What's new

Markhor is Pakistan's national animal – so why is its hunting allowed?

FearlessRoar

T20I Star
Joined
Sep 11, 2023
Runs
30,521
The Kashmir markhor, known for its iconic twisted horns, is not only a symbol of Pakistan’s wildlife but also its national animal. However, despite its endangered status, the government permits trophy hunting of this majestic species through a regulated program.

Why does Pakistan allow the hunting of its national animal? Is this practice truly helping in preserving the species, or is it putting the markhor's future at risk?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

American hunter secures first Kashmir Markhor of season in Chitral with record bid​


A significant moment in trophy hunting occurred as American hunter Ronald Geo Whinton successfully hunted the first Kashmir markhor of the season in Chitral with the highest permit bid ever placed in Pakistan’s history.

According to local media, Farooq Nabi, the Divisional Forest Officer (Wildlife) for Chitral, Whinton won the permit in an open auction held in October, paying a record $271,000.

The permit allowed him to hunt the endangered species under the supervision of wildlife authorities. The hunt took place on Sunday, and the animal’s horns measured 49.5 inches, with the markhor being 11 years old.

“This is a notable achievement for both the hunter and the local conservation efforts,” Nabi said. The permit was part of an auction where four permits for hunting the markhor in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa were sold.

The Thoshi One and Thoshi Two reserves both sold their permits at the same record price of $271,000 each.

In addition, a permit for hunting a markhor in the Kigga area of Kohistan fetched more than $181,000, while a single permit for the Gahirat Gol Chitral reserve was sold for $180,000.

The revenue generated from the trophy hunting program is shared with local communities, with 80% of the proceeds distributed among residents. The remaining funds are used for community development and wildlife conservation efforts.

Trophy hunting in Pakistan began in 1999, following a decision at a 1997 international conference on endangered species trade.

Initially, the country was permitted six markhor hunting trophies annually, a number later increased to 12.

Nabi noted that the success of trophy hunting and community-managed conservation efforts has led to a dramatic increase in the Kashmir markhor population in Chitral, which numbered only a few hundred in 1999 but now totals in the thousands.

 
Last edited:
It’s been said in the past but for the sake of it I will mention again that Pakistan can hardly even be recognized as a proper functioning nation. It is a military dictatorship created to allow the affluent Muslim families of the subcontinent to utilize politics for their own good, to make them richer and strengthen their own dynasties by creating a fake narrative about Bharat as an enemy. The benefits such dynasties enjoy in Pakistan region wouldn’t have been easier in a united Bharat where they would have to compete with other religions on equal footing.

Pakistan does not have a proper functioning government. Does not have proper functioning institutions. Everyone wants leave as soon as they have accumulated little bit of wealth.

The country literally runs on China funded projects, US hand outs and international aid in the form of IMF bail out packages.

Pakistanis lack a sense of pride arising from a lack of a strong national identity because the identity is literally being Hindus a few centuries ago and being Bharatiyas less than 100 years ago.

The fact that the designated national animal is being allowed to be hunted by rich American, Saudi hunters is only testament to everything said above.

These are of course bitter words but there is no other sugar coated way to describe it.
 
They allow it under special circumstances. Usually a old male Markhor is selected by conservation hunters and the hunter is allowed to shoot only that. This kind

Pakistan has done a good job with the overall species preservation. Markhor are at record numbers and conservation is funded through these initiatives, natural breeding is enhanced by removing some older males from the ecosystem and money goes back into local communities.

Markhor numbers are at record numbers due to these efforts.

Despite this I won't ever understand what pleasure the hunter gains from this....
 
It’s been said in the past but for the sake of it I will mention again that Pakistan can hardly even be recognized as a proper functioning nation. It is a military dictatorship created to allow the affluent Muslim families of the subcontinent to utilize politics for their own good, to make them richer and strengthen their own dynasties by creating a fake narrative about Bharat as an enemy. The benefits such dynasties enjoy in Pakistan region wouldn’t have been easier in a united Bharat where they would have to compete with other religions on equal footing.

Pakistan does not have a proper functioning government. Does not have proper functioning institutions. Everyone wants leave as soon as they have accumulated little bit of wealth.

The country literally runs on China funded projects, US hand outs and international aid in the form of IMF bail out packages.

Pakistanis lack a sense of pride arising from a lack of a strong national identity because the identity is literally being Hindus a few centuries ago and being Bharatiyas less than 100 years ago.

The fact that the designated national animal is being allowed to be hunted by rich American, Saudi hunters is only testament to everything said above.

These are of course bitter words but there is no other sugar coated way to describe it.
lets deduce the false narratives here.

1. Pakistan does not care about India. Its the other way around. India promotes Pakistan as the enemy to win elections. What you have described is India in the first para, not Pakistan. India uses nationalism by creating an enemy and pouring fuel on to it.

Pakistan operations through religious nationalism. Our politicians/establishment doesnt bill India, it uses religious phrases, that if you dont vote for Imran you will go to hell etc. We stoop to a different kind of level.

2. Institutions are not proper that is true, but this label of everyone is corrupt is just plain dumb. India has corruption way worse, but they still operate.

The govt is not properly functioning due to what the army has done by always trying to fund an enemy aganst PMLN and PPP. In the first para you are complaining about families, than you are complaining about lack of institutions.

Pakistan's system can only improve if the army backs off and let the politicians do their thing. However, the mistakes that were made in 2013, a corrective measure still needs to be taken place, which is happening now.

3. Nice trying bringing in your hindu slogans here. While its true Pakistan does lack an identity, however our identity would be Indians, not hindus. Religion cannot be your identity, your identity is through the civilization that existed. By saying that we should have a Hindu identity is just like justifying a Muslim identity.

4.
 
Let's not derail this thread with India-Pakistan stuff and Hindu-Muslim debate. We have many other threads available for that chat.

Stay on topic
 
They allow it under special circumstances. Usually a old male Markhor is selected by conservation hunters and the hunter is allowed to shoot only that. This kind

Pakistan has done a good job with the overall species preservation. Markhor are at record numbers and conservation is funded through these initiatives, natural breeding is enhanced by removing some older males from the ecosystem and money goes back into local communities.

Markhor numbers are at record numbers due to these efforts.

Despite this I won't ever understand what pleasure the hunter gains from this....

The conservation efforts have been very good, it’s a fact. Although in future i hope the government - private partnership can fund this because it’s just odd to put animal conservation and hunting in the same sentence as a partnership model. Hope you understand.
 
The conservation efforts have been very good, it’s a fact. Although in future i hope the government - private partnership can fund this because it’s just odd to put animal conservation and hunting in the same sentence as a partnership model. Hope you understand.
You are viewing through a solely Santani world view brother that's why you find it odd.

This practice is quite common in forward thinking countries like Pakistan and USA
 
One of the most beautiful animals i have ever seen. Proper grace and class - a symbol of what we are unlike some of our neighbours who dont have class in their dictionary to begin with.
 

American national pays Rs6m for Punjab urial trophy hunting​


After a two-year hiatus, trophy hunting of the Punjab urial, the province's national animal, has resumed in Punjab as an American hunter successfully bagged the first trophy in the Chakwal area, paying a sum of Rs6 million for the privilege.

According to Express News, the Ministry of Climate Change issued 16 permits for hunting the Punjab urial, which were auctioned by Punjab Wildlife.

The permits were sold for a total of $3.28 million, approximately Rs91.5 million in Pakistani currency. Each permit fetched $20,500, with an additional fee of $500, bringing the total cost of a permit to around Rs5.86 million.

Wildlife officials confirmed that most of the permits were purchased by outfitters, who then resell them to hunters.

Due to the efforts of Punjab Wildlife authorities, the population of the Punjab urial in the Salt Range has seen significant growth, allowing foreign hunters to successfully hunt the first trophy.

The horns of the hunted urial measured 30 inches, indicating it was a healthy and large specimen. Authorities stated that hunters are given one week to complete their hunt.

The trophy hunting process had been delayed in Punjab over the past two years due to the registration of Community-Based Conservancies (CBCs).

However, due to the efforts of Director General of Punjab Wildlife, Mudasir Riaz Malik, the registration process has been completed, and trophy hunting for the Punjab urial has now officially resumed, marking a significant achievement.

A spokesperson for Punjab Wildlife stated that 80% of the revenue generated from trophy hunting would be allocated to local CBCs. These funds will be used for wildlife conservation, protection, and efforts to increase wildlife populations in their respective areas.

 
What a shame that Arab sheikhs can't hasn't migrating birds in their own land but spent millions to hunt same in Pakistan. Just show how joke of a government Pakistan has become.
 
American hunter hunts Markhor in Chitral for $66,000

An American hunter, Kyle Adam Miller, successfully hunted a Kashmir Markhor in the Shoghore Wildlife Range of Chitral, local wildlife officials confirmed.

The Markhor, known for its impressive spiral horns, measured 45 inches in length. According to officials, the hunt was conducted under a legal permit system, with Miller having obtained a non-exportable hunting permit for the first time in the history of Chitral Gol National Park, for $66,000.

According to reports, the hunter selected the 9.5-year-old markhor of trophy size in the national park's buffer zone, close to Shoghore hamlet on Garam Chashma Road, and easily pursued it.

The Kashmir Markhor, Pakistan’s national animal, is a prized species for trophy hunting due to its majestic appearance and rarity. However, such hunts are strictly regulated under Pakistan’s Community-Based Trophy Hunting Program, which aims to balance conservation efforts with economic incentives for local communities.

A significant portion of the permit fee is typically allocated to local development and wildlife preservation initiatives.

According to a local, the government decided last year to begin non-exportable trophy hunting in the national park's buffer zones in response to the demand from the communities that depend on the area.

The hunters were prohibited from taking the trophy (horns) of the killed animal back to their home nations, the local said. He claimed that the community had long demanded it because the markhor population in the park area had grown as a result of the effective conservation efforts.


 
They allow it under special circumstances. Usually a old male Markhor is selected by conservation hunters and the hunter is allowed to shoot only that. This kind

Pakistan has done a good job with the overall species preservation. Markhor are at record numbers and conservation is funded through these initiatives, natural breeding is enhanced by removing some older males from the ecosystem and money goes back into local communities.

Markhor numbers are at record numbers due to these efforts.

Despite this I won't ever understand what pleasure the hunter gains from this....
Thanks, for this detailed explanation , makes my worry less.
 
I have never seen a markhor in real life. I didn't know it was an animal until I visited PP. :rabada2

Anyway, markhor has been listed on the IUCN Red List as "Near Threatened" (source: Wikipedia).
 
Foreigner hunts markhor in Chitral with record horn length

Creating a new record in the history of trophy hunting of Kashmir Markhor, a Russian national, Alexey Kim, hunted down an animal of 14 years of age, whose horns measured 55 inches, in Singoor Doke area, which buffered the Chitral Gol National Park (CGNP).

Rizwanullah Yousufzai, divisional forest officer of CGNP wildlife division, told Dawn that the non-exportable trophy hunt was unique in respect of both size of the horn and the age of the animal, while the previous highest record was 53 inches and the age was 10 years.

He said that due to the successful conservation strategy involving the local community, the population of Kashmir Markhor, once declared to be endangered species, had attained a satisfactory numerical strength, while the hunter did not face any difficulty in searching out a trophy of desired size and age.

He said that this was the fourth and the last trophy hunting of Kashmir Markhor, for which the hunter had paid $71,000 (Rs19.862 million). He said that the hunter accomplished the task with the help of the community members and the field staff of CGNP.

 
Back
Top