What's new

PCB should take the bitter pill and appoint Mohammad Amir as the ODI captain

The_Odd_One

ODI Debutant
Joined
Dec 27, 2015
Runs
8,950
PCB should take the bitter pill and appoint Mohammad Aamir as the captain in ODIs. Give him a younger team and at least an year. I am sure, his team will do better than what teams under Afridi, Misbah, Azhar, and Sarfraz have done so far. This is a practical playing XI (no far fetched ideas like Akmal opening, etc) that can easily represent Pakistan until the 2023 world cup.

This is a very strong team with plenty of batting and bowling options.

1. Sami Aslam (Batsman)
He is not rated highly by most of the posters here but he definitely is a much stronger player mentally than the other options available. Most of his good test scores have come in tough conditions and when chips were down. Even in Pakistan cup, both of his 100s came in pressure games. He hit 169 of 126 balls chasing 375 in Pakistan cup which shows he can play the modern game and handles pressure much better than what he is credited for.

2. Babar Azam (Batsman & Vice Captain)
He is by far the most promising batting talent to have come out of Pakistan since Yousuf. However, I feel like he bats more like Amla and Kane rather than Kohli and Root. Pakistan has tried Azhar as an batsman who can consistently provide good platforms. Azhar failed in doing so but Babar is capable of averaging 40/45 @ 85/90 SR. With Sami, he can form a very formidable opening partnership for years to come.

3. Harris Sohail (Batsman & Part-Timer)
He is best suited for #3 and can play pace, swing, and seam better than anyone else in Pakistan. He was doing extremely well in ODIs before he got injured. I think most will agree to his selection as the #3 batsman for Pakistan. On top of this batting, he is a very useful part-timer too. He can actually turn the ball and can easily bowl 4-5 overs in every match.

4. Umar Amin (Batsman & Part-Timer)
Another left handed batsman who is a stroke maker and can bat at a decent SR. Amin has an X-factor in his batting which is missing from the current Pakistani batting unit. He is another handy part-timer who can bowl 4-5 overs in a match.

5. Shoaib Malik (Batsman & Part-Timer)
The only Pakistani batsman who understands the modern game. His comeback has been remarkable. He is extremely fit, can hit long sixes, and contribute with his bowling and fielding too. He is the only 30+ player who should be playing for Pakistan. I think he has good 2 years of Cricket left in him and can retire after the next world cup.

6. Aamir Yamin (Batting All-Rounder)
Everybody wants him in the team. His bowling is not the best but he can be the lower order batsman that Pakistan has been missing. He is a very clean striker of the ball and is the closest to what is currently available as a replacement for Abdur Razzaq.

7. Shadab Khan (Bowling All-Rounder)
He is one player who can win a match single handedly with his batting or bowling. He has shown good promise so far and must be retained in ODIs. A leggie who can smack a few is gold in shorter formats.

8. Mohammad Rizwan (Batsman & Wicket Keeper)
Sadly, none is better than Sarfraz as a wicket-keeper batsman in Pakistan. This said, Sarfraz can only bat in top 5 spots. However, he lacks power hitting skills and is approaching cut off age of 30. In the long run, Rizwan might be a better option for #8 position. He is younger, a better athlete and can improve his batting/hitting skills. His batting has been really disappointing recently, and hence he is batting at #8 in this team.

9. Mohammad Aamir (Bowler and Captain)
He is the only Pakistani player who commands some sort of respect from most of the opposition teams. He is young, an automatic pick, and has the right attitude to lead a team. He made a mistake and served his time. I see no reason why he should not be a captain. Pakistan has done better with bowling captains historically and it is time PCB and some fans let go of their ego and do the right thing for the team.

10. Hassan Ali (Bowler)
A very good bowler who can be a decent slogger. He must take the new ball with Aamir. Their partnership can be the best since the days of Wasim and Waqar.

11. Mohammad Asghar (Bowler)
Pakistan has badly missed a leading spinner like Saqlain and Ajmal who won their teams countless matches. Asghar can be groomed in that role. He has shown some promise and deserves a run in the national team. If two spinners are not need in some conditions, then Pakistan can replace him with another pacer. The point is he should be consistently in the squad.

12. Rumman Raees (Bowler)
He looks like an intelligent bowler. He is not an express bowler but he can play a container role very well in the middle overs. One of him or Asghar can be selected based on the playing conditions.
 
On second thought, when they do the eyewash press conference to announce Sharjeel's innocence in spot fixing, they can announce aamir as new captain. Buy 2 for the price of one
 
No captaincy experience. Shady past. Not a wicket taker. Bowls defensive which tells his mindset.

Also your team has no stroke maker.
 
No captaincy experience. Shady past. Not a wicket taker. Bowls defensive which tells his mindset.

Also your team has no stroke maker.

Can only go with practical options. Sohail Khan is a wicket taker but he is way too old to play international cricket.

I would have picked Sharjeel but he cannot be selected for obvious reasons.

Pakistan does not have the batting talent, simple as that. There are no Buttlers and De Kocks hidden in Pakistan's domestic cricket. All you can do is go with the best available players.
 
The guy should be put on notice, the amount of investment and backing he has gotten from most corners, his numbers do not justify the investment.
 
Sarfraz ahmed is pathetic. If you can't figure out whether to play Imad against India or not or when you open the bowling with a darter or if you are more concerned with containing this Indian team than look for wickets and go for attack then you definitely have no right to captain. All the hype he got was exposed yesterday.

Not just he is overrated as capatain but he is also not as good batsman as people make him out to be.
 
It will be stabbing your own feet. People may say he has earned redemption, served his time ...changed man blah blah and blah. But can everyone in Pakistan say with hand on their hrart that a person with such a past can be trusted 100 percent... i doubt so..plus what are his hidden or unknown leadership qualities...has he atleast captained a club team or psl team ?
 
A guy who sold out his country captaining it. Only in Pakistan. :facepalm:

Even from a cricketing aspect, he's not even the best bowler in our ODI team. Only performed anything close to his previous self in the 2 matches against India since his comeback. Has done jack. No captaincy experience, no one even knows if he has the cricketing mind to captain. Just because one might be a good player (which I don't believe he is), doesn't mean he'll make a good captain.
 
Hassan Ali is our best ODI bowler I'm sure? The same Hassan Ali who kept on serving a free-flowing, predominant front-foot player such as Yuvraj Singh a plethora of full tosses to dispatch in every part of the ground.
 
What captaincy acumen or leadership has he shown? He is talented, no doubt but when has he shown any inclination of even talking to others, giving advice or any thing which shows he can captain?
 
Hassan Ali is our best ODI bowler I'm sure? The same Hassan Ali who kept on serving a free-flowing, predominant front-foot player such as Yuvraj Singh a plethora of full tosses to dispatch in every part of the ground.

Unlike the safe Amir who hides and bowls the same safe length every ball, he at least tries to bowl wicket taking balls so that team can win. Bowlers who try for wickets will sometimes go for runs
 
People who are bashing Aamir must be in some sort of delusion. Aamir is not keeping a Wasim or Waqar out of Pakistani team. He and Hassan are the best Pakistan can offer at the moment. What are the other options?

Junaid Khan? Serial match loser
Sohail Khan? Too old and unfit
Mohammad Sami? Too old and mentally weakest cricketer
Mohammad Abbass? Even his List A record is far from impressive
Sohail Tanvir? Certified TTF
Sadaf Hussain? Many call him Trundler
Mohammad Irfan? LOL
Mohammad Irfan Jr? Probably the worst bowler in last 10 years to have played an international game for Pakistan

Other options:
Wahab Riaz
Imran Khan
Rahat Ali
Bilawal Bhatti
Anwar Ali
Ehsan Aadil

Reality check for some delusional Pakistani fans!
 
Sorry but that comment is absolute nonsense and doesn't even deserve a reply, but I will still humour you. Amir beat Rohit Sharma's bat consistently in his first spell. Even got an edge which should have been taken had there been a second slip. Hasan only beat the once when Kohli gave himself too much room to smack him to Mumbai and missed the wide delivery by a fraction. He was terrible in the death, but hes young and he will learn from this. Nowhere close to Amir's performance yesterday though. I knew once Amir went off with that cramp situation that we would be in deep trouble. I know you have a chip on your shoulder when it comes to Amir, but save it for today since Pakistan fans don't have the time nor the patience to read your rubbish when there are six-seven other hopeless players in this team that makes us want to tear our hairs out.
 
What captaincy acumen or leadership has he shown? He is talented, no doubt but when has he shown any inclination of even talking to others, giving advice or any thing which shows he can captain?

There are not many options available. Sarfraz is proving to be as clueless as Azhar and he has sufficient captaincy experience.
 
what's the obsession with constantly changing captains? Our problems are more deeply rooted than that.
 
what's the obsession with constantly changing captains? Our problems are more deeply rooted than that.

Just do not change captains, change the team as well. Get rid of all TTFs. With the same team even Steve Waugh will not be able to win anything.
 
Sami Aslam as an odi opener :))) :)))? Bhai he is to slow for tests and your putting him in an odi team.

Amir as captain isn't a bad idea but how can you make a player who sold his country out captain? Pcb won't make him captain ever.
 
Make him captain when he picks up a meaningful wicket by his own ability rather than Batsman's mistake.
 
Sami Aslam as an odi opener :))) :)))? Bhai he is to slow for tests and your putting him in an odi team.

Amir as captain isn't a bad idea but how can you make a player who sold his country out captain? Pcb won't make him captain ever.

If I'm not mistaken, he has a SR of 90+ in List A.

Also, scored a 169 at 134 SR in Pakistan cup. Can't rule out a young batsman after a small sample size.
 
Lol imagine if Amir actually becomes captain would be respected don't know why
 
If I'm not mistaken, he has a SR of 90+ in List A.

Also, scored a 169 at 134 SR in Pakistan cup. Can't rule out a young batsman after a small sample size.


I don't need his list a stats. I have seen him bat at international level. His intent and strike was questioned at test level, so what hope is there for him in odi cricket?

He's a test specialist like Azhar.
 
Hassan Ali is our best ODI bowler I'm sure? The same Hassan Ali who kept on serving a free-flowing, predominant front-foot player such as Yuvraj Singh a plethora of full tosses to dispatch in every part of the ground.
Yes, messiah is our best bowler.

Who cares if he doesn't take wickets, all that matters is that he beats the bat and commentators praise him.

Best bowler definitely isn't Hasan Ali who unlike Messiah has an average under 30.
 
how does muhammad amir merit selection let alone becoming captain, he is at best a decent bowler and on what merit he should become captain?
 
Last edited:
Changing captains will not transform the side.
 
Not a good idea. As he's a bowler, he can't play all the matches realistically because of workload management.
 
they should have appointed Hafeez or Malik as the captain after 2015 CWC... Young and new captains will not work with pak when the old guns sit in there...

You want a young captain give a younger team than the captain..
 
Yes, appoint a convicted fixer with questionable morals and even more questionable skill as captain, I am sure that will turn out well. Not to forget that there are already many players who don't even want him in the team due to his past, surely he'll be able to earn the respect of his teammates as captain and there will be no revolt against him :afridi1
 
People who are bashing Aamir must be in some sort of delusion. Aamir is not keeping a Wasim or Waqar out of Pakistani team. He and Hassan are the best Pakistan can offer at the moment. What are the other options?

One of the many problems that destroyed Pakistan cricket and its image. Effective psy ops. The above-mentioned point was used to keep Kamran Akmal in the team for 4-5 years incl. that dreadful Sydney Test in 2009. Psy ops again being done to bring back Akmal. There is political lobbying here for Akmals. I think Sarfraz should be removed and an open policy should be declared only Akmals and tainted players will play in the Pakistan team. Other good players instead of wasting their talent in Pakistan can either shift to other careers or leave the country for better opportunity abroad. Current drama not helping.
 
Giver Sarfaraz some time , 20-20 team current ranking is No.2 from No.7 since he has taken over , He is positive and aggressive Captain only lats match he did poor captaincy , give him some time I am sure he will do well
 
You must be kidding. The guy is bottler under pressure. For god sake he chickened out against India when he was badly needed which was the difference in the end between us chasing maximum 270 and not 324.
Btw, same idea was floated about Wahab Riaz been given the limited overs captaincy after that one off Watson spell.
 
This continuous idea of chopping and changing the side isn't going to stop our free-fall in ODI's, Sarfraz is an excellent T20 captain and it's going to take time for him to start winning in ODI's, I think he's got the right mindset for the format so we should let him do what he has to do.
 
Sarfaraz has just won 7-8 T20s consecutively and lost just two one dayers as of now and you want to remove him as captain and make Amir captain. :facepalm:
 
Last edited:
they should have appointed Hafeez or Malik as the captain after 2015 CWC... Young and new captains will not work with pak when the old guns sit in there...

You want a young captain give a younger team than the captain..

I think Pak gave too much time to Azhar as ODI captain. I would have selected Sarfraz as captain after WC 2015.
 
Sarfraz has had a grand total of 4 matches as captain and already everyone in talking about axing him, he made a blunder vs India, i think that he will learn from that and move on. Previously everyone wanted sarfraz now that you have ur wish, u are talking about replacing him, I still believe that Sarfraz is definitely a good enough captain and the best option we have. I am certain he will transfer his T20 fortunes to ODI's if he is given a team that actually has some element of a balanced squad in there.

As for Amir as captain, he is the star bowler of the team, he should focus on his bowling and that alone, If he is given too many responsibilities then his bowling will suffer. I know be hasn't been amounts the wickets as much, but he has been really unlucky with that, he has been the best bowler in the team since his comeback.
 
what's the obsession with constantly changing captains? Our problems are more deeply rooted than that.

This.
Mickey and sarfaraz until next world cup.
These 2 r not the reason our batters can't bat in modern odi
 
Changing captains will not transform the side.

One of the many problems that destroyed Pakistan cricket and its image. Effective psy ops. The above-mentioned point was used to keep Kamran Akmal in the team for 4-5 years incl. that dreadful Sydney Test in 2009. Psy ops again being done to bring back Akmal. There is political lobbying here for Akmals. I think Sarfraz should be removed and an open policy should be declared only Akmals and tainted players will play in the Pakistan team. Other good players instead of wasting their talent in Pakistan can either shift to other careers or leave the country for better opportunity abroad. Current drama not helping.

Giver Sarfaraz some time , 20-20 team current ranking is No.2 from No.7 since he has taken over , He is positive and aggressive Captain only lats match he did poor captaincy , give him some time I am sure he will do well

This continuous idea of chopping and changing the side isn't going to stop our free-fall in ODI's, Sarfraz is an excellent T20 captain and it's going to take time for him to start winning in ODI's, I think he's got the right mindset for the format so we should let him do what he has to do.

Sarfaraz has just won 7-8 T20s consecutively and lost just two one dayers as of now and you want to remove him as captain and make Amir captain. :facepalm:

I think Pak gave too much time to Azhar as ODI captain. I would have selected Sarfraz as captain after WC 2015.

Sarfraz has had a grand total of 4 matches as captain and already everyone in talking about axing him, he made a blunder vs India, i think that he will learn from that and move on. Previously everyone wanted sarfraz now that you have ur wish, u are talking about replacing him, I still believe that Sarfraz is definitely a good enough captain and the best option we have. I am certain he will transfer his T20 fortunes to ODI's if he is given a team that actually has some element of a balanced squad in there.

As for Amir as captain, he is the star bowler of the team, he should focus on his bowling and that alone, If he is given too many responsibilities then his bowling will suffer. I know be hasn't been amounts the wickets as much, but he has been really unlucky with that, he has been the best bowler in the team since his comeback.

This.
Mickey and sarfaraz until next world cup.
These 2 r not the reason our batters can't bat in modern odi

Refreshing to see finally some sense. There is no magic wand and Messiah who will turn Pakistan cricket.
 
Such a poor thread. I wonder how you guys go about your lives with non existent thinking skills.

Alas, the state of our country is also mirrored in our cricket setup and fan base.
 
After reading the heading i feel :facepalm: This will only happen in pakistan. How on earth you come up with this idea. Amer is lucky he is playing for pakistan again after what he did. Now don't expect anything more than this. Give sarfaraz ahmed time he definitely comes good.
 
Back
Top