What's new

Kumbh And Markaz Should Not Be Compared: Uttarakhand Chief Minister

MP2011

Senior T20I Player
Joined
Aug 22, 2018
Runs
18,787
Post of the Week
1
Kumbh And Markaz Should Not Be Compared: Uttarakhand Chief Minister

Dehradun: Uttarakhand Chief Minister Tirath Singh Rawat on Tuesday said the ongoing Kumbh Mela in Haridwar should not be compared with the Nizamuddin Markaz which was held in a closed space and attended even by foreigners.

"There should be no comparison between Kumbh and Markaz. The Markaz was held in a closed space, in a Kothi like structure whereas the Kumbh is being held in the open on the sprawling ghats of the Ganga," Mr Rawat said on a weekly talk show organised by the Hindustan Times.

The Chief Minister was replying to a question as to why the two religious events should not be equated (Nizamuddin Markaz and Kumbh) as Kumbh also draws crowds and could strengthen the second wave of the coronavirus infection.

Citing other differences between the Kumbh Mela in Haridwar and Nizamuddin Markaz, Mr Rawat said, "The devotees attending Kumbh are not from outside but our own people."

"Moreover, when the Markaz was held there was not much awareness about Corona nor were there any guidelines. No one knew for how long the attendees of the Markaz had remained in the confines of the structure," he said.

"Now there is more awareness both about Covid and the guidelines related to it," the Chief Minister added.

He also said Kumbh comes once in 12 years and is linked with the faith and sentiments of millions of people.

"Holding it successfully amid the challenge posed by Covid-19 by ensuring that the SOP is strictly followed by all is our goal," he said.

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/utt...mbh-and-markaz-should-not-be-compared-2412958
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Bigotry, hypocrisy and illiteracy are at their peak in India these days. See the kind of excuses being put forward to defend Kumbh,

1) "There should be no comparison between Kumbh and Markaz. The Markaz was held in a closed space, in a Kothi like structure whereas the Kumbh is being held in the open on the sprawling ghats of the Ganga,"

2) Citing other differences between the Kumbh Mela in Haridwar and Nizamuddin Markaz, Mr Rawat said, "The devotees attending Kumbh are not from outside but our own people."

3) He also said Kumbh comes once in 12 years and is linked with the faith and sentiments of millions of people.

4) Ganga maiya will take care of all devotees.
 
1,000 Covid Cases In 2 Days In Haridwar As Millions Gather At Kumbh Mela

New Delhi: Uttarakhand's Haridwar reported 594 new cases of coronavirus on Tuesday, taking the active caseload of the city to 2,812, as thousands gathered to take dips in the Ganges for the 13th day of Mahakumbh. On Monday, Haridwar had registered 408 cases.
Uttarakhand logged 1,925 cases with 13 deaths in the last 24 hours.

Devotees continue to throng the ghats of Haridwar even as the country reels under a more severe second wave of coronavirus infections with many states running out of vaccines and beds for patients.

Nearly a million people have flocked to the banks of the Ganges to participate in the months-long "Kumbh Mela" or pitcher festival.

On Monday, the day of the auspicious Shahi Snan (ritualistic bath), nearly a lakh had gathered for the holy dip in absolute violation of Covid protocols issued by the Union Health Ministry.

People were seen without mask, with no social distancing as India logged over 1.6 lakh cases of coronavirus on Tuesday.

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/1-0...kumbh-mela-2412931?pfrom=home-ndtv_topstories
 
And these 1000 Covid cases are official numbers!
 
Bigotry, hypocrisy and illiteracy are at their peak in India these days.

Exactly. That is why people consume fevicol on gatherings depending on which side they favour. I hope you are not one of them, and want social distancing in the anti farm reforms laws.
 
India’s new coronavirus infections hit a record on Wednesday, as crowds of pilgrims gathered for a religious festival despite oxygen shortages and strict curbs in other areas.

The country reported 184,372 cases in the last 24 hours, health ministry data showed, taking total infections to 13.9 million. Deaths rose by 1,027, to a toll of 172,085.

Still, hundreds of thousands of devout Hindus gathered to bathe in the Ganges river on Wednesday, the third key day of the weeks-long Kumbh Mela - or pitcher festival.

Sanjay Gunjyal, the inspector general of police at the festival, said around 650,000 people had bathed on Wednesday morning.

“People are being fined for not following social distancing in non crowded ghats (bathing areas), but it is very hard to fine people in the main ghats, which are very crowded,” he said.

There was little evidence of social distancing or mask-wearing, according to a Reuters witness.

More than a thousand cases have been reported in Haridwar district in the last two days, according to government data.

From reporting less than 10,000 cases per day earlier this year, India has been the world's worst-hit country since April 2 by new daily cases, with the government blaming here a widespread failure to heed curbs on movement and social interaction.

India’s richest state Maharashtra, the epicentre of the national second wave and which accounts for about a quarter of the country’s cases, is due to impose stringent restrictions from Wednesday to try to contain the spread.

Read more: India, overwhelmed by Covid surge, fast-tracks approval for foreign vaccines

Elsewhere, overstretched private hospitals are turning patients away, placing an increasing burden on government facilities.

In the western state of Gujurat, local media showed a long queue of ambulances waiting outside Ahmedabad Civil Hospital, with some patients being treated there while they waited.

A hospital source, who declined to be named as he is not authorised to speak publicly, said this was because a lot of private hospitals were short of oxygen and were sending their patients to the public hospital.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/229466...it-record-as-hindu-devotees-immerse-in-ganges
 
Exactly. That is why people consume fevicol on gatherings depending on which side they favour. I hope you are not one of them, and want social distancing in the anti farm reforms laws.

Ha ha. While I disagree with some of your posts, this one is a gem.
 
By the way UP and Uttarakhand BJP government including their respective CMs are bigots and idiots of highest order. The only way to save the nation from them is utter suffering of the 'faithful'. I am hoping the current wave to clock 1 crore victims, when that happens the public will come out as mob and shove sticks from behind of these jaahil gawar who are enjoying a godly status today.
 
I think he has a point and it should be respected. In the event of a calamity Muslims are able to pray at home or can listen to gatherings via zoom.

The kumbh seems to be very sacred to Hindus and if there no option for them to postpone it or do an alternative form of worship at home then they should be able to attend their worship.
 
By the way UP and Uttarakhand BJP government including their respective CMs are bigots and idiots of highest order. The only way to save the nation from them is utter suffering of the 'faithful'. I am hoping the current wave to clock 1 crore victims, when that happens the public will come out as mob and shove sticks from behind of these jaahil gawar who are enjoying a godly status today.

Let’s not wish bad on anyone. It’s not good for our own mental health.
 
Last edited:
Let’s not wish bad on anyone. It’s not good for our own mental health.

Don't want to and agree with your.comment. But when you see the mass and their leaders are equally stupid and playing at each other , then a grand disaster awaits.
 
I think he has a point and it should be respected. In the event of a calamity Muslims are able to pray at home or can listen to gatherings via zoom.

The kumbh seems to be very sacred to Hindus and if there no option for them to postpone it or do an alternative form of worship at home then they should be able to attend their worship.
You couldn't be more wrong!
 
Comparing Kumbh with Markaz is likening ‘Gangajal to dirty drain water’, says VHP

New Delhi: The Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) has called for the Kumbh Mela to continue at Haridwar in Uttarakhand, despite the town having recorded over a 1,000 Covid-19 cases in the last 48 hours.

VHP vice-president Champat Rai also told ThePrint that the mela cannot be equated with the Tablighi Jamaat event at the Markaz in Delhi’s Nizamuddin as the latter, according to him, was not a religious function.

Comparisons have been drawn between both events as the Markaz, held in March last year, was deemed a super spreader at the start of the pandemic while the media reaction to the mela, in the middle of a second Covid-19 wave, has been relatively muted.

“The Kumbh is a very old and traditional festival,” Rai said. “In its organisation, learned mandaleshwars and shankaracharyas are involved. Rules should be followed but it’s a Hindu religious festival that is organised every 12 years. There is no need to restrict the festival; we just need to follow Covid guidelines.”

VHP joint secretary Surendra Jain was even more emphatic, slamming those comparing the mela with the Jamaat event.

“There are three differences between the Tablighi Markaz and the Kumbh,” he said. “The Kumbh is a religious function unlike the markaz, which was an authoritarian event to demonstrate Muslim hegemony. The second difference is that the Kumbh has government permission and is not a hidden affair. The Kumbh is also a religious function and it is a festival of astha.”

“Comparing the Kumbh with the Markaz is like comparing Gangajal with dirty water of drains,” he added. “There is no need to restrict and curtail the Kumbh as it is happening with the blessings of the dharmacharya.”

The VHP backing for the event comes a day after Uttarakhand Chief Minister Tirath Singh Rawat made it clear that the Kumbh will continue.

Rawat had Tuesday also said that the Kumbh Mela can’t be compared to the Nizamuddin Markaz.

“They (Markaz attendees) were all inside a building and here it is out in the open,” Rawat had told reporters. “And this is near the Ganges. The flow and blessings of Ma Ganga will ensure that coronavirus does not spread. The question does not arise of a comparison.”

https://theprint.in/india/comparing...angajal-to-dirty-drain-water-says-vhp/639963/
 
More bigotry from sanghis,

“Comparing the Kumbh with the Markaz is like comparing Gangajal with dirty water of drains,”
 
By the way UP and Uttarakhand BJP government including their respective CMs are bigots and idiots of highest order. The only way to save the nation from them is utter suffering of the 'faithful'. I am hoping the current wave to clock 1 crore victims, when that happens the public will come out as mob and shove sticks from behind of these jaahil gawar who are enjoying a godly status today.
Don't agree with this. However, its true our current lot are a gullible lot and will blindly follow what these bigots tell them.
 
Worried about the safety of the minorities only, best government for minorities in the region.
 

Attachments

  • FB_IMG_1618405259486.jpg
    FB_IMG_1618405259486.jpg
    124.1 KB · Views: 390
Society has a death wish as per Madmen. No bigger proof than this. I thought India managed covid well and it appears they are going to lose it because of this stupid mela.
 
I don't see any social distancing or face coverings at the kumbh then how is it different to any other religious gathering? No Indian news channel is condemning this or are they?
 
Congress MLA Irfan Ansari performs puja at Baidyanath Dham, BJP MP demands his arrest

Jharkhand's Congress MLA Irfan Ansari on Wednesday performed puja at the famous Baidyanath Dham temple at Deoghar, considered to be the most sacred abode of Lord Shiva, creating a controversy. Claiming that the entry of non-Hindus is not allowed in the temple, BJP MP Dr Nishikant Dubey demanded immediate arrest of Ansari.

Ansari claimed that he has been coming to the Baidyanath Dham temple since his childhood to take the blessings of Lord Shiva. "Whenever elections come, I have been blessed by Baba Bhole (Lord Shiva) and I have won. Who is Nishikant Dubey to take me away from Baba?" Ansari said.

बाबा भोलेनाथ के दरबार में हजारों बार गया हूं ।लेकिन भगोड़े सांसद की नजर में पहली बार गया हूं ।इतिहास पता नहीं ,मां पार्वती और शंकर भगवान जी के मंदिर का गठजोड़ हमारे पूर्वजों के द्वारा बुने धागे से होता आ रहा है@INCJharkhand [MENTION=370]Rahul[/MENTION]Gandhi @BJP4Jharkhand @nishikant_dubey

— Dr Irfan Ansari April 14, 2021



"No non-Hindu has entered the sanctum sanctorum of the Baba temple till date. Just as the entry of non-Muslims is forbidden in the Kaaba in Mecca, the entry of non-Hindus into the Baba temple is also forbidden," Nishikant Dubey said.

Days ago, the duo had engaged in a war of words on Twitter between the two leaders over who would be inaugurating the newly constructed railway station in Godda.

According to Dubey, BJP MP from Godda constituency in Jharkhand, the decision to virtually inaugurate the station was taken after the Hemant Soren government tried to stop its physical inauguration. He took a jibe at the Soren government and tweeted that the COVID-19 threat existed only for the opening of the new railway station. For other events such as massive gatherings, election meetings, and political rallies that continued uninterrupted in the state, there was no threat from the coronavirus.

Responding to the BJP MP, Ansari said come what may, the inauguration of the Godda railway station will be done by Jharkhand CM Hemant Soren.

“Stay on the ground. This is not Bhagalpur, it is Jharkhand. People here do not tolerate making false promises. You were making big claims of inaugurating the railway station, seems like it is not going to happen. Godda rail project Humsafar train will be flagged off by none other than our dynamic CM Hemant,” Dr Irfan Ansari tweeted.


https://www.timesnownews.com/india/article/congress-mla-irfan-ansari-performs-puja-at-baidyanath-dham-bjp-mp-nishikant-dubey-demands-his-arrest/745337
 
‘Super-spreader’: Over 1,000 COVID positive at India’s Kumbh Mela
Virus detected in more than 1,000 people in Haridwar city along the Ganges River where the weeks-long festival is being observed.


More than 1,000 people have tested positive for the coronavirus at the site of a major Hindu festival in India in two days, officials said, as huge crowds of mostly maskless devotees descend on the Ganges River in the northern Uttarakhand state.

The virus was detected in the city of Haridwar, which lies along the river where the weeks-long Kumbh Mela, or the pitcher festival, is being observed, officials said. Of some 50,000 samples taken from people in Haridwar, 408 tested positive on Monday and 594 on Tuesday, the Uttarakhand government said.

The latest figures came as Yogi Adityanath, the chief minister of neighbouring Uttar Pradesh state, tweeted on Wednesday that he had also tested positive for COVID-19.

A second wave of coronavirus infections is sweeping across India, with the country on Wednesday hitting a new high of 184,372 new cases.

With a total of almost 13.9 million COVID-19 infections, India now has the second-highest number of cases in the world. The country’s daily death toll passed 1,000 on Wednesday for the first time since mid-October.

Local authorities in many states have imposed night curfews and clamped down on movement and activities.

‘Our faith is the biggest thing’

Experts have blamed large religious events, packed political rallies in poll-bound states and crowded public places for the surge.

Still, hundreds of thousands of ash-smeared ascetics and devout Hindus jostled to take a dip in the Ganges during the religious festival on Wednesday, hoping to wash away their sins, as India reported another record surge in coronavirus infections.

“Our faith is the biggest thing for us. It is because of that strong belief that so many people have come here to take a dip in Ganga,” Siddharth Chakrapani, a member of one of the Kumbh Mela organising committees, told AFP news agency.

“They believe that Maa (mother) Ganga will save them from this pandemic.”

As huge crowds made their way towards the river on a special day of bathing during the Kumbh Mela, health authorities had to pull back a COVID-19 testing crew.

“We have moved away our sampling team to avoid a stampede-like situation,” said SK Jha, chief medical officer of the northern city of Haridwar, where the event is being held.

“We do, of course, expect cases to rise when the priests and other crowd move away.”

Police said 650,000 devotees had bathed in the river since Wednesday morning and people were being fined for failing to observe social distancing in some areas.

‘It’s already a super-spreader’
Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government, however, has refused to call off the festival that is scheduled to last the whole month, possibly fearing a backlash from religious leaders in the Hindu-majority country.

“It is already a super-spreader because there is no space to test hundreds of thousands in a crammed city and the government neither has the facilities nor the manpower,” said a senior Uttarakhand official.

Devout Hindus believe bathing in the Ganges absolves people of sins, and during the Kumbh Mela, it brings salvation from the cycle of life and death.


A short distance from the river, Hotel Sachin International had converted itself into a COVID isolation centre. All 72 rooms were packed with more than 150 patients, a hotel executive said.

“We started taking in patients on April 5, and three days ago all our rooms got filled,” the employee said, declining to be identified because of a gag order from local authorities.

The hotel did not respond to an email seeking comment. A doctor from the region said at least four other hotels have been turned into COVID wards.

“What you are seeing is not Kumbh Mela but it’s a corona atom bomb,” tweeted Indian filmmaker Ram Gopal Varma, alongside a picture of a sea of devotees. “I wonder who will be made accountable for this viral explosion.”

Comparisons with Tablighi Jamaat row

Critics of the Indian government have also compared the government’s response to the festival to the response last year when Indian Muslims faced rising Islamophobia following accusations that an initial surge in infections was tied to a three-day meeting of an Islamic missionary group, the Tablighi Jamaat, in New Delhi.

Some leaders from Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and India’s freewheeling TV channels, which have long favoured the government’s Hindu-nationalist policies, labelled Muslims as “jihadis” and “super spreaders” in March 2020 when the seven-day rolling average of coronavirus cases in the country was not even 200 per day.

The blame triggered a wave of violence, business boycotts and hate speech towards Muslims.

India’s 200 million Muslims account for 14 percent of the population and are the largest minority group in the Hindu-majority nation.

Worst-hit state imposes curbs
Starting on Wednesday, India’s worst-hit and richest state, Maharashtra, will impose stricter restrictions for 15 days to stem the surge of coronavirus infections that is threatening to overcome hospitals.

In state capital Mumbai, migrant workers at a railway station said they were leaving for their homes in other states after the tighter restrictions were announced.

“Since I don’t have any work, I am not able to pay my rent,” migrant worker Imraan Khan told AFP.

Last year, a sudden, harsh, nationwide lockdown left millions jobless overnight. Stranded in cities with no income or food, thousands of migrant workers walked on highways to get home. Since then, state leaders have repeatedly stressed that another lockdown was not on the cards.

Officials in Maharashtra have stressed that the closure of most industries, businesses, public places and limits on the movement of people did not constitute a lockdown.

But the distinction did little to allay Ramachal Yadav’s anxieties. On Wednesday morning, he joined others at a Mumbai railway station getting on a train back home. “There is no work,” said the 45-year-old.

The scenes playing out in Maharashtra in the past week mirror those developing in other parts of the country: patients gasping for air turned away from hospitals that are running out of oxygen and weeping families waiting for their turn to bid farewell to their loved ones at crematoria.

Compounding concerns is the question of whether India, despite being the world’s largest maker of vaccines, will have enough to immunise its vast population swiftly enough to slow down the virus.

India on Tuesday authorised vaccines that had been given an emergency nod by the World Health Organization or regulators in the United States, Europe, Britain or Japan. Indian regulators also approved Russia’s Sputnik V for emergency use.

But experts said the decision was unlikely to have any immediate impact on supplies available in the country.

“All one can think of is that I hope I don’t fall ill over the next month or so,” said Dr Vineeta Bal, who studies immune systems at the Indian Institute of Science Education and Research in Maharashtra’s Pune city.

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021...people have,in the northern Uttarakhand state.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
When the Tablighi Jammat had a few hundred cases the Indian media called it “Corona Jihad”. What are they going to call thousands of these cases? Corona Yudh?
 
When the Tablighi Jammat had a few hundred cases the Indian media called it “Corona Jihad”. What are they going to call thousands of these cases? Corona Yudh?

Indian media, its internet trolls and other Indian hate spreading organizations like recently exposed Srivastav Group should never be taken seriously.

These people are literally getting paid to spread misinformation, hate and agendas (mostly against Pakistan / Muslims).

That said, next few weeks can be crucial for Indian healthcare system. The cases are on the rise.

Sometimes, it is very difficult to comprehend but India is a massive massive space and there were a lot of communities and regions that had 0 cases.

I'm afraid, in upcoming weeks a lot of places will start getting their 1st case and we could potentially see an alarming rise in cases & deaths...
 
When the Tablighi Jammat had a few hundred cases the Indian media called it “Corona Jihad”. What are they going to call thousands of these cases? Corona Yudh?

To be honest, many Indians are clueless or hypocrites in this regard. You can very well see not much criticism from Indian posters here who were at arms when the Markaz was found messing up things. The fact is Kumbh is an even more messier event and putting the society in danger at much larger scale than what Markaz did but very few will dare to criticize.
 
To be honest, many Indians are clueless or hypocrites in this regard. You can very well see not much criticism from Indian posters here who were at arms when the Markaz was found messing up things. The fact is Kumbh is an even more messier event and putting the society in danger at much larger scale than what Markaz did but very few will dare to criticize.

Because they maybe espouse to the same ideally as this VHP leader does who said said comparing Kumbh mela to Markaz was like comparing Gangajal to a gutter...

Read more here: https://theprint.in/india/comparing...angajal-to-dirty-drain-water-says-vhp/639963/
 
Hindus are entitled to their beliefs but why is the Indian government not putting a stop to this?

If you see Mecca, people are keeping a distance.

It seems more extremism in India than other places around the world continues.
 
Congress MLA Irfan Ansari performs puja at Baidyanath Dham, BJP MP demands his arrest

Jharkhand's Congress MLA Irfan Ansari on Wednesday performed puja at the famous Baidyanath Dham temple at Deoghar, considered to be the most sacred abode of Lord Shiva, creating a controversy. Claiming that the entry of non-Hindus is not allowed in the temple, BJP MP Dr Nishikant Dubey demanded immediate arrest of Ansari.

Ansari claimed that he has been coming to the Baidyanath Dham temple since his childhood to take the blessings of Lord Shiva. "Whenever elections come, I have been blessed by Baba Bhole (Lord Shiva) and I have won. Who is Nishikant Dubey to take me away from Baba?" Ansari said.

बाबा भोलेनाथ के दरबार में हजारों बार गया हूं ।लेकिन भगोड़े सांसद की नजर में पहली बार गया हूं ।इतिहास पता नहीं ,मां पार्वती और शंकर भगवान जी के मंदिर का गठजोड़ हमारे पूर्वजों के द्वारा बुने धागे से होता आ रहा है@INCJharkhand [MENTION=370]Rahul[/MENTION]Gandhi @BJP4Jharkhand @nishikant_dubey

— Dr Irfan Ansari April 14, 2021



"No non-Hindu has entered the sanctum sanctorum of the Baba temple till date. Just as the entry of non-Muslims is forbidden in the Kaaba in Mecca, the entry of non-Hindus into the Baba temple is also forbidden," Nishikant Dubey said.

Days ago, the duo had engaged in a war of words on Twitter between the two leaders over who would be inaugurating the newly constructed railway station in Godda.

According to Dubey, BJP MP from Godda constituency in Jharkhand, the decision to virtually inaugurate the station was taken after the Hemant Soren government tried to stop its physical inauguration. He took a jibe at the Soren government and tweeted that the COVID-19 threat existed only for the opening of the new railway station. For other events such as massive gatherings, election meetings, and political rallies that continued uninterrupted in the state, there was no threat from the coronavirus.

Responding to the BJP MP, Ansari said come what may, the inauguration of the Godda railway station will be done by Jharkhand CM Hemant Soren.

“Stay on the ground. This is not Bhagalpur, it is Jharkhand. People here do not tolerate making false promises. You were making big claims of inaugurating the railway station, seems like it is not going to happen. Godda rail project Humsafar train will be flagged off by none other than our dynamic CM Hemant,” Dr Irfan Ansari tweeted.


https://www.timesnownews.com/india/article/congress-mla-irfan-ansari-performs-puja-at-baidyanath-dham-bjp-mp-nishikant-dubey-demands-his-arrest/745337

Why is he as a Muslim doing puja in the first place... :mw
 
Why is he as a Muslim doing puja in the first place... :mw

It's a cultural thing. Hindus do visit Mazars, Dargas, Churches and Muslims do volunteer for organizing Pujas. It brings the communities together amidst diverse spiritual practices.
 
It's a cultural thing. Hindus do visit Mazars, Dargas, Churches and Muslims do volunteer for organizing Pujas. It brings the communities together amidst diverse spiritual practices.

Everytime we visit India, we have these customary visits to Temples, dargahs churches and Gurdwara langars. Mostly as a tourist but pretty common scene there. Sometimes go along with friends.
Taught me not to look at media reports and form an opinion about any community
 
Modi appeals to keep Hindu festival symbolic as India’s COVID-19 infections surge

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday appealed to devotees to keep a key Hindu festival symbolic as the country reported more than 200,000 new COVID-19 infections for the third straight day.

India reported 234,692 COVID-19 infections over the last 24 hours, taking the total number of cases to nearly 14.5 million, second only to the United States. Deaths in the country from COVID-19 rose by 1,341 to 175,649.

Criticism has mounted over the Indian government’s handling of the health crisis, as religious festivals and election rallies continue amid increasing reports of shortage of hospital beds, oxygen cylinders and vaccination doses.

After hundreds of thousands of ascetics and devout Hindus gathered for several days along the banks of the Ganges in a northern state for a religious festival Kumbh Mela, Modi on Saturday called for restraint, saying on Twitter the festival should now be kept "symbolic".

Responding to Modi's appeal, one of religious leader Swami Avdheshanand urged devotees to not gather in large numbers. Devout Hindus believe bathing in the holy Ganges absolves people of sins, and during the Kumbh Mela, it brings salvation from the cycle of life and death.

Experts have warned about the spread of more contagious variants of the disease, with especially during large-scale gathering for religious festivals and political rallies.

On Saturday, Modi was scheduled to hold two election rallies in eastern state of West Bengal where state elections are ongoing. In recent weeks, such rallies have attracted thousands of people, few of whom follow COVID-19 safety protocols.

"Stop spreader rallies," the Times of India said in an editorial on Saturday, adding: "Business as usual is an unaffordable luxury until this virus is conclusively tamed."

After imposing one of the world’s strictest lockdowns for nearly three months last year, India’s government relaxed almost all curbs by the beginning of 2021, although many regions have now introduced localised restrictions.

“This is Narendra Modi’s biggest crisis yet. It is bigger than any security threat, external or internal, or even the economic attrition of 2020,” prominent editor and political commentator Shekhar Gupta wrote in a column on Saturday.

https://www.reuters.com/world/india/india-reports-another-record-daily-rise-covid-19-infections-2021-04-17/
 
Hope everybody who went to this useless mela suffer hard. But don't die.
 
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday appealed to devotees to keep a key Hindu festival symbolic as the country reported more than 200,000 new Covid-19 infections for the third straight day.

India reported 234,692 Covid-19 infections over the last 24 hours, taking the total number of cases to nearly 14.5 million, second only to the United States. Deaths in the country from Covid-19 rose by 1,341 to 175,649.

Criticism has mounted over the Indian government’s handling of the health crisis, as religious festivals and election rallies continue amid increasing reports of shortage of hospital beds, oxygen cylinders and vaccination doses.

After hundreds of thousands of ascetics and devout Hindus gathered for several days along the banks of the Ganges in a northern state for a religious festival Kumbh Mela, Modi on Saturday called for restraint, saying on Twitter the festival should now be kept "symbolic".

Responding to Modi's appeal, one of religious leader Swami Avdheshanand urged devotees to not gather in large numbers. Devout Hindus believe bathing in the holy Ganges absolves people of sins, and during the Kumbh Mela, it brings salvation from the cycle of life and death.

Experts have warned about the spread of more contagious variants of the disease, with especially during large-scale gathering for religious festivals and political rallies.

On Saturday, Modi was scheduled to hold two election rallies in eastern state of West Bengal where state elections are ongoing. In recent weeks, such rallies have attracted thousands of people, few of whom follow Covid-19 safety protocols.

"Stop spreader rallies," the Times of India said in an editorial on Saturday, adding: "Business as usual is an unaffordable luxury until this virus is conclusively tamed."

After imposing one of the world’s strictest lockdowns for nearly three months last year, India’s government relaxed almost all curbs by the beginning of 2021, although many regions have now introduced localised restrictions.

“This is Narendra Modi’s biggest crisis yet. It is bigger than any security threat, external or internal, or even the economic attrition of 2020,” prominent editor and political commentator Shekhar Gupta wrote in a column on Saturday.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/229526...-symbolic-as-indias-covid-19-infections-surge
 
After attending Kumbh Mela, Nepal’s former King Gyanendra, Queen Komal test positive for Covid

Kathmandu: Nepal’s former King Gyanendra Shah and former Queen Komal Shah have tested positive for the coronavirus on their return from India after participating in the Maha Kumbh at Haridwar, according to a media report on Tuesday.

The 73-year-old former King and 70-year-old former Queen recently returned from India where they had taken a holy dip at Haridwar’s Har Ki Pauri during the Maha Kumbh — a religious congregation of Hindu seers and devotees, according to the Health Ministry.

Their samples for the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) test were confirmed positive for the COVID-19 infection, The Himalayan Times reported.

According to the report, hundreds of people had gathered at the airport in Kathmandu to welcome the former king and queen during their arrival back home.

The authorities have also initiated a contact tracing to test anyone who came in contact with the royal couple.

https://theprint.in/world/after-att...a-queen-komal-test-positive-for-covid/642961/
 
Good lord what are these fools doing. Firstly with a population of well over 1 billion people social distancing is impossible in India. In addition to this they are having a massive religious gathering attended by millions with the blessing of the government. The Markaz was attended by much fewer people then the Kumbh as well. The pandemic is already out of control there yet they seem more interested in the Kumbh and the IPL. It's crazy.
 
If the Modi government had banned the markaz, the leftist ***** brigade would have labelled him 'intolerant and anti-muslim'.

If the kumbh had been banned, the leftists would have said nothing, but the right wingers would have come out whining and accused the government of psuedo-secularism and 'neglecting the sentiments of the majority'.

If both had been banned, both sides of the political circus would have howled.

Hard to be ruling India. :facepalm:
 
Last edited:
Testing negative without even giving a sample: What happened when I went to Kumbh Mela

Kumbh Mela, Haridwar: On 15 April, I was sitting in my hotel room in Haridwar, filing a report on the Kumbh Mela’s third shahi snaan (royal bath), when at 8.44 am, I got a text message (image below) from the Government of India saying my sample for a Rapid Antigen Test (RAT) had been successfully collected, along with the routine advice to isolate.

That’s odd, I thought. Curious, I clicked on the link that accompanied the message. A PDF (embedded below) of the ICMR Specimen Referral Form, complete with my name and phone number, opened up. It showed that my sample had been collected in Haridwar and that my result was negative.

This outcome would have not been alarming, except that I had never taken a RAT, had not filled out any Specimen Referral Form (SRF) and wasn’t at any testing facility at the time my sample was purportedly collected. In fact, at the time I was sitting in my hotel, typing out a story.

So, what had just happened?

The Uttarakhand government had on 25 March, made it mandatory for anyone attending the Kumbh Mela to have tested negative in a RT-PCR test.

https://theprint.in/iwitness/testin...at-happened-when-i-went-to-kumbh-mela/642232/
 
Shows how much of a sham it was! No wonder, we are seeing the kind of results we're in India during last fortnight or so. With so much carelessness, criminal negligence and devil may care attitude, something had to give in. It did and how!
 
Now next such humongous religious congregation happening in India is Char Dham Yatra starting from 14-May. Lets see how that is managed or mismanaged!
 
If the Modi government had banned the markaz, the leftist ***** brigade would have labelled him 'intolerant and anti-muslim'.

If the kumbh had been banned, the leftists would have said nothing, but the right wingers would have come out whining and accused the government of psuedo-secularism and 'neglecting the sentiments of the majority'.

If both had been banned, both sides of the political circus would have howled.

Hard to be ruling India. :facepalm:

The main cause of Covid spread is the people themselves. Not that much any government can do other than to send alerts and set rules.
 
It's a cultural thing. Hindus do visit Mazars, Dargas, Churches and Muslims do volunteer for organizing Pujas. It brings the communities together amidst diverse spiritual practices.
Although this can be debatable or what not but in the article it said "perform" that makes you a non muslim...
 
If the Modi government had banned the markaz, the leftist ***** brigade would have labelled him 'intolerant and anti-muslim'.

If the kumbh had been banned, the leftists would have said nothing, but the right wingers would have come out whining and accused the government of psuedo-secularism and 'neglecting the sentiments of the majority'.

If both had been banned, both sides of the political circus would have howled.

Hard to be ruling India. :facepalm:

Both should have been banned.

The objection however is how the govt aligned media and certain spokespersons tried to paint Markaz as mindless idiots(rightly so) and dark characters(not right) while keeping completely mum on the complete arrogance and lack of governance when it comes to Kumbh which has been blatantly backed by BJP CMs and ministers. That lack of objectivity and presence of clear bias is as stark as it gets in my lifetime.
 
The main cause of Covid spread is the people themselves. Not that much any government can do other than to send alerts and set rules.

You are wrong here. Govt has been facilitator with open Statements in media. The fact is the BJP CMs in UP and adjoining areas are bigots and idiots of highest order. It's a failure of BJP that they could not get better leaders to rule their states. If Yogi Adityanath is indeed the best of their current lot then in 10 years time BJP will suffer the same fate as current Congress.
 
Although this can be debatable or what not but in the article it said "perform" that makes you a non muslim...

There is nothing to debate man. It is upto him how he wants to lead his life and how he wants to identify himself. He should not need permission from anybody to call himself a Muslim or Hindu or whatever.
 
You are wrong here. Govt has been facilitator with open Statements in media. The fact is the BJP CMs in UP and adjoining areas are bigots and idiots of highest order. It's a failure of BJP that they could not get better leaders to rule their states. If Yogi Adityanath is indeed the best of their current lot then in 10 years time BJP will suffer the same fate as current Congress.

I am not giving a clean chit. I believe that any step GOI or its elected leaders and even opposition take should be open to constructive criticism as we are a democracy.

When I said not much any government can do, I was talking about the entire government system including the leadership, administration, the industry and the health care professionals themselves.
You will agree that there is more to GOI than Modi or Yogi or Sonia or Rahul.

I know the leadership should prohibit gatherings like Markaz or Kumbh mela and I admit they failed there.

What about the people?
Everyone knows the creed of politicians very well in India. For every politician who says its ok to gather, there are 1000's of sane advisors (medical and well wishing friends) who say don't crowd, wear masks, wash hands etc.
Don't believe that people can claim ignorance and start gathering.

Bash the politicians as we will but the fact remains that people (including us) are to blame now. The stage of government controlling Indian population or educating masses has long gone. It has been one year and by now everyone knows the risks but still keeps adding to it. Some do it as they have no choice and some do it just because they can exercise their freedom.

Not much any government system can do other than to hold their end and keep developing solutions as best as they can.
In cricketing parlance, the GOI and the entire health care industry is batting to score sixes and be criticised for dot balls while the asking rate is too high.
 
Last edited:
I am not giving a clean chit. I believe that any step GOI or its elected leaders and even opposition take should be open to constructive criticism as we are a democracy.

When I said not much any government can do, I was talking about the entire government system including the leadership, administration, the industry and the health care professionals themselves.
You will agree that there is more to GOI than Modi or Yogi or Sonia or Rahul.

I know the leadership should prohibit gatherings like Markaz or Kumbh mela and I admit they failed there.

What about the people?
Everyone knows the creed of politicians very well in India. For every politician who says its ok to gather, there are 1000's of sane advisors (medical and well wishing friends) who say don't crowd, wear masks, wash hands etc.
Don't believe that people can claim ignorance and start gathering.

Bash the politicians as we will but the fact remains that people (including us) are to blame now. The stage of government controlling Indian population or educating masses has long gone. It has been one year and by now everyone knows the risks but still keeps adding to it. Some do it as they have no choice and some do it just because they can exercise their freedom.

Not much any government system can do other than to hold their end and keep developing solutions as best as they can.
In cricketing parlance, the GOI and the entire health care industry is batting to score sixes and be criticised for dot balls while the asking rate is too high.

Completely agree on the naivety of people and they are indeed responsible for this mess. But end of the day Govt is accountable. If they can be critical of Markaz(and I support that), what stops them from taking a stand against Kumbh gathering? Shouldn't the learnings from Markaz be enough to stop Kumbh rather than glorifying it?

People wont like it, I agree. But then job of the govt is to enact things in the best interest of the citizens, not necessarily go by the popular culture. The fact is that this government failed royally in Covid management.

Does not make state governments or opposition parties any saints but central government has the majority accountability in the overall management and has failed miserably in last two months.
 
Completely agree on the naivety of people and they are indeed responsible for this mess. But end of the day Govt is accountable. If they can be critical of Markaz(and I support that), what stops them from taking a stand against Kumbh gathering? Shouldn't the learnings from Markaz be enough to stop Kumbh rather than glorifying it?

People wont like it, I agree. But then job of the govt is to enact things in the best interest of the citizens, not necessarily go by the popular culture. The fact is that this government failed royally in Covid management.

Does not make state governments or opposition parties any saints but central government has the majority accountability in the overall management and has failed miserably in last two months.

Yes, agree about leadership failure (at UP and MH especially and now in the UK CM statements in OP).

Also agree central govt be held accountable but shouldn't this be done if they have encouraged these brash decisions?
But fact is the center has not. Earlier last year, when the center had imposed strict rules, there was a backlash from state govts abut timing and logistic and there were calls that state govt be allowed to set their own rules. At that time there was a bit of politicking involved as all parties were using Covid to further their interests and to shift the blame to central govt.
and tbh Covid hadn't spread to all states equally but the fear of covid was very huge so people believed what they were fed.

The state govts have now got their freedom and are taking their own decisions and obviously they are still catering to their vote banks and uttering words which make them popular with one community while it riles up the other communities.
The common cry is that why don't the central government do something about it?

IMO, the central government is playing safe because they know opposition will make it a political issue. Search the net and scroll through the last 5 posts each from Priyanka and Rahul where they admonish the central government and steer clear of criticizing the state governments where they rule. At least Kejriwal is focusing on the urgent need and pushing for oxygen supplies in Delhi hospitals.

Right now, no one has a clue on how to handle this situation and are alternately blaming one or another.

I sincerely think that Modi govt. throw caution to the wind and declare this as a national emergency and force states to work under an emergency framework.
If people complain about lack of jobs, let states bear the burden of wages and employment.
If people complain about migrant workers being forced to move, let state govt handle the logistics.
If people complain about freedom of movement (Kumbh Markaz or any of hundreds of reasons people find to gather), just don't give in. Lose the vote bank but stand firm.
 
Last edited:
It's been at least a week and a half since the Mela began.

Hope every single person bar none who attended it is suffering Covid symptoms right now, gasping for breath as the triple mutant does its thing. But I also hope they live to tell the tale - and walk about for the rest of their lives as a live example of stupidity that kids mustn't emulate.
 
It's been at least a week and a half since the Mela began.

Hope every single person bar none who attended it is suffering Covid symptoms right now, gasping for breath as the triple mutant does its thing. But I also hope they live to tell the tale - and walk about for the rest of their lives as a live example of stupidity that kids mustn't emulate.

While I understand your frustration, I also pray that your wish doesn't come true.
 
Covid does not recognise Markaz or Kumbh. It attacks anywhere people are converged in large numbers. Last year the Indian right media was blasting the tableeghi jamaat for being carriers of this pandemic. Now with the Kumbh they are so silent that can hear a pin drop. Perhaps Indian people here can explain?
 
Covid does not recognise Markaz or Kumbh. It attacks anywhere people are converged in large numbers. Last year the Indian right media was blasting the tableeghi jamaat for being carriers of this pandemic. Now with the Kumbh they are so silent that can hear a pin drop. Perhaps Indian people here can explain?

Yes Covid doesn't care for anyone. and everyone blamed each other wrongly whereas they only needed to watch their own steps.

Lol, Indian media is not truly Indian. all of them are politically aligned and news that you see often is very tainted views of one media house. Same goes for social media posts.
So whenever you want, you can buy your favourite news if you know which news channel to see/read.
 
Yes Covid doesn't care for anyone. and everyone blamed each other wrongly whereas they only needed to watch their own steps.

Lol, Indian media is not truly Indian. all of them are politically aligned and news that you see often is very tainted views of one media house. Same goes for social media posts.
So whenever you want, you can buy your favourite news if you know which news channel to see/read.

Aptly said.
 
Coronavirus | Registration for Amarnath yatra suspended: Officials

The Shri Amarnath Shrine Board (SASB), which organises the annual yatra in Kashmir, on Thursday announced to temporarily suspend the registration of pilgrims for the upcoming pilgrimage.

"In view of evolving COVID situation in the country and the need to take all necessary precautionary measures, registration for Shri Amarnath ji Yatra is being temporarily suspended. The situation is being constantly monitored and it would be reopened once the situation improves," a Board spokesman said.

The board had started registration of pilgrims online from April 15 for the Baltal and the Pahalgam routes, which leads to the Amarnath cave shrine. The 56-day yatra will start from June 28.

The annual pilgrimage was suspended in 2019 and 2020, first due to the Centre decision to end J&K's special constitutional position and later due to the pandemic.

https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/covid-19-registration-for-amarnath-yatra-suspended-officials/article34383865.ece
 
Kumbh Mela Now ‘Symbolic’, Yet Crowds Gather for Last ‘Shahi Snan’

Despite the mounting COVID-19 cases that have left the country’s hospitals and crematoriums overburdened, a crowd of Hindu devotees gathered at ‘Har Ki Pauri’ in Haridwar on Tuesday, 27 April, for the last ‘shahi snan’ at the Kumbh Mela.

Visuals showed scores of pilgrims taking a holy dip in the Ganga, flouting physical distancing measures with no masks in sight.

https://www.thequint.com/news/india...f64f-3b62487d6e-137974814#read-more#read-more
 
So even after happenings of last few weeks, there are still people who consider this as more important than well being of themselves and others. Truly regrettable.
 
Three days before the Kumbh Mela in Haridwar comes to an end, around 1,350 seers from various akharas and 25,000 devotees bathed in Brahmkund at Har Ki Pauri during the last shahi snan on Tuesday — nearly 1 per cent of the total attendance expected by the authorities for the shahi snan on April 27.

Hours later, the Haridwar district administration announced a ‘corona curfew’ in Haridwar in the evening. It will be effective from April 28 to the morning of May 3.

After an appeal by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and amid criticism over violation of Covid protocols at the Mela, the akharas had agreed to mark a symbolic Kumbh Mela to avoid any new coronavirus infections.

IG Kumbh Mela, Sanjay Gunjyal, told The Indian Express, “Following appeal from the Prime Minister and constant review by the Chief Minister, akharas cooperated in keeping the crowd low today. There were meetings with akharas daily over the last three days on crowd management. They followed social distancing too. Even Naga sadhus wore masks.”

Police personnel also participated in a shahi snan and officials said it was “symbolic”. Before the shahi snan Tuesday, Gunjyal visited every akhara camp to ensure attendance was restricted.

According to data shared by the police, around 85 seers from Niranjani and Anand akhadas, 250 from Juna, Agni and Ahvaham; 80 from Mahanirvani and Atal; around 600 from Nirmohi, Nirvani and Diganmbar, around 230 from Bada Udaseen and Naya Udaseen and 100 from Nirmal akhara took part in the shahi snan Tuesday.

The footfall of devotees during the first shahi snan on March 11 was 32 lakh and the figure was almost the same on the second shahi snan on April 14. Attendance came down to 13 lakh on the third shahi snan on April 14.

Juna Akhara spokesperson Mahant Narayan Giri said, “In view of appeals from Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah, we kept the shahi snan symbolic today. Around 5,000 seers and followers with 150 chariots had taken part in each of the past three shahi snans… Around 90 per cent seers and followers who had come from other states have already returned.”

https://indianexpress.com/article/i...-seers-mark-last-shahi-snan-7291759/#comments
 
So even after happenings of last few weeks, there are still people who consider this as more important than well being of themselves and others. Truly regrettable.

To be honest I am not surprised at all.


May Allah SWT protect us all from this evil disease.
 
To be honest I am not surprised at all.


May Allah SWT protect us all from this evil disease.
Me too.

Religion makes so many of us totally immune to rational thinking which of course no religion teaches us but our faulty interpretation of the religious teachings.
 
At the beginning of March, it seemed that India had the COVID-19 pandemic under control.

But a number of public events over the past few weeks have seen the virus take hold with devastating consequences.

The Health Ministry has announced yet another record number of cases and deaths in the last 24 hours, with 379,257 new cases and 3,645 new deaths.

World Health Organisation experts and leading doctors say large gatherings have played a major part in a dramatic rise in cases.

A religious festival lasting several weeks, which began on 11 March, saw more than three million people gather on the banks of the River Ganges.

Pilgrims to Kumbh Mela, which is celebrated about once every 12 years by Hindus, believe a dip in the holy river will wash away their sins.

Regional governments throughout the country have now asked those who've taken part to self-isolate and get tested.

The chart below shows how the number of cases has risen as major events have been held.

The decision to allow the festival to take place has been heavily criticised.

Political rallies have also attracted large crowds where social distancing has been absent.

While key elections in some states have been taking place in March and April, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has continued campaigning with rallies drawing large numbers of supporters.

The rise in COVID-19 infections from these events has prompted a high court to blame the Election Commission of India for allowing the polls to go ahead during a pandemic.

The Indian government has said more than 200,000 people have died from coronavirus so far, although many believe the real figure is much higher.

Earlier in April, daily new cases in Delhi started increasing exponentially, doubling every six days.

Last week, a record was set with more than 28,000 cases identified in 24 hours.

The map below shows which area have been worst hit.

Maharashtra, where the city of Mumbai is located, is also seeing a steady rise in daily infections with case rates doubling every two weeks or so.

The graph below shows how case rates in the two worst hit states - Delhi and Maharashtra - compare.

Although daily cases have declined in the past few days, experts say this is largely due to a drop in testing.

Health economist Rijo M John of the Indian Institute of Management in Kerala, a southern state said: "This should not be taken as an indication of falling cases, rather a matter of missing out on too many positive cases."

SKY
 
Me too.

Religion makes so many of us totally immune to rational thinking which of course no religion teaches us but our faulty interpretation of the religious teachings.

Nah... this one is entirely on our collective stupidity and foolishness.

“When you hear that [a plague] is in a land, do not go to it and if it occurs in a land that you are already in, then do not leave it, fleeing from it,” the Prophet (Peace be upon him) said.

You see, Muslims who are not following doctors' advice are going against teachings of Islam.

And of course, there are examples of so many people who don't follow any religions yet are so stubborn when it comes to using common sense.
 
70 Lakh Participated In Kumbh Mela Held Amid Covid Surge

Dehradun/Rishikesh: Seventy lakh devotees participated in Haridwar's Kumbh Mela, the mammoth religious congregation which ended Friday after triggering a scare that it might have acted as a coronavirus "super-spreader".

Despite the huge number of people gathering around Haridwar to take a dip in the holy Ganga, the 2021 event was a comparatively modest event -- reduced to just one month and scaled down midway due to the raging pandemic.

Held over three months in normal circumstances, the Kumbh Mela this time formally begun as late as April 1 due to concerns over COVID-19.

About 2,600 devotees tested positive out of the nearly two lakh tests conducted by medical personnel during the mela.

Three shahi snans took place during the event on April 12, 14 and 27, the last one being reduced to a largely symbolic event.

Haridwar's Chief Medical Officer SK Jha said the Kumbh was a big challenge considering its potential to fuel the surge of coronavirus.

Medical officer for Kumbh Arjun Singh Sengar said, "The situation was challenging for us as the crowd, though relatively smaller this time was big enough to violate the norms of social distancing."

"The seers were initially reluctant to go for tests but they relented after the second shahi snan on April 14," he said.

"With the help of healthcare personnel brought from Uttar Pradesh, we conducted a total of 1,900,83 tests, out of which 2642 reported positive," he said.

The "scaling down" is said to be the first in the history of the mela, which is held once every twelve years in Haridwar.

The crowds began petering out after an appeal by Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the seers to keep their representation in Kumbh symbolic.

The Joona Akhada, the largest among the sects which attend the mela, was the first to respond to PM Modi's appeal, followed by several other akhadas which withdrew from the event.

Ordinary devotees then followed their example.

Mela organisers claim that the event, among the largest religious gatherings on earth, passed off without any serious untoward incident anywhere in the Kumbh Mela Kshetra spread over an area of 641 hectares from Haridwar to Devprayag.

Mela Inspector General Sanjay Gunjyal claimed this to be a "first" since 1912.

"A stampede, a clash or a dispute among seers of different Akhadas marked most of the editions of the event in the past. But this time, despite the extraordinary circumstances arising out of a strong second wave of coronavirus, the Kumbh Mela passed off without any interruption," he said.

"It is a kind of record," he told PTI

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/70-lakh-participated-in-kumbh-mela-amid-covid-19-surge-2425654
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Last year around 5K markaz participants were termed super spreaders, Corona Jihadists and what not by Godi media and bhakts.

This year, there were 7 million devotees (let this number sink in for once!) who took plunge without caring about any Covid protocols with open support from feku and his gang.

Will bhakts finally shed their pretense of being rational beings and lambast these Corona 'hindus' as well?
 
When millions of devout Hindus gathered last month in the Himalayan town of Haridwar to participate in the Kumbh Mela festival even as India battled a devastating second wave of coronavirus, many feared that it would turn out to be a "super-spreader event".

Those fears, it now seems, are coming true, with reports of Kumbh returnees testing positive - and possibly spreading the infection - coming from many parts of the country.

When Mahant Shankar Das arrived in Haridwar on 15 March to participate in the festival, cases of Covid-19 were already rising in many parts of India.

On 4 April, just four days after the festival officially began, the 80-year-old Hindu priest tested positive for Covid-19 and was advised to quarantine in a tent.

But instead of isolating, he packed his bags, boarded a train and travelled 1,000km (621 miles) to the city of Varanasi.

There, his son Nagendra Pathak met him at the railway station and they rode a shared taxi to their village 20km (12 miles) away in the adjoining district of Mirzapur.

Speaking to me on the phone from his home recently, Mahant Das said he was "now hale and hearty" and that after his return, he had remained at home in quarantine.

He insisted that he did not pass on the virus to anyone else, but within days, his son and a few other villagers also developed Covid symptoms.

Mr Pathak, who's also made a full recovery, says their village has seen "13 deaths in the past fortnight from fever and cough".

The infections in the villagers may - or may not - be linked to Mahant Das, but health experts say his behaviour was irresponsible and that by travelling in a crowded train and sharing a taxi, he may have spread the virus to many along the way.

Epidemiologist Dr Lalit Kant says "huge groups of mask-less pilgrims sitting on the river bank singing the glories of the Ganges" created an ideal environment for the virus to spread rapidly. "We already know that chorus singing in churches and temples are known to be super-spreader events."

In Haridwar, officials said 2,642 devotees had tested positive, including dozens of top religious leaders.

Akhilesh Yadav, former chief minister of neighbouring Uttar Pradesh state, and Nepal's former King Gyanendra Shah and former Queen Komal Shah, were among those who tested positive after returning home. Bollywood composer Shravan Rathod died in a Mumbai hospital soon after his return from Kumbh. Nine Hindu seers from one group also perished.

With growing fears that the Kumbh returnees could start to infect others, several worried state governments ordered a 14-day mandatory quarantine and warned of strict action against those who withheld information about their travels.

Some made the RT-PCR test mandatory for them, but few states have a database of travellers and no state has a foolproof system of testing and tracing those entering its borders.

In the past fortnight, reports of Kumbh returnees testing positive have come from all over India:

Authorities in Rajasthan blame the pilgrims for the rapid spread of Covid cases in the state, especially in rural areas
At least 24 Kumbh visitors tested positive on return to the eastern state of Odisha (formerly Orissa)
In Gujarat, at least 34 of a total of 313 passengers returning by one train were positive
And 60 of the 61 - or 99% - returnees tested in a town in central Madhya Pradesh state were found to be infected. Officials are now frantically looking for 22 others who are missing

"It's disastrous," says Dr Kant. "And these numbers are only the tip of the iceberg. The groups of pilgrims travelling in crowded trains and buses would have the multiplier effect on the number of infections. I can say without hesitation that the Kumbh Mela is one of the main reasons behind the rise in cases in India."

Mahant Das is combative when I ask him if it would have been better to cancel the Kumbh at a time India was recording huge surges in daily cases and hospitals were turning away patients due to a shortage of beds, medical oxygen and life-saving drugs.

"How is it right for the government to hold election rallies and elections in West Bengal then? Why is it that only we, the devout, are being told that it was wrong to gather?" he asks.

Critics say Prime Minister Narendra Modi's reluctance to cancel the gathering was because of possible backlash from Hindu religious leaders like Mahant Das. The priests, the seers and the ascetics are among the party's biggest supporters and play an important role in mobilising Hindu votes during elections.

On 12 April, the first big day of the festival - when more than three million devotees took a dip in the river Ganges in the belief that bathing there would help them attain salvation - India logged more than 168,000 new cases, overtaking Brazil to become the country with the second-highest number of cases globally.

The festival was scaled down only a week later after the lead monk of one of the participating groups died. Mr Modi requested the seers to turn the festival from then on into a symbolic event.

But the damage had already been done.

Last week, the event organisers said 9.1 million pilgrims visited Haridwar even as the Uttarakhand high court said the state had become a "laughing stock by allowing the Kumbh Mela in the midst of a raging pandemic".

There had been concerns from the start that holding the Kumbh was fraught with risks.

Health experts had warned the government in early March that "a new and more contagious variant of the coronavirus was taking hold in the country" and letting millions of largely unmasked people gather for a festival was not prudent.

Uttarakhand's former chief minister, Trivendra Singh Rawat, told me that he had planned the Kumbh to be a "limited, symbolic event" from the start because experts were "telling me that the pandemic is not going to end soon".

"The festival attracts people from not just India, but other countries too. I was worried that healthy people would visit Haridwar and take the infection back with them everywhere. "

But just days before the festival, he was replaced by Tirath Singh Rawat, who famously remarked that with "the blessings of Ma Ganga [Ganges, the river goddess] in the flow, there would be no corona".

The new chief minister said "nobody will be stopped", a negative Covid report was not necessary to attend, and that it would be enough to follow safety rules. But as millions descended on the town, officials struggled to impose safety norms.

Haridwar's chief medical officer, Dr Shambhu Kumar Jha, told me that crowd management became "very difficult" because people didn't come with negative reports and that they "couldn't turn back the devout who had come all the way driven by faith".

"You can't hang people for wanting to attend a religious festival, can you?" he asked.

"There were standard operating procedures (SOPs) by the federal government and the high court and we tried our best to implement them," he added.

"With crowds of that size, SOPs became almost impossible to follow. They look very good on paper, but it's impossible to implement them," Anoop Nautiyal, founder of an Uttarakhand-based think tank, told the BBC.

Mr Nautiyal, who has been collating the health ministry data since the state recorded its first case on 15 March 2020, says Uttarakhand had recorded 557 cases in the week from 14 to 20 March, just as pilgrims had begun arriving. The cases rose rapidly after that, with 38,581 cases recorded between 25 April and 1 May - the last week of the festival.

"It will be wrong to say all the cases were because of the festival, but the surge has coincided with the festival," he said.

I asked Dr Kant if there's anything India could do now to contain the damage done by allowing the gathering.

"Someone said that the devotees will take the coronavirus as prasad [god's blessing] and spread it. It's tragic that the pilgrims have carried the infection everywhere," he said.

"I can't think of anything that can be done now to rectify the situation. Our ship has gone too far out into the sea. We can't even return to the safety of the harbour. It's very, very tragic. I just pray that the infections were mild and people can get over them."

BBC
 
Shouldn’t have gone to Kumbh, ‘Covid-guilty’ mela returnees now say in MP’s Vidisha

Vidisha (Madhya Pradesh): At a time when India was reporting record high Covid-19 figures in the second wave around April, Kanhaiya Lal, a 49-year-old teacher in Gyaraspur, a small town in Madhya Pradesh’s Vidisha district, was attending the Kumbh Mela in Haridwar — between 11 and 15 April.

Lal returned home on 16 April, and soon after, started complaining of high fever and body ache. In the next few days, he along with many other people who had returned to the district from the Kumbh Mela, were traced by the administration and tested for Covid.

Lal tested positive, went into isolation and recovered in a few weeks.

But a month on, he is still battling guilt and regret for visiting the religious congregation that some have now started calling a Covid “super spreader“.

“I shouldn’t have gone, not when there was a Covid surge. Cases in Vidisha began rising rapidly after we (Kumbh attendees) returned. That’s when I realised that it had been a mistake,” said Lal.

Lal is not alone in repenting the visit to the mela. Many others in the district — from where highest number of people had gone to Kumbh — shared his feeling. But mixed with this regret was a sense that there had been a lapse on the part of the government.

“The government shouldn’t have allowed it, either. It’s only because the government allowed it that we felt it was safe to go. There’s no way such a congregation should have been allowed in those times,” said Lal.

According to data shared by Additional District Magistrate (ADM), Vidisha, Vrindavan Singh, Lal was one of the 60 returnees who tested positive in Gyaraspur — among the 83 traced in the entire district.

Some of those ThePrint spoke to in Vidisha also questioned the timing of the elections — also crowd-pullers — held in many states that month, arguing that the polls didn’t even have the logic of adhering to religious sentiments that the mela had.

The Kumbh Mela, held between 11 March and 30 April, earned widespread criticism for the Modi government. The religious congregation, where millions gather to take a holy dip, saw extensive flouting of Covid protocols with few people wearing masks and following social distancing.

Following criticism, the government did eventually scale down the gathering from 17 April onwards, announcing that the mela should only continue as a “symbolic” event.

But by then, many Kumbh attendees had already returned to their hometowns. According to the state health bulletin, the total active cases in Madhya Pradesh stood at 55,694 on 15 April. On 17 April, when the situation seemed to be getting out of hand, the state home ministry asked for Kumbh returnees in the state to be traced and tested. By 26 April, the total number of active cases in the state had risen to 95,864.

In Kherua Haat, a small village in Vidisha, residents said there had been barely any Covid cases till March. Then, a busload of 40-odd villagers travelled to Haridwar for the Kumbh Mela, and when they returned, there was sudden spike in numbers.

Vikram Raghuvanshi, 28, thought he was just being a dutiful nephew, when he took his 50-year-old aunt Maya Bai, whom he addresses as ‘Badi Ma’, with him to the Kumbh Mela for the first snan (bath/dip) on 11 March.

“When we came back, we realised just how quickly the cases began rising because of us. If the mela had been cancelled, none of this would have happened. The village wouldn’t have had to be sealed for weeks,” he said.

The 28-year-old had also tested positive for Covid, though his aunt had not been infected.

What made matters even more precarious was that many of the attendees from the village were elderly — like Govind Raghuvanshi and Bhogiram Raghuvanshi, two brothers, both aged in seventies.

“We went for the first snan in March because cases weren’t as high at that time. But even then, so many of us got Covid and infected others,” said Govind.

Both brothers said they had all the symptoms of Covid after they returned from the Kumbh, but their results were negative. Still, they followed the prescribed Covid treatment and have since recovered.

Govind felt that even if the first snan in March was allowed — the Covid scene wasn’t so out of hand yet — the subsequent days could have been cancelled.

“At least in April, the Mela should have been completely cancelled, given the rise of cases,” he added.


His brother Bhogiram agreed, and gave examples of other gatherings that had been curbed during the pandemic. “If weddings and other mass congregations could be cancelled, why not the Kumbh?” he questioned and added that “there were no restrictions (Covid appropriate behaviour) being adhered to” at the mela.

Some in Vidisha felt that it was the multi-state elections “being held around the same time” that gave people the confidence to attend the mela. If the polls were not being conducted, they felt, the pandemic situation couldn’t be so bad.

“No one stopped the elections in five states. The Kumbh is a matter of Hindu aastha [faith]. But the elections weren’t stopped either, and that resulted in a gathering too. People saw all that crowd and felt it was okay to travel for the Kumbh too,” reasoned Brajesh Kumar, the Kherua haat village sarpanch.

https://theprint.in/india/shouldnt-...mela-returnees-now-say-in-mps-vidisha/661495/
 
No wonder ECI has been called murderer by Madras HC. And we all know how big murderer the current regime is!
 
similar news

--------------------
Gujarat Villagers Take Out Religious Procession To "Prevent Coronavirus", 86 Arrested: Cops


Over a hundred people from a Gujarat village took out the procession on May 22 to perform a ritual with a belief that it will "prevent coronavirus" from affecting their village, a local police official said.


Himmatnagar (Gujarat): More than 80 people were arrested after a social media video showed them participating in a religious procession for performing a ritual to "protect" their village from the scourge of coronavirus in Prantij taluka in Gujarat's Sabarkantha district, police said on Tuesday.
Over a hundred people from Lalpur village took out the procession on May 22 to perform a ritual with a belief that it will "prevent coronavirus" from affecting their village, a local police official said.

He said some members of the procession beat drums while others, including women, carried a ''kalash'' or a small pot filled with sacred water on their heads.

Police came to know about the incident on Monday after a video went viral on social media, said Prantij police inspector PL Vaghela.

"We have registered an FIR against 28 identified and a hundred unidentified people for participating in the procession in violation of the government's notification regarding the coronavirus pandemic. We arrested 83 people in the last two days," the officer said.

A case was registered against the participants of the procession, including women, under the provisions of the Epidemic Diseases Act, the Disaster Management Act, and under section 188 (disobedience to order duly issued by public servant) of the Indian Penal Code, he said.

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/gujarat-villagers-take-out-religious-procession-to-prevent-coronavirus-86-arrested-cops-2449059
 
Lucknow: The Uttarakhand government on Tuesday decided to cancel the annual 'Kanwar Yatra' in view of the looming threat of the third wave of COVID-19. However, the Uttar Pradesh government has given the nod for the yatra that begins on July 25.

In an important development, the Supreme Court has taken suo motu cognizance of the UP government's decision to allow Kanwar Yatra. A notice has been issued to the UP government in this regard. A bench headed by Justice RF Nariman posted the matter for hearing on July 16.

"Amid fears of a possible third wave of COVID-19, the Uttarakhand government has suspended the 'Kanwar Yatra' even as neighbouring Uttar Pradesh is pressing ahead with the annual ritual that sees a heavy movement of pilgrims across states in the northern belt. We read something disturbing in the media today that the state of UP has chosen to continue with the 'Kanwar Yatra', while the state of Uttarakhand with its hindsight of experience, has said that there will be no Yatra. We wish to know what the stand of the respective governments is. The citizens of India are completely perplexed. They don't know what is going on. And all this amid the Prime Minister, when asked about the third wave of COVID-19 striking the nation, saying 'we cannot compromise even one bit'. We are issuing notice to the Centre, the state of UP and the state of Uttarakhand and because the yatra is scheduled to leave from 25 July, we want them to file an early response so that the matter can be heard on Friday," said Justice RF Nariman.

Earlier, Uttarakhand Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami announced: "We decided to cancel the yatra, according topmost priority to human life in view of the threat of a possible third wave, the surfacing of the Delta Plus variant of the virus and its impact across the country and abroad."

This may be recalled that the Uttarakhand government was criticised for holding the Kumbh Mela in Haridwar in April as several COVID-19 norms were brazenly violated during the event.

In addition, the CM has asked Director General of Police Ashok Kumar to work closely with officials of neighbouring states to stop any spread of the virus.

The BJP is in power in both Uttarakhand and Uttar Pradesh.

The UP government, which had suspended the Kanwar Yatra in 2020, has decided to allow the two-week-long annual pilgrimage for devotees of Lord Shiva, or kanwariyas, this year with strict adherence to COVID-19 protocols.

Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath has asked officials to ensure that just a few people take part in the yatra and COVID-19 protocols, particularly social distancing, be strictly implemented.

The government may make a negative RT-PCR test report compulsory for pilgrims.

The CM has also officials to take special care of cleanliness and proper lighting in all travel routes, Shiva temples, and shivalayas.

This may be noted that the Indian Medical Association has warned against conducting the yatra due to the COVID-19 situation.

As part of the pilgrimage, lakhs of devotees travel on foot to Uttarakhand’s Haridwar and other parts of the country to fetch holy water from the Ganga River. Then, they offer the same at various Shiva temples.

https://www.timesnownews.com/india/...anwar-yatra-but-up-decides-to-go-ahead/784685
 
Coronavirus News LIVE Updates: The Supreme Court directed state governments to not permit the movement of Kanwariyas for bringing ‘Ganga Jal’ from Haridwar in view of Covid-19. “Considering religious sentiments, State govts must develop system to make ‘Ganga Jal’ available via tankers at designated locations,” SC said.

An Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) study revealed that the majority of the clinical cases in the breakthrough were infected with the Delta variant, only 9.8% of cases required hospitalization while fatality was observed in only 0.4% cases. This clearly suggests that the vaccination does provide reduction in hospital admission and mortality, said the study.

In the past 24 hours, India recorded 38,949 fresh cases, pushing the active case load to 4,30,422, as per data by Health Ministry. After the Uttar Pradesh government allowed the Kanwar Yatra which has been suspended by neighbouring Uttarakhand amid fears of a possible third Covid-19 wave, the Supreme Court sought responses by Friday from the Centre and the governments of UP and Uttarakhand. With the wide prevalence of the Delta variant, the Manipur Government has announced a total curfew for 10 days, starting July 18.

NEWS18
 
Kanwar yatra is a problem and can spread covid, i agree.

But the state reporting highest covid cases and highest TPR, can relax covid norms for Eid. Thats ok,?

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Lockdown restrictions will be relaxed on July 18, 19 & 20 as part of Bakrid. Apart from shops selling essential items in the A, B & C categories, permission will be given to open textile shops, footwear shops, electronics shops, fancy shops & jewellery shops till 8 pm: Kerala CMO</p>— ANI (@ANI) <a href="https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1416009457629220867?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">July 16, 2021</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
Kanwar yatra is a problem and can spread covid, i agree.

But the state reporting highest covid cases and highest TPR, can relax covid norms for Eid. Thats ok,?

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Lockdown restrictions will be relaxed on July 18, 19 & 20 as part of Bakrid. Apart from shops selling essential items in the A, B & C categories, permission will be given to open textile shops, footwear shops, electronics shops, fancy shops & jewellery shops till 8 pm: Kerala CMO</p>— ANI (@ANI) <a href="https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1416009457629220867?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">July 16, 2021</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

I am seeing similar kind of things done by the EU governments.

Economy is the reason.

But it is still reckless especially now that delta "Indian" variant is punishing us all.
 
PRAYAGRAJ, INDIA:Hundreds of thousands of Hindu worshippers gathered on the banks of India's Ganges river on Friday for a holy bathe despite a 30-fold rise in coronavirus cases in the past month.

Hindus believe a bath in the holy river on the January 14 Makarsankranti festival washes away sins.

A large number of devotees were taking a dip in the sacred river where it flows through the eastern state of West Bengal, which is reporting the most number of cases in the country after Maharashtra state in the west.

In the northern state of Uttar Pradesh, thousands of devotees, few wearing masks, thronged the river's banks in the holy city of Prayagraj.

"I can't breathe with a mask," Ram Phal Tripathi, who came with his family from a village in Uttar Pradesh state, said after emerging from the river.

"Every year I come for a holy dip. How could I have missed it this year?"

India is again facing a surge in coronavirus cases, fuelled mostly by the highly transmissible Omicron variant, but hospitalisations are low, with most people recovering at home.

Doctors had appealed unsuccessfully to the West Bengal state high court to reverse a decision to allow the festival this year, worrying it will become a virus "super spreader" event.

Last year, a big religious gathering in northern India contributed to a record rise in coronavirus cases.

On Friday, the health ministry reported 264,202 new cases of the coronavirus in the previous 24 hours, taking India's total tally to 36.58 million.

Deaths from COVID-19 rose by 315, with total now at 485,350, the ministry said.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/233870...ns-gather-for-holy-dip-defying-covid-19-surge
 
These people won't ever get it. Not only they endanger themselves but they endanger the health of those who they'll mingle with later on.
 
Laurene Powell Jobs, the widow of Apple co-founder Steve Jobs, has arrived in Prayagraj to participate in the Maha Kumbh Mela. A devoted follower of Swami Kailashnand Giri, the Acharya Mahamandleshwar of Niranjini Akhara, Ms Laurene reached the spiritual camp on Saturday night, accompanied by a 40-member team.

Dressed in a peach-yellow salwar suit with a Rakshasutra on her arm and a Rudraksha mala around her neck, the American businesswoman-philanthropist was warmly welcomed at the camp on Sunday, as per news agency ANI. The reception included a grand trumpet fanfare, and she was served hot masala tea in a traditional kulhad.

Ms Laurene will stay at the Niranjini Akhara camp till January 15, before returning to the US to attend the swearing-in ceremony of President-elect Donald Trump on January 20.

Before arriving in Prayagraj, she visited the Kashi Vishwanath Temple in Varanasi on Saturday. She was accompanied by Swami Kailashanand Giri Maharaj of Niranjani Akhara.

Wearing a salwar suit and a dupatta on her head, Ms Laurene offered prayers from outside the main temple area. Swami Kailashanand explained that according to temple tradition, no one other than a Hindu can touch the Shivling, which is why she prayed from outside the sanctum.

"I am an Acharya, and it is my duty to uphold traditions, principles, and conduct," he explained to news agency ANI.

"She is my daughter," he added. "All of our family participated in the 'Abhishek' and worshipped. She was given a prasad and a garland. However, the tradition is that anyone other than a Hindu cannot touch Kashi Vishwanath. If I do not maintain this tradition, then it will be broken."

Swami Kailashanand also spoke to ANI about her profound respect for Indian traditions and spirituality. "She is very religious and spiritual," he said. "She wants to learn about our traditions. She respects me as a father and a Guru. Everyone can learn from her. Indian traditions are being accepted by the world."

The Maha Kumbh Mela, held at the confluence of the Ganga, Yamuna, and the mythical Saraswati rivers, witnessed a massive influx of devotees on Sunday, with nearly 50 lakh pilgrims taking a holy dip ahead of Paush Purnima, the first bathing festival.

The ceremonial Amrit Snan (auspicious bath) is scheduled for January 14, marking Makar Sankranti. All akharas, including Niranjini Akhara, will take their ordained dips in a sequence, with the Niranjini Akhara slated to bathe between 7:05 am and 7:45 am.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Link: https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/ste...ives-in-prayagraj-for-maha-kumbh-mela-7461265
 
That toxic sludge a.k.a the Ganges river of Uttar Pradesh is unfortunately going to hurt a lot of people.
 
Back
Top