What's new

Pakistan allows man to register as country’s first Jew in decades

MenInG

PakPassion Administrator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Runs
217,912
Pakistan has allowed one of its 180 million citizens to publicly register as a Jew for the first time since the 1980s.

Fischel Benkhald, 29, was notified on Tuesday that the religious status in his National Database and Registration Authority profile can be changed from Muslim to Jew, Fox News reported Wednesday.

Benkhald, who was born Faisal Benkhald, was brought up by a Jewish mother and Muslim father in Karachi. He had been pushing to change his national identity card status for three years. He chose the Yiddish name Fischel.

Get The Times of Israel's Daily Edition by email and never miss our top stories FREE SIGN UP
Wilson Chowdry, chairman of the British Pakistani Christian Association, took up Benkhald’s cause with the Pakistani High Commission in London.

In 2014, Benkhald told The Times of Israel he intended to register as a Jew, but feared being rejected and a backlash from neighbors if they found out he was Jewish.

“It is dangerous but I will go at least once to record my request to change the status of my religion from Islam to Judaism so that their response can be documented,” he said.

In Pakistan, the national identity card is used for voting, purchasing public transportation tickets, applying to college, buying phones and more, according to Fox News. It contains one’s name, date of birth, photo, a thumbprint and religion.

Before rampant anti-Israel sentiment forced Jews to leave the Asian country in the years following 1948, Karachi was once home to over 1,000 Jews. Chowdry estimates that hundreds of Jews are now living secretly in Pakistan.

Approximately 95 percent of the population there is Muslim. According to Fox News, a 2010 Pew survey found that 76 percent of Pakistanis advocate the death penalty for leaving Islam.

Benkhald argues that he never left Islam because he was born to a Jewish mother and therefore has always been Jewish.

“Of course we are concerned about the safety of Fischel,” Chowdry told Fox News. “Hopefully his brave decision to alter his faith will convince other Jews to come out of hiding.”

Benkhald has been campaigning to preserve Karachi’s old Jewish cemetery, which he said in 2014 was a first step toward setting up a synagogue in Karachi.

The cemetery, whose 300 remaining graves date to the late 19th and early 20th centuries, is at risk of encroachment from the surrounding Muslim graveyard.

“After getting that little piece of paper in my hand stating that legally we are allowed to have a synagogue, my dream will come true,” he said in 2014.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/pakis...lHG6aQc5c-4sB288mBb5OxxJAku5OwYa5Mu2I0Nr_Dlgg
 
A brave step. FGS, Let him live a normal life as a citizen of his country.
Rule number 1 = A religion can not be anti-social.
Religion without socialism is easiest way to hell. INFERNO.
 
I don't understand this article title and content. There are close to a thousand registered Jewish families in Pakistan. When were they stopped from registering as Jews, as this article insinuates with the claim that this man is the first in a long time?

Also why would Jews be registering if there aren't any new Jews t register? I mean Judaism has an exceptionally low conversion rate and many Jewish societies do not accept converts anyway.
 
I don't understand this article title and content. There are close to a thousand registered Jewish families in Pakistan. When were they stopped from registering as Jews, as this article insinuates with the claim that this man is the first in a long time?

Also why would Jews be registering if there aren't any new Jews t register? I mean Judaism has an exceptionally low conversion rate and many Jewish societies do not accept converts anyway.

What I understood here is its "First registration since 1980s". Not first since 47.
 
I don't understand this article title and content. There are close to a thousand registered Jewish families in Pakistan. When were they stopped from registering as Jews, as this article insinuates with the claim that this man is the first in a long time?

Also why would Jews be registering if there aren't any new Jews t register? I mean Judaism has an exceptionally low conversion rate and many Jewish societies do not accept converts anyway.

Yes that was also my first thought when I read the headline, that there were no Jews allowed to register previously, not very well presented headline. It seems the issue here is one of this fellow adopting a Jewish identity rather than Islamic due to having a Jewish mother.
 
What I understood here is its "First registration since 1980s". Not first since 47.

He was originally registered as a Muslim as his father was a Muslim so this could be the first time it had been changed from a Muslim to a Jew and of course in Pakistan and for Muslims around the world changing from Islam to another religion is one of the biggest sins..

Maybe that’s why this one is a big deal?
 
He was originally registered as a Muslim as his father was a Muslim so this could be the first time it had been changed from a Muslim to a Jew and of course in Pakistan and for Muslims around the world changing from Islam to another religion is one of the biggest sins..

Maybe that’s why this one is a big deal?

This headline title is from an Israeli Newspaper. Same news will get a different headline in Pakistani Newspapers. No big deal.
 
IIRC Judaism has matrilineal character, if the mother is Jewish it automatically makes the child Jewish. That is what they believe.
 
Good to see him come out into the open with this. Hopefully he remains safe and this encourages others to also disclose their faith.
 
Yes that was also my first thought when I read the headline, that there were no Jews allowed to register previously, not very well presented headline. It seems the issue here is one of this fellow adopting a Jewish identity rather than Islamic due to having a Jewish mother.

yet another misleading headline regarding Pakistan
 
Good. he Jews are just a religious group. It does not make him anti Pakistani.
 
Back
Top