Pakistan (242/7) defeat South Africa (239/9) by 3 wickets in a nail biting encounter to win the 1st ODI

Cricket Warrior

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Aug 12, 2023
Runs
18,304
Pakistan lost their T20I series to South Africa 2-0, but they will be confident in the longer white-ball format, having recently rallied from 1-0 down to win ODI series in Australia and Zimbabwe over the past six weeks.

The visitors are clearly taking this series seriously. Babar Azam, Shaheen Shah Afridi, and Naseem Shah, who were rested for the Zimbabwe trip, are back in the squad.

Moreover, Saim Ayub, Abdullah Shafique, and Babar Azam were the top three run-scorers across both sides in Australia. Additionally, Haris Rauf, Shaheen Shah, and Naseem Shah emerged as the leading wicket-takers. Given that South African conditions are similar, and all these players are part of the squad, this bodes well for Pakistan.

Contests between these two teams, regardless of the format, are invariably engaging as they pit some of the game's most fearsome fast bowlers against its most inventive and aggressive batters.

This dynamic may change in February, when Pakistan will host a tri-series involving South Africa and New Zealand. The South Africans' squad for that tournament is likely to be impacted by their players' commitments to the SA20.

Therefore, the coming days warrant close attention. While South Africa won both T20Is, those games were alive with possibility and unpredictability. ODIs may not usually carry the same level of excitement, but when South Africa and Pakistan are involved, conventional expectations rarely apply.


Squads

Pakistan:
Mohammad Rizwan (captain & wk), Abdullah Shafique, Abrar Ahmed, Babar Azam, Haris Rauf, Kamran Ghulam, Mohammad Hasnain, Muhammad Irfan Khan, Naseem Shah, Saim Ayub, Salman Ali Agha, Shaheen Shah Afridi, Sufyan Moqim, Tayyab Tahir and Usman Khan (wk)

South Africa: Temba Bavuma (capt), Ottneil Baartman, Tony de Zorzi, Marco Jansen, Heinrich Klaasen (wk), Keshav Maharaj, Kwena Maphaka, Aiden Markram, David Miller, Andile Phehlukwayo, Kagiso Rabada, Tristan Stubbs, Ryan Rickelton, Tabraiz Shamsi, Rassie van der Dussen


=======

All posters please take note of the following guidelines for match threads on PakPassion:

1. No personal insults at other posters, players, officials, coaching staffs etc.

2. No making fun of player's, official's, coaching staff's names.

3. Do not add any references to media, their social media or post any pictures or screenshots from other sports websites.

4. Stick to commenting on this match. There is no need to bring other countries into the match discussion as there are plenty of other threads where those discussions can be added.
 
KG will most likely play at 5. He will need to figure out a way to score.

Overall Pakistan batters will be much happier with the 50 over format.
 
2 of my worst players bavuma and rizzu captaining. Allah khair karei
Rizwan just captained Pakistan to a spanking win vs overrated Australia in Australia and he is the worst player? The delusion and hate! Show some respect to the best wicket keeping bat in the world today across formats. Only in Pakistan can people take potshots at their own whereas other teams fans are head over heels over players like Pant, Quinton De Kock, Carey, Bairstow.
 
Pakistan are going to win this series for sure. I have a very good feeling about this series. ODI has been Pakistan's best format for a while now and tend to do well in SA. Bat first, score 280-300 and let SA choke as usual.
 
Rizwan just captained Pakistan to a spanking win vs overrated Australia in Australia and he is the worst player? The delusion and hate! Show some respect to the best wicket keeping bat in the world today across formats. Only in Pakistan can people take potshots at their own whereas other teams fans are head over heels over players like Pant, Quinton De Kock, Carey, Bairstow.
Quinton retired from the odi format with 4 centuries in a single icc event to his name from odi's.

He's literally cemented himself as the greatest wk batter that sa has ever had and in terms of pure wicket keeping ability he's the 2nd best after Mark boucher.

But overall QDK is 1st choice due to batting.

As a wicket keeper, he is one touch below Gilly but significantly superior to the likes of Dhoni, Butler and many other wicket keeping greats.

Comparing rizwan to him is hilarious and it's why no one, not even rizwan's biggest fan boys excluding @shah9425 @Caved12 and @Major will take you seriously lol.

Pant, bairstow and Carey are >>>>>> Rizwan but if you want to mock these 3 for rizzu, it's whatever since many posters have done so and I have handled it.

Qdk is one where not a single soul will put rizzu > Qdk lol.

Travis head, Qdk, Butler, are all 100 tiers > Rizwan and literally no one would doubt it.

Even when it comes to Bumrah, While I hate that indian posters have made Bumrah their father and are pretending that Bumrah is > Malcolm marshall, Mcgrath and wasim, they are wrong 100%.

However not a single soul will put Shaheen > Bumrah lol. Bumrah is 100 tiers > Shaheen.
 
Quinton retired from the odi format with 4 centuries in a single icc event to his name from odi's.

He's literally cemented himself as the greatest wk batter that sa has ever had and in terms of pure wicket keeping ability he's the 2nd best after Mark boucher.

But overall QDK is 1st choice due to batting.

As a wicket keeper, he is one touch below Gilly but significantly superior to the likes of Dhoni, Butler and many other wicket keeping greats.

Comparing rizwan to him is hilarious and it's why no one, not even rizwan's biggest fan boys excluding @shah9425 @Caved12 and @Major will take you seriously lol.

Pant, bairstow and Carey are >>>>>> Rizwan but if you want to mock these 3 for rizzu, it's whatever since many posters have done so and I have handled it.

Qdk is one where not a single soul will put rizzu > Qdk lol.

Travis head, Qdk, Butler, are all 100 tiers > Rizwan and literally no one would doubt it.

Even when it comes to Bumrah, While I hate that indian posters have made Bumrah their father and are pretending that Bumrah is > Malcolm marshall, Mcgrath and wasim, they are wrong 100%.

However not a single soul will put Shaheen > Bumrah lol. Bumrah is 100 tiers > Shaheen.


I said Shaheeh has potential to be better than Bhumrah and has age on his side. Purely on skill, he is better. Judging bowlers on the impact they create, Shaheen routinely gets wickets in the first over.

QDK is a choker who choked at the first sign of knockouts. When he plays an innings like Rizwan vs NZ in T20WC Semi we can talk.
 
Genuinely speaking, the biggest compliment i can give Rizwan is that he's the misbah ul haq of this modern era.

Mainly because he doesn't get out and consumes alot of dot balls like Misbah does.

He does crawl to 40's and 50's and will occasionally play a good innings here and their.

Misbah also has had good innings so far rizwan and pakistan has had worse cricketers then these 2.

But I don't recall any bad pakistani cricketer that lingered around for as long as these 2 did.

Even the likes of Imam are now booted while rizzu is captain.
 
Genuinely speaking, the biggest compliment i can give Rizwan is that he's the misbah ul haq of this modern era.

Mainly because he doesn't get out and consumes alot of dot balls like Misbah does.

He does crawl to 40's and 50's and will occasionally play a good innings here and their.

Misbah also has had good innings so far rizwan and pakistan has had worse cricketers then these 2.

But I don't recall any bad pakistani cricketer that lingered around for as long as these 2 did.

Even the likes of Imam are now booted while rizzu is captain.
1734430279918.png
 
PAK is a very good ODI side and one of the favourites for 2027 World Cup so this should be a 3-0 thrashing of the Saffers coming up.

Saffers won't even outscore Rizwan
 
Fahim Ashraf should never be near a Pakistan shirt again. But yes we needed a pace allrounder. Aamer, Ahmad Butt, even Jehandad were options. Fahim is done and dusted.
Don't know the stats but watched a bit of Faheem in last year or so I feel he's improved slightly.
Plus he's experienced in these conditions
 
I genuinely wouldn’t be surprised if Rizwan now moves to bowling and takes the spot of Naseem or Shaheen

And then his fans could argue “we need Rizwan right now as a new ball bowler as our stocks are very low”
 
I genuinely wouldn’t be surprised if Rizwan now moves to bowling and takes the spot of Naseem or Shaheen

And then his fans could argue “we need Rizwan right now as a new ball bowler as our stocks are very low”
Rizwan Mcgrath
 
Lol Abdullah shafique, salman Agha abrar nerd should be nowhere near Pakistan limited overs side.
 
This is Zimbabar's best format.
If he doesn't even score in this format,he should be kicked out from national team.
 
Damn it they are not showing this match on sports18 as they will show that women match between India and West indies I think.

Nobody cares about women's cricket.
Pathetic....
 
PAK is a very good ODI side and one of the favourites for 2027 World Cup so this should be a 3-0 thrashing of the Saffers coming up.

Saffers won't even outscore Rizwan
How is Pak a very good ODI side...we are the most unbalanced side no allrounders all bowlers in there who cant even bowl never mind hold a bat and batting looks so fragile..i believe we did lose a one day to zimbabwe too
 
Bavuma has improved his batting significantly in recent times, and his ODI numbers are fairly good.
We'll see. I have horrible memories of watching him as an opener in the past. But i am impressed by his recent test performances no doubt.
 
Big chance for Pakistan as No Maharaj

He would have definitely stalled the Pakistan innings in the middle overs
 
Pakistan should have added Aamir Jamal to the ODI squad for this series. He is the only proper seam-bowling all-rounder we have who could have brought a balance to this side.

I don't know how tenable the strategy of playing four specialist bowlers is. What happens if someone has a really bad day? Will we be relying on Agha and Saim to deliver with the ball?
 
Pakistan should have added Aamir Jamal to the ODI squad for this series. He is the only proper seam-bowling all-rounder we have who could have brought a balance to this side.

I don't know how tenable the strategy of playing four specialist bowlers is. What happens if someone has a really bad day? Will we be relying on Agha and Saim to deliver with the ball?
Well,

You get smashed and learn.

Pakistan got smashed in the first T20i to get Saim Ayub to open in the second
 
Pakistan should have added Aamir Jamal to the ODI squad for this series. He is the only proper seam-bowling all-rounder we have who could have brought a balance to this side.

I don't know how tenable the strategy of playing four specialist bowlers is. What happens if someone has a really bad day? Will we be relying on Agha and Saim to deliver with the ball?

It's not a bad combination. Better than playing 2 pseudo allrounders in Shadab and Nawaz at 7 and 8, which benefits neither the batting nor the bowling .

The idea is to play the extra batter and make sure you attack and get a winning score.

Scoreboard pressure is your 5th bowler then.

Australia have primarily played 7+4 throughout their ODI history and they're 6 time champs.
 
Well,

You get smashed and learn.

Pakistan got smashed in the first T20i to get Saim Ayub to open in the second
Bro the issue is these are elementary mistakes.

Pakistan is a professional side that plays internationally. They aren't school children that make mistakes on a maths paper and then the teacher tells them mistakes to improve.

They should know this. Then again this is the same side that's playing KG at no 5, so who knows, maybe they have a Vision for the team.
 
SA left out Miller and Bavuma, this arrogance will come back to bite them. Pakistan are playing a full strength line up, let's not forget this is the Champions Trophy Champion team. Sheer arrogance and disrespect from SA. It will come back to bite them.
 
I can definitely see them getting carted for 350+ at Jo'burg. It generally has the flattest wicket for ODIs and T20Is.
It didn’t open their eyes when Pakistan got smashed in the Asia cup prior to the World Cup

These stupidities will continue through to the CT
 
SA left out Miller and Bavuma, this arrogance will come back to bite them. Pakistan are playing a full strength line up, let's not forget this is the Champions Trophy Champion team. Sheer arrogance and disrespect from SA. It will come back to bite them.
It has to come back and bite them in the CT. Not sure if you believe the CT is starting today?
 
Advantage SA with the toss . Just got to make a careful 300 and the game's almost over.

This wicket is traditionally not a 350 surface. It's slightly slower and the straight boundary is pretty big - 84 m !

They're also playing Andile at 8 which gives them good depth.
 
It's not a bad combination. Better than playing 2 pseudo allrounders in Shadab and Nawaz at 7 and 8, which benefits neither the batting nor the bowling .

The idea is to play the extra batter and make sure you attack and get a winning score.

Scoreboard pressure is your 5th bowler then.

Australia have primarily played 7+4 throughout their ODI history and they're 6 time champs.
I understand the thinking behind it. Just feel like it's a strategy that can backfire badly on any given day. I think it should be decided based on the pitch, but at any rate, leaving someone like Aamir Jamal out of the squad entirely is not a smart decision at all.

Well, Australia has more all-rounders than pretty much any other team in the world. They can do that.
 
Advantage SA with the toss . Just got to make a careful 300 and the games almost over.

This wicket is traditionally not a 350 surface. It's slightly slower and the straight boundary is pretty big - 84 m !

They're also playing Andile at 8 which gives them good depth.
Phelu is a crap bowler IMO

But it’s not like he is bowling to India or Australia line up
 
Mind your own business

Pray for Babar and Rizwan
I don't need to pray for anyone. Babar and Rizwan have been blessed with success. They will be the architects of an ODI series win in SA just like in Aus and haters will have stomach ache again.
 
I understand the thinking behind it. Just feel like it's a strategy that can backfire badly on any given day. I think it should be decided based on the pitch, but at any rate, leaving someone like Aamir Jamal out of the squad entirely is not a smart decision at all.

Well, Australia has more all-rounders than pretty much any other team in the world. They can do that.

If you look carefully at any Australia ODI XI, their Top 7 are all batters first, even the allrounders.

They are just very, very good at extracting 10 overs from a combination of the likes of Travis Head, Maxwell and Mitchell Marsh.

PAK should do something similar with Saim, KG etc.
 
Pakistan, India and Australia each hold 1 current ICC trophy and Pakistan/Aus are the only ones with ICC ODI trophies right now. I am ready.
Huh? Wdym by current?

England won in 2019, followed by aus in 2021, followed by eng in 2022 followed by aus in 2023 and India in 2024?

Where is pakistan in this picture? It's been 8 years? 8 years is recent? 🤣🤣
 
Huh? Wdym by current?

England won in 2019, followed by aus in 2021, followed by eng in 2022 followed by aus in 2023 and India in 2024?

Where is pakistan in this picture? It's been 8 years? 8 years is recent? 🤣🤣
There 3 live ICC trophies that are held today by current winners - Pakistan, India, Australia. The last ICC CT happened 7 years ago that is not Pakistan's fault.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Phelu is a crap bowler IMO

But it’s not like he is bowling to India or Australia line up

Saffers have to play more coloured/black players in bilaterals to make sure their quota averages over a year are maintained . This allows them to play their best squads in ICC events without worrying about transformation targets.

Besides , Mulder is injured and they probably don't have anyone else.
 
They will, when Shaheen wrecks them.

This Saffer lineup may prove to be tougher to dismantle than the Aussies.

The Rickleton's , Zorzi's and Stubbs' all have very decent List A records despite their lack of international experience.

That Aussie lineup had guys who had averages in the 20's and early 30's even in List A cricket.
 
This Saffer lineup may prove to be tougher to dismantle than the Aussies.

The Rickleton's , Zorzi's and Stubbs' all have very decent List A records despite their lack of international experience.

That Aussie lineup had guys who had averages in the 20's and early 30's even in List A cricket.
They have feasted on substandard bowlers in SA domestic. They won't cross 250 against this Pak line up. And they will lose this series.
 
Back
Top