I can just laugh at this thread now that again it is bumped! This only shows that it is not about criticizing Dhoni or calling for his exit, but it is about what you expect from the man! You actually don't want his exit, you want him in the team & perform with full-blaze! How on earth he is responsible for this loss? (totally/solely himself? I agree he was also part of the team which lost) He was not batting till the last ball & wasted balls & solely responsible (as Yuvaraj did in a T20 finals match). For that matter no single player from RPS was actually responsible for this defeat, they tried hard but they couldn't go far the line (and Mumbai did well!) Will you say that Smith was responsible for this who played almost run a ball innings and got out at critical stage? I can just think what would have people felt if Dhoni had played such similar knock instead of Smith! Dhoni is definitely capable of still playing such knocks! He would have got criticized even more than what he is getting now! Smith is at the prime of his career, and hence people see things differently & guys like Dhoni are treated like scapegoats!
People have conveniently ignored what Dhoni did when Mumbai (who have a powerful-long batting lineup) was restricted to small score on a big final. His inputs, his guidance, his advice (field placement for Pollard). The problem is you are expecting him to play like he did in his prime, continue to do all the magical stuffs! I am sure even if RPS had won yesterday these people would have criticized Dhoni for not doing his part! But just remember RPS did much better than previous year and Dhoni played some part in this (if not big part!) Don't expect Dhoni to do the main job anymore, he will just do the supporting role (Just like Amitabh has become supporting actor in films even though his name appears first in the title card

) Use him judicially just like yesterday, ask him to bat at No.4, not much harm will be done if others do their job properly... Don't make him a scapegoat for others failures (who are supposed to perform now like how Dhoni performed in his prime!) Even Indian ODI team has a vacancy at No.4 spot at the moment! Its not that Indian team is oozing with talent. Use him there, utilize his experience, his almost flawless wicket-keeping! Don't kill the spirit of talented Rishab Pant by putting unnecessary pressure of "replacing Dhoni", Let him make way in the team once Dhoni exits on his wish & when he decides gradually (I am sure Dhoni will stay out of Indian T20 team making way for Pant)! And don't put India back to the disastrous era of imbalanced team with hacks like Nayan Mongia playing ODI or even Dravid forced to keep wickets! Look at the backup guy chosen for CT (Dinesh Kartik- the pain in the a** guy whom every Indian Cricket fan is aware right since 80s!)