropping faster than Hafeez's test average.

Hahaha agree, that's what I mentioned in my above post too

 

[Cricfan4eva]

Jos Buttler's time has arrived.. finally!

 

[Gigii]

Buttler is the better keeper and will only get better since he'll be a full time keeper with Lancashire. Akmal is probably the better batsman but whereas Buttler's role, especially in the international team for now is known, Akmal is just messed about ridiculously.

 

[Gunther]

Jos Buttler's time has arrived.. finally!

We will see when that materializes on internation stage but for the moment, Akmal Jnr. is ten times the player as Buttler.

 

[PakistanKnight]

Terrible thread. Akmal is not that bad. You guys simply make some crap threads without thinking.

 

[FasihHeadtickler]

Have u ppl seen Aus vs Eng series?
Buttler was the star for England gave his 100% in every match

 

[Kianig89]

Laughable comparison Akmal is daylight better than Buttler who has nothing but a dilscoop in his armory coupled with some hoicks not to mention his pathetic skills against Spin

 

[pakistani pride]

Umar akmal is not a wk
I hope pak management realizes this. Also i wish the pak management had the same amount of time for ua as pakpassion.

 

[Executioner]

I would prefer umar akmal ofcourse

But whats with all the UA comparison's? This only shows that Pakistani fans think that UA is their best player and things have been so bad that they are trying to wonder whether their best is better than some other players in the world.

TBH, Umar is NOT the best player in pakistan and probably not the best youngster at this moment(I rate Jamshed higher)

 

[leatherface58]

We will see when that materializes on internation stage but for the moment, Akmal Jnr. is ten times the player as Buttler.

Whoever is compared to Junior gets a nitrous oxide boost to their career. Kohli, Raina, even talunted Rohit have benefitted from it. It's Buttler's turn to shine.

 

[Energetic]

lol Butler is basically hit and miss. Wicket keeping is also overrated.

 

[Bhaijaan]

Definitely Jossy after this effort.

Whattey Talent.

 

[volcyz]

Where is Umar Akmal?

lol

 

[Syed1]

UA can bat three times and still not play the innings that Butler played today..

 

[HuzaifaE]

Umar is sadly all show, no substance. He's never done half of what Jos did today in ODIs.

 

[Bhaijaan]

Laughable comparison Akmal is daylight better than Buttler who has nothing but a dilscoop in his armory coupled with some hoicks not to mention his pathetic skills against Spin

Never put your money on Umnar Akmal.

 

[LegbreakGoogly]

Difference is Butler has applied himself and worked really hard. Where as Akmal is all but a selfi guy........

 

[Abdullah719]

Whoever is compared to Junior gets a nitrous oxide boost to their career. Kohli, Raina, even ******** Rohit have benefitted from it. It's Buttler's turn to shine.

Some prediction, this.

Can we compare some of our own talunts to Umar to give them Nitro boosts as well?

 

[fahadshah]

If someone can go on and beats his own record of scoring big hundreds not once. You can bet your money on that player. Umar akmal is no way near


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Ahson8]

Tbh if I had to choose one player in PAK who can play a similar innings, it would be Akmal.

 

[in_cutter]

Comparing a guy with Jos that can't even get into the side

 

[Firebreaker]

I am feeling nostalgic about this thread

 

[zabalestmsm]

I am feeling nostalgic about this thread

Were u the OP in ur previous life???????????????? Lol!

 

[Cricfan4eva]

Jos Buttler's time has arrived.. finally!

Well took 2 years but this thread finally did him good..

 

[Cricfan4eva]

Some prediction, this.

Can we compare some of our own talunts to Umar to give them Nitro boosts as well?

Compare Umar v2 with Umar v1? Worth a try isn't it?

 

[Someone]

What a nice thread

 

[Hasan123]

Embarrassing thread.

 

[Ab Fan]

Butler has turned himself into a world class batsmen and will sooner become the second coming of AB de Villiers.

Thank you OP.

 

[msb314]

Embarrassing thread.

Reading some of the comments from 2013 seems so amusing now haha!

Benefit of hindsight at its best.
[MENTION=138254]Syed1[/MENTION]