Their squad selection didn’t make sense. Why pick Nabi when you already have Imad. Barring Amir, every bowler they picked was a defensive bowler rather than a wicket ticker. A couple of interesting picks they made, that never made the squad, we’re Romario Shepherd and Tom Abell. They may not have made a difference, but it would have been good to see them.
For the remaining games, it’s important that Qasim Akram gets sent ahead of Nabi at 4. It’s also worth replacing Umaid Asif with Faisal Akram, to see how the young lad does.
For next year, it’s important that Karachi disband the majority of this squad. Only retain Imad, Amir, Sharjeel and the Akrams. I would go as far as trading Babar to Peshawar, if I can get Livingston and Haider in return.
No point in keeping Amir either. He just plays random leagues now, doesnt even play domestic cricket. I dont expect him to consistently be fit and perform at the PSL. He was pretty bad the last time he played.