What's new

Pakistan refuses to evacuate citizens from Wuhan, China (Coronavirus)

Keeping them in China would be justified if

1)GOP Cannot guarantee an effective 14 day quarantine within Pakistan
2) If Coronavirus is as contagious as leprosy, which it looks like its not

So if there were no effective quarantine facilities, not evacuating was ok.

But its not like most of the students were infected

Most countries are using army camps for quarantine. In Pakistan , army has tons of resourse and it should be even easier to set up a place for couple of hundred students.

Claim of Pakistan not having resourse to keep 100 students in quarantine for 14 days seems absurd to me, but then I am not in Pakistan.
 
Why not extract them and keep them quarantined in pak somewhere? No such plan in place for an outbreak as this?
 
https://www.dawn.com/news/1533810/pakistani-student-in-wuhan-misses-fathers-funeral-as-anxiety-grows

This is plainly wrong - you cannot abandon the students (many of whom have young kids) stuck in a ground-zero on the mercy of a foreign government who itself is struggling to contain the virus for its citizens. If a country like Bangladesh can evacuate its citizens, what is the justification for Pakistan’s actions?

One of my friend showed me how BD is bringing their kids back ... Its a shame really. They don't even do proper check up or qurantine. This risk the virus spreading faster, especially in a small country like BD.
Hope that procedure changed.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Pakistan stands with the people & govt of China in their difficult & trying time and it will always stand by them. We will be extending every material & moral support to China just as China has always stood by us during all our times of trial and tribulation.</p>— Imran Khan (@ImranKhanPTI) <a href="https://twitter.com/ImranKhanPTI/status/1227613869562044416?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 12, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">I have issued instructions to our Foreign Office and Overseas Ministry to do everything possible for our students who are stuck in Wuhan city.</p>— Imran Khan (@ImranKhanPTI) <a href="https://twitter.com/ImranKhanPTI/status/1227614680715276288?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 12, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">We are pleased to learn that 3 Pakistani citizens affected by Coronavirus in China have been cured and discharged from hospitals in Guangzhou and Shenzhen of Guangdong Province. All the best to them! Thank you, medical team in China!@zfrmrza <a href="https://twitter.com/AmbNaghmanaHash?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@AmbNaghmanaHash</a></p>— Chinese Emb Pakistan (@CathayPak) <a href="https://twitter.com/CathayPak/status/1227538227327852546?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 12, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">213/ I am pleased to confirm that Alhamdolilah our four students that had developed <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/coronavirus?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#coronavirus</a> disease in China are now fully recovered and today they have been discharged from the hospital. 98% of all corona virus confirmed patients fully recover.</p>— Zafar Mirza (@zfrmrza) <a href="https://twitter.com/zfrmrza/status/1227640669222658048?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 12, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">We are pleased to learn that 3 Pakistani citizens affected by Coronavirus in China have been cured and discharged from hospitals in Guangzhou and Shenzhen of Guangdong Province. All the best to them! Thank you, medical team in China!@zfrmrza <a href="https://twitter.com/AmbNaghmanaHash?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@AmbNaghmanaHash</a></p>— Chinese Emb Pakistan (@CathayPak) <a href="https://twitter.com/CathayPak/status/1227538227327852546?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 12, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">213/ I am pleased to confirm that Alhamdolilah our four students that had developed <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/coronavirus?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#coronavirus</a> disease in China are now fully recovered and today they have been discharged from the hospital. 98% of all corona virus confirmed patients fully recover.</p>— Zafar Mirza (@zfrmrza) <a href="https://twitter.com/zfrmrza/status/1227640669222658048?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">February 12, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Alhamdulillah they are safe. All those 3 positive cases in India have also turned negative by now.
 
I heard they were from Kerala,Is that true?

This is an inside information from the doctors in those concerned Medical colleges I know. These students from China are recovering good and tested negative in the local station of NIV Alappuzha . Now they are waiting for the confirmational reports from the NIV Pune. Still they are in isolation as of now.
 
Insaan hai galti se mistake hogaya,Maaf kardo didi.

Patients are patients. It’s our duty to help them.

Every Indian should be proud of the National Institute of Virology in Pune which is a part of ICMR. It has been designated as a WHO H5 reference Laboratory for SE Asia region. Nippah outbreak in Kerala was also detected and controlled because of their timely efforts.
 
Patients are patients. It’s our duty to help them.

Every Indian should be proud of the National Institute of Virology in Pune which is a part of ICMR. It has been designated as a WHO H5 reference Laboratory for SE Asia region. Nippah outbreak in Kerala was also detected and controlled because of their timely efforts.

Iam proud that I was born in Pune.
 
Hundreds of Pakistani students trapped in the Chinese city at the centre of the coronavirus outbreak have said they are going through “mental torture” and pleaded with their government to help get them out.

Rehan Rasheed, who has been studying medicine in Wuhan since 2015, criticised the Pakistan government and prime minister Imran Khan for refusing to bring back the more than 800 students who have been trapped in the city since it was locked down by the Chinese authorities in an attempt to contain the outbreak.

He also said five Pakistani student studying at Wuhan’s university of science and technology had contracted the virus.

“We are not being evacuated and we are not being supported,” said Rasheed, speaking on the phone from China. “We are all very scared, this is a terrible situation. We have been imprisoned in a hostel room for more than 20 days. For the past three days we have not been allowed to leave at all, even for food, and are surrounded by fear.”

The students have witnessed their counterparts from India, Nepal, Bangladesh, the US, UK and other countries board evacuation flights provided by their governments. Officials in the Pakistan government urged the group to “remain calm”. Pakistan has close ties to China and government figures have repeatedly congratulated the Chinese government for their handling of the outbreak.

The refusal to evacuate the students back to Pakistan is also thought to be due to fears that the country does not have the medical facilities or capabilities to safely quarantine the returnees or handle a coronavirus outbreak on Pakistani soil. Pakistan has a poor record of handling disease outbreaks and is one of only two countries in the world which has failed to eliminate polio.

Imran Khan said in a tweet: “I have issued instructions to our Foreign Office and Overseas Ministry to do everything possible for our students who are stuck in Wuhan city.”

By Thursday, the number of people in China who had died from coronavirus had risen to 1,368 and the number infected is 59,805.

Rasheen added: “It is clear that our government don’t want to take us out from this situation. We met with people from the Wuhan authorities and they told us they have no problem with us leaving but that ‘your government is not willing to accept you or to receive you back home’.

‘‘It is mental torture here every morning. We appreciate what Chinese authorities are doing but they are not sure we will survive this, so we are asking our state to help us. Please evacuate us.”

His plea was echoed by Amjad Hussain, a PhD student at China University of Geoscience, who has been studying in Wuhan for three years. “There is panic here,” said Hussain. “Definitely there is anger among students against Pakistani state for doing nothing. We just want to know why is Pakistan not helping us and evacuating us? I want to go back home and want my country to help.”

The anger and pain was also felt by the students’ relatives back in Pakistan. Abdul Rasheed Baloch, Rasheed’s father, who lives in the Balochistan region of Pakistan, said: “I’m more than concerned. I feel like I have no soul. My heart and mind is there, with my son.”

Baloch said he was speaking to his son daily to keep the hope alive. “Talking to him everyday keeps me going or else I feel I’m dead,” he added. “There is no help from the government of Pakistan. Nothing at all.”

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2...ts-plead-for-help-to-escape-wuhan-coronavirus
 
Pakistan officials visit virus-struck Wuhan to meet Pakistani students

Officials from the Embassy of Pakistan in China visited virus-hit Wuhan on Tuesday and met the four Pakistani students who had contracted coronavirus in January.

The toll from China’s coronavirus epidemic jumped to 1,868 on Tuesday after 98 more people died. Nearly 72,500 people nationwide have been infected by the new COVID-19 strain of the virus, which first emerged in December before spiralling into a nationwide epidemic.

Chinese authorities allowed a two-member special task force from the Pakistan Embassy in Beijing to meet the students and obtain first-hand information regarding their health and recovery.
The task force will return to Beijing once the lockdown in Wuhan is lifted and the on-ground situation is stabilised.

The officials, Third Secretary Junaid and Education Attaché Suleman reached Wuhan on Monday and visited the university students on today. They also met the administration to ensure precautionary measures were being taken to protect the students.

“All the students in the universities visited today are safe, healthy and well looked after,” the statement by the Foreign Office read.

The Embassy of Pakistan has played a pivotal role in providing utmost facilitation to protect the students suffering from coronavirus.

They have taken a number of steps to provide assistance to the students, such as: establishing two 24-hour hotlines for the facilitation of Pakistani students in China and responding to queries of students via email.

An 11-member core group was also constituted to monitor the situation and respond to the requests of the Pakistani students, and a video conference was arranged with Health Minister Dr Zafar Mirza and SAPM for Overseas Pakistani’s Zulfi Bukhari.

Foreign Minister Wang Yi issued instructions to relevant authorities to ensure the safety of the Pakistani students in Hubei province and across China.

The Chinese government has reassured Pakistan that the students are as important as their own nationals, and took measures to provide basic amenities to the students – including food, water, regular medical checkups, spraying of disinfectant in students’ dormitories and residential localities.

The students were provided with protective masks and gloves and their body temperatures are monitored twice a day.

Students suffering from depression and stress were also provided psychological counselling.

In a video message, two of the students thanked the local doctors, the Chinese government and the Pakistani consulate for supporting them emotionally and financially.

“I want to thank the Chinese doctors who took really good care of us in the hospital, for taking care of all our requirements and for supporting us. I want to thank the Chinese government and the Pakistani consulate for supporting us,” a student said.

The student also said that the media is spreading false information about the intensity of the virus.

“I want to inform my Pakistani brothers that this virus is not as dangerous as the media has made it seem. The news is mostly fake.”

Hubei has been locked down to try to contain the virus, with tens of millions of people placed under effective quarantine in the province.

Chinese health officials have urged patients who recovered from the coronavirus to donate blood so that plasma can be extracted to treat others who are critically ill.

Plasma from patients who have recovered from a spell of pneumonia triggered by COVID-19 contains antibodies that can help reduce the virus load in critically ill patients, an official from the National Health Commission told a press briefing Monday.

More than 12,000 people have recovered and been discharged, according to health commission figures.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/215908...t-virus-struck-wuhan-meet-pakistani-students/
 
Pakistan officials visit virus-struck Wuhan to meet Pakistani students

Officials from the Embassy of Pakistan in China visited virus-hit Wuhan on Tuesday and met the four Pakistani students who had contracted coronavirus in January.

The toll from China’s coronavirus epidemic jumped to 1,868 on Tuesday after 98 more people died. Nearly 72,500 people nationwide have been infected by the new COVID-19 strain of the virus, which first emerged in December before spiralling into a nationwide epidemic.

Chinese authorities allowed a two-member special task force from the Pakistan Embassy in Beijing to meet the students and obtain first-hand information regarding their health and recovery.
The task force will return to Beijing once the lockdown in Wuhan is lifted and the on-ground situation is stabilised.

The officials, Third Secretary Junaid and Education Attaché Suleman reached Wuhan on Monday and visited the university students on today. They also met the administration to ensure precautionary measures were being taken to protect the students.

“All the students in the universities visited today are safe, healthy and well looked after,” the statement by the Foreign Office read.

The Embassy of Pakistan has played a pivotal role in providing utmost facilitation to protect the students suffering from coronavirus.

They have taken a number of steps to provide assistance to the students, such as: establishing two 24-hour hotlines for the facilitation of Pakistani students in China and responding to queries of students via email.

An 11-member core group was also constituted to monitor the situation and respond to the requests of the Pakistani students, and a video conference was arranged with Health Minister Dr Zafar Mirza and SAPM for Overseas Pakistani’s Zulfi Bukhari.

Foreign Minister Wang Yi issued instructions to relevant authorities to ensure the safety of the Pakistani students in Hubei province and across China.

The Chinese government has reassured Pakistan that the students are as important as their own nationals, and took measures to provide basic amenities to the students – including food, water, regular medical checkups, spraying of disinfectant in students’ dormitories and residential localities.

The students were provided with protective masks and gloves and their body temperatures are monitored twice a day.

Students suffering from depression and stress were also provided psychological counselling.

In a video message, two of the students thanked the local doctors, the Chinese government and the Pakistani consulate for supporting them emotionally and financially.

“I want to thank the Chinese doctors who took really good care of us in the hospital, for taking care of all our requirements and for supporting us. I want to thank the Chinese government and the Pakistani consulate for supporting us,” a student said.

The student also said that the media is spreading false information about the intensity of the virus.

“I want to inform my Pakistani brothers that this virus is not as dangerous as the media has made it seem. The news is mostly fake.”

Hubei has been locked down to try to contain the virus, with tens of millions of people placed under effective quarantine in the province.

Chinese health officials have urged patients who recovered from the coronavirus to donate blood so that plasma can be extracted to treat others who are critically ill.

Plasma from patients who have recovered from a spell of pneumonia triggered by COVID-19 contains antibodies that can help reduce the virus load in critically ill patients, an official from the National Health Commission told a press briefing Monday.

More than 12,000 people have recovered and been discharged, according to health commission figures.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/215908...t-virus-struck-wuhan-meet-pakistani-students/

Shows what the Chinese local media is feeding news to citizens. The statement “coronavirus is not as deadly as it seems” is hard to believe and contrary to lockdown and fatalities
 
Families of Pakistanis stranded in China reject govt briefing, demand students’ return

ISLAMABAD: The families of Pakistanis who have not been evacuated from China amid the outbreakof the coronavirus known as COVID-19 protested calling for their return and refused the argument put forward by special assistants to the prime minister onoverseas Pakistanis and national health services.

They blocked Margalla Road in F-8 in protest, arguing that even Afghanistan and Bangladesh had evacuated their citizens from China and asked why Pakistan decided not to do so.

They announced that they would protest and hold a sit-in outside the Chinese embassy and outside ministries if their concerns are not addressed.

A briefing for the relatives of Pakistanis who are stranded in China was arranged on directions from the Islamabad High Court (IHC) to take them into confidence regarding why the government decided not to evacuate citizens.

Special Assistant to the Prime Minister on Overseas Pakistanis Syed Zulfiqar Bukhari told participants at the briefing that the coronavirus situation in China has become complicated.

“We are aware and can realise the problem and anxiety of parents. However, we can assure you that those Pakistani citizens are in safe hands. China has also given permission for two representatives from the Pakistani embassy to visit the affected area and observe the students’ issues. Pakistan is the only country that has been sending diplomats to the affected area and even they will not be able to return without [being quarantined],” he said.

A representative from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said ministry officials care more about the 1,200 students than themselves, adding: “Two representatives of the embassy have gone into theNCV-hitarea and we can see their movement live.”

Special Assistant to the Prime Minister on NHS Dr Zafar Mirza said he, the cabinet and the government could understand the anxiety of the families and had therefore decided to hold the briefing.

“Being parents you must be wishing that your children should return today rather than tomorrow and you will not agree to any argument by us. Concerns of parents are right but we should also see the situation,” he said.

One person in attendance pointed to Dr Mirza and said that he had announced the students would not be evacuated.

Other participants also began criticising the government and refused tocontinue withthe briefing, and some even climbed on stage, at which point they were stopped by police.

The families of the students were of the view that the government was not doing enough. They said that even the briefing was held on the IHC’s orders, while the government was putting forward childish assurances.

Some parents said that they were willing to donate money to bring back their children and thanked the high court for hearing their issue. One of the parents said that his child was not getting food or water, and this situation was keeping him up at night.

“Dr Mirza said he cared about 200 million people but we have nothing to do with the people. We just want our children to return, and we are not ready to listen to any other logic,” he said.

Dr Mirza said that the government was ensuring that the students and the nation is protected from the coronavirus outbreak, adding that there would be more disadvantages to bringing the students home than advantages.

One of the parents asked if the financial condition of Pakistan was worse than that of Bangladesh and Afghanistan, which have evacuated their citizens.

“You speak about the youth but do not care about it. If our children are not brought back in three days, we will hold a sit-in in front of the Chinese embassy. We will also lockdown your offices. Bring our children in Pakistan and keep them in a safe place,” he said.

The families then left the school, blocked the main road and shouted slogans against the government. Director General Health Dr Safi Malik and an additional deputy commissioner met with them to persuade them to disperse peacefully, but the families remained on the road until this report was filed.
https://www.dawn.com/news/1535516/f...a-reject-govt-briefing-demand-students-return
 
from only soyabean dust, 14 people died and 100+ suffered, in only 2 day.
sorry to say , no one gonna allow them to return, atleast for now.
 
Many local Chinese are trying to escape from epicentre and even major cities . This is what I heard from Chinese colleagues who recently flew back to place I live and work. Lack of medical facilities and heavy hand of authority in handling this are reasons
This poses 2 questions
Why are pakistan citizens not evacuated when local Chinese think this way of situation?
If fear of spread is reason, then why are flights moving in and out without restrictions

Inspite I can still say it’s not due to diplomatic reasons if it makes ppl happy
 
Students in Wuhan thankful for not being expatriated: Dr Mirza

"We also decided not to evacuate students from Wuhan. It was a very tough decision," said Dr Zafar Mirza. "But we worked very closely with the Chinese government. We just followed their recommendations and policies. They were very nice; they allowed countries to expatriate even against their recommendation."

"They took good care of our students"

"Today, when the disease is spreading in Pakistan, the students are thanking the government of Pakistan for not bringing them back," added Mirza. "They are asking us to take care of their families like China took care of them."
 
Special Assistant to Prime Minister on Health Dr Zafar Mirza on Sunday said that the Pakistani students who were stranded in the Chinese city of Wuhan, during the peak of the country's Covid-19 outbreak, are now thanking the government for not evacuating them.

Briefing a team of doctors from China at the National Institute of Health (NIH) in Islamabad, Zafar said: "We decided — it was a tough decision for us — against evacuating our students from Wuhan. We worked very closely with the Chinese government and just followed their recommendations.

"Today, now that the disease is spreading in Pakistan, the same students are thanking the government for not evacuating them and requesting us to take care of their families in the same way they were looked after by the Chinese government."

He said that when President Arif Alvi Umar and Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi visited China recently, they spoke to the students in Wuhan through Skype.

"They [students] thanked the president and said that the decision [to not bring them back] was the right thing to do, even though their families were pressuring the government to do so," he added.

The PM's aide went on to say that China has written a new chapter in the history of public health by putting approximately 60 million people under lockdown.

"The world has a lot to learn from China regarding the prevention and control of communicable diseases," he said.

Expressing his gratitude to the Chinese government for their cooperation by providing medical supplies and expertise during this difficult time, Mirza said: "It is truly remarkable that out of all the cases reported in Pakistan, not a single patient has a travel history to China.

"This was only achieved through cooperation and coordination between the two countries," he said.

Earlier, NIH Executive Director Major General Aamer Ikram welcomed the delegation and briefed them about the coronavirus outbreak in the country.

He said that all of NIH's departments are coordinating national response activities for Covid-19, adding that China has once again shown to the world that it is Pakistan's ally.

After the briefing, the delegation visited the different departments at NIH and discussed techniques they had used to combat the spread of the coronavirus in their country.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1544684/p...ankful-for-not-being-evacuated-dr-zafar-mirza
 
PIA announces first flight to bring back Pakistani students from Wuhan on May 18

Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) spokesperson Abdullah Hafeez has confirmed that a flight of the national flag carrier will bring back Pakistani students stranded in Wuhan on May 18.

Some 250 students will be brought back in the first flight which will land in Islamabad. The schedule for three more flights will be announced next week.
 
PIA's special flight to bring back Pakistani students stranded in China

A special flight of the Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) will repatriate Pakistani students who were stranded in China due to the coronavirus pandemic. The flight will leave for the city of Wuhan on Friday, according to Radio Pakistan.
 
Back
Top